| class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders" |
| Season
! Player
! Nationality
! Club
! class=unsortable|Other finalists
! class=unsortable|Ref. |
|---|
| style="text-align:center"| 2013
!scope="row"| {{sortname|Nicole|Barnhart}}
| {{USA}}
| FC Kansas City
|
|style="text-align:center"| [{{cite news|url=https://www.kansascity.com/sports/soccer/kc-current/article325737.html|title=FC Kansas City's Nicole Barnhart is league's goalie of the year|last=McDowell|first=Sam|date=2013-08-22|newspaper=The Kansas City Star|access-date=2024-06-27}}] |
| style="text-align:center"| 2014
!scope="row"| {{sortname|Alyssa|Naeher}}
| {{USA}}
| Boston Breakers
| Ashlyn Harris, Hope Solo
|style="text-align:center"| [{{cite news|url=https://equalizersoccer.com/2014/08/25/breakers-naeher-voted-goalkeeper-of-the-year/|title=Breakers' Naeher voted Goalkeeper of the Year|last=Lauletta|first=Dan|date=2014-08-25|website=The Equalizer|access-date=2024-06-27}}] |
| style="text-align:center"| 2015
!scope="row"| {{sortname|Michelle|Betos}}
| {{USA}}
| Portland Thorns FC
| Nicole Barnhart, Brittany Cameron
|style="text-align:center"| [{{cite news|url=https://equalizersoccer.com/2015/09/16/thorns-michelle-betos-named-nwsl-goalkeeper-of-year/|title=Thorns' Betos named NWSL Goalkeeper of Year|last=Kassouf|first=Jeff|date=2015-09-16|website=The Equalizer|access-date=2024-06-27}}]
{{cite news|url=https://www.timbers.com/thornsfc/news/thorns-fcs-michelle-betos-shocked-and-humbled-nwsl-goalkeeper-year-recognition|title=Thorns FC's Michelle Betos 'shocked' and humbled by NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year recognition|last=Froh|first=Tim|date=2015-09-17|publisher=Portland Thorns FC|archive-date=2024-06-27|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20240627043125/https://www.timbers.com/thornsfc/news/thorns-fcs-michelle-betos-shocked-and-humbled-nwsl-goalkeeper-year-recognition}} |
| style="text-align:center"| 2016
!scope="row"| {{sortname|Ashlyn|Harris}}
| {{USA}}
| Orlando Pride
| Michelle Betos, Alyssa Naeher
|style="text-align:center"| [{{cite news|url=https://equalizersoccer.com/2016/10/03/ashlyn-harris-nabs-top-goalkeeper-honor/|title=Ashlyn Harris nabs top goalkeeper honor|date=October 3, 2016|website=The Equalizer|access-date=2024-06-27}}] |
| style="text-align:center"| 2017
!scope="row"| {{sortname|Adrianna|Franch}}
| {{USA}}
| Portland Thorns FC
| Alyssa Naeher, Katelyn Rowland
|style="text-align:center"| [{{cite news|url=https://equalizersoccer.com/2017/10/18/shutout-record-helps-adrianna-franch-snag-nwsl-goalkeeper-of-the-year-honors/|title=Shutout record helps Adrianna Franch snag NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year honors|date=2017-10-18|website=The Equalizer|access-date=2024-06-27}}] |
| style="text-align:center"| 2018
!scope="row"| {{sortname|Adrianna|Franch}} (2)
| {{USA}}
| Portland Thorns FC
| Lydia Williams, Aubrey Bledsoe
|style="text-align:center"| [{{cite news|url=https://equalizersoccer.com/2018/09/27/adrianna-franch-repeats-as-goalkeeper-of-the-year/|title=Adrianna Franch repeats as NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year|date=September 27, 2018|website=The Equalizer|access-date=2024-06-27}}] |
| style="text-align:center"| 2019
!scope="row"| {{sortname|Aubrey|Kingsbury}}
| {{USA}}
| Washington Spirit
| Casey Murphy, Kailen Sheridan
|style="text-align:center"| [{{cite news|url=https://www.blackandredunited.com/washington-spirit-womens-soccer/2019/11/1/20944366/aubrey-bledsoe-2019-nwsl-goalkeeper-of-the-year-washington-spirit|title=Aubrey Bledsoe named 2019 NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year|last=Anderson|first=Jason|date=2019-11-01|website=Black and Red United|publisher=SB Nation|access-date=2024-06-27}}] |
| style="text-align:center"| 2020
|style="text-align:center" colspan=4| 2020 regular season cancelled due COVID-19 pandemic
|style="text-align:center"| [{{cite web |title=2020 Champions Cup Presented by P&G and Secret Roster Rules |url=https://prod-nwsl-cdn.s3.amazonaws.com/wp/uploads/2020/06/challengecup_rosterrules.pdf |publisher=NWSL |access-date=July 24, 2020 |archive-date=June 23, 2020 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20200623143416/https://prod-nwsl-cdn.s3.amazonaws.com/wp/uploads/2020/06/challengecup_rosterrules.pdf |url-status=live}}] |
| style="text-align:center"| 2021
!scope="row"| {{sortname|Aubrey|Kingsbury}} (2)
| {{USA}}
| Washington Spirit
| Bella Bixby, Kailen Sheridan
|style="text-align:center"| [{{cite news|url=https://justwomenssports.com/reads/audrey-bledsoe-wins-2021-nwsl-goalkeeper-of-the-year/|title=Aubrey Bledsoe Wins 2021 NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year|date=2021-11-19|last=Hruby|first=Emma|website=Just Women's Sports|access-date=2024-06-27}}] |
| style="text-align:center"| 2022
!scope="row"| {{sortname|Kailen|Sheridan}}
| {{CAN}}
| San Diego Wave FC
| Adrianna Franch, Phallon Tullis-Joyce
|style="text-align:center"| [{{cite news|url=https://equalizersoccer.com/2022/10/26/kailen-sheridan-named-2022-nwsl-goalkeeper-of-the-year/|title=Kailen Sheridan named 2022 NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year|last=Kassouf|first=Jeff|date=October 26, 2022|website=The Equalizer|access-date=2024-06-27}}] |
| style="text-align:center"| 2023
!scope="row"| {{sortname|Jane|Campbell|dab=soccer}}
| {{USA}}
| Houston Dash
| Katie Lund, Kailen Sheridan
|style="text-align:center"| [{{cite news|url=https://justwomenssports.com/reads/houston-dash-jane-campbell-nwsl-goalkeeper-award-2023/|title=Houston Dash's Jane Campbell Wins NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year|date=2023-11-08|website=Just Women's Sports|access-date=2024-06-27}}] |
| style="text-align:center"| 2024
!scope="row"| {{sortname|Ann-Katrin|Berger}}
| {{GER}}
| NJ/NY Gotham FC
| Mandy Haught, Anna Moorhouse
|style="text-align:center"| [{{Cite press release |url=https://www.nwslsoccer.com/news/nj-ny-gotham-fc-ann-katrin-berger-named-2024-nwsl-goalkeeper-of-the-year |title=NJ/NY Gotham FC Ann-Katrin Berger Named 2024 NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year |date=2024-11-20 |access-date=2024-11-20 |publisher=National Women's Soccer League}}] |
