Confusion Bowl
{{Short description|College football game}}
{{Use mdy dates|date=May 2025}}
{{Infobox sports rivalry
| wide = yes
| name = Confusion Bowl
| image =
| image_size = 200
| caption =
| team1 = Miami RedHawks
| team1logo = Miami Redhawks logo.svg
| team2 = Miami Hurricanes
| team2logo = Miami Hurricanes logo.svg
| sport = Football
| firstmeeting = October 26, 1945
Miami (FL), 27–13
| mostrecent = September 1, 2023
Miami (FL), 38–3
| nextmeeting = None scheduled
| total = 4
| series = Miami (FL), 4–0
| largestvictory = Miami (FL), 54–3 (1987)
| longeststreak = Miami (FL), 4 (1945–present)
| currentstreak = Miami (FL), 4 (1945–present)
}}
The Confusion Bowl is a nickname given to college football games played between the Miami RedHawks (formerly known as the Miami Redskins) of Miami University in Oxford, Ohio and the Miami Hurricanes of the University of Miami in Coral Gables, Florida.{{Cite web |last=Oates |first=Bob |date=1987-07-21 |title=MIAMI OF OHIO : A Coaching Factory : This University Is Renowned, Not Because of Its Testaverdes and Kosars, but Because of Its Parseghians and Schembechlers, etc. |url=https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1987-07-21-sp-5276-story.html |access-date=2023-08-23 |website=Los Angeles Times |language=en-US}} The schools, who have met four times, share the name "{{Linktext|Miami}}", leading the midwestern school to be referred to as "Miami of Ohio" and the Florida school to be regularly indicated in publications and polls as "Miami (FL)".{{Cite web |last=Moriarty |first=Morgan |date=2019-02-19 |title=The history of the Miami vs. Miami 'Confusion Bowl' |url=https://www.sbnation.com/college-football/2019/2/19/18231650/miami-florida-ohio-football-teams-name |access-date=2023-08-22 |website=SBNation.com |language=en}}{{OSM Location map
| coord = {{coord|34.675902|-82.831544}}
| zoom = 3
| width = 295
| height = 250
| caption = Locations of Miami (OH) and Miami (FL)
| mark1 = Red pog.svg
| label1 = Miami (OH)
| mark-coord1 = {{coord|39.508740|-84.734309}}
| label-pos1 = bottom
| label-color1 = black
| mark2 = Red pog.svg
| label2 = Miami (FL)
| mark-coord2 = {{coord|25.712214|-80.277096}}
| label-pos2 = top
| label-color2 = black
}}
History
Both universities have prestigious histories in college football, with Miami of Ohio's Redskins/RedHawks having produced some of the most successful football coaches of all time, earning it the nickname of the Cradle of Coaches, and the Hurricanes of Miami, Florida having won five national championships.
Although the two institutions share names, they have different namesakes. Miami University derives its name from its location in the Miami Valley area of Ohio, which was historically the homeland of the indigenous Miami people.{{cite web|url=http://www.miamioh.edu/documents_and_policies/bulletin06/gen_info/index.html|title=Miami University: Documents and Policies: General Bulletin|publisher=Miami University|access-date=2010-02-28}} The University of Miami gets its name from the city of Miami, Florida, which traces its own name back to Mayaimi, the historic name of Lake Okeechobee and the indigenous people that settled around it. The two Native American tribes have no relation to one another, and the similarity between their names is coincidental.
Concerns over confusion between the two universities predates the football games and began with the founding of the Florida institution in the 1920s. Alfred H. Upham, president of Miami University from 1928 to 1945, published a protest in the Ohio university's bulletin in February 1927. Upham wrote:
Presumably names of collegiate institutions are not copyrighted and these good citizens of Florida have the legal right to adopt such a name as they choose. But they certainly have not much moral right to usurp the name of a university which has established itself by more than a century of sound scholarship and effective educational service. . . .There are so many perfectly good names for a new and aspiring university. What justification or justice is there in appropriating one that has made its place in the academic world through more than a century of achievement?{{cite news|author=Katie Kapusta |title=Miami vs. Miami? That'll Be Confusing on Sept. 1st|publisher=Loveland Magazine|date=August 7, 2023|access-date=September 1, 2023|url=https://www.lovelandmagazine.com/miami-vs-miami-thatll-be-confusing-on-sept-1st/}}
The first football game between the schools was held in 1945 at Miami, Florida, and was dubbed the "Confusion Bowl" by The Atlanta Journal.{{cite news |author1=Ed Danforth |title=Miami to play Miami in Confusion Bowl |url=https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-atlanta-journal-miami-to-play-miami/130881780/ |access-date=29 August 2023 |work=The Atlanta Journal |date=12 August 1945 |page=19 |via=Newspapers.com}}{{open access}} The name gained traction as other newspapers also began calling the game the "Confusion Bowl", including the Logan Daily News and The Dayton Daily News.{{Cite web |author=Hugh Fullerton Jr. |title=Sports roundup |publisher=The Logan Daily News |date=26 Oct 1945 |page=7 |url=https://www.newspapers.com/image/86866640/ |access-date=22 August 2023 |via=Newspapers.com |language=en}}{{open access}}{{Cite web |title=Six eastern undefeated teams play |publisher=The Journal Herald |date=26 Oct 1945| page= 11 |url=https://daytondailynews.newspapers.com/image/391679716/ |access-date=23 August 2023 |agency=UP |via=Newspapers.com |language=en}}{{open access}} Miami (FL) won the 1945 game, 27–13, snapping Miami of Ohio's five-game winning streak.
When the Miami football teams played again in 1946, the name "Confusion Bowl" continued to be used,{{cite news |author1=Luther Evans |title=30,000 to see Confusion Bowl scuffle between Miami eleven |url=https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-miami-herald-30000-to-see-confusion/130881584/ |access-date=29 August 2023 |work=The Miami Herald |date=8 November 1946 |pages=1D, 3D |via=Newspapers.com}}{{open access}}{{cite news |author1=John Pennekamp |title=Up at Oxford they're building tradition for Confusion Bowl |url=https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-miami-herald-up-at-oxford-theyre-bu/130881320/ |access-date=29 August 2023 |work=The Miami Herald |date=28 October 1946 |page=6A |via=Newspapers.com}}{{open access}} with the Daily News having a section of their newspaper titled "Miami, O., 'Confusion Bowl' Loser" after Miami of Ohio again lost to the Miami Hurricanes, 20–17, in Florida.
The programs met again in 1987, and the Confusion Bowl monicker stuck,{{cite news |title=Miami plays Miami in 'Confusion Bowl' |url=https://www.newspapers.com/article/news-journal-miami-plays-miami-in-confu/130882298/ |access-date=29 August 2023 |work=Mansfield News Journal |agency=Associated Press |date=7 November 1987 |page=6C |via=Newspapers.com}}{{open access}} with Gannett's newswire joking "The lock of the week is that Miami is going to lose on Saturday". The Hurricanes won again, this time by a convincing 54–3 score, and went on to win the 1987 national championship.
The teams met again in the 2023 season opener.{{cite news|title=Miami vs Miami: The Confusion Bowl|publisher=Spectrum News|date=August 31, 2023|url=https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/news/2023/08/25/miami-vs-miami--the-confusion-bowl}}{{cite news |author=Susan Miller Degnan|title=Will the 'real Miami' please rise? Miami Hurricanes not biting other Miami's bravado|newspaper=Miami Herald|date=August 31, 2023|access-date=August 31, 2023|url=https://www.miamiherald.com/sports/college/acc/university-of-miami/article278772374.html}}{{closed access}} As a solution to the confusion, Miami of Ohio's veteran broadcaster Steve Baker said he would avoid references to "Miami" and instead refer to the RedHawks and Hurricanes.
Game results
{{sports rivalry series table
| series_summary = yes | legend_tie_text = | cols=1 | format = compact
| team1 = Miami OH
| team1style = {{NCAA color cell|Miami RedHawks}}
| team2 = Miami FL
| team2style = {{NCAA color cell|Miami Hurricanes}}
| October 26, 1945 | Miami, FL | Miami FL |27| Miami OH |13
| November 8, 1946 | Miami, FL |Miami FL| 20 | Miami OH | 17
| November 7, 1987 | Miami, FL | Miami FL | 54 | Miami OH | 3
| September 1, 2023 | Miami Gardens, FL | Miami FL | 38 | Miami OH | 3
References
{{Reflist |refs=
{{cite news |last=Miller |first=Glenn |agency=Gannett News Service |date=November 7, 1987 |title=Today's safest bet: Take Miami |url=https://www.newspapers.com/article/the-courier-journal-miami-confusion-bowl/130873994/ |work=The Courier-Journal |place=Coral Gables, Florida |publication-place=Louisville, Kentucky |access-date=August 29, 2023 |quote="It does get confusing," Hirsch said.}}
}}
{{Miami Hurricanes football navbox}}
{{Miami RedHawks football navbox}}