| class="wikitable sortable"
|+
!Name
!Race
!Age
!Sex
!Date of execution
!County
!Crime
!Victim(s)
!Governor |
| Mrs. Cornish
|White
|
|F
|1644
|
|Murder
|Mr. Cornish, white (husband)[{{Cite book |last=Jones |first=Ann |url=https://www.google.com/books/edition/Women_Who_Kill/yKd9DwAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Mrs.+Cornish+1644&pg=PT47&printsec=frontcover |title=Women Who Kill |date=2009-10-01 |publisher=The Feminist Press at CUNY |isbn=978-1-55861-652-3 |language=en}}]
| rowspan="5" |N/A (Province of Massachusetts Bay) |
| Joseph Quasson
|Native
|
|M
|June 29, 1726
|
|Murder
|Jonathan Boler, Native[{{Cite book |last=Hearn |first=Daniel Allen |url=https://www.google.com/books/edition/Legal_Executions_in_New_England/qA1eCgAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Joseph+Quasson+1726&pg=PA119&printsec=frontcover |title=Legal Executions in New England: A Comprehensive Reference, 1623-1960 |date=2015-08-13 |publisher=McFarland |isbn=978-1-4766-0853-2 |language=en}}] |
| Patience Sampson
|Native
|23
|F
|July 31, 1735
|York
|Murder
|Benjamin Trott, 8, white[{{Cite journal |date=1735-07-31 |title=Summary of the execution of Patience Sampson |url=https://archives.albany.edu/concern/daos/1544c6064?locale=en |language=en}}] |
| Solomon Goodwin
|White
|
|M
|November 12, 1772
|Cumberland
|Murder
|Male, race unknown[{{Cite book |last=Society |first=Maine Historical |url=https://www.google.com/books/edition/Collections_of_the_Maine_Historical_Soci/JfKhKokyfp4C?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Solomon+Goodwin+Maine&pg=PA162&printsec=frontcover |title=Collections of the Maine Historical Society |date=1890 |publisher=The Society |language=en}}] |
| James McCormic
|White
|
|M
|1773
|Cumberland
|Murder
|Reuben Bishop, race unknown |
| Jeremiah Baum
|White
|
|M
|1780
|Knox
|Treason
|N/A
| rowspan="5" |N/A (District of Maine) |
| Thomas Bird
|White
|
|M
|June 25, 1790
|Cumberland (Federal)[{{Cite journal |last=Genesio |first=Jerry |date=2006 |title=The Trial and Execution of Thomas Bird in Portland, Maine, 1790: The First Execution under the United State Constitution |url=https://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/mainehistoryjournal/vol42/iss4/2/ |journal=Maine History |language=en |volume=42 |issue=4 |pages=199–214 |issn=1090-5413}}]
|Murder
|Capt. John Connor, white |
| Edmund Fortis
|Black
|
|M
|September 25, 1794
|Lincoln
|Murder-Rape
|Pamela Tilton, 14, white[{{Cite web |title=Edmund Fortis, d. 1794 The Last Words and Dying Speech of Edmund Fortis, a Negro Man, Who Appeared to Be between Thirty and Forty Years of Age, but Very Ignorant. He Was Executed at Dresden, on Kennebeck River, on Thursday the Twenty-Fifth Day of September, 1794, for a Rape and Murder, Committed on the Body of Pamela Tilton, a Young Girl of about Fourteen Years of Age, Daughter of Mr. Tilton of Vassalborough, in the County of Lincoln. |url=https://docsouth.unc.edu/neh/fortis/menu.html |access-date=2025-02-09 |website=docsouth.unc.edu}}] |
| Joseph Drew
|White
|24
|M
|July 21, 1808
|Cumberland
|Murder
|Ebenezer Parker, white (deputy sheriff)[{{Cite journal |date=1808-07-21 |title=Summary of the execution of Joseph Drew |url=https://archives.albany.edu/concern/daos/d791t0160?locale=en |language=en}}] |
| Ebenezer Ball
|White
|
|M
|October 31, 1811
|Hancock
|Murder
|John Tileston Downes, white[{{Cite book |url=https://www.loc.gov/item/rbpe.02601100/ |title=[Lines] made on Ebenezer Ball, who was executed at Castine, October 31st, 1811, for the murder of Mr. John Tileston Downes. [Two poems. One written the day before his execution, and the other written the day he was executed.] |date=1811 |language=english}}] |
| Seth Elliott
|White
|
|M
|February 3, 1825
|Knox
|Murder
|John Wilson Elliott, 3, white (son)[{{Cite journal |date=1825-02-03 |title=Summary of the execution of Seth Elliott |url=https://archives.albany.edu/concern/daos/rn301j73c?locale=en |language=en}}]
|Parris |
| Joseph Sager
|White
|
|M
|January 2, 1835{{efn|Last public execution in Maine.}}
|Kennebec
|Murder
|Female, white (wife)[{{Cite journal |date=1835-01-02 |title=Summary of the execution of Joseph Sager |url=https://archives.albany.edu/concern/daos/zw12zp666?locale=en |language=en}}]
|Smith |
| Abram Cox
|Black
|
|M
| rowspan="2" |August 27, 1860
| rowspan="2" |Androscoggin
| rowspan="2" |Murder
| rowspan="2" |Four people, races unknown[{{Cite journal |date=1860-08-27 |title=Summary of the execution of Abram Cox, Peter Williams |url=https://archives.albany.edu/concern/daos/6h441b241?locale=en |language=en}}]{{efn|Capt. Daniel Humphrey, two mates, and a seaman.}}
| rowspan="2" |Morrill |
| Peter Williams
|White
|
|M |
| Francis Spencer
|White
|
|M
|June 24, 1864{{efn|First execution at Maine State Prison.}}
|Knox
|Murder
|Mr. Tinker, white (warden)[{{Cite journal |date=1864-06-24 |title=Summary of the execution of Francis Spencer |url=https://archives.albany.edu/concern/daos/5t34t2784?locale=en |language=en}}]
|Cony |
| Clifton Harris
|Black
|20
|M
|March 12, 1869
|Androscoggin
|Murder-Rape-Robbery
|Mrs. Justin Kingsley and Polly Caswell, white[{{Cite journal |date=1869-03-12 |title=Summary of the execution of Clifton Harris |url=https://archives.albany.edu/concern/daos/xs55mw30x?locale=en |language=en}}]
|Chamberlain |
| Louis Wagner
|White
|
|M
|June 25, 1875
|York
|Murder-Rape-Robbery
|Anetha and Karen Christiansen, white[{{Cite journal |date=1875-06-25 |title=Summary of the execution of Louis Wagner |url=https://archives.albany.edu/concern/daos/vd66wg952?locale=en |language=en}}]
| rowspan="2" |Dingley |
| John Gordon
|White
|
|M
|June 25, 1875
|Waldo
|Murder
|Three people, white[{{Cite journal |date=1875-06-25 |title=Summary of the execution of John Gordon |url=https://archives.albany.edu/concern/daos/5d86ph17c?locale=en |language=en}}]{{efn|His 24-year-old brother Almon, Almon's wife Emma, and their two-year-old daughter.}} |
| Raffaele Capone
|White
|27
|M
| rowspan="2" |April 17, 1885
| rowspan="2" |Penobscot
| rowspan="2" |Murder-Robbery
| rowspan="2" |Pasquale Coscia, white[{{Cite journal |date=1885-04-17 |title=Summary of the execution of Raffaele Capone, Carmine Santore |url=https://archives.albany.edu/concern/daos/vh53xd71x?locale=en |language=en}}]
| rowspan="3" |Robie |
| Carmine Santore
|White
|44
|M |
| Daniel Wilkinson
|White
|39
|M
|November 20, 1885
|Sagadahoc
|Murder
|William Lawrence, white (policeman)[{{Cite journal |date=1885-11-20 |title=Summary of the execution of Daniel Wilkinson |url=https://archives.albany.edu/concern/daos/4t64h553m?locale=en |language=en}}] |