| class="wikitable" width="95%"
! Date of ceremony
!
! Recipient |
| rowspan=5|March 24, 1991
| rowspan=5|File:Sofia Coppola 2010 b.jpg
| style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Sofia Coppola in The Godfather Part III as Mary Corleone |
| Ingrid Chavez in Graffiti Bridge as Aura |
| Leo Damian in Ghosts Can't Do It as Fausto |
| Carre Otis in Wild Orchid as Emily Reed |
| Donald Trump (as himself) in Ghosts Can't Do It |
| rowspan=5|March 29, 1992
| rowspan=5|File:Vanilla Ice.jpg
| style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Vanilla Ice in Cool as Ice as Johnny Van Owen[[https://www.tuscaloosanews.com/story/news/2016/03/08/concert-to-feature-90s-stars/29974125007/ Concert to feature '90s stars - Tuscaloosa News]] |
| Brian Bosworth in Stone Cold as Joe Huff / John Stone |
| Milla Jovovich in Return to the Blue Lagoon as Lilli Hargrave |
| Brian Krause in Return to the Blue Lagoon as Richard Lestrange, Jr. |
| Kristin Minter in Cool as Ice as Kathy Winslow |
| rowspan=5|March 28, 1993
| rowspan=5|File:Pauley-shore.jpg
| style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Pauly Shore in Encino Man as Stoney[[https://screenrant.com/actors-who-won-most-razzie-awards-ever/ 15 Actors Who Have Won The Most Razzie Awards|ScreenRant]] |
| Georges Corraface in Christopher Columbus: The Discovery as Christopher Columbus |
| Kevin Costner's crew cut in The Bodyguard |
| Whitney Houston in The Bodyguard as Rachel Marron |
| Sharon Stone's tribute to Theodore Cleaver in Basic Instinct |
| rowspan=5|March 20, 1994
| rowspan=5|File:Janet Jackson.jpg
| style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Janet Jackson in Poetic Justice as Justice |
| Roberto Benigni in Son of the Pink Panther as Gendarme Jacques Gambrelli |
| Mason Gamble in Dennis the Menace as Dennis Mitchell |
| Norman D. Golden II in Cop and a Half as Devon Butler |
| Austin O'Brien in Last Action Hero as Danny Madigan |
| rowspan=5|March 26, 1995
| rowspan=5|File:Anna Nicole Smith crop.jpg
| style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Anna Nicole Smith in Naked Gun 33 1/3: The Final Insult as Tanya Peters |
| Jim Carrey in Ace Ventura: Pet Detective (as Ace Ventura), Dumb and Dumber (as Lloyd Christmas) and The Mask (as Stanley Ipkiss/The Mask) |
| Chris Elliott in Cabin Boy as Nathaniel Mayweather |
| Chris Isaak in Little Buddha as Dean Conrad |
| Shaquille O'Neal in Blue Chips as Deon |
| rowspan=5|March 24, 1996
| rowspan=5|File:Elizabeth Berkley 2008.jpg
| style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Elizabeth Berkley in Showgirls as Nomi Malone |
| Amy the talking gorilla in Congo |
| David Caruso in Jade and Kiss of Death as David Corelli and Jimmy Kilmartin (respectively) |
| Cindy Crawford in Fair Game as Kate McQuean |
| Julia Sweeney in It's Pat: The Movie (as Pat Riley) and Stuart Saves His Family |
| rowspan=5|March 23, 1997
| rowspan=5|File:Pam Anderson 2009.jpg
| style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Pamela Anderson in Barb Wire as Barb Wire[[https://movieweb.com/best-pamela-anderson-performances/ These Are Pamela Anderson's Best Performances, Ranked - MovieWeb]] |
| Beavis and Butt-head in Beavis and Butt-head Do America |
| Ellen DeGeneres in Mr. Wrong as Martha Alston |
| Friends cast members turned movie star wannabes (Jennifer Aniston in She's the One, Lisa Kudrow in Mother, Matt LeBlanc in Ed, David Schwimmer in The Pallbearer) |
| The new "serious" Sharon Stone in Diabolique and Last Dance as Nicole Horner and Cindy Liggett (respectively) |
| rowspan=5|March 22, 1998
| rowspan=5|File:Dennis Rodman, 2001.jpg
| style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Dennis Rodman in Double Team as Yaz |
| The animatronic anaconda in Anaconda |
| Tori Spelling in The House of Yes and Scream 2 as Lesly and herself (respectively) |
| Howard Stern in Private Parts as himself |
| Chris Tucker in The Fifth Element and Money Talks as Ruby Rhod and Franklin Hatchett |
| rowspan=5|March 20, 1999
| rowspan=5|File:Jerry Springer at Emory.jpg
| style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Joe Eszterhas in An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn as himself (tie)[[https://www.theguardian.com/world/1999/mar/22/julianborger Raspberry for Spice Girls as anti-Oscars handed out|World news|The Guardian]] |
| style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Jerry Springer in Ringmaster as Jerry Farrelly (tie) |
| Barney the Friendly Dinosaur in Barney's Great Adventure: The Movie |
| Carrot Top in Chairman of the Board as Edison |
| The Spice Girls in Spice World as themselves |
