1991 Ryder Cup#Ballesteros/Azinger feud

{{short description|1991 edition of the Ryder Cup}}

{{Use mdy dates|date=April 2020}}

{{Infobox team golf tournament

| name = Ryder Cup

| year = 1991

| logo =

| dates = September 27–29, 1991

| venue = Kiawah Island Golf Resort
The Ocean Course

| location = Kiawah Island, South Carolina

| home = USA

| away = Europe

| homecaptain = Dave Stockton

| awaycaptain = Bernard Gallacher

| homescore = 14{{1/2}}

| awayscore = 13{{1/2}}

| result = United States wins

}}

{{Location map

|USA

|relief = 1

|label = Kiawah Island 

|lat = 32.612

|long = -80.023

|caption = Location in the United States

|marksize = 5

|float =

|background =

|width = 240

}}

{{Location map

|USA South Carolina

|relief = 1

|label = Kiawah Island

|position = top

|lat = 32.612

|long = -80.023

|caption = Location in South Carolina

|marksize = 5

|float =

|background =

|width = 160

}}

The 29th Ryder Cup Matches were held September 27–29, 1991, on The Ocean Course at Kiawah Island Golf Resort in Kiawah Island, South Carolina, southwest of Charleston.

The United States team won the competition by 14{{1/2}} to 13{{1/2}} points, winning back the Cup on the 18th hole of the final match. Bernhard Langer missed a six-foot (1.8 m) par putt which would have won his match and clinched a 14-all tie and retained the Ryder Cup for Europe.{{cite magazine|url=http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1140457/index.htm |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20121003005914/http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1140457/index.htm |url-status=dead |archive-date=October 3, 2012 |magazine=Sports Illustrated |last=Garrity |first=John |title=Blood, Sweat, and Tears |date=October 7, 1991 |page=26}} It was the first win for the U.S. since 1983, after consecutive losses to Europe in 1985 and 1987 and a tie in 1989.{{cite news|url=https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=ouFRAAAAIBAJ&pg=3067%2C7484625 |newspaper=Pittsburgh Post-Gazette |agency=Associated Press |last=Green |first=Bob |title=U.S. reclaims Ryder Cup from Europeans |date=September 30, 1991 |page=11}} Due to the fierce competition, gamesmanship and general over-exuberance of the U.S. Team and their fans, these Ryder Cup Matches became known as the "War on the Shore."

The event was originally slated for PGA West, but was moved in 1989 to accommodate television coverage in both the United States and Europe.{{cite news |last=Rosaforte |first=Tim |title=Ryder Cup makes a Landmark move |url=https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-palm-beach-post-when-the-ryder-cup-m/174406837/ |newspaper=The Palm Beach Post |date=19 May 1989 |page=3C |via=Newspapers.com |access-date=13 June 2025}}

The Ocean Course later hosted the PGA Championship in 2012 and 2021.

Format

The Ryder Cup is a match play event, with each match worth one point. The competition format in 1991 was as follows:

  • Day 1 (Friday) — 4 foursome (alternate shot) matches in a morning session and 4 four-ball (better ball) matches in an afternoon session
  • Day 2 (Saturday) — 4 foursome matches in a morning session and 4 four-ball matches in an afternoon session
  • Day 3 (Sunday) — 12 singles matches

With a total of 28 points, 14{{1/2}} points were required to win the Cup, and 14 points were required for the defending champion to retain the Cup. All matches were played to a maximum of 18 holes.

Teams

border="1" cellpadding="3" style="border-collapse: collapse;text-align:center"
style="background:#dfd;"

| colspan="8"|{{flagicon|USA|size=50px}} Team USA

style="background:#dfd;"

!Name

!Age

!Points
rank

!World
ranking

!Previous
Ryder Cups

!Matches

!W–L–H

!Winning
percentage

align=left|Dave Stockton

| 49

colspan="6" | Non-playing captain
align=left|Fred Couples

| 31

17120–2–00.00
align=left|Payne Stewart

| 34

26283–5–037.50
align=left|Lanny Wadkins

| 41

31362515–9–162.00
align=left|Hale Irwin

| 46

41241611–4–171.88
align=left|Paul Azinger

| 31

58143–1–075.00
align=left|Corey Pavin

| 31

6160colspan="3"|Rookie
align=left|Mark O'Meara

| 34

715251–4–020.00
align=left|Mark Calcavecchia

| 31

8=24273–4–042.86
align=left|Wayne Levi

| 39

8=380colspan="3"|Rookie
align=left|Steve Pate

| 30

10300colspan="3"|Rookie
style="background:#ffa;"

| align=left|Chip Beck

| 35

1321143–0–187.50
style="background:#ffa;"

| align=left|Raymond Floyd

| 49

23396237–13–336.96

Captains picks are shown in yellow.{{cite news|url=https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=8j0eAAAAIBAJ&pg=6422%2C6408998 |newspaper=The Dispatch |location=Lexington, North Carolina |last=Mossman |first=John |agency=Associated Press |title=Floyd, Beck picked for Ryder Cup team |date=August 14, 1991 |page=1C }}{{cite news |url=http://golf.about.com/od/rydercup/a/ryder-cup-captains-picks.htm |publisher=About.com |title=Ryder Cup captain's picks and how they've fared |last=Kelley |first=Brent |access-date=September 4, 2014 |archive-date=September 4, 2014 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20140904171603/http://golf.about.com/od/rydercup/a/ryder-cup-captains-picks.htm |url-status=dead }} The world rankings and records are at the start of the 1991 Ryder Cup.

The selection process for the European team remained the same as used since 1985, with nine players chosen from the 1991 European Tour money list at the conclusion of the German Open on August 25 and the remaining three team members being chosen immediately afterwards by the team captain, Bernard Gallacher. Gallacher had announced before the final event that he would choose Nick Faldo as one of his picks. He also announced that he would select José María Olazábal, who was then in the 9th and final automatic spot, even if he dropped out of the top nine."Olazábal is assured of place in Ryder Cup". The Times, August 20, 1991; pg. 32; Issue 64103. At the time Olazábal and Faldo were second and third in the world rankings. Olazábal had just won The International on the PGA Tour. Eamonn Darcy, in 7th place in the points list, chose to miss the German Open. However, with David Gilford earning £4,320 in prize money, Sam Torrance tying for 3rd place and Paul Broadhurst losing a playoff, Darcy dropped to 10th place in the final list, £58.26 behind Gilford. Olazábal dropped to 11th place in the points list but had been assured of selection anyway. Gallacher chose Mark James as his third choice in preference to Darcy."Broadhurst loses but gains Ryder Cup place". The Times, August 26, 1991; pg. 21; Issue 64108.

border="1" cellpadding="3" style="border-collapse: collapse;text-align:center"
style="background:#dfd;"

| colspan="8"|{{flagicon|Europe|size=50px}} Team Europe

style="background:#dfd;"

!Name

!Age

!Points
rank

!World
ranking

!Previous
Ryder Cups

!Matches

!W–L–H

!Winning
percentage

align=left|{{flagicon|SCO}} Bernard Gallacher

| 42

colspan="6" | Non-playing captain
align=left|{{flagicon|ESP}} Seve Ballesteros

| 34

1552513–8–460.00
align=left|{{flagicon|SCO}} Colin Montgomerie

| 28

2350colspan="3"|Rookie
align=left|{{flagicon|ENG}} Steven Richardson

| 25

3360colspan="3"|Rookie
align=left|{{flagicon|WAL}} Ian Woosnam

| 33

414177–7–350.00
align=left|{{flagicon|SCO}} Sam Torrance

| 38

5415184–10–433.33
align=left|{{flagicon|DEU}} Bernhard Langer

| 34

6952210–8–454.55
align=left|{{flagicon|ENG}} Paul Broadhurst

| 26

7930colspan="3"|Rookie
align=left|{{flagicon|NIR}} David Feherty

| 33

8440colspan="3"|Rookie
align=left|{{flagicon|ENG}} David Gilford

| 26

9990colspan="3"|Rookie
style="background:#ffa;"

| align=left|{{flagicon|ESP}} José María Olazábal

| 25

1122107–2–175.00
style="background:#ffa;"

| align=left|{{flagicon|ENG}} Nick Faldo

| 34

15372716–9–262.96
style="background:#ffa;"

| align=left|{{flagicon|ENG}} Mark James

| 37

22454145–8–139.29

Captains picks are shown in yellow. The world rankings and records are at the start of the 1991 Ryder Cup.

Friday's matches

=Morning foursomes=

border="1" cellpadding="3" style="border-collapse:collapse; text-align:center;"
style="background:#dfd;"

! style="width:12em;"| {{flagicon|Europe|size=50px}}

! style="width:5.5em;"| Results

! style="width:12em;"| {{flagicon|USA|size=50px}}

Ballesteros/Olazábal

|align=left|{{flagicon|Europe}} 2 & 1

|Azinger/Beck

Langer/James

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 2 & 1

|Floyd/Couples

Gilford/Montgomerie

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 4 & 2

|Wadkins/Irwin

Faldo/Woosnam

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 1 up

|Stewart/Calcavecchia

style="background:#dfd;"

| 1

| Session

| 3

style="background:#afa;"

! 1

! Overall

! 3

=Afternoon four-ball=

border="1" cellpadding="3" style="border-collapse:collapse; text-align:center;"
style="background:#dfd;"

! style="width:12em;"| {{flagicon|Europe|size=50px}}

! style="width:5.5em;"| Results

! style="width:12em;"| {{flagicon|USA|size=50px}}

Torrance/Feherty

|halved

|Wadkins/O'Meara

Ballesteros/Olazábal

|align=left|{{flagicon|Europe}} 2 & 1

|Azinger/Beck

Richardson/James

|align=left|{{flagicon|Europe}} 5 & 4

|Pavin/Calcavecchia

Faldo/Woosnam

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 5 & 3

|Floyd/Couples

style="background:#dfd;"

| 2{{1/2}}

| Session

| 1{{1/2}}

style="background:#afa;"

! 3{{1/2}}

! Overall

! 4{{1/2}}

Saturday's matches

=Morning foursomes=

border="1" cellpadding="3" style="border-collapse:collapse; text-align:center;"
style="background:#dfd;"

! style="width:12em;"| {{flagicon|Europe|size=50px}}

! style="width:5.5em;"| Results

! style="width:12em;"| {{flagicon|USA|size=50px}}

Feherty/Torrance

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 4 & 2

|Irwin/Wadkins

James/Richardson

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 1 up

|Calcavecchia/Stewart

Faldo/Gilford

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 7 & 6

|Azinger/O'Meara

Ballesteros/Olazábal

|align=left|{{flagicon|Europe}} 3 & 2

|Couples/Floyd

style="background:#dfd;"

| 1

| Session

| 3

style="background:#afa;"

! 4{{1/2}}

! Overall

! 7{{1/2}}

=Afternoon four-ball=

border="1" cellpadding="3" style="border-collapse:collapse; text-align:center;"
style="background:#dfd;"

! style="width:12em;"| {{flagicon|Europe|size=50px}}

! style="width:5.5em;"| Results

! style="width:12em;"| {{flagicon|USA|size=50px}}

Woosnam/Broadhurst

|align=left|{{flagicon|Europe}} 2 & 1

|Azinger/Irwin

Langer/Montgomerie

|align=left|{{flagicon|Europe}} 2 & 1

|Pavin/Pate

James/Richardson

|align=left|{{flagicon|Europe}} 3 & 1

|Wadkins/Levi

Ballesteros/Olazábal

|halved

|Stewart/Couples

style="background:#dfd;"

| 3{{1/2}}

| Session

| {{1/2}}

style="background:#afa;"

! 8

! Overall

! 8

Sunday's singles matches

border="1" cellpadding="3" style="border-collapse: collapse; text-align:center;"
style="background:#dfd;"

! style="width:12em;"| {{flagicon|Europe|size=50px}}

! style="width:5.5em;"| Results

! style="width:12em;"| {{flagicon|USA|size=50px}}

Nick Faldo

|align=left|{{flagicon|Europe}} 2 up

|Raymond Floyd

David Feherty

|align=left|{{flagicon|Europe}} 2 & 1

|Payne Stewart

Colin Montgomerie

|halved

|Mark Calcavecchia

José María Olazábal

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 2 up

|Paul Azinger

Steven Richardson

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 2 & 1

|Corey Pavin

Seve Ballesteros

|align=left|{{flagicon|Europe}} 3 & 2

|Wayne Levi

Ian Woosnam

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 3 & 1

|Chip Beck

Paul Broadhurst

|align=left|{{flagicon|Europe}} 3 & 1

|Mark O'Meara

Sam Torrance

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 3 & 2

|Fred Couples

Mark James

|align=left|{{flagicon|USA}} 3 & 2

|Lanny Wadkins

Bernhard Langer

|halved

|Hale Irwin

David Gilford

|halvedSteve Pate withdrew because of injury, so this match was not actually played.{{cite news |url=https://www.espn.com/golf/rydercup04/news/story?id=1880647 |title=Secret envelope adds to the intrigue |date=September 13, 2004 |first=Jim |last=Moriarty |work=ESPN |access-date=March 18, 2013}}

|Steve Pate

style="background:#dfd;"

| 5{{1/2}}

| Session

| 6{{1/2}}

style="background:#afa;"

! 13{{1/2}}

! Overall

! 14{{1/2}}

Individual player records

Each entry refers to the win–loss–half record of the player.

Source: {{cite web|url=http://2014rcmediaguide.com/2014RyderCupMediaGuide/ |title=2014 Ryder Cup Media and Players' Guide |access-date=October 5, 2014 |url-status=usurped |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20141006074322/http://2014rcmediaguide.com/2014RyderCupMediaGuide/ |archive-date=October 6, 2014 }}

=United States=

class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align:center"

! Player !! Points

Overall !! Singles !! Foursomes !! Fourballs
align=left|Paul Azinger22–3–01–0–01–1–00–2–0
align=left|Chip Beck11–2–01–0–00–1–00–1–0
align=left|Mark Calcavecchia2.52–1–10–0–12–0–00–1–0
align=left|Fred Couples3.53–1–11–0–01–1–01–0–1
align=left|Raymond Floyd22–2–00–1–01–1–01–0–0
align=left|Hale Irwin2.52–1–10–0–12–0–00–1–0
align=left|Wayne Levi00–2–00–1–00–0–00–1–0
align=left|Mark O'Meara1.51–1–10–1–01–0–00–0–1
align=left|Steve Pate0.50–1–10–0–10–0–00–1–0
align=left|Corey Pavin11–2–01–0–00–0–00–2–0
align=left|Payne Stewart2.52–1–10–1–02–0–00–0–1
align=left|Lanny Wadkins3.53–1–11–0–02–0–00–1–1

=Europe=

class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align:center"

! Player !! Points !! Overall !! Singles !! Foursomes !! Fourballs

align=left|Seve Ballesteros4.54–0–11–0–02–0–01–0–1
align=left|Paul Broadhurst22–0–01–0–00–0–01–0–0
align=left|Nick Faldo11–3–01–0–00–2–00–1–0
align=left|David Feherty1.51–1–11–0–00–1–00–0–1
align=left|David Gilford0.50–2–10–0–10–2–00–0–0
align=left|Mark James22–3–00–1–00–2–02–0–0
align=left|Bernhard Langer1.51–1–10–0–10–1–01–0–0
align=left|Colin Montgomerie1.51–1–10–0–10–1–01–0–0
align=left|José María Olazábal3.53–1–10–1–02–0–01–0–1
align=left|Steven Richardson22–2–00–1–00–1–02–0–0
align=left|Sam Torrance0.50–2–10–1–00–1–00–0–1
align=left|Ian Woosnam11–3–00–1–00–1–01–1–0

Steve Pate injury controversy

On the eve of the games, Steve Pate and some other members of the U.S. team were involved in a minor caravan crash causing Pate to bruise his ribs and need hospital treatment. Much was discussed by the U.S. captain to either replace him at the last minute or carry on as planned.{{cite news |url=https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1991-09-26-sp-3895-story.html |title=Car Crash May Hurt U.S. Team : Ryder Cup: Steve Pate suffers injured ribs. His status for matches against Europe is questionable. |date=September 26, 1991 |first=MaryAnn |last=Hudson |newspaper=Los Angeles Times |access-date=March 18, 2013}} The decision was taken to allow Pate to participate in the games causing him to sit out the first three sessions of play. The only session he played in was a four-ball on Saturday afternoon, losing to Bernhard Langer and Colin Montgomerie. Prior to the first singles tee off on Sunday the U.S. team announced that Steve Pate was unable to play in the singles due to his earlier sustained injury. As a result, the match he was due to contend with David Gilford was automatically halved causing Gilford to miss out his singles match.

This brought heavy criticism from the general media and the European team feeling a sense of bad sportsmanship on behalf of the Americans. Especially considering U.S. captain Dave Stockton had chosen to play Pate in an earlier match thus risking causing further unnecessary injury to the player. In post-match interviews serious questions were asked of the American's reasoning and tactics behind claiming half a point for one of their weaker players.{{cn|date=May 2020}}

Ballesteros/Azinger and Floyd controversies

Ballesteros and Azinger had previously locked horns in 1989 when Ballesteros tried to have a scuffed ball taken out of play which Azinger disagreed with.{{cite web |url=http://www.golf.com/photos/best-feuds-golf/paul-azinger-seve-ballesteros-best-feuds |title=Best Feuds in Golf – Paul Azinger vs. Seve Ballesteros |website=golf.com |access-date=March 18, 2013 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20160303230312/http://www.golf.com/photos/best-feuds-golf/paul-azinger-seve-ballesteros-best-feuds |archive-date=March 3, 2016 |url-status=dead }}

The bad blood escalated at Kiawah Island when on the morning of the Friday foursomes with Ballesteros partnering José María Olazábal against Paul Azinger and Chip Beck the Europeans noticed the Americans had changed the compression of the ball on the 7th tee which is in violation of the one-ball rule. Ballesteros accused his opponents of doing this at least three times since the start of the match. On speaking with the referee at first Azinger flatly denied it. However once it had become apparent to the Americans that they were not called up on the violation at the time of incident therefore could no longer be penalized by loss of hole they admitted to switching their ball.{{Cite magazine |url=https://www.golfdigest.com/story/1991-ryder-cup-at-kiawah |title=The Rowdy Ryder Cup at Kiawah |last1=Huggan |first1=John |last2=Yocom |first2=Guy |date=July 31, 2012 |magazine=Golf Digest |access-date=July 9, 2018}}

This incident was the stem of accusations of the U.S. side of repeated gamesmanship, bad sportsmanship and ill tactics in many future matches to come.

On the morning of the Saturday foursomes with Ballesteros partnering José María Olazábal against Raymond Floyd and Fred Couples, Ballesteros developed a small cough. After noise was coincidentally made during swings made by the United States Team on the first 2 holes, Floyd approached Ballesteros with a severe warning that he was "better than you (Ballesteros) could ever be at this" and that if Ballesteros did not stop he would reciprocate with force. {{cite web |url=https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=507562393155217 |title=Ray Floyd shuts down Seve |work=Golf Channel |access-date=April 22, 2020}}

Since the mid-1980s, the European team had dominated the event including wins in 1985, 1987 and retaining the cup in 1989. With exception to 1993, the European team continued to dominate until ill feelings between the two sides came to a head in an explosive match at Brookline in 1999 where the U.S. side and their fans were again accused of having the mindset of "anything to win" going against the spirit of how the matches were intended to be played.{{cite news |url=https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2004/sep/17/rydercup2004.rydercup3 |title=Day of shame that refuses to die |newspaper=The Guardian |first=David |last=Davies |date=September 16, 2004 |access-date=March 18, 2013}}

References

{{reflist}}

{{refbegin}}

  • {{cite web |url=http://www.rydercup.com/2006/europe/history/results/1991.html |title=Ryder Cup 2006 » History » 1991 Results |publisher=The PGA of America, Ryder Cup Limited, and Turner Sports Interactive |access-date=March 14, 2007 |archive-date=October 22, 2006 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20061022153340/http://www.rydercup.com/2006/europe/history/results/1991.html |url-status=dead }}
  • {{cite web |url=http://golf.about.com/od/teamcompetitions/p/rydercup1991.htm |title=Ryder Cup – 1991 |publisher=About:Golf |access-date=March 14, 2007 |archive-date=January 26, 2017 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20170126210023/http://golf.about.com/od/teamcompetitions/p/rydercup1991.htm |url-status=dead }}
  • {{cite web |url=http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/golf/3913347.stm |title=Ryder Cup history: 1991 |publisher=BBC Sport |access-date=March 14, 2007 |date=September 13, 2004 }}

{{refend}}