Absolute Strangers

{{short description|1991 TV film by Gilbert Cates}}

{{Use mdy dates|date=April 2025}}

{{Infobox television

| image = Absolute Strangers.jpg

| image_size =

| alt =

| caption =

| genre = Drama

| director = Gilbert Cates

| writer = Robert Anderson

| starring = Henry Winkler

| music = Charles Fox

| country = United States

| language = English

| executive_producer = Gilbert Cates

| producer = Dennis E. Doty

| cinematography = Mark Irwin

| editor = Millie Moore

| runtime = 96 minutes

| location =

| company = {{Plainlist|

  • Absolute Strangers Company
  • Gilbert Cates Productions

}}

| network = CBS

| released = {{Start date|1991|4|14}}

}}

Absolute Strangers is a 1991 made-for-television CBS docudrama featuring Happy Days star Henry Winkler returning to his first major TV role in eight years.{{cite news | newspaper = The Free Lance-Star | title = Henry Winkler returns to acting | first = Jerry |last=Buck |agency=Associated Press | date = April 13, 1991 | url = https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=wOJNAAAAIBAJ&dq=absolute-strangers%20film&pg=3062%2C2455515 }}

The screenplay, written by Robert Woodruff Anderson, was based on the true story of Marty Klein's controversial decision to have his wife Nancy undergo an abortion to aid her recovery after a head-trauma accident had left her comatose.{{cite news |last1=Singer |first1=Cathy |title=Fight for Injured Woman's Abortion in a TV Movie |url=https://www.nytimes.com/1991/04/14/nyregion/fight-for-injured-womans-abortion-in-a-tv-movie.html |access-date=8 May 2025 |work=The New York Times |date=April 14, 1991}}{{cite news | title = Real Life Story Sets Up Hard Choices | first = Pat |last=Milton |agency=Associated Press| date = April 13, 1991 | newspaper = The Free Lance-Star | url = https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=wOJNAAAAIBAJ&dq=absolute-strangers%20film&pg=5524%2C2455198 }}

The title is taken from the real-life court decision that used the phrase "absolute strangers", itself apparently derived from a courtroom outburst by Klein—to describe two anti-abortion activists, one of whom sued Klein to get custody of the fetus, the other to be appointed guardian of Nancy.

The impending broadcast of the film spurred anti-abortion activists, including the American Family Association, to try to discourage advertisers from buying time during the show.{{cite news | title = Battle Lines Form Over 'Strangers' | first = Dennis |last=McDougal | date = March 13, 1991 | newspaper =Los Angeles Times | url = https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1991-03-13-ca-273-story.html | accessdate = 2011-10-09 }}

These efforts provoked counter-demonstrations,

and campaigns of letter-writing in support of the broadcast from Planned Parenthood, the National Council of Jewish Women, and other groups.{{cite book | title = Law and the Web of Society |author-first1=Cynthia L. |author-last1=Cates |author-first2= Wayne V. |author-last2=McIntosh | pages = 187–190 | publisher = Georgetown University Press | series = Hastings Center Studies in Ethics | year = 2001 | isbn = 0-87840-860-6 | url = https://books.google.com/books?id=mJ7ge3HCRdsC&q=absolute.strangers&pg=PA188 }}

The real-life Klein appeared in a cameo. Henry Winkler played Martin Klein, with his wife Nancy played by Jennifer Hetrick. Others in the cast included Karl Malden as Nancy Klein's father, Patty Duke as the appeals court judge (personally opposed to abortion) in the pivotal court case, and Richard Kiley as a doctor who favors abortion in such cases.{{cite news |last=Tucker |first=Ken |date=April 12, 1991 |title=Absolute Strangers |url=https://ew.com/article/1991/04/12/absolute-strangers/ |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20210920211933/https://ew.com/article/1991/04/12/absolute-strangers/ |archive-date=2021-09-20 |accessdate=2011-08-09 |newspaper=Entertainment Weekly}}{{cite news | title = Henry Winkler returns in 'Absolute Strangers | first = Ron |last=Miller | newspaper = The Day | date = April 11, 1991 | url = https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=hgQhAAAAIBAJ&pg=1382%2C3041955 }}

The film's director, Gilbert Cates, was nominated for a Primetime Emmy.{{cite web | title = Absolute Strangers |website = Academy of Television Arts & Sciences | url = http://www.emmys.com/shows/absolute-strangers | accessdate = 2011-10-09 }}

Plot

Following a car accident, Marty Klein is advised that only an abortion can save the life of his comatose and pregnant wife, Nancy. Other doctors note that the wife is in no immediate danger, but Marty realizes those doctors are acting on anti-abortion views and want to reach the limit of the second trimester when abortion is disallowed. The husband reluctantly agrees to an abortion because his wife will be at high risk of death if she delivers a baby while comatose.

However, the procedure is blocked by activists opposed to abortion. Marty faces the hospital's ethics board to find a doctor willing to perform the procedure. He must then undergo the legal process to declare his wife incompetent to make her own decisions, and to appoint himself as her guardian. Anti-abortion activists challenge him each step of the way.

Eventually a court case allows the abortion to proceed. Anti-abortion activists appeal the case to higher courts, and eventually to Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia. Along the way, the news media get involved, and the story gains national prominence. The anti-abortion activists seek guardianship of the fetus; Marty denounces them in court as "absolute strangers" trying to take control of his life and his wife's life.

With all appeals exhausted, the abortion procedure is begun. Nancy later emerges from the coma and recuperates to a normal life.

Cast

{{cast listing|

}}

Critical reception

In The Baltimore Sun, Michael Hill said the film handled the controversial topic of abortion with "involving style and grace".{{Cite news |last=Hill |first=Michael |date=April 12, 1991 |title=Absolute Strangers' is skillful, compelling look at abortion |url=https://www.baltimoresun.com/1991/04/12/absolute-strangers-is-skillful-compelling-look-at-abortion/ |url-status=live |archive-url=https://archive.today/20250507021004/https://www.baltimoresun.com/1991/04/12/absolute-strangers-is-skillful-compelling-look-at-abortion/ |archive-date=May 7, 2025 |access-date=May 8, 2025 |work=The Baltimore Sun}} In The Buffalo News, Alan Pergament wrote, "In his first acting role in years, Winkler gives a very understated performance. He does a good job in the few scenes that detail Marty's outrage against the strangers. The subject matter is the star of the film, not the performances…Tastefully filmed, thought-provoking, emotionally involving and willing to take a stand, 'Absolute Strangers' is a rarity in network television".{{Cite news |last=Pergament |first=Alan |date=April 12, 1991 |title='Absolute Strangers' is Likely to Arouse the Pro-Life Forces |url=https://buffalonews.com/news/article_0de02bca-0b56-55a3-b139-684b1d2412c6.html |url-status=live |archive-url=https://archive.today/20250507021333/https://buffalonews.com/news/article_0de02bca-0b56-55a3-b139-684b1d2412c6.html |archive-date=May 7, 2025 |access-date=May 8, 2025 |work=The Buffalo News}} Others were more critical, with Ray Loynd of the Los Angeles Times calling it a "predictable advocacy drama" with a "lack of strong characterization".{{Cite news |last=Loynd |first=Ray |date=April 13, 1991 |title=TV Reviews : Winkler Returns in Predictable 'Strangers' |url=https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1991-04-13-ca-33-story.html |url-status=usurped |archive-url=https://archive.today/20250507020811/https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1991-04-13-ca-33-story.html |archive-date=7 May 2025 |access-date=8 May 2025 |work=Los Angeles Times}} In Entertainment Weekly, Ken Tucker criticized the script's writing of Marty's character as too much of a blank slate, saying "To have an interesting movie, Cates needed a protagonist who was willing to commit himself to his beliefs. Instead, he ended up with a movie in which everyone is either a victim or a villain."

References

{{Reflist}}