Human rights in Moldova
{{Short description|Overview of human-rights abuses in Moldova}}
{{Update|date=March 2015}}
{{Politics of Moldova}}
The condition of human rights in Moldova has come under scrutiny since 2002, and human rights organizations within Moldova and around the world have spoken out against what they feel to be unfair suppression of the independent media, as well as other abuses.
As of 2024, the U.S. State Department's Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons places Moldova on the "Tier 2 Watch List", indicating that while the government is making significant efforts to combat human trafficking, it does not yet fully meet the minimum standards for elimination.{{Cite web |title=Moldova |url=https://www.state.gov/reports/2024-trafficking-in-persons-report/moldova/ |access-date=2025-04-02 |website=United States Department of State |language=en-US}}
History
State media coverage of the street protests in 2002 regarding the Communists’ attempt to reinstate obligatory study of the Russian language and to defend the cultural identity that the majority of Moldovans share with neighboring Romania was censored. In February 2002, in response to severe censorship of the state broadcast station Teleradio-Moldova (TVM), hundreds of TVM journalists went on strike in solidarity with the anti-communist opposition. In retribution, a few journalists and staff members were dismissed or suspended from the station in March.{{cite web|url=http://www.cpj.org/attacks02/europe02/moldova.html|title=Attacks on the Press 2002: Moldova|date=31 March 2003 |access-date=6 March 2015}}
However, in 2004 an improvement was made and the Moldovan Parliament removed Article 170 from the country's Criminal Code. Article 170 called for up to five years imprisonment for defamation.{{cite web|url=http://www.ifex.org/alerts/layout/set/print/layout/set/print/content/view/full/58518/|title=IFEX|access-date=6 March 2015|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20150119000442/http://www.ifex.org/alerts/layout/set/print/layout/set/print/content/view/full/58518/|archive-date=19 January 2015|url-status=dead}}
According to the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, the media climate in Moldova remained restrictive as of 2004.[http://www.osce.org/item/3999.html Report on Assessment Visit to Moldova by the OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media] Authorities continued a long-standing campaign to silence independent opposition voices and movements. In a case widely criticized by human rights defenders, opposition politician Valeriu Pasat was sentenced to a ten-year prison term. The United States and human rights defenders from the European Union consider him a political prisoner, and an official statement from Russia's Ministry of Foreign Affairs called the judgment "striking in its cruelty".{{Citation needed|date=April 2007}}
According to Amnesty International's 2007 annual report, the state of human rights in Moldova was poor. Torture and ill-treatment were widespread and conditions in pre-trial detention were poor. A number of treaties protecting women's rights were ratified, but men, women and children continued to be trafficked for forcible sexual and other exploitation.{{citation needed|date=February 2012}} Measures to protect women against domestic violence were inadequate. Constitutional changes to abolish the death penalty were made. Freedom of expression was restricted and opposition politicians were targeted.
In 2009, when Moldova experienced its most serious civil unrest in a decade, several civilians like Valeriu Boboc were killed by police and many more injured.Bureau of Diplomatic Security, [https://www.osac.gov/pages/ContentReportDetails.aspx?cid=10459 Moldova 2011 Crime and Safety Report] According to Human Rights Report of the United States Department of State, released in April 2011, "In contrast to the previous year, there were no reports of killings by security forces. During the year reports of government exercising undue influence over the media substantially decreased." But "Transnistrian authorities continued to harass independent media and opposition lawmakers; restrict freedom of association, movement, and religion; and discriminate against Romanian speakers."United States Department of State, [https://2009-2017.state.gov/j/drl/rls/hrrpt/2010/eur/154439.htm 2010 Human Rights Report: Moldova] Moldova "has made “noteworthy progress” on religious freedom since the era of the Soviet Union, but it can still take further steps to foster diversity," said the UN Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief Heiner Bielefeldt, in Chişinău, in September 2011.[https://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=39500 Moldova: UN human rights expert calls for more fostering of religious diversity]
On 19 April 2021, the Council of Europe Action Plan for the Republic of Moldova 2021–2024, which had among its objectives working on the situation of human rights in Moldova, was signed on Strasbourg, France.{{cite news|url=https://www.coe.int/en/web/portal/-/new-council-of-europe-action-plan-for-the-republic-of-moldova-launched-in-strasbourg|title=New Council of Europe Action Plan for the Republic of Moldova launched in Strasbourg|publisher=Council of Europe|date=19 April 2021}}
Rights of vulnerable groups
=Romani people=
Discrimination against Romani people is a systemic problem in Moldovan society. Law enforcement bodies, the police in particular, show a discriminatory attitude, hostility, abusive behavior, and physical and psychological violence towards them.{{cite web |url=https://promolex.md/old/upload/publications/ro/doc_1332166962.pdf |title=Rele tratamente pe motiv de discriminare în Moldova |work=Promo-LEX |location=Chișinău |date=2012 |page=28 |access-date=2019-01-08 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20180702233245/https://promolex.md/old/upload/publications/ro/doc_1332166962.pdf |archive-date=2018-07-02 |url-status=dead }} Bad treatments usually take place during detention and aim to obtain testimonies and statements. There were also cases where state authorities refused to investigate or sanction cases of physical abuse committed by individuals against Romani people. The Romani people literacy level is below the national average, and some communities do not have running water, plumbing and heating.{{cite web |url=https://md.usembassy.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/210/2017/04/MOLDOVA-HRR-2016-ROM.pdf |title=Moldova: Raport asupra drepturilor omului pe anul 2016 |work=Ambasada SUA în Moldova}}
Freedom of expression and of the press
{{main|Media of Moldova}}
Moldovan Constitutions and laws protect freedom of expression and media freedom, and forbid censorship. Still, direct and indirect censorship is practiced, and Moldova is ranked as "partly free" in Freedom House 2016 Freedom of the Press report.{{cite news|date= 2016|title= Moldova / Country report / Freedom of the Press|url= https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-press/2016/moldova|publisher= Freedom House|access-date= 2017-02-28|archive-date= 2018-10-22|archive-url= https://web.archive.org/web/20181022165102/https://freedomhouse.org/report/freedom-press/2016/moldova|url-status= dead}}
In 2020, freedom house said that while on paper there was strong media protection, the defamation laws allow for rights to be stripped, which becomes " an easy and comfortable mechanism for exerting pressure on the media as people acting in bad faith can influence official examiners, particularly at the local level."(e.g. in 2020, president Igor Dodon filed a defamation case against Ziarul de Gardă for reporting on his holidays.){{Cite web |date=November 26, 2023 |title="FoTP_Moldova-2021_En_0.pdf" |url=https://freedomhouse.org/sites/default/files/2021-10/FotP_Moldova-2021_En_0.pdf |access-date=November 26, 2023 |website=Freedom House}}
Historical situation
The following chart shows Moldova's ratings since 1991 in the Freedom in the World reports, published annually by Freedom House. A rating of 1 is "free"; 7, "not free".{{cite web | url = https://freedomhouse.org/sites/default/files/2024-02/Country_and_Territory_Ratings_and_Statuses_FIW_1973-2024.xlsx | title = Country and Territory Ratings and Statuses, FIW 1973-2024 | access-date = 21 December 2024 | author = Freedom House | author-link = Freedom House | year = 2024 | format = XLS}}{{ref|a|1}}
The 2021 ratings were for Political rights 3, and for Civil Liberties 3.
class="wikitable collapsible collapsed" style="border:none; "
!Historical ratings |
style="padding:0; border:none;"|
{| class="wikitable sortable" width=100% style="border-collapse:collapse;" |
style="background:#eee; font-weight:bold; text-align:center;"
| style="width:3em; text-align:left;" | Year | style="width:3em;" |Political Rights | style="width:3em;" |Civil Liberties | style="width:3em;" |Status | style="width:3em;" |President{{ref|b|2}}{{ref|c|3}} |
align=center
| align=left | 1991 | style="background:#ff9;" |5 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Mircea Snegur |
align=center
| align=left | 1992 | style="background:#ff9;" |5 | style="background:#ff9;" |5 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Mircea Snegur |
align=center
| align=left | 1993 | style="background:#ff9;" |5 | style="background:#ff9;" |5 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Mircea Snegur |
align=center
| align=left | 1994 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Mircea Snegur |
align=center
| align=left | 1995 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Mircea Snegur |
align=center
| align=left | 1996 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Mircea Snegur |
align=center
| align=left | 1997 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Mircea Snegur |
align=center
| align=left | 1998 | style="background:#ff9;" |2 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Petru Lucinschi |
align=center
| align=left | 1999 | style="background:#ff9;" |2 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Petru Lucinschi |
align=center
| align=left | 2000 | style="background:#ff9;" |2 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Petru Lucinschi |
align=center
| align=left | 2001 | style="background:#ff9;" |2 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Petru Lucinschi |
align=center
| align=left | 2002 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Vladimir Voronin |
align=center
| align=left | 2003 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Vladimir Voronin |
align=center
| align=left | 2004 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Vladimir Voronin |
align=center
| align=left | 2005 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Vladimir Voronin |
align=center
| align=left | 2006 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Vladimir Voronin |
align=center
| align=left | 2007 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Vladimir Voronin |
align=center
| align=left | 2008 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Vladimir Voronin |
align=center
| align=left | 2009 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Vladimir Voronin |
align=center
| align=left | 2010 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Mihai Ghimpu (acting) |
align=center
| align=left | 2011 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Marian Lupu (acting) |
align=center
| align=left | 2012 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Marian Lupu (acting) |
align=center
| align=left | 2013 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Nicolae Timofti |
align=center
| align=left | 2014 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Nicolae Timofti |
align=center
| align=left | 2015 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Nicolae Timofti |
align=center
| align=left | 2016 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Nicolae Timofti |
align=center
| align=left | 2017 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Igor Dodon |
align=center
| align=left | 2018 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Igor Dodon |
align=center
| align=left | 2019 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |4 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Igor Dodon |
align=center
| align=left | 2020 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Igor Dodon |
align=center
| align=left | 2021{{ref|d|4}} | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Maia Sandu |
align=center
| align=left | 2022 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Maia Sandu |
align=center
| align=left | 2023 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |3 | style="background:#ff9;" |Partly Free | style="background:#ff9;" |Maia Sandu |
|}
See also
Notes on Historical Ratings Table above
:1.{{note|a}}Note that the "Year" signifies the "Year covered". Therefore the information for the year marked 2008 is from the report published in 2009, and so on.
:2.{{note|b}}As of January 1.
:3.{{note|c}}Moldova is a parliamentary republic; the presidency is considered a ceremonial position, with the prime minister and parliament holding most of the legislative power.{{Cite web|date=14 November 2016|title=Moldova elects pro-Russian Igor Dodon as president|url=https://www.politico.eu/article/moldova-elects-pro-russian-igor-dodon-as-president/|access-date=9 March 2022|website=Politico |language=en-US}}{{Cite news|date=19 November 2020|title=Maia Sandu, a reformist ex-prime minister, becomes president|newspaper=The Economist|url=https://www.economist.com/europe/2020/11/19/maia-sandu-a-reformist-ex-prime-minister-becomes-president|access-date=9 March 2022|issn=0013-0613}}
:4.{{note|d}}On the Freedom House spreadsheet, the ratings for every country from North Macedonia through North Korea are applied to the country that precedes it alphabetically, with North Macedonia's ratings (3 for both civil and political rights) being applied to North Korea. North Macedonia is listed as beginning with the letter “M” (as in “Macedonia, North”), whereas North Korea is listed as beginning with the letter “N”; hence, every country beginning with the letters "M" and "N" (excluding Norway) are affected.
References
{{More footnotes|date=August 2009}}
{{reflist|2}}
{{Moldova topics}}
{{Human rights in Europe}}
{{DEFAULTSORT:Human Rights In Moldova}}