| class="wikitable sortable mw-collapsible"
|+Awards for Coyle's writing
!Year
!Title
!Award
!Result
!Ref. |
| rowspan="4" |2014
| rowspan="4" |Yesterday’s Echo
|Anthony Award for Best First Novel
|Winner
|[{{Cite web |title=The Anthony Awards: A Literary Award for Crime Fiction |url=http://awards.omnimystery.com/mystery-awards-anthonys.html |access-date=2022-07-31 |website=Crime Fiction Awards}}][{{Cite web |title=Matt Coyle |url=http://stopyourekillingme.com/C_Authors/Coyle_Matt.html |access-date=2023-01-05 |website=Stop, You're Killing Me!}}][{{Cite web |last=Foster |first=Jordan |date=2014-11-19 |title=Bouchercon 2014: Lots of Awards |url=https://www.publishersweekly.com/pw/by-topic/industry-news/trade-shows-events/article/64799-bouchercon-2014-lots-of-awards.html |access-date=2023-01-05 |website=Publishers Weekly |language=en}}] |
| Ben Franklin Award for Best New Voice in Fiction
|Winner
| |
| Macavity Award for Best First Mystery
|Finalist
|[{{Cite web |last=Cogdill |first=Oline |title=Macavity Award Nominations |url=https://mysteryscenemag.com/article/3726-macavity-award-nominations |access-date=2023-01-02 |website=Mystery Scene Magazine}}] |
| San Diego Book Award for Best Mystery
|Winner
| |
| rowspan="3" |2016
| rowspan="3" |Night Tremors
|Anthony Award for Best Paperback Original
|Finalist
| |
| Lefty Award for Best LCC Regional Mystery
|Finalist
|[{{Cite web |title=Lefty Award Archives |url=https://leftcoastcrime.org/LeftyArchives.html |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Left Coast Crime}}][{{Cite web |title=Left Coast Crime Awards |url=https://lincolnlibraries.org/bookguide/award-winners/left-coast-crime-awards/ |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Lincoln City Libraries}}] |
| Shamus Award for Best First PI Novel
|Finalist
| |
| rowspan="3" |2017
|Blood Truth
|INDIES Award for Thriller & Suspense (Adult Fiction)
|Silver
|[{{Cite web |title="Blood Truth" is a 2017 Foreword INDIES Winner |url=https://www.forewordreviews.com/awards/books/blood-truth/ |access-date=2023-01-05 |website=Foreword Reviews |language=en}}] |
| rowspan="2" |Dark Fissures
|Lefty Award for Best Mystery Novel
|Finalist
|[{{Cite web |last= |first= |date=2017-01-17 |title=2017 Left Coast Crime "Lefty" Awards Nominations |url=https://www.criminalelement.com/2017-left-coast-crime-qleftyq-awards-nominations/ |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Criminal Element |language=en-US}}] |
| Macavity Award for Best Mystery Novel
|Finalist
|[{{Cite web |last= |first= |date=2017-07-05 |title=Announcing the 2017 Macavity Awards Nominees |url=https://www.criminalelement.com/announcing-the-2017-macavity-awards-nominees/ |access-date=2023-01-02 |website=Criminal Element |language=en-US}}] |
| rowspan="4" |2018
| rowspan="2" |Blood Truth
|Lefty Award for Best Mystery Novel
|Finalist
|[{{Cite web |title=Lefty Awards |url=http://www.stopyourekillingme.com/Awards/Lefty_Awards.html |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Stop, You're Killing Me!}}] |
| Shamus Award for Best Novel
|Finalist
| |
| rowspan="2" |"{{sortname|The|#2 Pencil|nolink=1}}" in Coast to Coast
|Derringer Award
|Finalist
| |
| Macavity Award for Best Mystery Short Story
|Finalist
|[{{Cite web |title=Macavity Awards 2018 |url=https://www.bookreporter.com/features/awards/macavity-awards-2018 |access-date=2023-01-02 |website=Bookreporter}}] |
| 2019
|Wrong Light
|Shamus Award for Best Novel
|Finalist
| |
| 2020
| rowspan="2" |Lost Tomorrows
|Lefty Award for Best Mystery
|Winner
|[{{Cite web |last= |date=2020-03-23 |title=2020 Left Coast Crime Lefty Awards - |url=https://nightstandbookreviews.com/2020-left-coast-crime-lefty-awards/ |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Nightstand Book Reviews |language=en-US}}] |
| rowspan="4" |2020
|Shamus Award for Best P. I. Hardcover Novel
|Winner
|[{{cite web |title=The Private Eye Writers of America and The Shamus Awards |url=http://www.thrillingdetective.com/trivia/triv72.html |access-date=2019-06-04 |publisher=Thrillingdetective.com}}] |
| rowspan="3" |Wrong Light
|Lefty Award for Best Mystery Novel
|Winner
|[{{Cite web |date=2019-04-01 |title=Lefty Awards - 2019 (Left Coast Crime) - |url=https://nightstandbookreviews.com/lefty-awards-2019-left-coast-crime/ |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Nightstand Book Reviews |language=en-US |author1=Patti }}][{{Cite web |last= |first= |date=2019-01-17 |title=2019 Left Coast Crime "Lefty" Award Nominations Announced |url=https://crimespreemag.com/2019-left-coast-crime-lefty-award-nominations-announced/ |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Crimespree Magazine |language=en-US}}] |
| San Diego Book Award
|Finalist
| |
| Shamus Award for Best Novel
|Finalist
| |
| rowspan="4" |2021
| rowspan="4" |Blind Vigil
|Barry Award for Best Novel
|Finalist
| |
| Lefty Award for Best Mystery Novel
|Finalist
|[{{Cite web |last=Cogdill |first=Oline |title=Left Coast Crime Lefty Award Winners |url=https://www.mysteryscenemag.com/blog-article/7049-left-coast-crime-announces-lefty-award-winners |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Mystery Scene Magazine}}][{{Cite web |last= |date=2021-04-10 |title=2021 Left Coast Crime Awards - |url=https://nightstandbookreviews.com/2021-left-coast-crime-awards/ |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Nightstand Book Reviews |language=en-US}}][{{Cite web |date=2021-01-19 |title=Lefty Award Nominees |url=https://poisonedpen.com/2021/01/19/lefty-award-nominees/ |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Poisoned Pen Press |language=en-US}}] |
| Macavity Award for Best Mystery Novel
|Finalist
|[{{Cite web |title=Macavity Awards |url=https://mysteryreaders.org/macavity-awards/ |access-date=2023-01-01 |website=Mystery Readers International}}][{{Cite web |title=Macavity Awards |url=http://www.stopyourekillingme.com/Awards/Macavity_Awards.html |access-date=2023-01-02 |website=Stop, You're Killing Me!}}][{{Cite web |date=September 2022 |title=Macavity Awards |url=https://lincolnlibraries.org/bookguide/award-winners/macavity-awards/ |access-date=2023-01-02 |website=Lincoln City Libraries}}] |
| Shamus Award for Best P. I. Hardcover Novel
|Winner
| |
| rowspan="3" |2022
| rowspan="3" |Last Redemption
|Barry Award for Best Mystery/Crime Novel
|Finalist
|[{{Cite web |title=The Barry Award Winners — 2022 |url=http://new.deadlypleasures.com/2022/09/12/the-barry-award-winners-2022/ |access-date=2023-01-05 |website=Deadly Pleasures Magazine |date=12 September 2022 |language=en-US}}] |
| Lefty Award for Best Mystery Novel
|Finalist
|[{{Cite web |last=Cogdill |first=Oline H |title=Compliments to Left Coast Crime |url=https://www.mysteryscenemag.com/blog-newsfeed/60-books/7466-compliments-to-left-coast-crime?highlight=WyJsZWZ0IiwiY29hc3QiLCJjcmltZSIsImNyaW1lJ3MiLCJsZWZ0IGNvYXN0IiwibGVmdCBjb2FzdCBjcmltZSIsImNvYXN0IGNyaW1lIl0= |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Mystery Scene Magazine}}][{{Cite web |last= |date=2022-04-20 |title=2022 Left Coast Crime Awards (the Lefties) - |url=https://nightstandbookreviews.com/2022-left-coast-crime-awards-the-lefties/ |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Nightstand Book Reviews |language=en-US}}][{{Cite web |date=2022-01-18 |title=The 2022 Left Coast Crime "Lefty" Nominees |url=https://poisonedpen.com/2022/01/18/the-2022-left-coast-crime-lefty-nominees/ |access-date=2023-01-04 |website=Poisoned Pen Press |language=en-US}}] |
| Shamus Award for Best Novel
|Finalist
| |
