Aesthetic taste

David Hume addressed the subject of aesthetic taste in an essay entitled “Of the Standard of Taste”, one of four essays published in his Four Dissertations in 1757.{{Cite book |last=Hume |first=David |title=Four Dissertations |publisher=London: A. Millar in the Strand |year=1757 |edition=1st}} "Of the Standard of Taste" is highly regarded for its insights into aesthetics. While Hume is generally seen as an empiricist, in matters of taste, he can be classified as an ideal observer theorist, allowing for individual and cultural preferences. Hume distinguishes between sentiments, always correct as they reference only themselves, and determinations, which can be incorrect as they refer to something beyond. Beauty, for Hume, is "no quality in things themselves: It exists merely in the mind which contemplates them; and each mind perceives a different beauty".{{Cite book |last=Hume |first=David |title=Essays: Moral, Political, and Literary |publisher=Liberty Fund |year=1985 |editor-last=Miller |editor-first=Eugene F. |edition=Revised |pages=230}} This, according to Hume, makes judgments of beauty and taste sentiments rather than determinations.

Hume argues that beauty lies in the mind, not the object, and opinions about beauty are influenced by cultural conventions, subject to change. He introduces the concept of a true judge, an individual with "strong sense, united to delicate sentiment, improved by practice, perfected by comparison, and cleared of all prejudice."{{Cite web |title=Internet History Sourcebooks: Modern History |url=https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/mod/1760hume-taste.asp |access-date=2023-12-30 |website=sourcebooks.fordham.edu}} The combined opinions of these rare individuals form the standard of taste, existing within them. This standard is not to be confused with contemporary art critics; the true judge does not apply a standard to objects but possesses ideal perception, enhancing their ability to appreciate beauty.{{Cite web |title=Aesthetic Taste {{!}} Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy |url=https://iep.utm.edu/aesthetic-taste/ |access-date=2023-12-30 |language=en-US}} Hume suggests that improving perception leads to better taste.

For Immanuel Kant, as discussed in his Critique of Judgment, beauty is not a property of any object, but an aesthetic judgement based on a subjective feeling. He claims that a genuine good taste does exist, though it could not be empirically identified. The validity of a judgement is not to be ascertained by means of the general view of the majority or some specific social group because taste is both personal and beyond reasoning. Nonetheless, Kant stresses that our preferences, even on generally liked things, do not justify the objectivity of our judgements.{{cite book|last=Gronow|first=Jukka|year=1997|title=Sociology of Taste|location=London|publisher=Routledge|isbn=0-415-13294-0|pages=11, 87}}

Bourdieu argued against the Kantian view of pure aesthetics, stating that the legitimate taste of the society is the taste of the ruling class.{{cn|reason=|date=August 2023}} This position also rejects the idea of genuine good taste, as the legitimate taste is merely a class taste. This idea was also proposed by Simmel, who noted that the upper classes abandon fashions as they are adopted by lower ones.{{cn|reason=|date=August 2023}}

Bad taste (also poor taste or vulgarity) is generally used to deride individuals with 'poor' aesthetic judgment.{{cite journal|first=Theodore A.|last=Gracyk|title=Having Bad Taste|journal=The British Journal of Aesthetics|volume=30|number=2|pages=117–131|doi=10.1093/bjaesthetics/30.2.117|

date=1 April 1990}} Bad taste can become a respected and cultivated (if perhaps defiant and belligerent) aesthetic, for example in the works of filmmaker John Waters, sculptor Jeff Koons, or the popular McMansion style of architecture.{{cn|date=March 2025}}

A contemporary view—a retrospective review of literature—is that "a good deal of dramatic verse written during the Elizabethan and Jacobean periods is in poor taste because it is bombast [high-sounding language with little meaning]".{{cite book|first=M. H.|last=Abrams|chapter=Vulgarity|title=Dictionary of Literary Terms and Literary Theory|publisher=Penguin|year=1998|page=976|isbn=978-0-631-20271-4}}

Grayck argues that individuals can only be judged as having poor taste if their tastes are informed by the aesthetics education they received.

• Aesthetics
• Artistic merit
• Camp (style)
• Censorship
• Fashion
• Highbrow
• Kitsch
• Low culture
• Style (visual arts)
• Subjectivism
• Western canon

{{Reflist|30em}}

{{wikiquote}}

{{refbegin}}

• {{cite journal|last=Arsel|first=Zeynep|author2=Jonathan Bean |title=Taste Regimes and Market-Mediated Practice|journal=Journal of Consumer Research|volume=39|issue=5|pages=899–917|year=2013|doi=10.1086/666595}}
• {{cite book

| last = Bourdieu

| first = Pierre

| author-link = Pierre Bourdieu

| title = Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste

| publisher = Routledge

| year = 1984

| location = London

| isbn = 0-415-04546-0}}

• {{cite book

| last = Bourdieu

| first = Pierre

| author-link = Pierre Bourdieu

| editor-last = Richardson

| editor-first = John G

| chapter = The Forms of Capital

| title = Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education

| publisher = Greenwood Press

| year = 1986

| location = New York

| chapter-url = http://www.marxists.org/reference/subject/philosophy/works/fr/bourdieu-forms-capital.htm

| isbn = 0-313-23529-5}}

• {{Citation

| last=Bragg

| first=Melvyn

| author-link=Melvyn Bragg

| title = Taste

| series=In Our Time

| publisher = BBC Radio 4

| date =25 October 2007

| url = http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b0082dzm

| access-date = 18 September 2010}}

• {{cite book

| last = Ekelund

| first = Robert B. Jr.

|last2=Hébert|first2= Robert F.

| title = A History of Economic Theory and Method. 3rd ed.

| publisher = McGraw-Hill Publishing Company

| year = 1990

| location = New York

| isbn = 0-07-019416-5}}

• {{cite journal|last=Friedman|first=Sam|first2=Giselinde|last2= Kuipers|title=The divisive power of humour: Comedy, taste and symbolic boundaries|journal=Cultural Sociology|volume=7|issue=2|pages=179–195|year=2013|doi=10.1177/1749975513477405|s2cid=53362319|url=http://openaccess.city.ac.uk/2209/1/DivisivePowerofHumour.pdf}}
• {{cite book

| last = Gronow

| first = Jukka

| title = Sociology of Taste

| publisher = Routledge

| year = 1997

| location = London

| isbn = 0-415-13294-0}}

• {{cite journal

| last = Hennion

| first = Antoine

| title = Those Things That Hold Us Together: Taste and Sociology

| journal=Cultural Sociology|volume=1|number=1|pages=97–114.

| publisher = Sage

| year = 2007

| location = London

}}

• {{cite journal

| last = Holt

| first = Douglas B.

| title = Does Cultural Capital Structure American Consumption?"

| journal=The Journal of Consumer Research|volume=25|number=1|date=June 1998|pages=1–25

}}

• {{cite book

| last = Horkheimer

| first = Max

| last2 = Adorno|first2= Theodor W

| title = Dialectic of the Enlightenment

| publisher = The Continuum publishing Corporation

| year = 1982

| location = New York

| url = https://archive.org/details/dialecticofenlig0000hork

| url-access = registration

| isbn = 0-8264-0093-0

}}

• {{cite journal|last=Koehrsen|first=Jens|title=Religious Tastes and Styles as Markers of Class Belonging|journal= Sociology|year=2018|doi=10.1177/0038038517722288|s2cid=149369482|url=https://edoc.unibas.ch/55612/1/20171003104102_59d34d1e5bedc.pdf}}
• {{cite book

| last = Outwaite

| first = William

|last2=Bottonmore|first2= Tom

| title = The Blackwell Dictionary of Twentieth-Century Social Thought

| publisher = Blackwell Publishers

| year = 1996

| location = Oxford

}}

• {{cite journal

| last = Simmel

| first = Georg

| title = Fashion

| journal = The American Journal of Sociology|volume=62|number=6|date=May 1957|pages=541–558

}}

• {{cite book

| last = Slater

| first = Don

| title = Consumer Culture and Modernity

| publisher = Polity Press

| year = 1997

| location = Cambridge

| isbn = 978-0-7456-0304-9}}

• {{cite web|url=https://iep.utm.edu/aesthetic-taste/|title=Aesthetic Taste|website=Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy|first=Michael R.|last=Spicher}}
• {{cite book | last=Stern | first=Jane | first2=Michael|last2= Stern | title=The Encyclopedia of Bad Taste | year=1990 | publisher=Harper Collins | location=New York | isbn=0-06-016470-0 | url-access=registration | url=https://archive.org/details/encyclopediaofba00ster }}
• {{cite book

| last = Vercelloni

| first = Luca

| title = The Invention of Taste. A Cultural Account of Desire, Delight and Disgust in Fashion, Food and Art

| publisher = Bloomsbury

| year = 2016

| location = London

| isbn = 978-1-4742-7360-2}}

{{refend}}

{{aesthetics}}

{{Virtues}}

{{Portal bar|Philosophy|Society}}

{{DEFAULTSORT:Taste (Sociology)}}

Category:Sociological terminology

Category:Concepts in aesthetics