Murder of Emma Grace Cole

{{Infobox civilian attack

| title = Murder of Emma Grace Cole

| location = Smyrna, Delaware, U.S.

| date = {{circa}} July – September 2019 (murder)
September 13, 2019 (discovery of remains)

| image = Emma Grace Cole.jpg

| caption = Victim Emma Grace Cole

| type = Child murder, torture murder, burning, starvation, filicide, child abuse, child neglect

| victim = Emma Grace Cole, aged 3{{Infobox event

| title =

| child = yes

| burial = Clear Creek Cemetery
Bloomington, Indiana, U.S.{{cite web|title=Obituary information for Emma Grace Cole - Chandler Funeral Homes|url=https://www.chandlerfh.com/obituaries/Emma-Grace-Cole?obId=20491183}}}}{{Infobox person

|child = yes

| monuments = Emma Grace Memorial Field in Smyrna, Delaware}}

| perpetrators = Kristie Lynn Haas
Brandon L. Haas

| motive = Unknown

| verdict = Pleaded guilty

| convictions = Kristie:

First-degree murder by abuse or neglect
Abusing a corpse
Felony endangering the welfare of a child (3 counts){{efn|Dropped charges as part of Kristie's plea bargain:
One additional count of first-degree murder by abuse or neglect
One count of second-degree assault
One count of reckless burning
One count of first-degree child abuse
Three misdemeanor counts of endangering the welfare of a child
One count of hindering prosecution}}

Brandon:
Endangering the welfare of a child (4 counts){{efn|One felony count, three misdemeanor counts.}}{{efn|Dropped charges as part of Brandon's plea bargain:

One count of first-degree child abuse
Two felony counts of endangering the welfare of a child
One count of hindering prosecution}}{{Infobox event

| title =

| child = yes

| sentence = Kristie:
30 years in prison (parole possible after {{frac|26|3|4}} years)
Brandon:
4 years and 1 month in prison

}}

Emma Grace Cole (January 10, 2016 – {{Circa|July to September 2019}}) was an American murder and torture victim from Bloomington, Indiana, whose burnt skeletal remains were discovered near a softball complex in Smyrna, Delaware, on September 13, 2019. She remained unidentified for over a year and was known as "Baby Elle", "Jane Smyrna Doe 2019", and "Smyrna Doe" until her identification in October 2020. The murder has gained significant attention and media coverage due to the brutality of Emma's death and her former status as an unidentified murder victim. She was murdered by her mother, Kristie Lynn Haas, who pleaded guilty to murder in 2023.

In October 2020 following Emma's identification, her mother, 28-year old Kristie Haas, and step-father, 38-year old Brandon Haas, were arrested in connection with her death and were charged with first-degree child abuse. In May 2021, they were re-indicted, with Kristie then facing first-degree murder by abuse or neglect charges.

On May 25, 2023, Kristie Haas agreed to a plea deal for a recommendation from the prosecution of 30 years in prison, and faced a maximum of life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.

Brandon Haas had agreed in February 2023 to a plea deal for a recommendation from the prosecution of a sentence of probation.

In September 2023, Kristie Haas was sentenced to 30 years in prison, and Brandon was sentenced to 4 years and 1 month in prison. The sentences were met with outrage from Emma's family and the public over their perceived leniency.

Murder

According to prosecutor Kevin Smith, following extensive torture, starvation, and physical abuse, Kristie Haas found her daughter, 4-year-old Emma Grace Cole unresponsive and tried to revive her with a cold shower. Her husband and Emma's stepfather, Brandon Haas, was stopped by Kristie from calling 911. Kristie later threw away Emma's clothing, stating, "That's it for Emma. Emma's not coming back." Kristie later lied to family members about why Emma was absent after the murder, telling them that Emma had "the devil in her eyes" and was in a facility for children with mental illness. Kristie burned Emma's body and discarded her skeleton into the bushes of the softball field near the Smyrna Middle School. Following the murder, the couple fled to Indiana where they had previously resided, and were later arrested in Pennsylvania.{{Cite news |last=Hughes |first=Isabel |date=February 22, 2022 |title=Remembering Emma Grace Cole and the joy she brought in her short life |work=The News Journal |url=https://www.delawareonline.com/in-depth/news/crime/2022/02/22/emma-grace-cole-smyrna-child-remains-kristie-haas/6599320001/}}

Discovery of remains and investigation

On September 13, 2019, the burnt skeletal remains of a female child were discovered by a dogwalker near a softball complex across from Smyrna Middle School in Smyrna, Delaware. It was estimated that her remains had been there for weeks at minimum. The identity of the remains was not initially determined. It had been estimated that the unidentified child was either Caucasian or Hispanic, between the ages of 2 and 5 years old, and had slightly wavy brown hair.{{Cite web |last=Anderson |first=Craig |date=February 21, 2021 |title=Documents unsealed in Smyrna child death case: Affidavit brings details |url=https://baytobaynews.com/delaware/stories/childs-death-remains-a-mystery,40967 |access-date=2022-12-22 |website=Bay to Bay News |language=en}}{{Cite web |last=Bies |first=Jessica |date=19 September 2019 |title=After remains found, National Center for Missing & Exploited Children helping Smyrna police |url=https://www.delawareonline.com/story/news/2019/09/19/childs-remains-found-smyrna-national-center-missing-exploited-children-case/2374127001/ |access-date=2022-12-22 |website=The News Journal |language=en-US}}{{Cite web |date=2019-11-18 |title=NEW FACIAL RECONSTRUCTION FOR JANE DOE, FOUND IN SMYRNA, DELAWARE |url=https://www.wvbr.com/post/new-facial-reconstruction-for-jane-doe-found-in-smyrna-delaware |access-date=2022-12-22 |website=WVBR 93.5 FM |language=en}} The case garnered major attention in media and public discourse because of the child's status as an unidentified person and for the initial lack of suspects in the case. The unidentified child was nicknamed "Baby Elle" by law enforcement and the public until her identification.{{Cite web |last=Bonvillian |first=Crystal |date=2020-10-13 |title=Couple jailed in connection with toddler's remains found at Delaware softball field last year |url=https://www.actionnewsjax.com/news/trending/couple-jailed-connection-with-3-year-olds-remains-found-delaware-softball-field-last-year/F5VFQYUCGBDAJE2DV34GPZKTFY/ |access-date=2022-12-22 |website=Action News Jax |language=en}} She did not match any missing person reports in the state.

= Identification and arrests =

In October 2020, the child was identified as Emma Grace Cole, the 3-year-old daughter of Kristie Lynn Haas (previously Kristie Lynn Cole) and Joshua Douthitt. Soon after, on October 12, Kristie and her husband, Brandon L. Haas, were arrested in Pennsylvania on charges of child abuse.

Legal proceedings

Kristie and Brandon Haas were extradited to Delaware, and in May 2021, Kristie and Brandon were re-indicted, with Delaware Attorney General Kathy Jennings announcing that murder charges had been added for Kristie.{{Cite web |last=Giletto |first=Damian |date=4 May 2021 |title=Prosecutor details new charges in death of Emma Cole |url=https://www.delawareonline.com/videos/news/local/2021/05/04/prosecutor-details-new-charges-death-emma-cole/4939303001/ |access-date=2022-12-22 |website=The News Journal |language=en-US}}{{Cite web |last=Hughes |first=Isabel |date=4 May 2021 |title=Mom of Emma Cole, whose remains were found in Smyrna in 2019, charged with murder |url=https://www.delawareonline.com/story/news/crime/2021/05/04/mom-girl-whose-remains-were-found-smyrna-2019-charged-murder/4935564001/ |access-date=2022-12-22 |website=The News Journal |language=en-US}}{{Cite web |date=2021-05-04 |title=Murder charges added in Smyrna child remains case |url=https://news.delaware.gov/2021/05/04/murder-charges-added-in-smyrna-child-remains-case/ |access-date=2022-12-22 |website=State of Delaware News |language=en-US}}{{Cite web |title=Haas Indictments |url=https://attorneygeneral.delaware.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/50/2021/05/Haas-Indictments.pdf}}

Specific details of the abuse that Emma had endured at the hands of Kristie and Brandon were revealed. According to the indictment, Emma was tortured by Kristie and Brandon for periods between January 2018 and September 2019. The indictment revealed that the couple deprived Emma of food, tortured her, endangered her welfare, deprived her of necessary medical care, bruised her face, forced her to exercise to an unreasonable level, inflicted inappropriate physical discipline, and burned her.{{Cite web |last=Bonvillian |first=Crystal |date=2021-05-05 |title=Mom charged with murder of 3-year-old found buried near Delaware softball field in 2019 |url=https://www.fox13memphis.com/news/trending/mom-charged-with-murder-3-year-old-found-buried-near-delaware-softball-field-2019/JHG6Q2KQNJHODEBHG2Y3PZ5TZI/ |access-date=2022-12-22 |website=FOX13 News Memphis |language=en}} Court records showed that Kristie had been in multiple custody battles between 2016 and 2017 over Emma with Emma's great-aunt and other family members. Kristie and Brandon had lived with Emma in both Indiana and Smyrna, Delaware. At the time of Emma's murder, the couple had lived a mile from the Little Lass softball fields where Emma's remains would end up being found.

The murder and abuse trial for Kristie and Brandon was originally scheduled for July 10, 2023.{{Cite web |last=Anderson |first=Craig |date=December 5, 2022 |title=Smyrna-related infant's death trial continued until 2023 |url=https://baytobaynews.com/stories/smyrna-related-infants-death-trial-continued-until-2023,95986 |access-date=2022-12-22 |website=Bay to Bay News |language=en}} If convicted, Kristie faced a minimum of 15 years in prison and a maximum of life in prison without the possibility of parole, and Brandon faced up to 44 years in prison.{{cite web |title=SUMMARY OF PRESUMPTIVE SENTENCES |url=https://cjc.delaware.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/61/2018/01/Benchbook-2018v2.pdf}}

= Guilty pleas =

On May 25, 2023, Kristie Haas entered a plea deal to the charges of first-degree murder by abuse or neglect, abusing a corpse, and three felony counts of endangering the welfare of a child, with her remaining charges dropped. As a part of the plea deal, both the prosecution and defense asked for 30 years in prison followed by a 20-year suspended sentence, and for sentences of probation on the remaining counts.

Emma's other family members were shocked and angered by the plea deal due to Kristie's somewhat lax sentence recommendation, since she had originally faced up to life in prison, and the fact that they were not informed of the plea deal until Kristie's guilty plea. Emma's great-aunt stated, "I feel like I'm being hit by a bus all over again. I am so mad that they didn't even bother to say a damn thing to any of us. We should have had the right to know, in case we wanted to be there."{{Cite web |last=Hughes |first=Isabel |date=2023-05-25 |title='We've all been left out': Family not told prior to toddler's mother taking murder plea |url=https://www.delawareonline.com/story/news/crime/2023/05/25/emma-cole-smyrna-murder-kristie-cole-haas-pleads-guilty/70257674007/ |access-date=2023-05-25 |website=The News Journal |language=en-US}}{{Cite web |last=Chase |first=Randall |date=2023-05-25 |title=Delaware Woman Pleads Guilty to Killing 3-Year-Old Daughter, Dumping Burned Remains on Softball Field |url=https://www.nbcphiladelphia.com/news/local/delaware-woman-pleads-guilty-to-killing-3-year-old-daughter-dumping-remains-on-softball-field/3573759/ |access-date=2023-05-25 |website=NBC10 Philadelphia |language=en-US}}{{Cite web |last= |date=2023-05-25 |title=Mother Pleads Guilty In Emma Cole Murder |url=https://firststateupdate.com/2023/05/mother-pleads-guilty-in-emma-cole-murder/ |access-date=2023-05-25 |website=First State Update |language=en-US}}

Delaware Attorney General Kathy Jennings stated of Kristie's guilty plea,{{Cite web |date=2023-05-25 |title=DOJ secures guilty plea in Emma Cole killing |url=https://news.delaware.gov/2023/05/25/doj-secures-guilty-plea-in-emma-cole-killing/ |access-date=2023-05-25 |website=State of Delaware News |language=en-US}}

{{Blockquote|text=What this defendant did to her own daughter was heinous, and this week brings a complex and harrowing case to a just end. This conviction doesn’t just bring certainty in outcome and a lengthy sentence—it ensures that Emma's young siblings, who would otherwise have been absolutely required to testify at trial, will not be re-traumatized by having to relive the terror of Emma's last days. I'm enormously grateful to the DOJ team and many investigators who took on this difficult case; identified Emma; and ultimately secured justice. Today, like every day, we’re reminded to hold our young ones close.|author=Attorney General Kathy Jennings}}

On May 26, 2023, it was revealed that Brandon L. Haas, the step-father of Emma and husband of Kristie Haas had also been given a plea deal in Emma's case. He pleaded guilty to one felony count and three misdemeanor counts of endangering the welfare of a child, with the remaining charges dropped. Prosecutors recommended a sentence of probation, and he faced a maximum of 8 years in prison. He formerly faced up to 44 years in prison if his case went to trial with all his initial charges.{{Cite web |last1=Parra |first1=Esteban |last2=Hughes |first2=Isabel |date=31 May 2023 |title=Stepfather pleads in connection with case of toddler's charred remains found in Smyrna |url=https://www.delawareonline.com/story/news/2023/05/31/stepdad-pleads-guilty-emma-cole-smyrna-child-killed-brandon-haas-kristie-cole-haas/70259243007/ |access-date=2023-06-01 |website=The News Journal |language=en-US}}{{Cite web |last=Chase |first=Randall |date=2023-05-26 |title=Stepfather of murdered Delaware 3-year-old pleads guilty to child endangerment |url=https://apnews.com/article/child-murder-delaware-emma-cole-guilty-plea-c82b9d71d94df8dfcd31c4007fdc04fd |access-date=2023-06-01 |website=AP NEWS |language=en}} Brandon had agreed to the plea deal in February 2023, originally in exchange for testimony against Kristie. This was not revealed publicly at the time due to the fact that Kristie had written a letter to Brandon telling him to take out a life insurance policy on her because she was contemplating committing suicide. Attorneys feared there may have been consequences in this regard if Kristie learned of the plea. Emma's family were similarly outraged by Brandon's plea deal given his lenient sentencing recommendation. Emma's aunt, Kelsey Cole Navarro said of Brandon's plea deal, "I think it's atrocious. Maybe he didn't kill her, but he was with Kristie for a whole year after and didn't say anything. How do you do something so heinous and be a part of that for so long? And then just get a slap on the wrist?"{{Cite web |title=Inside the plea deals for mom, stepdad of toddler found dead in Smyrna softball field |url=https://www.delawareonline.com/story/news/crime/2023/06/26/kristie-haas-delaware-plea-deal-emma-grace-cole-brandon-haas/70289680007/ |access-date=2023-06-27 |website=The News Journal |language=en-US}}

=Sentencing=

On September 14, 2023, Kristie Haas was sentenced by Superior Court Judge Noel Primos to the recommended sentence of 30 years in prison for the murder of Emma. Kristie stated at her sentencing, "I'm sorry for all the hurt that I inflicted and the pain that I caused … I knew everything was wrong, and I was so messed up because of everything I did. I thought I could get away with it, to be honest." Kristie blamed her actions on drug addiction, stating, "I wasn't okay then. I'm trying my best to be better than I was."

The same day, Brandon Haas was also sentenced for endangering the welfare of Emma and her siblings. Though Primos followed the prosecutors' recommended sentence for Kristie, he rejected the prosecutors' recommended sentence of probation for Brandon, instead sentencing him to 4 years and 1 month in prison. At the sentencing, Brandon tearfully apologized for not going to authorities after the murder of Emma, stating that Kristie told him that he would be blamed for Emma's death. He maintained that he did not know what happened between Emma and Kristie before Emma's death.

Emma's father, Joshua Douthitt stated at court, "I will never comprehend why Emma Grace had to lose her life. I don't know what this beautiful little baby could have done to deserve this." Kristie's defense attorney, Patrick Collins stated that "the true monster" was not Kristie, but rather drug addiction. Kristie will be eligible for parole in July 2047, after serving {{frac|26|3|4}} years.{{cite web|title=Woman who killed 3-year-old daughter and left her on ballfield is sentenced to 30 years|website=Associated Press News |url=https://apnews.com/article/child-abuse-murder-delaware-haas-softball-field-17391eeaded80f0d4e876e971e6e3617}}

Legacy

File:Emma Grace Memorial Field.jpg

The Little Lass softball field where Emma's remains were found was dedicated as the Emma Grace Memorial Field in November 2020.{{Cite web |date=2021-05-05 |title=Mom charged with murder of 3-year-old found buried near Delaware softball field in 2019 |url=https://www.fox13memphis.com/news/trending/mom-charged-with-murder-3-year-old-found-buried-near-delaware-softball-field-2019/JHG6Q2KQNJHODEBHG2Y3PZ5TZI/ |access-date=2022-12-22 |website=FOX13 News Memphis |language=en}}