Caning of Michael Fay

{{short description|1993–1994 Singaporean judicial sentence of an American teenager}}

{{Expert needed|1=Singapore|reason=Unclear narrative, verification of facts needed|date=May 2023}}

In 1994, a court in Singapore sentenced an American teenager, Michael Fay (born 30 May 1975),{{cite web |title=Michael Fay | website=National Library Board (Singapore)| date=October 2021 | url=https://www.nlb.gov.sg/main/article-detail?cmsuuid=61e0277e-fbeb-4ebc-88ea-8a9c58e13e05 | access-date=2025-01-13}} to be lashed six times with a cane for violating the Vandalism Act. This caused a temporary strain in relations between Singapore and the United States.{{cite news |first=Philip |last=Shenon |date=March 16, 1994 |newspaper=The New York Times |url= https://www.nytimes.com/1994/03/16/world/singapore-journal-a-flogging-sentence-brings-a-cry-of-pain-in-us.html |title=A Flogging Sentence Brings a Cry of Pain in U.S. |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20170823121533/http://www.nytimes.com/1994/03/16/world/singapore-journal-a-flogging-sentence-brings-a-cry-of-pain-in-us.html |archive-date=August 23, 2017 |url-status=live}}

Fay was arrested for stealing road signs and vandalizing 18 cars over a ten-day period in September 1993. Fay pled guilty, but he later claimed that he was advised that such a plea would preclude caning and that his confession was false, that he never vandalized any cars, and that the only crime he committed was stealing road signs. Although caning is a routine court sentence in Singapore, Fay's sentence garnered controversy and was widely covered in the media in the United States, as it was believed to be the first judicial corporal punishment involving an American citizen.{{cite news |title= Singapore Blasts Back at Clinton in Caning Case |newspaper=Los Angeles Times |date= March 9, 1994 |first= Charles P. |last= Wallace |url= https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1994-03-09-mn-31971-story.html |access-date= March 25, 2009 }} The number of cane strokes in Fay's sentence was ultimately reduced from six to four after United States officials requested leniency, and the sentence was carried out on May 5, 1994.

Early life

Fay's parents divorced when he was a child. After living with his father for a time, he was sent to Singapore to live with his mother and stepfather, where he was enrolled in the Singapore American School.

Theft and vandalism in Singapore

In September 1993, 67 cars were vandalized in various neighborhoods of Singapore. The damage included spray painting and being pelted with eggs, and at least one had its windshield smashed.

The Singapore police eventually arrested two teenagers who were driving a car similar to one that witnesses had described as being involved in the vandalism. During questioning, the two gave seven names, all male students from the Singapore American School and ISS International School, whom police tracked down and raided. They found about 50 stolen items, including a telephone booth and road signs.{{Cite news |last=Tan |first=Ooi Boon |date=October 7, 1993 |title=9 foreign students held for vandalism |pages=1 |work=The Straits Times |location= Singapore |url= https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/Digitised/Article/straitstimes19931007-1.2.6 |access-date=March 6, 2023}}

Fay was one of these students. He pleaded guilty to two counts of vandalism, referring to two cars that were spray-painted in a car park in mid-September, two counts of mischief, and one count of keeping 16 stolen items. Fay later claimed that he had been intimidated and threatened during the police interrogation, and maintained that he had been advised such a plea would preclude caning and that his confession was false, that he never vandalized any cars, and that the only crime he committed was stealing signs.{{cite news |url= https://www.corpun.com/sgju9404.htm#26056 |title= Overlooked Question in Singapore Caning Debate: Is the Teen-Ager Guilty? |work=The New York Times |date=April 17, 1994 |first=Philip |last=Shenon }}

Under the 1966 Vandalism Act, originally passed to curb the spread of political graffiti and which specifically penalized vandalism of government property,{{cite news |last=Reyes |first=Alejandro |date=May 25, 1994 |url= https://www.corpun.com/awfay9405.htm |title=Rough Justice: A Caning in Singapore Stirs Up a Fierce Debate About Crime And Punishment |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20190511182701/https://www.corpun.com/awfay9405.htm |archive-date=May 11, 2019 |work=Asiaweek |location= Hong Kong |url-status=live}} Fay was sentenced on March 3, 1994, to four months in jail, a fine of S$3,500 (at the time equivalent to US$2,230 or £1,450), and six strokes of the cane.{{cite news |first=Charles P. |last=Wallace |url= https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1994-03-04-mn-29913-story.html |title=Ohio Youth to be Flogged in Singapore |archive-url= |archive-date= |newspaper=Los Angeles Times |date=March 4, 1994 }}{{cite news| first=David |last=Watts |title=Singapore sentences American to caning |newspaper=The Times |location=London |url=https://www.corpun.com/sgju9403.htm#21566 |date=March 4, 1994}} Another student who pleaded not guilty was sentenced to eight months in prison and 12 strokes of the cane.{{cite news |first=Ian |last=Stewart |url= https://www.corpun.com/sgju9404.htm#3891 |title=Flogging for vandal |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20100920031803/http://corpun.com/sgju9404.htm |archive-date=September 20, 2010 |newspaper=South China Morning Post |location=Hong Kong |date=April 22, 1994 |url-status=live}}

Fay's lawyers lost on appeal after arguing that the Vandalism Act provided caning only for indelible forms of graffiti vandalism, and that the damaged cars had been cheaply restored to their original condition.{{cite news |first=Elena |last=Chong |url= https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/Digitised/Article/straitstimes19940401-1.2.4 |title=Fay loses appeal |archive-url= |archive-date= |newspaper=The Straits Times |location=Singapore |date=April 1, 1994 }}

Response

=Media and public reactions=

Following Fay's sentence, the case received coverage by the American, Singaporean and international media.{{cite news |title=Singapore Hosts Some Most Unruly Guests |work=American Journalism Review |date=August 1994 |url= http://ajr.org/article.asp?id=2093 |first=Rocco |last=Parascandola |access-date=February 24, 2007 |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20070930014537/http://ajr.org/article.asp?id=2093 |archive-date= September 30, 2007 |url-status=dead }}

Some US news outlets launched scathing attacks on Singapore's judicial system for what they considered an "archaic punishment", while others turned the issue into one of Singapore asserting "Asian values" towards "western decadence".{{cite news |first=Andrea |last=Stone |url= https://www.corpun.com/sgju9403.htm#21567 |title=Whipping penalty judged too harsh – by some |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20200617214944/https://www.corpun.com/sgju9403.htm#21567 |archive-date=June 17, 2020 |work=USA Today |location= Washington DC |date=March 10, 1994 |url-status=live}} The New York Times, The Washington Post and the Los Angeles Times ran editorials and op-eds condemning the punishment.{{cite news |url= https://eresources.nlb.gov.sg/newspapers/Digitised/Article/straitstimes19940408-1.2.46.6 |title=What US columnists say about Fay's caning |newspaper=The Straits Times |location= Singapore |date=April 8, 1994 |archive-url= |archive-date= |access-date=August 13, 2019 }} USA Today reported that the caning involved "bits of flesh flying with each stroke."{{cite news |url= https://www.corpun.com/usju9404.htm#02 |title=Don't copy Singapore |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20090208212700/http://www.corpun.com/usju9404.htm#02 |archive-date=February 8, 2009 |work=USA Today |location= Washington DC |date=April 5, 1994 |url-status=live}}

However, Singapore also found supporters among the foreign media and the US public. For example, Chicago Tribune columnist Mike Royko reported that he had been sent a large number of letters, nearly all of which supported the punishment.{{Cite news |date=April 2, 1994 |title='Joe Public' backs caning of American |first=David |last=Usborne |url= https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/joe-public-backs-caning-of-american-1367479.html |access-date=May 16, 2023 |website=The Independent |location= London}}{{Cite news |title=Readers get 'behind' flogging of vandal |date=March 30, 1994 |url= https://www.corpun.com/sgju9403.htm#3658 |first=Mike |last=Royko |work=Daily News |location= New York |access-date=May 18, 2023 |via=www.corpun.com}} A Los Angeles Times poll found that Americans were evenly divided (49% approved, 48% disapproved) as to the appropriateness of the punishment, but would have only been 36% in favor had the sentence been handed down inside the US.{{Cite news |last=Brownstein |first=Ronald |date=April 21, 1994 |title=Singapore's Caning Sentence Divides Americans, Poll Finds |url=https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1994-04-21-mn-48524-story.html |access-date=May 18, 2023 |website=Los Angeles Times |language=en-US}}

=From the United States government=

The Clinton administration ultimately expressed its objection to Singapore's decision to cane Fay. The official position of the United States government was that although it recognized Singapore's right to punish Fay within the due process of law, the punishment of caning was "excessive" for a teenager who committed a non-violent crime.

On March 3, 1994, the day the sentence was passed, {{em|chargé d'affaires}} Ralph Boyce at the United States Embassy in Singapore had also said that the punishment was too severe for the offence.{{cite news |first= Karen |last=Fawcett |url= https://www.corpun.com/sgju9403.htm#1199 |title= Americans in Singapore condemn caning for teen |work= USA Today |location= Washington DC |date= March 9, 1994 |access-date= March 25, 2009 |archive-date= June 19, 2008 |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20080619173801/http://www.corpun.com/sgju9404.htm#1199 |url-status= live }} The embassy claimed that, while the graffiti and physical damage to the cars was not permanent, caning could leave Fay with permanent physical scars.

Bill Clinton, the then-President of the United States, also called Fay's punishment "extreme" and "mistaken", and pressured the Singapore government to grant Fay clemency from caning. Two dozen United States senators signed a letter to the Singapore government also appealing for clemency.{{cite news |title= Responding to Clinton's Plea, Singapore Cuts 6 Lashes to 4 |work= The New York Times |date= May 5, 1994 |url= https://www.nytimes.com/1994/05/05/news/05iht-cane_0.html |last= Richardson |first= Michael |access-date= February 17, 2017 |archive-date= February 9, 2017 |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20170209061224/http://www.nytimes.com/1994/05/05/news/05iht-cane_0.html |url-status= dead}}

=From the Singapore government=

The Singapore government stood its ground and defended the sentence and the country's right to uphold its own laws. On March 3, in response to Boyce's comments on Fay's sentence, the Ministry of Home Affairs said that it was Singapore's tough laws that kept the country orderly and relatively crime-free, unlike "in cities like New York City, where even police cars are not spared the acts of vandals". Various Singaporean ministers also spoke publicly about the case throughout the episode. In April during a local television program, Lee Kuan Yew, then Senior Minister, said that the US was neither safe nor peaceful because it did not dare to restrain or punish those who did wrong, adding, "If you like it this way, that is your problem. But, that is not the path we choose."

Nevertheless, on May 4 that year, the Singapore government via Ong Teng Cheong, then the country's President, announced that the number of cane strokes would be reduced from six to four out of consideration for President Clinton as it valued the good historical relations between both countries.{{cite news |first=William |last=Branigin |url= https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1994/05/05/singapore-reduces-americans-sentence/1d28b069-749b-40ce-928e-1ac3f4aaa990/ |newspaper=The Washington Post |date=May 5, 1994 |title=Singapore Reduces American's Sentence |archive-url= |archive-date= }} The other student's sentence was later also reduced, from 12 strokes to six, after a similar clemency appeal. Fay was caned on May 5, 1994, at the Queenstown Remand Centre.{{cite news |first=Charles P. |last=Wallace |url= https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1994-06-22-mn-7134-story.html |title= Singapore Frees Flogged U.S. Teen-Ager |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20160513012208/http://articles.latimes.com/1994-06-22/news/mn-7134_1_michael-fay |access-date=May 13, 2016 |work=Los Angeles Times |date=June 22, 1994 |archive-date= May 13, 2016}}{{cite news |url=https://www.nytimes.com/1994/05/06/world/singapore-carries-out-the-caning-of-a-us-teen-ager.html |title= Singapore Carries Out Caning of U.S. Teenager |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20170424111829/http://www.nytimes.com/1994/05/06/world/singapore-carries-out-the-caning-of-a-us-teen-ager.html |archive-date=April 24, 2017 |first=Philip |last=Shenon |work=The New York Times |date=May 6, 1994}}

Caning

Describing the caning day, Fay told Reuters that he did not know the time had come for punishment when he was taken from his cell. He said he was bent over a trestle so his buttocks stuck out, with his hands and feet buckled to the structure. He was naked except for a protective rubber pad fixed to his back. The flogger, a doctor, and prison officials were also present. Fay told Reuters the caner walked sharply forward three steps to build power. "They go 'Count one'—you hear them yell it really loud—and a few seconds later they come, I guess I would call it charging at you with a rattan cane." Fay reported that when the fourth stroke was delivered he was immediately unbuckled from the trestle and taken to a cell to recover. The caning, which Fay estimated took one minute, left a "few streaks of blood" running down his buttocks, and seven weeks later, left three dark-brown scar patches on his right buttock and four lines each about half-an-inch wide on his left buttock. He said that the wounds hurt for about five days after which they itched as they healed. "The first couple of days it was very hard to sit," Fay reported, but he said he was able to walk after the caning.{{cite web |url=https://buffalonews.com/1994/06/26/teen-tells-of-scars-in-singapore-caning-fay-says-flogging-lasted-about-a-minute/ |title=Teen tells of scars in Singapore caning: Fay says Flogging Lasted about a minute |last=Arkus |first=Michael |date=June 25, 1994 |website=The Buffalo News |access-date=February 25, 2019 |archive-date=February 26, 2019 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20190226050023/https://buffalonews.com/1994/06/26/teen-tells-of-scars-in-singapore-caning-fay-says-flogging-lasted-about-a-minute/ |url-status=live }}

Aftermath

After his release from prison in June 1994, Fay returned to the United States to live with his biological father.{{cite news |url= https://www.corpun.com/sgju9406.htm#4308 |title=The Road From Singapore |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20150308093142/http://www.corpun.com/sgju9406.htm#4308 |archive-date=March 8, 2015 |newspaper= Daily News |location=New York |date=June 22, 1994 |url-status=live |via=www.corpun.com}} He gave several television interviews, including one with his American lawyer on CNN with Larry King on June 29, 1994, in which he admitted taking road signs but denied vandalizing cars.{{cite news |url= https://www.corpun.com/sgju9406.htm#4344 |title= Larry King Live |url-status=live |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20150308093142/http://www.corpun.com/sgju9406.htm#4344 |archive-date=March 8, 2015 |work=CNN |date=June 29, 1994}} While he did not detail his experience, he said that he was "ill-treated" at times during questioning, but had shaken hands with the caning operative after his four strokes had been administered and the prison guards when he was released.

Several months after returning to the United States, Fay suffered burns to his hands and face after a butane incident."Michael Fay," People Magazine, December 26, 1994, p. 60."Drug Rehab For Teen Caned in Singapore," Chicago Tribune, September 29, 1994, p. 14."The Nation," USA Today, Washington, D.C., September 29, 1994, p. 03A. He was subsequently admitted to the Hazelden rehabilitation program for butane abuse. He said that sniffing butane "made [him] forget what happened in Singapore.""Teen Punished in Singapore Has Drug Habit – Michael Fay Was Sniffing Butane," Times-Picayune, New Orleans, September 29, 1994, p. A24. In 1996, he was cited in Florida for a number of violations, including careless driving, reckless driving, not reporting a crash, and having an open bottle of alcohol in a car."Q&A," The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, October 13, 2003, p. B2. Later, in 1998, still in Florida, Fay was arrested for possession of marijuana and drug paraphernalia, charges to which he confessed but was acquitted{{cite news |url= http://www.csmonitor.com/1998/0409/040998.feat.feat.2.html |title=Boy Caned in Singapore Makes News Again |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20160624053457/http://www.csmonitor.com/1998/0409/040998.feat.feat.2.html |archive-date=June 24, 2016 |work=The Christian Science Monitor |location= Boston MA |first=Kerry A. |last=Flatley |date=April 9, 1998 |page=18}} because of technical errors in his arrest."Drug Charges Dropped," Asiaweek, Hong Kong, June 29, 1998, p. 1.

In June 2010, Fay's case was recalled in international news, after another foreigner in Singapore, Swiss national Oliver Fricker, was sentenced to five months in jail and three strokes of the cane for trespassing a rail depot to vandalise a metro train that is a part of the country's Mass Rapid Transit.{{cite news |title=Graffiti man faces Singapore caning |work=BBC News |date=June 25, 2010 |url=https://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/world/asia_pacific/10417167.stm |access-date=December 5, 2010 |archive-date=June 28, 2010 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20100628033833/http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/world/asia_pacific/10417167.stm |url-status=live }}

In popular culture

Season 19, episode 18 of Saturday Night Live cold-opened with a skit of Michael Fay's caning. The players included host Emilio Estevez as Fay, Kevin Nealon administering the caning, Rob Schneider as the warden, and Phil Hartman as the doctor.{{cite web |url=http://www.nbc.com/saturday-night-live/video/singapore-cold-open/2868162?snl=1 |title=Caning in Singapore Cold Open |author= |date=May 25, 2015 |website=NBC.com |publisher=NBCUniversal |access-date=March 30, 2018 |quote="Mr. Fay. I have some good news, and bad news." |archive-date=March 31, 2018 |archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20180331040837/http://www.nbc.com/saturday-night-live/video/singapore-cold-open/2868162?snl=1 |url-status=live }}
In September 1994, "Weird Al" Yankovic released the song "Headline News" (a parody of the Crash Test Dummies hit "Mmm Mmm Mmm Mmm"), which satirized the Fay case along with the Tonya Harding and John and Lorena Bobbitt stories.{{cite news |last=McDonald |first=Patrick |title=Magical Music |newspaper=The Seattle Times |date=December 1, 1994}}
In October 1994, Death Row Records released the soundtrack album Murder Was The Case, which contained the song "Natural Born Killaz", performed by Dr. Dre and Ice Cube, where Ice Cube references the incident in his second verse.{{cite web|author=Chuck Philips|url=https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1994-11-03-ca-58255-story.html|title=Snoop Doggy Dogg's Still Tops With Album Buyers : Pop music: His 'Murder Was the Case,' the soundtrack to a short film that premieres tonight, remains atop the charts.|date=November 3, 1994|work=Los Angeles Times|access-date=November 24, 2019}}
The case inspired a 1995 Simpsons episode, "Bart vs. Australia", in which Australia is to punish Bart via "booting"—a kick in the buttocks using a giant boot (later reduced to a shoe).{{cite video |people=Mirkin, David |date=2005 |title=The Simpsons season 6 DVD commentary for the episode "Bart vs. Australia" |medium=DVD |publisher=20th Century Fox}}
In the 1997 film One Eight Seven, Dave Childress (John Heard), a burned-out teacher, upon hearing that his co-worker Trevor Garfield (Samuel L. Jackson) was stabbed by a student, who was then sent to a juvenile facility, comments "They should've caned the bastard like they did that kid in Singapore." and quotes Lee Kuan Yew's statement in favor of caning.{{Cite web |title=One Eight Seven Movie Script |url= https://www.scripts.com/script.php?id=one_eight_seven_15238&p=4 |access-date=October 1, 2023 |website=www.scripts.com}}{{Cite news |title=Caning Case Prompts Look At Singapore's Tough Stand On Crime |work=The Seattle Times |url= https://archive.seattletimes.com/archive/?date=19940403&slug=1903663 |date=April 3, 1994 |access-date=September 30, 2023}}