Dotty Fothergill

{{Infobox sportsperson

| name = Dotty Fothergill

| image = Dorothy Ann Fothergill.png

| caption = Fothergill in 1963

| full_name = Dorothy Ann Fothergill

| birth_date = c. {{birth year and age|1943}}

| birth_place =

| years_active =

| height =

| country = United States

| sport = Ten-pin bowling

| league =

| turnedpro =

| nationals =

}}

Dorothy Ann Fothergill (born c. 1943) is an American former left-handed ten-pin bowler who competed in the Professional Women's Bowling Association (PWBA). In a brief career that was cut short by injury, she won 12 titles on the PWBA Tour, including six major championships. She was named the Woman Bowler of the Year in 1968 and 1969, and defeated many top men's competitors in exhibition play. She sued the Professional Bowlers Association in 1970 when her application to compete in men's tournaments was rejected. She was inducted into the Women's International Bowling Congress (WIBC) Hall of Fame (later merged into the United States Bowling Congress Hall of Fame) in 1980. She was also one of the charter inductees into the PWBA Hall of Fame in 1995.

Early years

Fothergill was raised in North Attleboro, Massachusetts. She graduated from North Attleboro High School in 1963.North Attleboro High School 1963 yearbook, p. 34. Also in 1963, at age 18, she finished third in The Boston Globe's Ten Pin Tournament.{{cite news |title=Whitfield May Land Big Bout |newspaper=The Boston Globe |author=Herb Ralby |date=November 2, 1966 |page= |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69720196/fothergill/ |via=Newspapers.com}} She supported herself as a secretary at Walpole Lanes.{{cite news |title=Fails in 'Cap Singles, Qualifies in Scratch |newspaper=The Boston Globe |date=May 17, 1964 |page=72 |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69719309/fothergill/ |via=Newspapers.com}}

In 1966, she got a taste of her future success, finishing third at the WIBC doubles tournament in New Orleans.{{cite news |title=El Segundo Woman Second in WIBC Meet |newspaper=Los Angeles Times |date=May 30, 1966 |page=III-4 |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69720886/fothergill/ |via=Newspapers.com}} She also joined the PWBA Tour in 1966, acquiring sponsorship from Lincoln Lanes in Rhode Island. She won her first professional tournament at the PWBA Papago Phoenix Open in March 1967, winning $1,850 in prize money.{{cite news |title=Lefty Dot Fothergill Captures Pin Contest |newspaper=The Arizona Republic |author=Abe Gutierrez |date=March 20, 1967 |page= |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69721875/fothergill/ |via=Newspapers.com}} The following month, she tallied a record 2,409 in 12 games to win the women's division in the Sixth Annual Connecticut Cancer Bowlathon.{{cite news |title=Mrs. Fothergill, Hoestery, Sullivan Take 3 Top Bowlathon Honors |newspaper=The Hartford Courant |author=Max Liebman |date=April 3, 1967 |page=28 |url=}}

Bowler of the Year in 1968 and 1969

Fothergill's career peaked in 1968 and 1969, when she won seven PWBA titles, four of them majors. At ages 23 and 24, she was named woman Bowler of the Year in consecutive years by the Bowling Writers' Association of America (BWAA).{{cite news |title=Dotty Fothergill Bowler of Year |newspaper=The Capital Times |date=January 23, 1970 |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69175381/dotty-fothergill/ |via=Newspapers.com}} In 1968, she became the first woman bowler to win more than $10,000 in one season.{{cite news |title=Bay State Girl Bowler Favorite on Pro Circuit |newspaper=The Boston Globe |author=Jack Murphy |date=May 23, 1969 |page= |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69726147/bay-state-girl-bowler-favorite-on-pro/ |via=Newspapers.com}} A 1969 profile on Fothergill noted that, despite her tiny frame ({{convert|5|ft|1|in|cm}}, {{convert|110|lb|kg}}), she was able to throw a {{convert|16|lb|kg|adj=on}} ball with power and accuracy. The author compared her approach to "a hungry wolf after a lamb chop."

Her tournament victories during those years included:

May 1968 – She set an all-time WIBC record with a total score of 2,101 in nine games at the Schenectady Press tournament.{{cite news |title=A Pair of Queens |newspaper=The Morning Call |author=Chuck Pezzano |date=May 9, 1968 |page=35 |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69725352/a-pair-of-queens/ |via=Newspapers.com}}{{cite news |title=Amazing Miss Fothergill |newspaper=The Morning Call |author=Chuck Pezzano |date=June 6, 1968 |page= |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69725554/amazing-miss-fothergill/ |via=Newspapers.com}}
May 1968 – She won the Women's BPAA All-Star championship (later renamed the U.S. Women's Open) in Garden City, New York. She was the first woman to win in her first All-Star appearance and the first left-hander in the men's or women's division to claim an All-Star championship. Her average of 211.11 in 36 games was just short of the record of 211.47 set by Marion Ladewig in 1951.{{cite news |title=Highlights of Bowling |newspaper=The Hartford Courant |date=June 9, 1968 |page= |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69723633/highlights-of-bowling/ |via=Newspapers.com}}
August 1968 – She won the PWBA Championship tournament in Flint, Michigan, taking home $3,000 in prize money.{{cite news |title=Fothergill Keg Leader |newspaper=Arizona Republic |date=August 11, 1968 |page= |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69724374/fothergill/ |via=Newspapers.com}} She repeated as winner at the PWBA Championship in 1969.
May 1969 – For the second consecutive year, she won the BPAA All-Star championship held at Hialeah Lanes in Florida, becoming the first player to successfully defend her crown in this event since Marion Ladewig in 1954.{{cite news |title=Crowd-Pleasing Miss Bows Out in All-Star |newspaper=St. Louis Post-Dispatch |author=John J. Archibald |date=May 16, 1969 |page=5C |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/70128765/crowd-pleasing-miss-bows-out-in-all-star/ |via=Newspapers.com}}

In 1970, Fothergill appeared on the syndicated version of What's My Line?. Her status as a champion bowler was guessed by Werner Klemperer.

Lawsuit to compete in men's tournaments

Despite being the best female bowler, Fothergill's total earnings over a three-year period were less than the prize money for some single men's tournaments. A competitor finishing 20th in a men's tournament earned as much as the first-place finisher in a women's tournament.{{cite news |title=Dottie Applies For PBA Tour |newspaper=Naples Daily News |date=December 6, 1970 |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69750701/dottie-applies-for-pba-tour/ |via=Newspapers.com}} In May 1969, she noted that she might seek to compete in men's tournaments.{{cite news |title=Men's Bowling Offers New Area For Dotty Fothergill to Conquer |newspaper=The Miami Herald |author=Dick Evans |date=May 4, 1969 |page= |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69728455/mens-bowling-offers-new-area-for-dotty/ |via=Newspapers.com}} Her league and tournament averages were as good as 99% of the professional male bowlers. She also defeated many of the top men's bowlers, including Jim Stefanich (by 115 pins), Dick Weber (by 105 pins), Billy Hardwick (by 113 pins), and Dick Ritger (by 79 pins), in exhibition matches.

When she submitted an application to participate in the men's tournament, the executive board of the Professional Bowlers Association (PBA) voted to reject it. Fothergill recounted the reaction of male bowlers to her application: "A lot of pros have told me, 'Now listen, Dotty, if it were only you it wouldn't be bad at all. But if you get in, how many other women are going to try to do the same thing?{{nbsp}}... What would we tell our wives?' And I tell them, 'What do you tell your wives about the girls who travel the tour now and don't bowl?'"

Fothergill filed a lawsuit against the PBA seeking $2.5 million in damages on the grounds that the organization had deprived her of the ability to make a sufficient living based on her sex.{{cite news |title=$2 Million Up for Grabs |newspaper=The Sunday Home News |date=November 1, 1979 |page=C4 |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69750280/fothergill/}} The PBA responded with a countersuit seeking $6 million in damages for injury to its reputation and bringing "disastrous ridicule" to the organization.{{cite news |title=Dotty Fothergill Gets Fast Countersuit: Wanted Shot at Purses |newspaper=Miami Herald |author=Dick Evans |date=November 29, 1970 |page= |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69750502/dotty-fothergill-gets-fast-countersuit/ |via=Newspapers.com}}

Specifics as to the resolution of the suit are unclear, though one account published in 1993 indicated that Fothergill "found she had too many problems to continue the fight."{{cite news |title=Men's, women's tours needn't stay separated |newspaper=The Sunday Record |author=Chuck Pezzano |date=January 3, 1993 |page=S18 |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69751141/mens-womens-tours-neednt-stay/ |via=Newspapers.com}}

Later years

Fothergill continued to compete on the women's professional tour from 1970 to 1976. Between 1971 and 1973, she won four titles on the Professional Women's Bowlers Association tour, half of them majors. Her major titles came the WIBC Queens tournament in both 1972 and 1973. She became the second player at the time, and one of only four players all-time, to successfully defend a WIBC Queens title.

In 1970, Dotty won the all-events title in the Women's International Bowling Congress (WIBC) Open Championships, setting a WIBC record for a nine-game score in the event. She won WIBC doubles championships (with Mildred Martorella) in 1971 and 1973. She was also the only WIBC bowler to win national titles in singles, doubles, all-events, and Queens.{{cite news |title=WIBC Bowling Tournament |newspaper=Salt Lake Tribune |date=April 27, 1994 |page=D2 |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69751501/fothergill/ |via=Newspapers.com}}

Over the course of her career, Fothergill won a total of 12 titles in professional competition and another six titles in the WIBC Open Championships.

Fothergill sustained an arm injury in 1976 that ended her career as a competitive bowler at age 31.{{cite news |title=Dotty Fothergill elected to pin Hall of Fame |newspaper=Berkshire Eagle |date=November 27, 1979 |page= |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69751443/fothergill-hof/ |via=Newspapers.com}} The injury required surgery.{{cite news |title=Dottie strikes out with WIBC |newspaper=Akron Beacon-Journal |date=December 19, 1975 |page=58 |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/11398535/dotty-fothergill-strikes-out-with-wibc/ |via=Newspapers.com}}

In December 1979, Fothergill was voted into the WIBC Hall of Fame, and officially inducted in April 1980.{{cite news |title=Women bowlers named to Hall |newspaper=Ravalli Republic |date=December 19, 1979 |page=6 |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/69751219/women-bowlers-named-to-hall/ |via=Newspapers.com}}{{cite web |title=profile |publisher=USBC |work=bowl.com |accessdate=February 2, 2021 |url=https://www.bowl.com/Hall_of_Fame/Hall_of_Famers/Superior_Performance/Dorothy_Fothergill/}} She was also one of the charter inductees into the PWBA Hall of Fame in 1995.{{cite web |title=PWBA Hall of Fame (Inductees) |publisher=PWBA |accessdate=February 2, 2021 |url=https://pwba.com/Players/Hall-of-Fame}}{{cite news |title=First 10 elected to women's Hall of Fame |newspaper=Palm Beach Post |date=April 2, 1995 |page=16C |url=https://www.newspapers.com/clip/11398473/patty-costello-dotty-fothergill-elected/}}

She lived in later years in Center Ossipee, New Hampshire.

Professional titles

Major championships in bold text. (Source: 11thframe.com{{cite web |url=https://www.11thframe.com/pwba/tournaments?fbclid=IwAR3oI0Y0jkKqaQIh0ry5rjXMUIHgxm5qURt_Fl7vLUB6NuWZl3i0KAXnF2E |title=Women's Pro History |publisher=11thframe.com |accessdate=May 31, 2023}})