| class="wikitable"
!Year
!Player
!Position
!High School
!College
!Professional team(s) |
| 1991
|Jumpity Springster
|RB
|Stratford
|South Carolina |
| 1992
|Stephen Davis
|RB
|Spartanburg
|Auburn
|Washington Redskins, Carolina Panthers, St. Louis Rams |
| 1993
|Jeff Coleman
|DT
|Gaffney
|Tennessee
|CFL - Montreal Alouettes |
| 1994
|Anthony Downs
|RB
|Berea
|Clemson
| |
| 1995
|Jermale Kelley
|WR
|Berea
|South Carolina
|NFL Europe - Berlin, Rhein |
| 1996
|Kyle Young
|OL
|Daniel
|Clemson
| |
| 1997
|Chris Hope
|DB
|Rock Hill
|Florida State
|Pittsburgh Steelers, Tennessee Titans |
| 1998
|Derek Watson
|RB
|Palmetto
|South Carolina
|Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Calgary Stampeders |
| 1999
|Mark Logan
|QB
|Greenwood
|Georgia Tech
| |
| 2000
|Roscoe Crosby
|WR
|Union
|Clemson
| |
| 2001
|Moe Thompson
|DE
|Stratford
|South Carolina
| |
| 2002
|Eric McCollom
|QB
|Camden
|Iowa
| |
| 2003
|Trey Elder
|QB
|Byrnes
|Appalachian State
| |
| 2004
|J.D. Melton
|QB
|Myrtle Beach
|Navy
| |
| 2005
|Prince Miller
|DB
|Byrnes
|Georgia
|Baltimore Ravens, Detroit Lions, Indianapolis Colts, Cleveland Browns, Saskatchewan Roughriders |
| 2006
|Malcolm Long
|QB
|Gaffney
|South Carolina State
| |
| 2007
|Richard Mounce
|QB
|Blythewood
|Clemson**/Charleston Southern
| |
| 2008
|Stephon Gilmore
|CB
|South Pointe
|South Carolina
|Buffalo Bills, New England Patriots
Carolina Panthers
Indianapolis Colts
Dallas Cowboys |
| 2009
|Marcus Lattimore
|RB
|Byrnes
|South Carolina
|San Francisco 49ers |
2010[{{cite news|last=Byers|first=Barry|title=Stallions' Clowney named Mr. Football in S.C.|url=http://www.heraldonline.com/2010/12/11/2682315/stallions-clowney-named-this-years.html|accessdate=3 June 2013|date=11 December 2010}}]
|Jadeveon Clowney
|DE
|South Pointe
|South Carolina
|Houston Texans, Seattle Seahawks, Tennessee Titans, Cleveland Browns, Baltimore Ravens, Carolina Panthers |
2011[{{cite news|last=Byers|first=Barry|title=Roland keeps up USC trend of landing state's Mr. Football|url=http://www.heraldonline.com/2011/12/10/3588689/roland-keeps-up-usc-trend.html|accessdate=3 June 2013|date=10 December 2011}}]
|Shaq Roland
|WR
|Lexington
|South Carolina / West Georgia
|Chicago Bears |
2012 [{{cite news|last=Byers|first=Barry|title=Mr. FOOTBALL: Tramel Terry|url=http://www.thestate.com/2012/12/08/2549017/mr-football-tramel-terry.html|accessdate=3 June 2013|date=8 December 2012}}]
|Tramel Terry
|WR
|Goose Creek
|Georgia / Jacksonville State
| |
2013[{{cite web|last=Leigh|first=Brian|title=4-Star Georgia QB Commit Jacob Park Wins South Carolina's Mr. Football|url=http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1889105-4-star-georgia-qb-commit-jacob-park-wins-south-carolinas-mr-football|work=Bleacher Report|publisher=Turner Broadcasting System, Inc.|accessdate=12 March 2014}}]
|Jacob Park
|QB
|Stratford
|Georgia / Iowa State
| |
| 2014
|Matt Colburn
|RB
|Dutch Fork
|Wake Forest
|Los Angeles Rams |
| 2015
|Tavien Feaster
|RB
|Spartanburg
|Clemson/South Carolina
|Arizona Cardinals |
| 2016
|Gage Moloney
|QB
|Northwestern
|James Madison
| |
| 2017
|Dakereon Joyner
|QB
|Fort Dorchester
|South Carolina |
| 2018
|Zacch Pickens
|DE
|TL Hanna
|South Carolina
|Chicago Bears |
| 2019
|Luke Doty
|QB
|Myrtle Beach
|South Carolina |
| 2020
|Tyrion Ingram-Dawkins
|DL
|Gaffney
|Georgia |
| 2021
|Jaylen Sneed[{{cite web|title=Jaylen Sneed named Mr. Football in South Carolina for 2021|author=Parks, Chris|url=https://www.wbtw.com/sports/jaylen-sneed-named-mr-football-in-south-carolina-for-2021/|date=December 11, 2021|access-date=July 15, 2022|website=wbtw.com}}]
|LB
|Hilton Head Island
|Notre Dame |
| 2022
|Xzavier McLeod[{{cite web|title=USC Gamecocks commitment Xzavier McLeod named SC Mr. Football for 2022|author=Bezjak, Lou|url=https://www.thestate.com/sports/high-school/prep-football/article269795672.html|date=December 10, 2022|access-date=December 10, 2022|website=thestate.com}}]
|DL
|Camden
|South Carolina |
| 2023
|Josiah Thompson[{{cite web|title=5-star South Carolina commit Josiah Thompson of Dillon wins 2023 Mr. Football|author=Shanesy, Todd|url=https://www.greenvilleonline.com/story/sports/high-school/2023/12/09/dillon-offensive-lineman-josiah-thompson-mr-football-south-carolina-gamecocks/71795177007/|date=December 9, 2023|access-date=January 9, 2024|work=Greenville News}}]
|OL
|Dillon High School
|South Carolina |
| 2024
|Will Wilson[{{cite web|title=NC State signee Will Wilson named South Carolina's Mr. Football for 2024|author=Bezjak, Lou|url=https://www.thestate.com/sports/high-school/article297350064.html|date=December 21, 2024|access-date=December 31, 2024|website=thestate.com}}]
|QB
|Richland Northeast
|NC State |