Down Will Come Baby

{{Infobox television

| image = Down Will Come Baby poster.jpg

| image_size =

| alt = The poster shows a happy family as seen through a camera lens; a creepy woman stands off to the side with a camera in hand.

| caption = Promotional poster

| genre = Thriller

| based_on = {{based on|Down Will Come Baby|Gloria Murphy}}

| teleplay = Gregory Goodell

| director = Gregory Goodell

| starring = {{plainlist|

}}

| music = Joseph Conlan

| country = United States

| language = English

| executive_producer = {{plainlist|

Renée Valente
Paulette Breen

}}

| editor = Paul Dixon

| cinematography = Tom Del Ruth

| runtime = 88 minutes

| company = Hearst Entertainment

| budget =

| network = CBS

| released = {{Start date|1999|05|04}}

}}

Down Will Come Baby is a 1999 American suspense thriller television film written and directed by Gregory Goodell, based on the 1991 novel of the same name by Gloria Murphy. The film tells the story of Leah (played by Meredith Baxter), a career woman who prioritizes work over her husband Marcus (Tom Amandes) and their young daughter Robin (Evan Rachel Wood). Leah accepts an out-of-state promotion that takes her away from her family, just as Robin is going through a difficult time following the accidental death of her friend at summer camp. The family's kindly new neighbor Dorothy (Diana Scarwid) steps in to help, but Leah suspects that Dorothy's seemingly innocent interest in her daughter belies a darker motive.

Down Will Come Baby was produced by Hearst Entertainment for CBS, following the network's adaptation of another one of Murphy's novels for the 1996 film Summer of Fear. The film was shot over 18 days in and around Phoenix, Arizona, from February to March 1999. Down Will Come Baby premiered on CBS on May 4, 1999, to negative reviews. Critics panned the film for its lurid depiction of child violence as well as its unflattering view on working mothers. It was watched by 11.4 million total viewers and was the 27th highest-rated prime time broadcast for its respective week.

Plot

Leah Garr is a workaholic whose career often takes her away from her home in Phoenix, Arizona, causing tension with her husband Marcus, who wants her to spend more time with her family. Tired of their constant fighting, the couple's 12-year-old daughter Robin insists on going away to summer camp. At camp, Robin befriends Amelia, an odd girl who lives with her abusive and controlling mother. One night, Robin decides to sneak off for a swim in a nearby lake and convinces Amelia to join her. Amelia is not a good swimmer and ends up drowning, leaving Robin ridden with guilt. Meanwhile, Leah accepts a big promotion that requires her to move to Denver, such that she only gets to see her family on the weekends.

While hanging out at the park, Robin is approached by a friendly stranger named Dorothy Cotton, who later turns out to be Robin's new neighbor. In Leah's absence, Dorothy ingratiates herself in Robin's life, offering to help look after the girl whenever Marcus is busy. Leah is suspicious of Dorothy's intentions, but Marcus reassures her that Dorothy is just trying to be a good friend. Dorothy encourages Robin to confide in her, and Robin admits that she blames herself for her friend Amelia's death. Dorothy shares that her younger sister was also named Amelia, who she claims accidentally fell to her death when they were playing in their attic as children. Robin becomes creeped out by Dorothy's increasingly obsessive behavior, which includes stalking her, rearranging her bedroom, and yelling at the girl when she does not follow her instructions to the letter. Robin shares her fears with Marcus, who thinks she is overreacting. Unbeknownst to the Garrs, Dorothy has also been listening in on their conversations through a baby monitor she hid in Robin's room.

Marcus is grateful when Dorothy agrees to stay over with Robin while he and Leah are out of town. While staying over, Dorothy's overbearing conduct gets on Robin's nerves. When the latter tries to call her mother to complain, Dorothy knocks her unconscious in a fit of rage. Leah and Marcus return home to find their daughter missing and they call the police after noticing blood on the doorframe. The worried couple convince their landlord to unlock Dorothy's barely lived-in apartment, where they find photographs of Robin's friend Amelia. The Garrs realize that Dorothy has been lying about her true identity, and that she is in fact the mother of Robin's deceased friend, who in turn was named after Dorothy's deceased sister. Meanwhile, Robin is being held captive in her late friend's bedroom by a delusional Dorothy, who believes that Robin is actually her daughter Amelia. Tired of waiting on the police, Leah and Marcus break into the summer camp's office, where they find out that Dorothy's real name is Gretchen McIntyre. They rush to Gretchen's address and arrive just in time to stop Gretchen from branding Robin with a hot iron as punishment for her disobedience. The police arrive shortly thereafter and Gretchen has a mental breakdown as she is taken into custody. On their way home, Leah announces that she is going to leave her job post in Denver to be with her family in Phoenix, much to Marcus and Robin's delight.

Cast

File:Meredith Baxter at the AIDS Project Los Angeles (APLA) benefit cropped and altered.jpg (pictured in 1990)]]

{{Cast listing|

Meredith Baxter as Leah Garr
Diana Scarwid as Dorothy Cotton a.k.a. Gretchen McIntyre
Tom Amandes as Marcus Garr
Evan Rachel Wood as Robin Garr
Katie Booze-Mooney as Amelia McIntyre
Kory Thompson as Calvin
Nicholas Glaeser as Detective Larkin
Warner McKay as Linus
Rahla Kahn as Sophie
Summer Patterson as Brina

}}

Production

File:Downtownphx.jpg (pictured in 2006)]]

Down Will Come Baby was written and directed by Gregory Goodell, based on the 1991{{cite magazine|title=Book Reviews: Fiction|last=Gifford|first=Judith A.|magazine=Library Journal|volume=116|issue=1|date=1991|pages=154–155|issn=0363-0277}} novel of the same name by Gloria Murphy.{{cite web|title=Thriller from Ringwood|url=https://www.proquest.com/docview/425033241|work=The Record|first=Jan|last=Barry|date=May 4, 1999|page=L03|access-date=August 24, 2022|id={{ProQuest|425033241}} }} It was produced by Hearst Entertainment for CBS, with Renee Valente and Paullette Breen serving as executive producers. The creative team also included Tom Del Ruth (director of photography), Paul Dixon (editor), and Joseph Conlan (composer). CBS had previously adapted another one of Murphy's novels, Simon Says (1994), into the 1996 television film Summer of Fear.{{cite web|url=https://www.proquest.com/docview/425037133|title=Ringwood novelist sues producers of TV movie|work=The Record|first=Jan|last=Barry|date=June 23, 1999|page=L03|access-date=August 20, 2022|id={{ProQuest|425037133}} }} While Murphy was unhappy with the previous adaptation, she approved of Goodell's adaptation of Down Will Come Baby, believing that his script stayed true to her original story and characters. There were some changes made for the film, such as the setting being switched from New England to Arizona.

Meredith Baxter said the role of Leah appealed to her because she could relate to the struggle of being a working mother.{{cite web|url=https://www.proquest.com/docview/237893183|title=Large circle of celebrities drawn to Radius|work=The Arizona Republic|date=March 10, 1999|page=B.8|first=Dolores|last=Tropiano|access-date=August 26, 2022|id={{ProQuest|237893183}} }} She was also drawn to the notion put forth in the script that even ordinary people can find themselves in extraordinary situations, noting that the film starts out following a very normal family before taking a sudden sinister turn. Having done her share of true crime television dramas, Baxter was pleased to be a part of a film that is based on a fictional story. She explained:

{{blockquote|This confirms that the networks are again ready and willing to accept stories made up by the magnificence of a writer's mind. For a long period of time, it seemed a script had to come from the headlines before it had any dramatic credibility.}}

The film was shot on location in Phoenix, Arizona, based out of the downtown area,{{cite web|url=https://www.proquest.com/docview/237892657|title=Phoenix is host to film for TV|work=The Arizona Republic|date=March 24, 1999|page=EV.11|last=Landau|first=Seth|access-date=August 25, 2022|id={{ProQuest|237892657}} }} from February to March 1999.{{cite news|title='Family Ties' star is coming here for 'Baby'|url=https://www.proquest.com/docview/237889583|first=Dolores|last=Tropiano|newspaper=The Arizona Republic|date=February 3, 1999|page=B.8|access-date=August 25, 2022|id={{ProQuest|237889583}} }}{{cite web|url=https://www.proquest.com/docview/237891115|title=Golf motivates snowbird Mackay|work=The Arizona Republic|date=March 28, 1999|page=B.10|first=Dolores|last=Tropiano|access-date=August 25, 2022|id={{ProQuest|237891115}} }} It was shot over 18 days in what Baxter described as a "pretty demanding" schedule.{{cite news|title=Dedicated delimma|newspaper=The Times of Northwest Indiana|date=May 2, 1999|first=Jay|last=Bobbin|agency=Tribune Media Services|page=7}} Several local Arizonan actors rounded out the supporting cast including Booze-Mooney, Thompson, Glaeser, and McKay.

Release and reception

Down Will Come Baby premiered on CBS on May 4, 1999, in the 9:00–11:00 pm time slot, as part of the network's season-ending "sweeps" line-up.{{cite web|last=Foley|first=Doug|date=April 29, 1999|title=Sweeping away|work=The Hamilton Spectator|url=https://www.proquest.com/docview/269965075|page=C.8|access-date=September 21, 2022|id={{ProQuest|269965075}} }} It was released on home video in the UK later that year by Odyssey Video.{{cite web|url=https://www.bbfc.co.uk/release/down-will-come-baby-q29sbgvjdglvbjpwwc00mdq5mjq|title=Down Will Come Baby|publisher=British Board of Film Classification|access-date=September 21, 2022|archive-date=August 31, 2022|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20220831155259/https://www.bbfc.co.uk/release/down-will-come-baby-q29sbgvjdglvbjpwwc00mdq5mjq|url-status=live}}{{cite news|first=Bob|last=Eborall|work=Ealing Leader|date=October 8, 1999|title=Video view: Cheaper classics|page=9}}

=Ratings=

The film earned a national Nielsen rating of 8.7, where each ratings point represents 994,000 households, making it the 27th highest-rated prime time broadcast for the week of May 3 to 9, 1999.{{cite news|url=https://www.proquest.com/docview/388306898|title=NBC's entries flood the week's top shows|agency=Associated Press|work=Sun-Sentinel|date=May 13, 1999|page=4E|access-date=August 20, 2022|id={{ProQuest|388306898}} }} Overall it was the 120th most-watched television film for the 1998{{endash}}1999 season, with a total of 11.4 million viewers.{{cite magazine|last=Rice|first=Lynette|title='98 Primetime 99 wrap-up|magazine=The Hollywood Reporter|volume=358|issue=1|date=May 28, 1999|page=65}}

=Critical response=

The Corpus Christi Caller-Times{{'}} Elaine Liner found that Down Will Come Baby plays out in such an uninspiring manner, that its only remarkable feature was having Baxter play a "good mom" in contrast to her usual "wack-job" roles. Given its depiction of brutality against a minor, Liner also thought it was irresponsible of CBS to broadcast the film just two weeks after the Columbine High School massacre.{{cite web|last=Liner|first=Elaine|date=May 4, 1999|title=Sweeps stinker: CBS' 'Down will come baby' is as bad as it gets|work=Corpus Christi Caller-Times|url=https://www.proquest.com/docview/2572109883|access-date=September 21, 2022|page=B.7|id={{ProQuest|2572109883}} }} Similarly, The Washington Post{{'s}} Tom Shales and The Times-Picayune{{'s}} Benjamin Morrison both condemned the film for stoking parental fears with its gratuitous depiction of child violence.{{cite news|url=https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1999/05/04/down-will-come-baby-daddy-dimwit/5ee09903-20e6-4f41-9a47-3f5419aa4553/|title='Down Will Come Baby': Daddy Dimwit|newspaper=The Washington Post|date=May 4, 1999|authorlink=Tom Shales|first=Tom|last=Shales|access-date=August 20, 2022|archive-url=https://archive.today/20220820110115/https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1999/05/04/down-will-come-baby-daddy-dimwit/5ee09903-20e6-4f41-9a47-3f5419aa4553/|archive-date=August 20, 2022|url-status=live}}{{cite news|last=Morrison|first=Benjamin|date=May 2, 1999|title=Been 'Down' so long it looks like up to me|work=The Times-Picayune|page=T10}} Despite his criticisms, Morrison acknowledged that the film was "effective and occasionally well-handled", with an engaging plot and cast; although he felt that its constant gloom ultimately made for an unpleasant viewing experience.

In The Scranton Times-Tribune, Faye Zuckerman opined that any potential for a compelling story was quickly discarded by the filmmakers in favor of typical horror fare. She compared Down Will Come Baby unfavorably to the 1992 film The Hand That Rocks the Cradle, noting the lurid violence displayed in both.{{cite news|title='Baby' turns family morality tale into horror film|work=The Scranton Times-Tribune|first=Faye|last=Zuckerman|agency=New York Times Syndicate|date=May 4, 1999|page=C5}} Variety{{'s}} Laura Fries found the cast to be adequate, highlighting Wood as the steadiest performer, but did not think their performances were enough to elevate the film from "a hodgepodge script and so many plot holes".{{cite web|url=https://variety.com/1999/tv/reviews/down-will-come-baby-1117499719/|title=Down Will Come Baby|work=Variety|date=May 4, 1999|first=Laura|last=Fries|access-date=August 20, 2022|archive-date=August 20, 2022|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20220820103129/https://variety.com/1999/tv/reviews/down-will-come-baby-1117499719/|url-status=live}} New York magazine's John Leonard highlighted Scarwid's unrestrained performance, but was otherwise unimpressed with what he considered to be a "by-the-numbers" production.

Reviewers also took issue with the apparent moral that sees Leah learning to cast aside her career to focus on being a mother and wife.{{cite journal |last=Leonard |first=John |authorlink=John Leonard (critic) |date=May 10, 1999 |title=Down Will Come Baby |journal=New York|volume=32 |issue= 18 |page=117 |issn= 0028-7369}} Morrison suggested that Marcus should have been the one to re-evaluate his behavior instead. Shales, who was especially annoyed by the "simpering" Marcus throughout the film, emphatically stated that the Garr family's problems were really the result of Marcus' foolish ignorance rather than Leah's career ambitions as the script asserted. Fries was critical of Goodell's unflattering treatment of the adult female characters as a whole, noting that they were pigeonholed as either being dedicated to their careers or to their families, with the underlying implication that women who forsake their maternal duties deserve to be punished. Susan Stewart's review in TV Guide Magazine concluded that "the real horror is that movies like this are still made in the era of two-income families".{{cite journal |last=Stewart |first=Susan |date=May 1, 1999 |title=Down Will Come Baby |journal=TV Guide Magazine|volume=47 |issue= 18 |page=55 |issn= 0039-8543}}

=Accolades=

For her performance as Robin, Wood was nominated for the YoungStar Award for Best Young Actress in a Miniseries/Made for TV Film.{{cite magazine|title=Merriman, Wylie head of YoungStar's class of '99|magazine=The Hollywood Reporter|last=Kit|first=Zorianna|volume=359|issue=21|date=September 3, 1999|page=4|issn=0018-3660}}