Godwin Sule
{{Use dmy dates|date=September 2020}}
{{short description|Sudanese-Ugandan military officer}}
{{Infobox military person
|name = Godwin Sule
|image =
|image_upright =
|alt =
|caption =
|birth_name =
|nickname =
|birth_date =
|birth_place = Southern Sudan
|death_date = 11 March 1979
|death_place = Near Lukaya, Uganda
|placeofburial =
|placeofburial_coordinates =
|allegiance = Anyanya
{{flag|Uganda}}
|branch = Uganda Army
|serviceyears = ? – 1979
|rank = Lieutenant Colonel{{efn|name=rank|Most sources state that Sule was still a lieutenant colonel at the time of his death,{{sfn|Otunnu|2016|p=296}}{{sfn|Reid|2017|p=70}} but researcher Thomas Lowman described him as "general".{{sfn|Lowman|2020|p=179}} }}
|unit =
|commands = Malire Battalion
Uganda Army Air Force
Paratroopers Military School
|battles = {{tree list}}
{{tree list/end}}
|awards =
|spouse =
|children =
|relations =
}}Godwin Sule (died 11 March 1979) was a high-ranking Sudanese-born Ugandan military officer who held important commands in the Uganda Army during the dictatorship of President Idi Amin. A native of southern Sudan, he fought as a rebel in the First Sudanese Civil War before migrating to Uganda. There he rose to command the Malire Battalion and later the Paratroopers Military School. Regarded as one of the most talented soldiers in the Uganda Army during Amin's rule, Sule was tasked with leading the last major Ugandan counter-offensive during the Uganda–Tanzania War of 1978–79. This operation culminated in the Battle of Lukaya of 10–11 March 1979, during which Sule was killed under unclear and disputed circumstances. His death resulted in the collapse of the Ugandan offensive, contributing to the eventual overthrow of Amin's regime.
Biography
= Rebel activity and rise in the Uganda Army =
Sule originated from southern Sudan.{{sfn|Otunnu|2016|p=296}}{{sfn|Smith|1980|p=131}} He was Christian{{cite web |url=https://www.monitor.co.ug/Magazines/PeoplePower/How-Amin-s-commander-betrayed-Ugandan-fighters-to-Tanzanians/689844-1747480-fubx8g/index.html |title=How Amin's commander betrayed Ugandan fighters to Tanzanians |first=Jaffar Rembo |last=Amin |website=Daily Monitor |date=14 April 2013 |access-date=3 February 2019 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20181219051029/https://www.monitor.co.ug/Magazines/PeoplePower/How-Amin-s-commander-betrayed-Ugandan-fighters-to-Tanzanians/689844-1747480-fubx8g/index.html |archive-date=19 December 2018 |url-status=live }}{{sfn|Smith|1980|p=131}} as well as an ethnic Sudanese-Nubian{{sfn|Lowman|2020|p=179}}{{sfn|Smith|1980|p=131}} and/or Kakwa.{{sfn|Reid|2017|p=70}} At some point, he joined the Anyanya rebels to fight against the Sudanese government in the First Sudanese Civil War. Sule eventually fled Sudan,{{sfn|Otunnu|2016|p=296}} and moved to Uganda, where he joined the Uganda Army, and rose in the ranks. His case was not uncommon, as many Sudanese rebels opted to join the Uganda Army instead of laying down their weapons in Sudan. President Amin regarded the ex-Anyanya troops as loyal to his government and therefore useful, although they factually acted as mercenaries.{{sfn|Hansen|1977|p=110}}
In January 1974, Sule was promoted from major to lieutenant colonel{{cite news|title= Uganda: Military Appointments |volume=Summary of World Broadcasts: Non-Arab Africa. No. 4490| newspaper = BBC| page = 5| date = January 1974| url = https://books.google.com/books?id=oQksAQAAIAAJ}}{{efn|name=rank}} and appointed commander of the Uganda Army's Malire Battalion. In that year, he and Air Force quartermaster Zeddy Maruru were sent to Europe by President Amin to assess the state of Uganda's embassies and the living situation of Ugandan exchange students. While there, the two heard stories of how Prince Mutebi had fought off an assassin who had attacked another student. Upon returning to Uganda, the two recommended that Amin recruit the prince into the Uganda Army, as they were impressed by his bravery.{{cite web| url = https://www.newvision.co.ug/new_vision/news/1511184/amin-related-prince-mutebi| title = How Amin Related with Prince Mutebi| date = 25 November 2019| website = New Vision|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20191129001740/https://www.newvision.co.ug/new_vision/news/1511184/amin-related-prince-mutebi |archive-date=29 November 2019 }}
In 1976 Sule served as commander of Entebbe Air Base{{sfn|Rwehururu|2002|p=76}} and acting commander of the Uganda Army Air Force.{{cite news| title = Magembe book tells how Amin was declared 'Life President of Uganda'| newspaper = The Observer| date = 10 April 2021| url = https://observer.ug/lifestyle/69226-magembe-book-tells-how-amin-was-declared-life-president-of-uganda| access-date = 19 April 2021}} He was not present at the facility during Operation Entebbe—a nighttime Israeli attack which destroyed a significant portion of the Uganda Army Air Force—having left early to meet a female companion at Lake Victoria Hotel. Uganda Army Chief of Staff Mustafa Adrisi reportedly wanted to incarcerate or execute Sule for his lapse in responsibility, but his closeness to Amin guaranteed his safety.{{sfn|Rwehururu|2002|p=76}} From at least 1977{{sfn|Smith|1980|p=131}} to his eventual death in combat, he headed the Paratroopers Military School in Uganda's capital Kampala.{{cite web| url = https://www.newvision.co.ug/new_vision/news/1207589/ugandas-paratroopers| title = He was one of Uganda's best paratroopers| last = Mugisa| first = Anne| date = 14 August 2009| website = New Vision|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20170227085827/https://www.newvision.co.ug/new_vision/news/1207589/ugandas-paratroopers |archive-date=27 February 2017 }}{{cite web| url = https://www.monitor.co.ug/SpecialReports/How-Idi-Amin-rescued-his--children-from-Kabale/688342-1752984-l8deedz/index.html| title = How Idi Amin rescued his children from Kabale| last = Amin| first = Jaffar Remo| date = 20 April 2013| website = Daily Monitor| access-date = 23 March 2020}}
= Uganda–Tanzania War =
In late 1978, the Uganda–Tanzania War broke out under unclear circumstances.{{sfn|Lowman|2020|pp=176–177}} After an initial Ugandan invasion of Tanzanian territory was defeated,{{sfn|Avirgan|Honey|1983|pp=67–69}} the Tanzania People's Defence Force (TPDF) launched a counter-invasion and overran the border town of Mutukula on 21–22 January 1979.{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|p=29}} Although the garrison had been promised immediate reinforcements, these never arrived. Shortly after the battle, Sule and Brigadier Taban Lupayi arrived with a helicopter at nearby Sanje, to where the Mutukula garrison had retreated. They informed the local commander, Bernard Rwehururu, that the reinforcements had halted in Lukaya, {{convert|120|km|mi}} to the north. This information was received badly by the local troops; Sule sensed that the soldiers could possibly revolt and instructed Lupayi to order the reinforcements to advance so that they could relieve Rwehururu's men. Regardless, the troops remained restive. A warrant officer informed Lupayi that some angry infantrymen might be tempted to shoot the officers, causing Sule and Lupayi to quickly leave in their helicopter.{{cite news|url=http://www.nationaudio.com/News/EastAfrican/15042002/Features/Magazine3.html|title=Fighting for Amin|newspaper=The East African|date=8 April 2002|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20080308114206/http://www.nationaudio.com/News/EastAfrican/15042002/Features/Magazine3.html|archive-date=8 March 2008|access-date=13 May 2019}} In the next months, the Uganda Army was repeatedly defeated by the TPDF and allied Ugandan rebels.{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|pp=29–32}}
In an attempt to reverse the Tanzanian victories, Amin placed Sule in charge of a large-scale counter-offensive that included Ugandan units as well as allied Libyan and Palestine Liberation Organisation forces.{{sfn|Lowman|2020|p=179}}{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|pp=33–34}} At the time, Sule was regarded as one of the Uganda Army's most competent commanders.{{cite web| url = https://www.monitor.co.ug/Magazines/PeoplePower/How-bar-fight-sparked-the-1979-Uganda--Tanzania-war/689844-3002788-12ob9gk/index.html| title = How bar fight sparked the 1979 Uganda - Tanzania war| last = Mugabe| first = Faustin| date = 20 December 2015| website = Daily Monitor| access-date = 7 February 2019| archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20190209125604/https://www.monitor.co.ug/Magazines/PeoplePower/How-bar-fight-sparked-the-1979-Uganda--Tanzania-war/689844-3002788-12ob9gk/index.html| archive-date = 9 February 2019| url-status = live| df = dmy-all}} While most foreign-born soldiers in the Uganda Army proved to be unreliable and unmotivated during the conflict,{{cite web| last = Golooba-Mutebi | first = Frederick | url = https://www.theeastafrican.co.ke/oped/434748-1137972-yudf18/index.html | title = Elite troops turn paper tigers again as Gaddafi's Touaregs melt into the sands | website = The EastAfrican | date = 4 April 2011 | access-date = 14 October 2018}} Sule was genuinely interested in driving the TPDF from Uganda. He emphasized mobile assaults instead of the previous defensive tactics of the Uganda Army,{{sfn|Reid|2017|p=70}} and personally led the operation. The initial offensive of the Ugandan-Libyan-Palestinian force targeted Lukaya, overwhelming the Tanzanian defenders and retaking the town on 10 March 1979. On the next day, the Tanzanian-led forces launched a counter-attack, surprising the Ugandan-led troops and driving them back.{{sfn|Avirgan|Honey|1983|p=91}}{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|pp=33–34}} Sule attempted to rally his troops, assuming command of several tanks and driving toward the frontline.{{cite web| url = https://www.monitor.co.ug/SpecialReports/Tanzanians-found-Amin---men-weak---Col-Kisuule/688342-2325484-yc2hibz/index.html| title = Tanzanians found Amin men weak - Col Kisuule| last = Lubega| first = Henry| date = 25 May 2014| website = Daily Monitor| access-date = 23 January 2019| archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20190124102143/https://www.monitor.co.ug/SpecialReports/Tanzanians-found-Amin---men-weak---Col-Kisuule/688342-2325484-yc2hibz/index.html| archive-date = 24 January 2019| url-status = live| df = dmy-all}} He was subsequently killed amid the fighting. His death prompted the collapse of the Ugandan command structure, and the remaining Ugandan troops abandoned their positions and fled, allowing the Tanzanians to secure the town.{{sfn|Rwehururu|2002|p=126}}
The circumstances surrounding Sule's death remain unclear. Lieutenant Colonel Rwehururu overheard conflicting radio reports that Sule had either been killed by enemy fire or had been crushed by one of his tanks. When Rwehururu asked for clarification, he was told that he should focus on his own affairs, and the radio in Lukaya was subsequently turned off.{{sfn|Rwehururu|2002|p=125}} When another Ugandan commander at Lukaya, Abdu Kisuule, could not determine Sule's whereabouts, he asked Amin to instruct soldiers to look for his corpse among the bodies brought back to Kampala. Amin later told him that Sule was found among them, his face crushed. Amin's son, Jaffar Rembo, claimed that Sule was shot from behind in a "so-called 'friendly fire'{{tsp}}" incident. According to journalist Faustin Mugabe, other "insiders" have said that his death was "treacherous". Lieutenant Muzamir Amule dismissed these claims and supported the assertion that Sule was crushed by one of his tanks, and that this was not understood until the day after the battle. He stated that the commander had been directing tank fire at the Tanzanian positions when it was still dark, resulting in his accidental death when a tank reversed to circumnavigate a ditch. In contrast, researcher Richard J. Reid stated that Sule was "apparently killed by his own mutinous troops".{{sfn|Reid|2017|p=70}}
Sule's death had a detrimental impact on the Uganda Army{{cite web| url = https://www.newvision.co.ug/new_vision/news/1336873/katonga-bridge-jewel-liberation| title = Katonga bridge, the jewel of the liberation| last = Kato| first = Joshua| date = 23 January 2014| website = New Vision| access-date = 12 October 2019| archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20190123010515/https://www.newvision.co.ug/new_vision/news/1336873/katonga-bridge-jewel-liberation| archive-date = 23 January 2019| url-status = live| df = dmy-all}} which disintegrated after the Battle of Lukaya.{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|p=34}} Amin was overthrown when Tanzanian-led forces captured Kampala in April 1979.{{sfn|Cooper|Fontanellaz|2015|pp=36–37}}
Notes
{{notelist}}
References
{{reflist}}
= Works cited =
{{refbegin}}
- {{cite book| last1 = Avirgan| first1 = Tony| last2 = Honey| first2 = Martha| title = War in Uganda: The Legacy of Idi Amin| location= Dar es Salaam|publisher = Tanzania Publishing House| date = 1983| url = https://books.google.com/books?id=OM9AAAAAYAAJ| isbn = 978-9976-1-0056-3}}
- {{cite book |last1 = Cooper |first1 = Tom |last2 = Fontanellaz |first2 = Adrien |title= Wars and Insurgencies of Uganda 1971–1994 |date= 2015 |publisher= Helion & Company Limited |location= Solihull |isbn= 978-1-910294-55-0 }}
- {{cite book| last = Hansen| first = Holger Bernt |title = Ethnicity and Military Rule in Uganda: a study of ethnicity as a political factor in Uganda, based on a discussion of political anthropology and the application of its results| publisher = Scandinavian Inst. of African Studies| date = 1977| location = Uppsala| url = http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:275789/FULLTEXT01.pdf}}
- {{cite thesis |last= Lowman|first= Thomas James|date= 2020|title= Beyond Idi Amin: Causes and Drivers of Political Violence in Uganda, 1971-1979|type= PhD|publisher= Durham University|url= http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/13439/1/Tom_Lowman_-_Thesis_Corrected_Draft.pdf?DDD17+|access-date=6 July 2020}}
- {{cite book |last = Otunnu |first = Ogenga |title= Crisis of Legitimacy and Political Violence in Uganda, 1890 to 1979 |url= https://books.google.com/books?id=aZDLDQAAQBAJ |date= 2016 |publisher= Palgrave Macmillan |location= Chicago |isbn= 978-3-319-33155-3 }}
- {{cite book| last = Reid| first = Richard J. | title = A History of Modern Uganda| url = https://books.google.com/books?id=zDQEDgAAQBAJ| publisher = Cambridge University Press| date = 2017| location = Cambridge|isbn= 978-1-107-06720-2}}
- {{cite book| last = Rwehururu| first = Bernard| title = Cross to the Gun| publisher = Monitor| date = 2002| location = Kampala| oclc = 50243051}}
- {{cite book |last = Smith |first = George Ivan |author-link = George Ivan Smith |title= Ghosts of Kampala |url= https://books.google.com/books?id=D14MAQAAIAAJ |date= 1980 |publisher= Weidenfeld & Nicolson |location= London |isbn= 978-0060140274 }}
{{refend}}
{{DEFAULTSORT:Sule, Godwin}}
Category:Ugandan military personnel
Category:Military personnel of the Uganda–Tanzania War