Elizabeth Marsh

Marsh moved to Gibraltar to board a ship on 28 July 1756, intending to join her fiancé back home and marry him. After the Ann was "unhappily deserted" by the Gosport, it was easily taken on 8 August by a Moroccan corsair of about 20 guns and 130 seamen, then carried to Salé. The captives were "conducted" to Marrakech and Marsh started to hate the idea of being sexually harassed. She had decided to disguise herself as the wife of a James Crisp, a merchant from London, in her narrative of the story. However, he is actually the ship's captain in the letters he sent out.{{clarify|date=April 2025}} After being presented to the Prince Sidi Mohammed, everything went downhill for Marsh. She was importuned to be the Prince's concubine, tricked into renouncing her Christianity and converting to Islam, and almost beaten into submission. After four months and with resumed peace talks with Morocco, Marsh gained her coveted liberty and returned home.

Marsh does not often show how she feels in her captive narrative, The Female Captive, about what is happening to her at the time she is being held captive. However, she does make sure to show the very little interest that she has in doing anything that the Prince Sidi Mohammed asks her to do. She repeatedly says she would prefer death to doing any sexual favors being asked. People judge her for using manipulation in her narrative,{{clarify|date=April 2025}} even if she used them for her own survival. Marsh uses the powerful dependent tactic, the constant victim tactic, and the multiple offender tactic{{clarify|date=April 2025}}{{Cite web|url=https://www.therapyideas.net/manipulation.htm|title=Manipulation & Relationship Triangles|last=Sommer|first=Rhoda Mills|website=Therapy Ideas|access-date=16 April 2019|archive-date=16 April 2019|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20190416212616/https://www.therapyideas.net/manipulation.htm|url-status=dead}} to help her survive as a captive. In The Female Captive it is said, "Despairing of cowing his hostage into submission, the Prince grudgingly granted her freedom and permission to leave the country, yet not before Britain formally agreed to resume peace talks with Morocco." This statement shows the powerful dependent tactic coming into play. The rest of the narrative gives many examples of Marsh using manipulation for her own survival.

Despite Marsh's position as an enslaved woman, she still holds power over her fellow white male captives, since whenever she desires an accommodation, she receives one. Her narrative is marked by her ability to evade the humiliating conditions and hard labor the male captives endured and, rather, how she was treated with care, and leisurely made her way through her time spent as a captive. Marsh had a dichotomous, paradoxical enslavement, in that she was technically a captive, yet was not enslaved the way the men were.{{Cite book|title=In the hands of savages : representations of female Barbary captivity in Anglo-American narratives, 1722–1818|last=Pal, Julie|oclc=65184251}} She was never given duties as harsh as those of the men, and could skew a situation in her favor by highlighting the fact that she was a woman. Marsh's complaints throughout the narrative can be read as reminders to those around her that she knew how she would be treated, thus implying that she understood her placement in the hierarchy of power among captives and used it to her advantage. When she needed the passivity to work in her favor, she did so to remain innocent and chaste, and when she needed the agency to get what she wanted, she did so in defiance and entitlement. Contrary to the males, female captives seemed to be given a chance to travel, self-reliance and assertiveness, and non-domestic work opportunities.{{Cite book|title=Women's orients : english women and the middle east, 17181918|last=Melman, Billie|date=2014|publisher=Palgrave Macmillan|isbn=978-1349101597|oclc=935188316}}{{pn|date=July 2022}} The Female Captive is a testament to how women in captivity narratives, particularly Marsh, used their femininity and sexuality to their benefit in order to bypass situations and pad their position. The book provides an alternative lens on the traditional, male slave tales.

Slavery was a part of Arab culture before the Qur’an.{{clarify|date=April 2025}}{{Cite book|title=Black Morocco|last=El Hamel|first=Chouki|publisher=Cambridge University Press|year=2013|pages=17–18}} It was a part of society that contributed to the financial stability and day-to-day lives of many people throughout the Arab world. While slavery was an accepted practice from the beginning, the idea of concubines was based more on individual interpretations of the Qur'an. Only slaves could become concubines, which led to the practice of enslaving women from other cultures for that purpose. While popular culture spread the idea of the harem to the Western world, the practice was largely confined to the wealthy. The practicalities of taking care of a large number of women were too much for the everyday man of the time to even consider.{{Cite book|title=Women and Gender in Islam: Historical Roots of a Modern Debate|last=Ahmed|first=Leila|publisher=Yale University Press|year=1992|page=107}}

The term "harem" referred not only to wives and concubines, but all other female members of the household, including children and domestic slaves. Screened from male view, the harem became a source of mystery and rumor for Europeans. This was enhanced due to the fact that male writers, many of whom purported to have knowledge of the harem, gave hugely exaggerated accounts. Thomas Pellow, who was enslaved for 23 years in Morocco, claimed that the harem of Moulay Ismail had eight thousand wives living in it. While European narratives about harems were largely exaggerated accounts given by men who had no access to them, evidence exists that points to abuse, poisonings, and women being sold when they started aging or their appearance started to decline.

Elizabeth Marsh faced scrutiny after returning home after her captivity. She stated in the author's note of The Female Captive, "Though I have unhappily seldom experienced those Hours [of Ease and Tranquility], who may say, with too much Truth, that the Misfortunes I met with in Barbary have been more equalled by those I have since experienced, in this Land of Civil and Religious Liberty."{{Cite book|title=White women captives in North Africa : narrative of enslavement, 1735–1830|date=2011|publisher=Palgrave Macmillan|author=Bekkaoui, Khalid.|isbn=9780230221987|location=Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire|page=124|oclc=428030675}}

Ssuspicion arose regarding the maintenance of her chastity while in captivity due to her many visits with the sultan. At the time, influential members of European society believed that women could be easily persuaded to undertake various actions thanks to the exotic allure of the Orient. These ideas were encouraged by the publication of a translated version of The Arabian Nights by French orientalist Antoine Galland (an English version of the book was first published in 1795, although French copies were available to Marsh).{{Cite book|title=The Arabian nights in historical context : between East and West|last=Bekkaoui|first=Khalid|date=2008|publisher=Oxford University Press|others=Makdisi, Saree., Nussbaum, Felicity.|isbn=9780191564963|location=Oxford|pages=153–66|oclc=302348441}}{{pn|date=July 2022}}

Even though almost two-thirds of all slaves brought into the Islamic world were female, female captive narratives were scrutinized more than captive narratives written by men. The argument against the legitimacy of captive narratives by women was rooted in the presumably-inherent feminine weakness that was believed to prevent women from resisting the opulence of the Orient.{{cite book |doi=10.1093/acrefore/9780190277734.013.99 |chapter=Prisoners, Ransoms, and Slavery in the Maghrib |title=Oxford Research Encyclopedia of African History |year=2018 |last1=Hopley |first1=Russell |isbn=978-0-19-027773-4 }} Marsh faced this criticism when she returned home, preventing her from publishing her narrative due to fear of the backlash it would cause. Even with her aforementioned display of strength when faced with Sultan Sidi Mohammad Ben Abdallah's offer of concubinage, she was accused of being a liar and giving up her virtue to him.{{Cite book|title=White women captives in North Africa : narrative of enslavement, 1735–1830|date=2011|publisher=Palgrave Macmillan|author=Bekkaoui, Khalid |isbn=9780230221987|location=Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire|oclc=428030675}}{{pn|date=July 2022}}

Marsh displayed multiple symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder. She exhibited loneliness, emotional detachment from herself and those around her, and distrust. Telling her story was a way for Marsh to digest what had happened to her and how to cope with it, even if she was pressured into writing about it.

Post-traumatic stress disorder is a key part of understanding why Marsh wrote her story. Some critics of these slave narratives claim that what she wrote was not the truth. Any manipulation of her story might indicate that she was focusing on handling PTSD without even being aware it was happening. The awareness of mental disorders and disease is a new area of health that has only started to come to light in recent years. For a woman to branch out and write about her traumatic experiences was unusual.{{Cite book|title=Trauma, ethics, and the Political beyond PTSD|last=Bisoten|first=Gregory}}{{pn|date=July 2022}}

After her captivity, Marsh married James Crisp, the man that she had pretended to be married to while a slave. She had done so in the hopes that she would not be assaulted by the other men she was traveling with. This succeeded, but the validity of her marriage was called into question after her release. After insistence from her parents, Marsh married Crisp and had two children with him.

Marsh's life took a turn when she left from her family for 18 months. It could be argued that Marsh did this as a result of her time in captivity and was making an attempt to live life independently.{{fact|date=July 2022}}

The largest impact that Marsh's captivity had on herself was likely the production and publication of her narrative. Though it was originally published anonymously, word traveled that she was the author. Her narrative became one of the most consumed female slavery narratives as well as one of the few to withstand time.

{{reflist}}

• {{cite journal |last1=Colley |first1=Linda |title=One life reveals a global history |journal=RSA Journal |date=2007 |volume=154 |issue=5531 |pages=38–43 |jstor=41380537 }}
• {{cite book |last1=Hanna |first1=Mark G. |title=Pirate Nests and the Rise of the British Empire, 1570–1740 |date=2015 |publisher=UNC Press Books |isbn=978-1-4696-1795-4 |jstor=10.5149/9781469617954_hanna }}
• [https://www.jjhc.info/crispelizabeth1785 www.jjhc.info Family history website showing links to relatives]

{{authority control}}

{{Slave narrative| state=expanded}}

{{DEFAULTSORT:Marsh, Elizabeth}}

Category:1735 births

Category:1785 deaths

Category:18th-century English memoirists

Category:18th-century English women writers

Category:18th-century slaves

Category:Barbary Wars

Category:Moroccan slaves

Category:English women memoirists

Category:Writers of slave narratives

Category:Slaves of the Barbary Coast