Rule 5 draft results

{{Short description|List of Major League Baseball player drafts}}

Below are lists of Rule 5 draft results since 1997. Players selected in the Major League Baseball (MLB) phase of the Rule 5 draft must be kept on their new team's active roster for the entire following MLB season, or they are placed on waivers and offered back to their original team if not claimed. Players chosen in the Minor League Baseball phase(s) of the Rule 5 draft remain with their new organization without restrictions.

The Rule 5 draft has happened every year since 1920. The 2021 MLB lockout led to the postponement of the major league phase of the Rule 5 draft, but the minor league phase proceeded as scheduled.{{cite web|url=https://www.baseballamerica.com/stories/major-league-rule-5-draft-postponed-minor-league-phase-will-still-take-place/|title=Major League Rule 5 Draft Postponed, Minor League Phase Will Still Take Place|first=Kyle|last=Glaser|work=Baseball America|date=December 2, 2021|accessdate=December 2, 2021}}

Key

class="wikitable plainrowheaders"
scope="row"\|Pos \|Position
scope="row"\|C \|Catcher
scope="row"\|1B \|First baseman
scope="row"\|2B \|Second baseman
scope="row"\|3B \|Third baseman
scope="row"\|SS \|Shortstop
scope="row"\|IF \|Infielder
scope="row"\|OF \|Outfielder
scope="row"\|RHP \|Right-handed pitcher
scope="row"\|LHP \|Left-handed pitcher

class="wikitable plainrowheaders"

scope="row"|Pos

|Position

scope="row"|C

scope="row"|1B

scope="row"|2B

scope="row"|3B

scope="row"|SS

scope="row"|IF

scope="row"|OF

scope="row"|RHP

|Right-handed pitcher

scope="row"|LHP

|Left-handed pitcher

Results

class="wikitable" style="width:15%;"

!scope="row" style="background:#FFCC00;"|

|All Star Selection

=2024=

;Major league phasehttps://www.mlb.com/news/rule-5-draft-results-2024

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Chicago White Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Shane\|Smith\|dab=baseball}} \|RHP	Milwaukee Brewers
2	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Liam\|Hicks}} \|C	Detroit Tigers
3	Los Angeles Angels !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Garrett\|McDaniels}} \|LHP	Los Angeles Dodgers
4	Athletics !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Noah\|Murdock}} \| rowspan="3" \|RHP	Kansas City Royals
5	Washington Nationals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Evan\|Reifert}} \|Tampa Bay Rays	Returned to the Rays on March 18.{{Cite web \|last=Adams \|first=Steve \|date=2025-03-18 \|title= Nationals Return Rule 5 Pick Evan Reifert To Rays \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/nationals-return-rule-5-pick-evan-reifert-rays.html \|access-date=2025-03-18 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
6	Toronto Blue Jays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Angel\|Bastardo}} \|Boston Red Sox
7	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Cooper\|Bowman}} \|2B	Athletics	Returned to the Athletics on March 12.{{Cite web \|last=McDonald \|first=Darragh \|date=2025-03-12 \|title= Reds Return Rule 5 Selection Cooper Bowman To Athletics \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/reds-return-rule-5-selection-cooper-bowman-to-athletics.html \|access-date=2025-03-12 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
8	Tampa Bay Rays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nathan\|Lavender}} \|LHP	New York Mets
9	Minnesota Twins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Eiberson\|Castellano}} \|RHP	Philadelphia Phillies	Returned to the Phillies on March 25.{{Cite web \|last=Adams \|first=Steve \|date=2025-03-25 \|title= Mickey Gasper, DaShawn Keirsey Make Twins’ Roster; Twins Exploring Bullpen Market \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/twins-rumors-reliever-mickey-gasper-dashawn-keirsey-make-roster.html \|access-date=2025-03-26 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
10	Chicago Cubs !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Gage\|Workman}} \|SS	Detroit Tigers
11	Atlanta Braves !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Anderson\|Pilar}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Miami Marlins	Returned to the Marlins on March 19.{{Cite web \|last=McDonald \|first=Darragh \|date=2025-03-19 \|title= Braves To Return Rule 5 Pick Anderson Pilar To Marlins \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/braves-to-return-rule-5-pick-anderson-pilar-to-marlins.html \|access-date=2025-03-19 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
12	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Juan\|Núñez\|dab=baseball}} \|Baltimore Orioles	Returned to the Orioles on March 25.{{Cite web \|last=McDonald \|first=Darragh \|date=2025-03-25 \|title= Padres Return Rule 5 Pick Juan Nunez To Orioles \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/padres-to-return-rule-5-pick-juan-nunez-to-orioles.html \|access-date=2025-03-25 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
13	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Connor\|Thomas}} \|LHP	St. Louis Cardinals
14	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mike\|Vasil}} \|RHP	New York Mets	Traded to the Rays on December 11.{{Cite web \|last=Morganstern \|first=Leo \|date=2024-12-11 \|title= Phillies Trade Rule 5 Pick Mike Vasil To Rays \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2024/12/phillies-trade-rule-5-pick-mike-vasil-to-rays.html \|access-date=2025-03-18 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}} Claimed off waivers by the White Sox on March 23.{{Cite web \|last=Deeds \|first=Nick \|date=2025-03-23 \|title= White Sox Claim Mike Vasil Off Waivers From Rays \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/white-sox-claim-mike-vasil-off-waivers-from-rays.html \|access-date=2025-03-23 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
15	Atlanta Braves !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Christian\|Cairo}} \|SS	Cleveland Guardians	Returned to the Guardians on March 19.{{Cite web\|title=Braves Return Rule 5 Pick Christian Cairo To Guardians\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/braves-return-rule-5-pick-christian-cairo-to-guardians.html\|access-date=March 19, 2025\|website=mlbtraderumors.com\|language=en}}

;Minor league phase

Hyun-il Choi, RHP, Washington Nationals from the Los Angeles Dodgers
Hobie Harris, RHP, Boston Red Sox from the New York Mets
Will Wilson, SS, Cleveland Guardians from the San Francisco Giants
John Rhodes, OF, Los Angeles Dodgers from the Baltimore Orioles
Landon Marceaux, RHP, Kansas City Royals from the New York Mets
Zach Peek, RHP, Milwaukee Brewers from the Baltimore Orioles
Randy Labaut, LHP, Pittsburgh Pirates from the Cleveland Guardians
Matt Cronin, LHP, Seattle Mariners from the Washington Nationals
Nick Swiney, LHP, Houston Astros from the San Francisco Giants

=2023=

;Major league phase{{cite web|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/rule-5-draft-results-2023|title=2023 Rule 5 Draft results: Pick by pick|first=Jonathan|last=Mayo|work=MLB.com|date=December 6, 2023|accessdate=December 6, 2023}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Oakland Athletics !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mitch\|Spence}} \| rowspan="3" \|RHP	rowspan="2" \|New York Yankees
2	Kansas City Royals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Matt\|Sauer}} \| Returned to the Yankees on May 26.{{Cite web\|title=Yankees\|url=https://x.com/Yankees/status/1794779378850881975\|access-date=May 26, 2024\|website=x.com\|language=en}}
3	Colorado Rockies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Anthony\|Molina\|dab=baseball}} \|Tampa Bay Rays
4	Chicago White Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Shane\|Drohan}} \|LHP	Boston Red Sox	Returned to the Red Sox on June 12.{{Cite web \|last=McDonald \|first=Darragh \|date=2024-06-12 \|title= White Sox Return Rule 5 Pick Shane Drohan To Red Sox \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2024/06/white-sox-return-rule-5-pick-shane-drohan-to-red-sox.html \|access-date=2024-06-23 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
5	Washington Nationals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nasim\|Nuñez}} \|SS	Miami Marlins
6	St. Louis Cardinals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Ryan\|Fernandez}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Boston Red Sox
7	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Justin\|Slaten}} \|Texas Rangers	Traded to the Red Sox on December 6, 2023.{{Cite web \|last=Cerullo \|first=Mac \|date=2023-12-06 \|title=Red Sox acquire RHP Justin Slaten from Mets \|url=https://www.bostonherald.com/2023/12/06/red-sox-acquire-rhp-justin-slaten-from-mets/ \|access-date=2023-12-07 \|website=The Boston Herald}}
8	Cleveland Guardians !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Deyvison\|De Los Santos}} \|3B	Arizona Diamondbacks	Returned to the Diamondbacks on March 23, 2024.{{Cite web\|title=Diamondbacks get back Deyvison De Los Santos after Rule 5 selection\|url=https://arizonasports.com/story/3544879/diamondbacks-get-back-deyvison-de-los-santos-after-rule-5-selection/\|access-date=March 23, 2024\|website=arizonasports.com\|date=March 23, 2024 \|language=en}}
9	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Stephen\|Kolek}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Seattle Mariners
10	Texas Rangers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Carson\|Coleman}} \|New York Yankees	Returned to the Yankees on November 19, 2024.{{Cite web\|title=Yankees Select Caleb Durbin, Jesus Rodriguez\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2024/11/yankees-select-caleb-durbin-jesus-rodriguez.html\|access-date=November 20, 2024\|website=mlbtraderumors.com\|language=en}}

;Notable players chosen in the minor league phase

T. J. Sikkema, LHP, Cincinnati Reds from the Kansas City Royals
Clay Dungan, SS, San Diego Padres from the Kansas City Royals
Tyler Thomas, LHP, Atlanta Braves from the New York Mets
Ryan Miller, RHP Los Angeles Angels from the Boston Red Sox
Seth Beer, 1B, Pittsburgh Pirates from the Arizona Diamondbacks
Connor Gillispie, RHP, Cleveland Guardians from the Baltimore Orioles
Dariel Lopez, SS, San Francisco Giants from the Pittsburgh Pirates
Omar Cruz, LHP, San Diego Padres from the Pittsburgh Pirates
Kervin Castro, RHP, New York Yankees from the Houston Astros
Ryan Fitzgerald, 2B, Kansas City Royals from the Boston Red Sox
John Doxakis, LHP, Cleveland Guardians from the Tampa Bay Rays
Levi Jordan, SS, Cincinnati Reds from the Chicago Cubs
Bryce Ball, 1B, Philadelphia Phillies from the Cleveland Guardians
Eric Wagaman, 1B, Los Angeles Angels from the New York Yankees

=2022=

;Major league phase{{cite web|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/rule-5-draft-results-2022|title=Clubs pluck high-ceiling talent during Rule 5 Draft|website=MLB.com|first=Jonathan|last=Mayo|date=December 7, 2022|access-date=December 7, 2022}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Washington Nationals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Thaddeus\|Ward}} \|RHP \|Boston Red Sox \|
2	Oakland Athletics !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Ryan\|Noda}} \|1B \| rowspan="2" \|Los Angeles Dodgers
3	Pittsburgh Pirates !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|José\|Hernández\|dab=pitcher}} \|LHP
4	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Blake\|Sabol}} \|OF	Pittsburgh Pirates	Traded to the San Francisco Giants{{cite web \| url=https://sports.yahoo.com/giants-trade-blake-sabol-lose-023049958.html \| title=Giants trade for Blake Sabol, lose eight Double-A players in Rule 5 Draft }}
5	Detroit Tigers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mason\|Englert}} \| rowspan="7" \|RHP	Texas Rangers
6	Colorado Rockies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Kevin\|Kelly\|dab=pitcher, born 1997}} \| rowspan="2" \|Cleveland Guardians	Traded to the Tampa Bay Rays{{cite web \| url=https://www.cleveland.com/guardians/2022/12/guardians-lose-pitchers-nic-enright-and-kevin-kelly-in-rule-5-draft.html \| title=Guardians lose pitchers Nic Enright and Kevin Kelly in Rule 5 draft \| date=December 7, 2022 }}
7	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nic\|Enright}} \|Returned to the Guardians on June 1{{Cite web \|title=Guardians' Nic Enright: Returned to Cleveland \|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/guardians-nic-enright-returned-to-cleveland/amp/ \|access-date=2023-07-09 \|website=www.cbssports.com}}
8	Chicago White Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nick\|Avila}} \|San Francisco Giants	Returned to the Giants on March 28{{cite web \| url=https://www.turlockjournal.com/sports/pro-sports/avila-returned-giants-soderstrom-reassigned-spring-trainings-wraps/ \| title=Avila returned to Giants; Soderstrom reassigned as spring trainings wraps up }}
9	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Andrew\|Politi}} \|Boston Red Sox	Returned to Red Sox on March 28{{Cite web\|title=Red Sox's Andrew Politi: Returns to Red Sox\|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/red-soxs-andrew-politi-returns-to-red-sox/amp/\|access-date=2023-03-28\|website=cbssports.com\|language=en}}
10	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Gus\|Varland}} \|Los Angeles Dodgers	Returned to Dodgers on May 22{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2023/05/brewers-return-rule-5-gus-varland-dodgers.html\|title=Brewers Return Gus Varland To Dodgers, Place Eric Lauer On Injured List\|work=MLB Trade Rumors\|first=Steve and Darragh McDonald\|last=Adams\|date=May 22, 2023\|accessdate=May 22, 2023}}
11	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Noah\|Song}} \|Boston Red Sox	Returned to Red Sox on August 4{{cite web \| url=https://www.masslive.com/redsox/2023/08/noah-song-lost-in-the-rule-5-draft-last-december-returns-to-red-sox.html?outputType=amp \| title=Noah Song, lost in the Rule 5 draft last December, returns to Red Sox \| date=August 4, 2023 }}
12	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|José\|López\|dab=pitcher}} \|LHP	Tampa Bay Rays	Returned to Rays on March 26{{Cite web\|title=Rays' Jose Lopez: Returned to Tampa Bay\|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/rays-jose-lopez-returned-to-tampa-bay/amp/\|access-date=2023-03-26\|website=cbssports.com\|language=en}}
13	Seattle Mariners !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Chris\|Clarke\|dab=baseball}} \| rowspan="3" \|RHP	Chicago Cubs	Returned to Cubs on March 26{{Cite web\|title=Cubs' Chris Clarke: Returned to CHC\|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/cubs-chris-clarke-returned-to-chc/amp/\|access-date=2023-03-26\|website=cbssports.com\|language=en}}
14	St. Louis Cardinals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Wilking\|Rodríguez}} \| rowspan="2" \|New York Yankees	Spent entire season on injured list, released and re-signed to minor league contract November 21 {{cite web \| url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/cardinals-wilking-rodriguez-re-signed-to-minors-contract/amp/ \| title=Cardinals' Wilking Rodriguez: Re-signed to minors contract }}
15	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Zach\|Greene}} \| Returned to Yankees on March 14{{cite web\|title=Yankees' Zach Greene: Returns to Yankees organization\|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/yankees-zach-greene-returns-to-yankees-organization/amp/\|access-date=2023-03-14\|website=cbssports.com\|language=en}}

;Notable players chosen in the minor league phase

Wei-Chieh Huang, RHP, Pittsburgh Pirates from the San Francisco Giants
Dane Myers, 3B, Miami Marlins from the Detroit Tigers
Joe Jacques, LHP, Boston Red Sox from the Pittsburgh Pirates
Evan Mendoza, 3B, San Diego Padres from the St. Louis Cardinals
Héctor Pérez, RHP, Tampa Bay Rays from the Baltimore Orioles
Josh Palacios, OF, Pittsburgh Pirates from the Washington Nationals
Jared Oliva, OF, Los Angeles Angels from the Pittsburgh Pirates
Nick Burdi, RHP, Chicago Cubs from the San Diego Padres
Trey McGough, LHP, Baltimore Orioles from the Pittsburgh Pirates
Logan Warmoth, SS, Seattle Mariners from the Toronto Blue Jays
Bryan King, LHP, Houston Astros from the Chicago Cubs
Peter Solomon, RHP, Arizona Diamondbacks from the Pittsburgh Pirates
Jonathan Araúz, 2B, New York Mets from the Baltimore Orioles
Josh Stowers, OF, Los Angeles Dodgers from the Texas Rangers
Mateo Gil, SS, New York Mets from the Colorado Rockies
Oliver Dunn, 2B, Philadelphia Phillies from the New York Yankees
Isaac Collins, 2B, Milwaukee Brewers from the Colorado Rockies
Ryan Miller, RHP, Boston Red Sox from the New York Yankees

=2021=

The major league phase of the Rule 5 draft following the 2021 season was postponed due to the 2021 MLB lockout.{{Cite web|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/2021-rule-5-draft-minor-league-phase|title = Rule 5 Draft results, pick by pick|website = MLB.com}} When the lockout was resolved, the draft was cancelled.{{cite web | url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2022/03/2021-rule-5-draft-officially-canceled.html | title=2021 Rule 5 Draft Officially Canceled | date=March 10, 2022 }}

;Notable players chosen in the minor league phase

Andrew Young, 2B, Washington Nationals from the Arizona Diamondbacks
Charles Leblanc, IF, Miami Marlins from the Texas Rangers
Conner Menez, LHP, Chicago Cubs from the San Francisco Giants
Kenny Rosenberg, LHP, Los Angeles Angels from the Tampa Bay Rays
Ronnie Dawson, OF, Cincinnati Reds from the Houston Astros
John Nogowski, 1B, Atlanta Braves from the San Francisco Giants
Ben DeLuzio, OF, St. Louis Cardinals from the Arizona Diamondbacks
Caleb Boushley, RHP, Milwaukee Brewers from the San Diego Padres
Cole Uvila, RHP, Baltimore Orioles from the Texas Rangers
Curtis Taylor, RHP, Washington Nationals from the Toronto Blue Jays
Robert Garcia, LHP, Miami Marlins from the Kansas City Royals
Brian Keller, RHP, Boston Red Sox from the New York Yankees
Carson Fulmer, RHP, Los Angeles Dodgers from the Cincinnati Reds
Allan Winans, RHP, Atlanta Braves from the New York Mets
Jon Duplantier, RHP, Los Angeles Dodgers from the San Francisco Giants

=2020=

;Major league phase{{cite web|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/2020-rule-5-draft-results|title=2020 Rule 5 Draft results: Pick by pick|website=MLB.com|date=December 10, 2020|access-date=December 10, 2020}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Pittsburgh Pirates !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|José\|Soriano\|dab=baseball}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Los Angeles Angels	Spent entire season on injured list, returned to Angels on November 14{{Cite web\|url=https://triblive.com/sports/pirates-return-rhp-jose-soriano-the-no-1-pick-in-rule-5-draft-to-angels/\|title = Pirates return RHP Jose Soriano, the No. 1 pick in Rule 5 Draft, to Angels\|date = November 15, 2021}}
2	Texas Rangers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brett\|de Geus}} \|{{nowrap\|Los Angeles Dodgers}}	Claimed off waivers by the Arizona Diamondbacks on June 25
3	Detroit Tigers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Akil\|Baddoo}} \|OF	Minnesota Twins
4	Boston Red Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Garrett\|Whitlock}} \| rowspan="7" \|RHP	New York Yankees
5	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mac\|Sceroler}} \|Cincinnati Reds	Returned to Reds on June 26
6	{{nowrap\|Arizona Diamondbacks}} !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Zach\|Pop}} \|Baltimore Orioles	Traded to the Miami Marlins
7	Colorado Rockies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Jordan\|Sheffield}} \|Los Angeles Dodgers
8	Los Angeles Angels !scope="row"\|{{nowrap\|{{sortname\|José Alberto\|Rivera\|nolink=y}}}} \|Houston Astros	Returned to Astros on March 24
9	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Luis\|Oviedo}} \|Cleveland Indians	Traded to the Pittsburgh Pirates
10	Seattle Mariners !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Will\|Vest}} \|Detroit Tigers	Returned to Tigers on July 17
11	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Kyle\|Holder}} \|SS	New York Yankees	Traded to the Cincinnati Reds, returned to Yankees on March 30.
12	San Francisco Giants !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Dedniel\|Núñez}} \| rowspan="4" \|RHP	New York Mets	Spent entire season on injured list, returned to Mets on November 19{{Cite web\|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/mets-protect-players-from-2021-rule-5-draft\|title = Mets shield 4 players from Rule 5 Draft\|website = MLB.com}}
13	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Paul\|Campbell\|dab=pitcher}} \|Tampa Bay Rays
14	Chicago Cubs !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Gray\|Fenter}} \|Baltimore Orioles	Returned to Orioles on March 12
15	Cleveland Indians !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Trevor\|Stephan}} \|New York Yankees
16	Oakland Athletics !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Ka'ai\|Tom}} \|OF	Cleveland Indians	Claimed off waivers by the Pittsburgh Pirates on April 21. Designated for assignment on August 16 and outrighted to Triple-A after Indians declined to take him back. Released by Pirates on September 20.
17	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Tyler\|Wells}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Minnesota Twins
18	Oakland Athletics !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Dany\|Jiménez}} \|Toronto Blue Jays	Returned to Blue Jays on March 15

;Notable players chosen in the minor league phase

Shea Spitzbarth, RHP, Pittsburgh Pirates from the Los Angeles Dodgers
Tyler Gilbert, LHP, Arizona Diamondbacks from the Los Angeles Dodgers
Brendon Davis, IF, Los Angeles Angels from the Texas Rangers
Jake Fishman, LHP, Miami Marlins from the Toronto Blue Jays
Matt Krook, LHP, New York Yankees from the Tampa Bay Rays
Nicholas Padilla, RHP, Chicago Cubs from the Tampa Bay Rays
Chris Roller, OF, Cleveland Indians from the Los Angeles Dodgers
A.J. Puckett, RHP, Atlanta Braves from the Chicago White Sox
Zach Jackson, RHP, Oakland Athletics from the Toronto Blue Jays
Reggie McClain, RHP, New York Yankees from the Philadelphia Phillies
Brett Graves, RHP, Oakland Athletics from the Miami Marlins
Drew Jackson, 2B, New York Mets from the Los Angeles Dodgers
Chuckie Robinson, C, Cincinnati Reds from the Houston Astros
Yohel Pozo, C/DH, Texas Rangers from San Diego Padres
Kaleb Ort, RHP, Boston Red Sox from the New York Yankees
Ronnie Williams, RHP, San Francisco Giants from the St. Louis Cardinals
Seth Martinez, RHP, Houston Astros from the Oakland Athletics

=2019=

;Major league phase{{cite web|url=https://www.mlb.com/breaking-news/rule-5-draft-2019|title=2019 Rule 5 Draft results: Pick by pick|website=MLB.com|date=December 12, 2019|access-date=December 12, 2019}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Detroit Tigers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Rony\|García }} \| rowspan="5" \|RHP	New York Yankees
2	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brandon\|Bailey\|dab=baseball}} \|Houston Astros	Returned to Astros
3	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Sterling\|Sharp}} \|Washington Nationals	Returned to Nationals
4	Kansas City Royals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Stephen\|Woods Jr.}} \|Tampa Bay Rays	Returned to Rays, then traded back to Royals
5	Seattle Mariners !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Yohan\|Ramírez}} \|Houston Astros
6	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mark\|Payton}} \|OF	Oakland Athletics	Returned to Athletics, then traded back to Reds
7	San Francisco Giants !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Dany\|Jiménez}} \|RHP	Toronto Blue Jays	Returned to Blue Jays
8	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Vimael\|Machín}} \|IF	Chicago Cubs	Traded to the Oakland Athletics{{cite web\|url=https://www.inquirer.com/phillies/phillies-rule-5-draft-winter-meetings-vimael-machin-20191212.html\|title=Phillies select, then trade minor-league infielder Vimael Machin in Rule 5 draft\|author=Scott Lauber\|date=December 12, 2019\|website=The Philadelphia Inquirer\|access-date=December 12, 2019}}
9	Chicago Cubs !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Trevor\|Megill}} \|RHP	San Diego Padres	Returned to Padres, then traded back to Cubs{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2020/07/cubs-select-jason-kipnis-return-re-acquire-trevor-megill.html\|title=Cubs Select Jason Kipnis, Return & Re-Acquire Trevor Megill\|author=Jeff Todd\|date=July 17, 2020\|website=MLB Trade Rumors\|access-date=July 17, 2020}}
10	Boston Red Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Jonathan\|Araúz}} \|IF	Houston Astros
11	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Michael\|Rucker\|dab=baseball}} \|RHP	Chicago Cubs	Returned to Cubs

;Notable players chosen in the minor league phase

Hobie Harris, RHP, Toronto Blue Jays from the New York Yankees
Brian O'Keefe, C, Seattle Mariners from the St. Louis Cardinals
Brock Stewart, RHP, Chicago Cubs from the Toronto Blue Jays
Raynel Espinal, RHP, Boston Red Sox from the New York Yankees
Adam Oller, RHP, New York Mets from the San Francisco Giants
Danny Young, LHP, Cleveland Indians from the Toronto Blue Jays
Jason Krizan, OF, Oakland Athletics from the New York Mets
José Espada, RHP, Boston Red Sox from the Toronto Blue Jays
Jacob Bosiokovic, RHP, St. Louis Cardinals from the Colorado Rockies

=2018=

;Major league phase{{cite web|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/2018-rule-5-draft-results/c-301780782|title=2018 Rule 5 Draft results|website=MLB.com|access-date=December 14, 2018}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Richie\|Martin}} \|SS	Oakland Athletics
2	Kansas City Royals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Sam\|McWilliams}} \| rowspan="4" \|RHP	Tampa Bay Rays	Returned to the Rays{{cite web\|url=https://www.tampabay.com/sports/2019/03/24/rule-5-pick-sam-mcwilliams-returned-to-rays/ \|title=Rule 5 pick Sam McWilliams returned to Rays \|publisher=Tampabay.com \|date=March 24, 2019 \|access-date=April 9, 2019}}
3	Chicago White Sox !scope="row" style="background:#fc0\|{{sortname\|Jordan\|Romano}} \|Toronto Blue Jays	Traded to the Texas Rangers, and returned to the Blue Jays{{cite web\|url=https://www.sportsnet.ca/baseball/mlb/rule-5-pitcher-jordan-romano-returning-blue-jays/\|title=Rule 5 pitcher Jordan Romano returning to Blue Jays\|work=Sportsnet\|date=March 24, 2019\|access-date=March 24, 2019}}
4	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Riley\|Ferrell\|nolink=y}} \|Houston Astros	Returned to the Astros{{cite web\|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/astros-riley-ferrell-sent-back-to-houston/\|title=Astros' Riley Ferrell: Sent back to Houston\|author=RotoWire Staff\|work=CBS Sports\|date=June 24, 2019\|access-date=June 24, 2019}}
5	Detroit Tigers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Reed\|Garrett}} \|Texas Rangers	Returned to the Rangers{{cite web\|url=https://sports.yahoo.com/tigers-return-rule-5-selection-214650257.html\|title=Tigers return Rule 5 selection Garrett to Rangers\|publisher=Yahoo Sports\|date=May 20, 2019 \|access-date=May 31, 2019}}
6	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Connor\|Joe}} \|IF/OF	Los Angeles Dodgers	Traded to the San Francisco Giants,{{cite web\|last=Simmons \|first=Rusty \|url=https://www.sfchronicle.com/giants/article/Pablo-Sandoval-s-future-even-murkier-after-13707692.php \|title=Pablo Sandoval's future even murkier after Giants acquire versatile Connor Joe from Reds \|publisher=SFChronicle.com \|date=March 21, 2019 \|access-date=April 9, 2019}} and returned to the Dodgers{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/rule-5-pick-connor-joe-returned-to-dodgers\|title=Rule 5 pick Joe returned to Dodgers\|work=MLB.com\|author=Ken Gurnick\|date=April 13, 2019\|access-date=May 31, 2019}}
7	Texas Rangers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Chris\|Ellis\|dab=baseball}} \|RHP	St. Louis Cardinals	Traded to the Royals,{{cite web\|last=Rieper \|first=Max \|url=https://www.royalsreview.com/2018/12/13/18139440/royals-rule-5-draft-sam-mcwilliams-chris-ellis-luciano \|title=Royals acquire two pitchers in the Rule 5 draft \|publisher=Royals Review \|date=December 13, 2018 \|access-date=April 9, 2019}} returned to the Cardinals{{cite web\|author=FOX Sports Midwest \|url=https://www.foxsports.com/midwest/story/st-louis-cardinals-get-former-rule-5-pick-chris-ellis-back-from-kansas-city-royals-040919 \|title=Cardinals get former Rule 5 pick Chris Ellis back from Royals \|work=FOX Sports \|date=April 9, 2019 \|access-date=April 9, 2019}}
8	San Francisco Giants !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Travis\|Bergen}} \|LHP	Toronto Blue Jays	Returned to Blue Jays.{{cite web\|author=Laura Armstrong\|url=https://www.thestar.com/sports/bluejays/2019/08/22/lefty-travis-bergen-latest-rule-5-returnee-for-blue-jays.html\|title=Lefty Travis Bergen latest Rule 5 returnee for Blue Jays\|work=Toronto Star\|date=August 22, 2019\|access-date=August 25, 2019}}
9	Toronto Blue Jays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Elvis\|Luciano}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Kansas City Royals
10	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Kyle\|Dowdy}} \|Cleveland Indians	Claimed by Rangers, and returned to Cleveland on July 28, 2019.{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2019/07/rangers-return-rule-5-pick-kyle-dowdy-to-indians.html\|title=Rangers Return Rule 5 Pick Kyle Dowdy To Indians\|author=George Miller\|website=MLB Trade Rumors\|date=July 28, 2019\|access-date=July 28, 2019}}
11	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Drew\|Jackson}} \|SS	Los Angeles Dodgers	Traded to the Baltimore Orioles in exchange for international bonus slot money,{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2018/12/2018-rule-5-draft-results.html\|title=2018 Rule 5 Draft Results\|website=MLB Trade Rumors\|date=December 13, 2018 \|access-date=December 14, 2018}} and returned to the Dodgers{{cite web\|url=https://www.baltimoresun.com/sports/orioles/bs-sp-orioles-drew-jackson-dodgers-20190410-story.html\|title=Orioles Rule 5 draftee Drew Jackson clears waivers, returned to Dodgers\|work=Baltimore Sun\|author=Nathan Ruiz\|date=April 10, 2019\|access-date=May 31, 2019}}
12	Arizona Diamondbacks !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nick\|Green\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	New York Yankees	Returned to the Yankees{{cite web\|url=http://arizonasports.com/story/1887606/arizona-diamondbacks-return-rule-5-pick-nick-green-to-yankees/ \|title=Arizona Diamondbacks return Rule 5 pick Nick Green to Yankees \|publisher=Arizonasports.com \|date=March 24, 2019 \|access-date=April 9, 2019}}
13	Seattle Mariners !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brandon\|Brennan}} \|Colorado Rockies
14	San Francisco Giants !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Drew\|Ferguson\|nolink=y}} \|OF	Houston Astros	Returned to the Astros{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2019/03/giants-return-rule-5-pick-drew-ferguson-to-astros.html\|title=Giants Return Rule 5 Pick Drew Ferguson To Astros\|last=Adams\|first=Steve\|work=mlbtraderumors.com\|date=March 22, 2019\|access-date=March 22, 2019}}

;Notable players chosen in the minor league phase

Braxton Lee, OF, New York Mets from the Miami Marlins
Dusten Knight, P, Minnesota Twins from the San Francisco Giants
Ryan Thompson, P, Tampa Bay Rays from Houston Astros
Luis Lugo, LHP, Chicago Cubs from the Kansas City Royals
Corban Joseph, 2B, Oakland Athletics from the Baltimore Orioles
Sam Moll, RHP, San Francisco Giants from the Toronto Blue Jays
Mark Payton, OF, Oakland Athletics from the New York Yankees
Chris Mazza, RHP, New York Mets from the Seattle Mariners
Ian Gardeck, RHP, Tampa Bay Rays from the San Francisco Giants

=2017=

;Major league phase{{cite web|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/2017-mlb-rule-5-draft-results/c-263351580|title=2017 MLB Rule 5 Draft results|website=MLB.com|access-date=December 14, 2018}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Detroit Tigers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Víctor\|Reyes}} \|OF	Arizona Diamondbacks
2	San Francisco Giants !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Julián\|Fernández\|dab=baseball}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Colorado Rockies	Spent entire season on the disabled list, traded to the Miami Marlins, spent another season on the disabled list, returned to Rockies
3	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nick\|Burdi}} \|Minnesota Twins	Traded to the Pittsburgh Pirates, started the season on the disabled list
4	Chicago White Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Carlos\|Tocci}} \|OF	Philadelphia Phillies	Traded to the Texas Rangers, made the Rangers' Opening Day roster{{cite web\|last=Morris \|first=Adam J. \|url=https://www.lonestarball.com/2018/3/23/17157686/carlos-tocci-will-make-texas-rangers-opening-day-roster \|title=Carlos Tocci, Ryan Rua will make Texas Rangers Opening Day roster \|date=March 23, 2018 \|publisher=Lone Star Ball \|access-date=March 24, 2018}}
5	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brad\|Keller\|dab=baseball}} \| rowspan="4" \|RHP	Arizona Diamondbacks	Traded to the Kansas City Royals
6	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Burch\|Smith}} \|Tampa Bay Rays	Traded to the Kansas City Royals
7	Atlanta Braves !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Anyelo\|Gómez\|nolink=y}} \|New York Yankees	Returned to the Yankees{{cite web\|author=New York Yankees \|url=https://twitter.com/Yankees/status/976188961122025472 \|title=New York Yankees on Twitter: "Earlier today, the Yankees received RHP Anyelo Gomez as a Rule 5 Draft return from the Atlanta Braves and assigned him to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre." \|publisher=Twitter.com \|date=March 20, 2018 \|access-date=March 24, 2018}}
8	Pittsburgh Pirates !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Jordan\|Milbrath}} \|Cleveland Indians	Returned to the Indians
9	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row" style="background:#fc0" \|{{sortname\|Néstor\|Cortés Jr.}} \|LHP	New York Yankees	Made the Orioles' Opening Day roster, returned to the Yankees on April 13{{cite web\|url=http://riveraveblues.com/2018/04/orioles-return-rule-5-draft-pick-nestor-cortes-yankees-168965/ \|title=Orioles return Rule 5 Draft pick Nestor Cortes to Yankees - River Avenue Blues \|date=April 14, 2018 \|publisher=Riveraveblues.com \|access-date=April 14, 2018}}
10	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Elieser\|Hernández}} \|RHP	Houston Astros
11	Seattle Mariners !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mike\|Ford\|dab=baseball}} \|1B	New York Yankees	Returned to the Yankees{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/mariners-send-rule-5-pick-mike-ford-to-yanks/c-269600818\|title=Mariners send Rule 5 pick Mike Ford to Yanks\|website=MLB.com\|access-date=December 14, 2018}}
12	Los Angeles Angels !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Luke\|Bard}} \| rowspan="3" \|RHP	Minnesota Twins	Made the Angels' Opening Day roster, returned to Twins on April 27 {{Cite web\|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/rule-5-selection-luke-bard-returns-to-twins-c274133084\|title = Rule 5 Draft selection Bard returns to Twins\|website = MLB.com}}
13	Minnesota Twins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Tyler\|Kinley}} \|Miami Marlins	Made the Twins' Opening Day roster,{{cite web\|last=Miller \|first=Phil \|url=http://www.startribune.com/phil-hughes-dl-stint-opens-door-for-relievers-gabriel-moya-tyler-kinley-to-join-twins/478120283/ \|title=Relievers Moya, Kinley get bullpen spots with Hughes sidelined \|publisher=StarTribune.com \|access-date=March 28, 2018}} designated for assignment on April 26{{cite web\|url=http://www.startribune.com/i-know-i-ll-be-all-right-says-slumping-twins-slugger-logan-morrison/480886281/\|title=Twins designate pitcher Tyler Kinley for assignment, call up Aaron Slegers\|website=Star Tribune\|date=April 26, 2018 \|access-date=December 14, 2018}} and returned to Marlins
14	Arizona Diamondbacks !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Albert\|Suárez}} \|San Francisco Giants
15	Houston Astros !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Anthony\|Gose}} \|LHP/OF	Texas Rangers	Returned to the Rangers
16	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Pedro\|Araújo\|dab=baseball}} \| rowspan="3" \|RHP	Chicago Cubs	Made the Orioles' Opening Day roster,{{cite web\|url=http://www.baltimoresun.com/sports/orioles/blog/bs-sp-orioles-araujo-20180324-story.html \|title=Rule 5 pick Pedro Araujo goes from low minors to Orioles' Opening Day roster \|publisher=Baltimore Sun \|access-date=March 24, 2018}} designated for assignment on April 3, 2019, returned to the Cubs, traded to Orioles {{Cite web\|url=https://www.baltimoresun.com/sports/orioles/bs-sp-orioles-wotherspoon-araujo-20190403-story.html\|title=Orioles add right-hander Matt Wotherspoon, only to send him back to Triple-A after loss\|date=April 3, 2019 }}
17	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brett\|Graves}} \|Oakland Athletics
18	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|José\|Mesa Jr.}} \|New York Yankees	Returned to the Yankees

;Minor league phase

Yermín Mercedes, C, Chicago White Sox from the Baltimore Orioles
Mitch Nay, 3B, Cincinnati Reds from the Toronto Blue Jays
Damien Magnifico, RHP, Pittsburgh Pirates from the Los Angeles Angels
Martin Červenka, C, Baltimore Orioles from the San Francisco Giants
Joseph Odom, C, Seattle Mariners from the Atlanta Braves
Locke St. John, LHP, Texas Rangers from the Detroit Tigers
Daniel Duarte, RHP, Kansas City Royals from the Texas Rangers
Jacob Wilson, 2B, Washington Nationals from the St. Louis Cardinals
R. C. Orlan, RHP, Cleveland Indians from the Washington Nationals
Tyler Smith, SS, Atlanta Braves from the Texas Rangers
Iván Castillo, IF/OF, Toronto Blue Jays from the Cleveland Indians

=2016=

;Major League phase{{cite web|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/2016-rule-5-draft-results-c210580878|title=2016 Rule 5 Draft results|work=MLB.com|access-date=December 8, 2016}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Minnesota Twins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Miguel\|Díaz\|dab=baseball}} \|RHP	Milwaukee Brewers	Traded to the San Diego Padres
2	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Luis\|Torrens}} \|C	New York Yankees	Traded to the San Diego Padres
3	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Allen\|Córdoba}} \|SS	St. Louis Cardinals	Made the Padres' Opening Day roster
4	Tampa Bay Rays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Kevin\|Gadea\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="3" \|RHP	Seattle Mariners	Started the season on the disabled list, waived and released in August 2019
5	Atlanta Braves !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Armando\|Rivero}} \|Chicago Cubs	Started the season on the disabled list
6	Arizona Diamondbacks !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Tyler\|Jones\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="2" \|New York Yankees	Returned to the Yankees{{cite web\|url=http://riveraveblues.com/2017/03/diamondbacks-return-rule-5-draft-pick-tyler-jones-to-yankees-151177/\|title=Diamondbacks return Rule 5 Draft pick Tyler Jones to Yankees – River Avenue Blues\|date=March 24, 2017\|access-date=April 3, 2017}}
7	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Caleb\|Smith\|dab=baseball}} \|LHP	Traded to the Chicago Cubs, and returned to the Yankees{{cite web\|url=http://www.csnchicago.com/chicago-cubs/cubs-return-rule-5-lefty-caleb-smith-yankees-roster-comes-focus\|title=Cubs return Rule 5 lefty Caleb Smith to Yankees as roster comes into focus\|date=March 28, 2017\|access-date=April 3, 2017}}
8	Los Angeles Angels !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Justin\|Haley\|dab=baseball}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Boston Red Sox	Traded to the San Diego Padres, and then to the Minnesota Twins, returned to Boston July 2017
9	Chicago White Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Dylan\|Covey}} \|Oakland Athletics	Made the White Sox' Opening Day roster
10	Pittsburgh Pirates !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Tyler\|Webb}} \| rowspan="2" \|LHP	New York Yankees	Returned to the Yankees{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2017/04/pirates-return-tyler-webb-to-yankees.html\|title=Pirates Return Tyler Webb To Yankees\|date=April 2017 \|access-date=April 3, 2017}}
11	Detroit Tigers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Daniel\|Stumpf}} \|Kansas City Royals	Elected free agency after waived by Detroit, and resigned with Detroit{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2017/04/tigers-to-re-sign-daniel-stumpf.html\|title=Tigers To Re-Sign Daniel Stumpf\|date=April 2017 \|access-date=April 3, 2017}}
12	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Aneury\|Tavárez}} \|OF	Boston Red Sox	Returned to the Red Sox
13	Toronto Blue Jays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Glenn\|Sparkman}} \|RHP	Kansas City Royals	Started the season on the disabled list and returned to the Royals
14	Boston Red Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Josh\|Rutledge}} \|SS	Colorado Rockies	Started the season on the disabled list
15	Cleveland Indians !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Hoby\|Milner}} \|LHP	Philadelphia Phillies	Returned to the Phillies{{cite web\|url=http://www.philly.com/philly/sports/phillies/Phillies-Hoby-Milner-sidearmer-back-should-reach-majors-in-2017.html\|title=Sidearmer Hoby Milner, back with Phillies, should reach majors in 2017\|date=March 27, 2017 \|access-date=April 3, 2017}}
16	Texas Rangers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mike\|Hauschild}} \|RHP	Houston Astros	Made the Rangers' Opening Day roster, returned to Astros
17	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Stuart\|Turner\|dab=baseball}} \|C	Minnesota Twins	Made the Reds' Opening Day roster
18	Baltimore Orioles \|!scope="row" style="background:#fc0" \|{{sortname\|Anthony\|Santander}} \|OF	Cleveland Indians	Started the season on the disabled list

;Minor league phase – notable players

Ty Hensley, RHP, Tampa Bay Rays from the New York Yankees
Anthony Bemboom, C, Colorado Rockies from the Los Angeles Angels
Cal Towey, OF, Miami Marlins from the Los Angeles Angels
Austin Wilson, OF, St. Louis Cardinals from the Seattle Mariners
Nick Maronde, LHP, Miami Marlins from the Cleveland Indians
Colten Brewer, RHP, New York Yankees from the Pittsburgh Pirates
Brian Moran, LHP, Baltimore Orioles from the Atlanta Braves
Alex Yarbrough, 2B, Miami Marlins from the Los Angeles Angels

=2015=

;Major League phase{{cite web|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/2015-rule-5-draft-results/c-159262782|title=2015 Rule 5 Draft results|work=Major League Baseball|access-date=December 10, 2015}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Tyler\|Goeddel}} \| rowspan="2" \|OF	Tampa Bay Rays	Remained with the Phillies for the entire season
2	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Jake\|Cave}} \| rowspan="2" \|New York Yankees	Returned to the New York Yankees
3	Atlanta Braves !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Evan\|Rutckyj}} \|LHP	Returned to the New York Yankees
4	Colorado Rockies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Luis\|Perdomo\|dab=baseball, born 1993}} \|RHP	St. Louis Cardinals	Traded to the San Diego Padres, remained with the Padres for the entire season
5	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Colin\|Walsh\|dab=baseball}} \|2B	Oakland Athletics	Returned to the Oakland Athletics
6	Oakland Athletics !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Jabari\|Blash}} \|OF	Seattle Mariners	Traded to the San Diego Padres
7	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Josh\|Martin\|nolink=1}} \|RHP	Cleveland Indians	Returned to the Cleveland Indians{{cite web\|url=http://www.letsgotribe.com/2016/4/12/11415312/josh-martin-rule-5-draft-cleveland-indians\|title=Josh Martin returned to Indians\|date=April 12, 2016\|access-date=April 3, 2017}}
8	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Joey\|Rickard}} \|OF	Tampa Bay Rays	Remained with the Orioles for the entire season
9	Los Angeles Angels !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Deolis\|Guerra}} \| rowspan="3" \|RHP	Pittsburgh Pirates	Remained with the Angels for the entire season
10	Toronto Blue Jays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Joe\|Biagini}} \|San Francisco Giants	Remained with the Blue Jays for the entire season
11	St. Louis Cardinals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Matt\|Bowman}} \|New York Mets	Remained with the Cardinals for the entire season
12	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Daniel\|Stumpf}} \| rowspan="2" \|LHP	Kansas City Royals	Returned to the Kansas City Royals{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2016/07/phillies-return-daniel-stumpf-royals-rule5.html\|title=Phillies Return Rule 5 Pick Daniel Stumpf To Royals\|date=July 25, 2016 \|access-date=April 3, 2017}}
13	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Chris\|O'Grady\|dab=baseball}} \|Los Angeles Angels	Returned to the Los Angeles Angels
14	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Zack\|Jones\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Minnesota Twins	Returned to the Minnesota Twins{{cite web\|url=http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2016/06/brewers-return-rule-5-pick-zack-jones-to-twins.html\|title=Brewers Return Rule 5 Pick Zack Jones To Twins\|date=June 19, 2016 \|access-date=April 3, 2017}}
15	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Blake\|Smith\|dab=baseball}} \|Chicago White Sox	Returned to the White Sox{{cite web\|url=http://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/2016/mar/27/padres-return-blake-smith-rule-5-white-sox/\|title=Padres return Blake Smith to White Sox\|first=Dennis\|last=Lin\|date=March 27, 2016\|access-date=April 3, 2017}}
16	Los Angeles Angels !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Ji-man\|Choi}} \|1B	Baltimore Orioles

;Minor league phases – notable players

Ariel Hernandez, RHP, Cincinnati Reds from the Arizona Diamondbacks
Enderson Franco, RHP, Atlanta Braves from the Miami Marlins
Brian Moran, LHP Cleveland Indians from the Seattle Mariners
Zack Cox, 3B, Washington Nationals from the Miami Marlins
Yefry Ramírez, RHP, New York Yankees from the Arizona Diamondbacks
David Freitas, C, Chicago Cubs from the Baltimore Orioles
John Brebbia, RHP, St. Louis Cardinals from the Arizona Diamondbacks
D. J. Johnson, RHP, Los Angeles Angels from the Miami Marlins

=2014=

;Major League phase{{cite web|url=http://m.mlb.com/news/article/103814668/2014-major-leaue-baseball-rule-5-draft-results/|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20141215064036/http://m.mlb.com/news/article/103814668/2014-major-leaue-baseball-rule-5-draft-results|url-status=dead|archive-date=December 15, 2014|title=2014 Major League Baseball Rule 5 Draft results|website=MLB.com|access-date=April 3, 2017}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Arizona Diamondbacks !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Oscar\|Hernández\|dab=baseball}} \|C	Tampa Bay Rays
2	Colorado Rockies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mark\|Canha}} \|IF	Miami Marlins	Traded to the Oakland Athletics
3	Texas Rangers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Delino\|DeShields Jr.}} \|OF	Houston Astros
4	Houston Astros !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Jason\|Garcia}} \| rowspan="3" \|RHP	Boston Red Sox	Traded to the Baltimore Orioles
5	Minnesota Twins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|J. R.\|Graham}} \|Atlanta Braves
6	Boston Red Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Jandel\|Gustave}} \|Houston Astros	Traded to the Kansas City Royals, claimed by the San Diego Padres, returned to the Astros
7	Chicago Cubs !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Taylor\|Featherston}} \|SS	Colorado Rockies	Traded to the Los Angeles Angels
8	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\|{{sortname\|Odúbel\|Herrera}} \|IF	Texas Rangers
9	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Andrew\|McKirahan}} \| rowspan="2" \|LHP	Chicago Cubs	Claimed by the Atlanta Braves
10	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Sean\|Gilmartin}} \|Minnesota Twins
11	Atlanta Braves !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Daniel\|Winkler\|dab=baseball}} \|RHP	Colorado Rockies	Did not spend 90 days on active roster. Needed about 2 months on the active roster to remain with the Braves{{cite web\|url=http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2015/09/september-rule-5-roundup.html\|title=September Rule 5 Roundup\|date=September 14, 2015 \|access-date=April 3, 2017}}
12	Seattle Mariners !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|David\|Rollins\|dab=baseball}} \|LHP	Houston Astros
13	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Logan\|Verrett}} \|RHP	New York Mets	Claimed by the Texas Rangers, made the Rangers' Opening Day roster, returned to the Mets
14	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Andy\|Oliver}} \|LHP	Pittsburgh Pirates	Outrighted to the minors by the Phillies, but opted for free agency

;Minor league phase – notable players

Tim Crabbe, RHP, Arizona Diamondbacks from the Cincinnati Reds
Greg Peavey, RHP, Minnesota Twins from the New York Mets
Sean Halton, OF, Baltimore Orioles from the Milwaukee Brewers
Brett Jackson, OF, San Francisco Giants from the Arizona Diamondbacks
Randy Fontanez, RHP, Los Angeles Dodgers from the New York Mets
Kentrail Davis, OF, Los Angeles Angels from the Milwaukee Brewers

=2013=

;Major League phase{{cite web|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/2013-mlb-rule-5-draft-results/c-64621448|title=2013 MLB Rule 5 Draft results|website=MLB.com|access-date=April 3, 2017}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Houston Astros !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Patrick\|Schuster}} \|LHP	Arizona Diamondbacks	Sent to the San Diego Padres as the player to be named later for Anthony Bass, Returned to the Diamondbacks
2	Chicago White Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Adrián\|Nieto}} \|C	Washington Nationals
3	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Kevin\|Munson}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Arizona Diamondbacks	Returned to the Diamondbacks
4	Colorado Rockies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Tommy\|Kahnle}} \|New York Yankees
5	Toronto Blue Jays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brian\|Moran\|dab=baseball}} \|LHP	Seattle Mariners	Traded to the Los Angeles Angels{{cite web\|url=http://www.ocregister.com/angels/rule-541334-moran-draft.html\|title=Angels acquire LHP Brian Moran in Rule 5 draft\|date=December 12, 2013\|access-date=December 10, 2015}}
6	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Seth\|Rosin}} \|RHP	Philadelphia Phillies	Traded to the Los Angeles Dodgers,{{cite web\|last=Adams \|first=Steve \|url=http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2013/12/dodgers-acquire-seth-rosin.html \|title=Dodgers Acquire Seth Rosin: MLB Rumors \|publisher=MLBTradeRumors.com \|access-date=December 12, 2013}} Claimed off waivers by the Rangers,{{cite web\|last=Cash \|first=David \|url=https://nolanwritin.com/2014/03/27/seth-rosin-acquired-by-the-texas-rangers-los-angeles-dodgers-spring-training-waivers/ \|title=Seth Rosin acquired by the Texas Rangers \|date=March 27, 2014 \|publisher=Fansided \|access-date=December 16, 2019}} Returned to the Phillies
7	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Wei-Chung\|Wang}} \|LHP	Pittsburgh Pirates
8	Arizona Diamondbacks !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Marcos\|Mateo}} \|RHP	Chicago Cubs	Returned to the Cubs during spring training{{cite web\|url=https://www.chicagotribune.com/sports/baseball/cubs/chi-marcos-mateo-back-20140313,0,2190358.story\|title=Cubs get Mateo back from Diamondbacks\|work=tribunedigital-chicagotribune\|access-date=December 10, 2015}}
9	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Michael\|Almanzar}} \|3B	Boston Red Sox	Returned to the Red Sox, later traded to Orioles

;Minor league phase – notable players

Justin Bour, 1B, Miami Marlins from the Chicago Cubs
Evan Crawford, LHP, Chicago White Sox from the Toronto Blue Jays
Kevin Mattison, OF, Milwaukee Brewers from the Miami Marlins
Julio Borbón, OF, Baltimore Orioles from the Chicago Cubs
Russell Wilson, 2B, Texas Rangers from the Colorado Rockies
Enderson Franco, RHP, Tampa Bay Rays from the Houston Astros
Tim Atherton, RHP, Oakland Athletics from the Minnesota Twins
Omar Narváez, C, Chicago White Sox from the Tampa Bay Rays
Richard Bleier, LHP, Toronto Blue Jays from the Texas Rangers
A. J. Morris, RHP, Pittsburgh Pirates from the Chicago Cubs

=2012=

;Major League phase{{cite web |url=http://m.mlb.com/news/article/40550616/ |title=Astros take Fields with first pick in Rule 5 Draft |website=MLB.com |access-date=April 7, 2017 |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20170620132452/http://m.mlb.com/news/article/40550616 |archive-date=June 20, 2017 }}

scope="col"\| Pick ! scope="col"\| By ! scope="col"\| Player ! scope="col"\| Pos ! scope="col"\| From ! scope="col"\| Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Houston Astros !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Josh\|Fields\|dab=pitcher}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Boston Red Sox
2	Chicago Cubs !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Héctor\|Rondón}} \|Cleveland Indians
3	Colorado Rockies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Danny\|Rosenbaum\|nolink=y}} \|LHP	Washington Nationals	Returned to the Nationals
4	Minnesota Twins !scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\|{{sortname\|Ryan\|Pressly}} \|RHP	Boston Red Sox
5	Cleveland Indians !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Chris\|McGuiness}} \|1B	Texas Rangers	Returned to the Rangers{{cite web\|url=http://rangersblog.dallasnews.com/2013/03/texas-rangers-return-rhp-coty-woods-to-rockies-get-1b-chris-mcguiness-back-from-indians.html/\|title=Texas Rangers return RHP Coty Woods to Rockies, get 1B Chris McGuiness back from Indians\|work=SportsDay\|access-date=December 10, 2015}}
6	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Alfredo\|Silverio\|nolink=y}} \|OF	Los Angeles Dodgers
7	Boston Red Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Jeff\|Kobernus}} \|2B	Washington Nationals	Traded to Detroit Tigers, returned to the Nationals{{cite web \|url=http://www.washingtontimes.com/blog/nationals-watch/2013/mar/23/tigers-return-rule-5-pick-jeff-kobernus-nationals/ \|title=Tigers return Rule 5 pick Jeff Kobernus to Nationals - Washington Times \|website=The Washington Times \|access-date=May 26, 2013 \|url-status=dead \|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20130324082655/http://www.washingtontimes.com/blog/nationals-watch/2013/mar/23/tigers-return-rule-5-pick-jeff-kobernus-nationals// \|archive-date=March 24, 2013 }}
8	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Kyle\|Lobstein}} \|LHP	Tampa Bay Rays	Traded to Detroit Tigers, acquired from the Rays and outrighted to the minor leagues
9	Arizona Diamondbacks !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Starling\|Peralta\|nolink=y}} \|RHP	Chicago Cubs	Returned to the Cubs{{cite web\|url=http://hardballtalk.nbcsports.com/2013/03/15/diamondbacks-return-rule-5-pick-starling-peralta-to-cubs/\|title=Diamondbacks return Rule 5 pick Starling Peralta to Cubs\|work=HardballTalk\|date=March 15, 2013\|access-date=December 10, 2015}}
10	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\|{{sortname\|Ender\|Inciarte}} \|OF	Arizona Diamondbacks	Returned to the Diamondbacks
11	Chicago White Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Ángel\|Sánchez\|dab=infielder}} \|IF	Los Angeles Angels
12	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|T. J.\|McFarland}} \|LHP	Cleveland Indians
13	Texas Rangers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Coty\|Woods\|nolink=y}} \|RHP	Colorado Rockies	Returned to the Rockies
14	Houston Astros !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nate\|Freiman}} \|1B	San Diego Padres	Claimed on waivers by the Oakland Athletics
15	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Braulio\|Lara}} \|LHP	Tampa Bay Rays	Returned to Tampa Bay{{Cite web \|url=http://blogs.palmbeachpost.com/marlins/2013/03/17/marlins-return-rule-5-draft-pick-braulio-lara-to-tampa-bay/ \|title=Marlins return Rule 5 draft pick Braulio Lara to Tampa Bay \| Fish Tank blog: Miami Marlins \| the Palm Beach Post \|access-date=March 28, 2013 \|archive-date=March 21, 2013 \|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20130321073043/http://blogs.palmbeachpost.com/marlins/2013/03/17/marlins-return-rule-5-draft-pick-braulio-lara-to-tampa-bay/ \|url-status=dead }}

;Minor league phases – notable players

Eric Farris, 2B, Seattle Mariners from the Milwaukee Brewers
Diego Goris, 3B, San Diego Padres from the Kansas City Royals
Robbie Widlansky, 1B, Los Angeles Angels from the Baltimore Orioles
Tommy Mendonca, 3B, Oakland Athletics from the Texas Rangers
Ryan Dennick, LHP, Cincinnati Reds from the Kansas City Royals
Federico Castañeda, RHP, San Diego Padres from the Kansas City Royals
Efraín Nieves, LHP, Toronto Blue Jays from the Detroit Tigers

=2011=

;Major League phase{{cite web|url=http://m.mlb.com/news/article/26127288/|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20150702121709/http://m.mlb.com/news/article/26127288|url-status=dead|archive-date=July 2, 2015|title=2011 Rule 5 Draft results|website=MLB.com|access-date=April 3, 2017}}

scope="col"\| Pick !scope="col"\| By !scope="col"\| Player !scope="col"\| Pos !scope="col"\| From !scope="col"\| Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Houston Astros !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Rhiner\|Cruz}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	New York Mets
2	Minnesota Twins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Terry\|Doyle}} \|Chicago White Sox	Returned to Chicago, later signed with the Fukuoka SoftBank Hawks in Japan
3	Seattle Mariners !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Lucas\|Luetge}} \|LHP	Milwaukee Brewers
4	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Ryan\|Flaherty}} \|IF	Chicago Cubs
5	Kansas City Royals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|César\|Cabral}} \|LHP	Boston Red Sox	Traded to the New York Yankees for cash.
6	Chicago Cubs !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Lendy\|Castillo}} \|RHP	Philadelphia Phillies
7	Pittsburgh Pirates !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Gustavo\|Núñez\|dab=baseball}} \|SS	Detroit Tigers
8	Atlanta Braves !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Robert\|Fish\|nolink=y}} \|LHP	Los Angeles Angels
9	St. Louis Cardinals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Erik\|Komatsu}} \|OF	Washington Nationals	Claimed off waivers by the Minnesota Twins and later returned to Washington.
10	Boston Red Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Marwin\|González}} \|SS	Chicago Cubs	Traded to the Houston Astros for Marco Duarte.
11	Arizona Diamondbacks !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brett\|Lorin\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Pittsburgh Pirates	Rights permanently acquired by Arizona from Pittsburgh in exchange for Robby Rowland.
12	New York Yankees !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brad\|Meyers\|nolink=y}} \|Washington Nationals

;Minor league phase – notable players

Aaron Poreda, LHP, Pittsburgh Pirates from the San Diego Padres
Barret Browning, LHP, St. Louis Cardinals from the Los Angeles Angels
Matt Buschmann, RHP, Washington Nationals from the San Diego Padres

=2010=

;Major League phase{{cite web|url=http://m.mlb.com/news/article/16289310/|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20150123045938/http://m.mlb.com/news/article/16289310/|url-status=dead|archive-date=January 23, 2015|title=2010 Rule 5 Draft results|website=MLB.com|access-date=April 3, 2017}}

scope="col" \| Pick ! scope="col" style="width:150px;"\| By ! scope="col" style="width:140px;"\| Player ! scope="col" \| Pos ! scope="col" \| From ! scope="col" \| Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Pittsburgh Pirates !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Josh\|Rodriguez}} \|SS	rowspan="2" \|Cleveland Indians	Returned to Cleveland on April 29, 2011.{{cite web \|url=http://www.cleveland.com/tribe/index.ssf/2011/04/adam_miller_assigned_to_kinsto.html \|title=Adam Miller assigned to Kinston as comeback continues: Indians Chatter \|first=Dennis \|last=Manoloff \|date=April 29, 2011 \|work=Cleveland Plain Dealer \|access-date=April 30, 2011}} Reacquired by Pittsburgh on June 21.{{cite web \|last=Bastian \|first=Jordan \|title=Rodriguez traded to Pirates for cash \|url=http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20110621&content_id=20808152&vkey=news_mlb&fext=.jsp&c_id=mlb \|date=June 21, 2011 \|publisher=MLB Advanced Media \|work=MLB.com \|access-date=September 17, 2011}}
2	Seattle Mariners !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|José\|Flores\|nolink=y}} \|RHP	Returned to Cleveland on March 25, 2011.{{cite web \|url=http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/marinersblog/2014597481_mariners_return_rule_5_selecti.html \|title=Mariners return Rule 5 selection Jose Flores to Indians \|first=Geoff \|last=Baker \|date=March 25, 2011 \|work=Seattle Times \|access-date=April 30, 2011}}
3	Arizona Diamondbacks !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Joe\|Paterson\|dab=baseball}} \|LHP	San Francisco Giants
4	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Adrian\|Rosario\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="6" \|RHP	Milwaukee Brewers	Returned to Milwaukee on March 24, 2011.{{cite web \|url=http://www.jsonline.com/blogs/sports/118607829.html \|title=Egan returned to Baltimore \|first=Andrew \|last=Gruman \|date=March 24, 2011 \|work=Milwaukee Journal Sentinel \|access-date=April 30, 2011}}
5	Kansas City Royals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nate\|Adcock}} \|Pittsburgh Pirates
6	Washington Nationals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Elvin\|Ramírez}} \|New York Mets	Returned to New York Mets on October 18, 2011.{{cite news \|url=https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/nationals-journal/post/nationals-return-elvin-ramirez-to-mets/2011/10/18/gIQAGQMDvL_blog.html \|title=Nationals return Elvin Ramirez to Mets \|first=Adam \|last=Kilgore \|date=October 18, 2011 \|newspaper=Washington Post \|access-date=June 3, 2013}}
7	Chicago Cubs !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mason\|Tobin}} \|Los Angeles Angels	Traded to Texas on December 9, 2010.{{cite web \|url=http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20101209&content_id=16289690 \|title=Rangers acquire righty Tobin from Cubs \|first=T.R. \|last=Sullivan \|date=December 9, 2010 \|work=MLB.com \|access-date=April 27, 2011}}
8	Houston Astros !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Aneury\|Rodríguez}} \|Tampa Bay Rays
9	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Pat\|Egan\|nolink=y}} \|Baltimore Orioles	Returned to Baltimore on March 24, 2011
10	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brad\|Emaus}} \|2B	Toronto Blue Jays	Returned to Toronto on April 21, 2011, then traded to Colorado on April 22, 2011.{{cite web \|url=http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20110422&content_id=18119992¬ebook_id=18123968 \|title=Rox acquire Emaus, add depth \|first=David \|last=Villavicencio \|date=April 22, 2011 \|work=MLB.com \|access-date=April 27, 2011}}
11	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|George\|Kontos}} \|RHP	New York Yankees	Returned to New York Yankees on March 14, 2011.{{cite web \|url=http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2011/03/padres-return-george-kontos-to-yankees.html \|title=Padres Return George Kontos To Yankees \|first=Ben \|last=Nicholson-Smith \|date=March 14, 2011 \|publisher=MLB Trade Rumors \|access-date=April 30, 2011}}
12	Minnesota Twins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Scott\|Diamond}} \| rowspan="3" \|LHP	Atlanta Braves	Rights acquired by Minnesota from Atlanta in exchange for Billy Bullock.{{cite web \|url=http://blogs.ajc.com/atlanta-braves-blog/2011/03/28/braves-trade-for-big-hard-throwing-prospect/?cxntfid=blogs_atlanta_braves_blog \|title=Braves trade for big, hard-throwing prospect \|first=David \|last=O'Brien \|date=March 28, 2011 \|work=Atlanta Journal-Constitution \|access-date=April 30, 2011}}
13	New York Yankees !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Robert\|Fish\|nolink=y}} \|Los Angeles Angels	Claimed off waivers by Kansas City on March 13, 2011.{{cite web \|url=http://www.kansascity.com/2011/03/13/2723352/day-in-camp-brewers-7-royals-5.html \|title=Day in camp: Brewers 7, Royals 5 \|first=Bob \|last=Dutton \|date=March 13, 2011 \|work=Kansas City Star \|access-date=April 30, 2011}} Returned to Los Angeles Angels on March 27.{{cite web \|url=http://www.kansascity.com/2011/03/27/2756959/royals-day-in-camp.html \|title=Betemit, Gordon power Royals to 7–4 win over Giants \|first=Bob \|last=Dutton \|date=March 27, 2011 \|work=Kansas City Star \|access-date=April 30, 2011}}
14	Tampa Bay Rays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|César\|Cabral}} \|Boston Red Sox	Claimed off waivers by Toronto on March 12, 2011,{{cite web \|url=http://mlb.mlb.com/news/press_releases/press_release.jsp?ymd=20110312&content_id=16922960&vkey=pr_tor&fext=.jsp \|title=Blue Jays claim Cesar Cabral \|date=March 12, 2011 \|publisher=Toronto Blue Jays \|access-date=April 27, 2011}} and by Tampa Bay on March 14.{{cite web \|url=http://www.tampabay.com/sports/baseball/rays/tampa-bay-rays-claim-pitcher-cesar-cabral-off-waivers-from-toronto-blue/1157256 \|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110317072621/http://www.tampabay.com/sports/baseball/rays/tampa-bay-rays-claim-pitcher-cesar-cabral-off-waivers-from-toronto-blue/1157256 \|url-status=dead \|archive-date=March 17, 2011 \|title=Tampa Bay Rays claim pitcher Cesar Cabral off waivers from Toronto Blue Jays \|first=Marc \|last=Topkin \|date=March 14, 2011 \|work=St. Petersburg Times \|access-date=April 27, 2011}} Returned to Boston on March 28.{{cite web \|url=http://www.tampabay.com/sports/baseball/rays/tampa-bay-rays-return-rule-5-pick-cesar-cabral-to-boston-red-sox/1160202 \|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110401045119/http://www.tampabay.com/sports/baseball/rays/tampa-bay-rays-return-rule-5-pick-cesar-cabral-to-boston-red-sox/1160202 \|url-status=dead \|archive-date=April 1, 2011 \|title=Tampa Bay Rays return Rule 5 pick Cesar Cabral to Boston Red Sox \|first=Marc \|last=Topkin \|date=March 28, 2011 \|work=St. Petersburg Times \|access-date=April 27, 2011}}
15	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Michael\|Martínez\|Michael Martínez (baseball)}} \|IF	Washington Nationals
16	Washington Nationals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brian\|Broderick}} \| rowspan="4" \|RHP	St. Louis Cardinals	Returned to St. Louis on May 23, 2011.{{cite web \|last=Strauss \|first=Joe \|title=Boggs will be starter in Memphis \|quote=The Cardinals regained reliever Brian Broderick after Washington placed the former Redbirds farmhand on waivers. The Nationals claimed Broderick in December's major-league Ruke 5 draft when the Cardinals elected not to place him on their 40-man roster. \|url=https://www.stltoday.com/sports/baseball/professional/article_56e35699-eb02-5f50-97e0-84b0a00300ea.html \|work=St. Louis Post-Dispatch \|date=May 24, 2011 \|access-date=May 27, 2011}}
17	Houston Astros !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Lance\|Pendleton}} \|New York Yankees	Returned to New York Yankees on March 27, 2011.{{cite web \|url=http://thetimes-tribune.com/sports/astros-return-pendleton-to-yankees-1.1124612 \|title=Astros return Pendleton to Yankees \|date=March 28, 2011 \|work=Scranton Times Tribune \|access-date=April 30, 2011}}
18	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Pedro\|Beato}} \|Baltimore Orioles
19	New York Yankees !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Daniel\|Turpen\|nolink=y}} \|Boston Red Sox	Returned to Boston on March 13, 2011.{{cite web \|url=http://yankees.lhblogs.com/2011/03/13/yankees-cut-three-more-turpen-returned-to-boston/ \|title=Yankees cut three more, Turpen returned to Boston \|first=Chad \|last=Jennings \|date=March 13, 2011 \|publisher=The LoHud Yankees Blog \|access-date=April 27, 2011}}

;Minor league phases – notable players

Dashenko Ricardo, C, San Francisco Giants from the Baltimore Orioles
Quintin Berry, OF, New York Mets from the San Diego Padres

=2009=

;Major league phase{{cite web|url=http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/minorleagues/rule_5.jsp?season=2009 |title=2009 Rule 5 Draft | MLB.com |publisher=Mlb.mlb.com |date=January 20, 2016 |access-date=March 24, 2018}}

scope="col"\| Pick ! scope="col" style="width:150px;"\| By ! scope="col" style="width:140px;"\| Player !scope="col"\| Pos ! scope="col" style="width:150px;"\| From !scope="col" \| Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Washington Nationals ! scope="row" style="text:align=center" \| {{sortname\|Jamie\|Hoffmann}} \| rowspan="2" \| OF	Los Angeles Dodgers	Acquired by the New York Yankees as the player to be named later in the trade for Brian Bruney. Returned to Los Angeles on March 22, 2010.
2	Pittsburgh Pirates ! scope="row" style="text:align=center" \| {{sortname\|John\|Raynor}} \| Florida Marlins	Returned to Marlins on May 4, 2010
3	Baltimore Orioles ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Ben\|Snyder\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="2" \| LHP	San Francisco Giants	Acquired by the Texas Rangers as the player to be named later in the trade for Kevin Millwood. Texas traded Edwin Escobar to San Francisco to retain his rights and outrighted him to the minors
4	Kansas City Royals ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Edgar\|Osuna\|nolink=y}} \| Atlanta Braves	Outrighted to the minor leagues after Atlanta declined to reclaim him
5	Cleveland Indians ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Héctor\|Ambriz}} \| RHP	Arizona Diamondbacks
6	Arizona Diamondbacks ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Zach\|Kroenke}} \| LHP	New York Yankees
7	New York Mets ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Carlos\|Monasterios}} \| RHP	Philadelphia Phillies	Sold to the Los Angeles Dodgers for cash on day of draft
8	Houston Astros ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Jorge\|Jiménez\|nolink=y}} \| 3B	Boston Red Sox	Acquired by the Florida Marlins as the player to be named later for Matt Lindstrom. Returned to Boston on March 21, 2010.
9	Oakland Athletics ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Bobby\|Cassevah}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	Los Angeles Angels	Returned to Los Angeles on March 15, 2010
10	Toronto Blue Jays ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Zech\|Zinicola\|nolink=y}} \| Washington Nationals	Returned to Washington on March 18, 2010.
11	Milwaukee Brewers ! scope="row" style="text:align=center" \| {{sortname\|Chuck\|Lofgren\|nolink=y}} \| LHP	Cleveland Indians	Milwaukee traded Omar Aguilar to Cleveland to retain his rights. Lofgren was then outrighted to the minor leagues.
12	Chicago Cubs ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Mike\|Parisi}} \| RHP	St. Louis Cardinals	Outrighted to the minor leagues after St. Louis declined to reclaim him.
13	Tampa Bay Rays ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Armando\|Zerpa\|nolink=y}} \|LHP	Boston Red Sox	Traded to Los Angeles Dodgers on December 10, 2009,{{cite book \|editor1-last=Vaughn \|editor1-first=Rick \|editor2-last=Costello \|editor2-first=Chris \|editor3-last=Molina \|editor3-first=Carmen \|editor4-last=Haller \|editor4-first=Dave \|editor5-last=Macolino \|editor5-first=Jeff \|editor6-last=Esterline \|editor6-first=Will \|title=2010 Tampa Bay Rays Media Guide \|page=173 \|year=2010 \| publisher=Tampa Bay Rays Communications Department \|location=St. Petersburg, Florida \|ref=Rays10MG}} returned to Boston on March 15, 2010
14	Seattle Mariners ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Kanekoa\|Texeira}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	New York Yankees	Designated for assignment on May 31, 2010, claimed off waivers by the Kansas City Royals
15	San Francisco Giants ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Steve\|Johnson\|dab=baseball}} \| Baltimore Orioles	Returned to Baltimore March 16, 2010.
16	St. Louis Cardinals ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|Ben\|Jukich}} \| LHP	Cincinnati Reds	Returned to Cincinnati on March 18, 2010.
17	Philadelphia Phillies ! scope="row" style="text:align=center"\| {{sortname\|David\|Herndon}} \| RHP	Los Angeles Angels

;Minor league phase – notable players

Brian Horwitz, OF, Cleveland Indians from the San Francisco Giants

=2008=

;Major league phase{{cite web|url=http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/minorleagues/rule_5.jsp?season=2008 |title=2008 Rule 5 Draft | MLB.com |publisher=Mlb.mlb.com |date=January 20, 2016 |access-date=March 24, 2018}}

scope="col"\| Pick ! scope="col" style="width:150px;"\| By ! scope="col" style="width:140px;"\| Player !scope="col"\| Pos ! scope="col" style="width:150px;"\| From !scope="col" \| Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Washington Nationals !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Terrell\|Young\|nolink=y}} \| RHP	Cincinnati Reds
2	Seattle Mariners !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Reegie\|Corona\|nolink=y}} \| IF	New York Yankees	Returned to the Yankees on April 2, 2009{{cite web\|url=http://mlb.mlb.com/news/press_releases/press_release.jsp?ymd=20090403&content_id=4117994&vkey=pr_sea&fext=.jsp&c_id=sea\|title=Mariners return Reegie Corona to New York Yankees\|work=Seattle Mariners\|access-date=December 10, 2015}}
3	San Diego Padres !scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\| {{sortname\|Everth\|Cabrera}} \| SS	Colorado Rockies
4	Pittsburgh Pirates !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Donnie\|Veal}} \| LHP	Chicago Cubs
5	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Lou\|Palmisano\|nolink=y}} \| C	Milwaukee Brewers	Traded to the Houston Astros for cash considerations. Retained by Houston after Milwaukee declined to accept him back on March 21, 2009.{{cite web \|author=Adam McCalvy and Alyson Footer \|url=http://houston.astros.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20090321&content_id=4043066&vkey=news_mlb&fext=.jsp&c_id=mlb \|title=Brewers decline Palmisano's return \|publisher=Houston.astros.mlb.com \|date=March 21, 2009 \|access-date=August 3, 2010 \|url-status=dead \|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20120225065700/http://houston.astros.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20090321&content_id=4043066&vkey=news_mlb&fext=.jsp&c_id=mlb \|archive-date=February 25, 2012 }}
6	San Francisco Giants !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Luis\|Perdomo\|dab=baseball, born 1984}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	St. Louis Cardinals	Started the season with San Francisco, but later designated for assignment and claimed by the San Diego Padres on April 10, 2009 {{cite web\|author=Corey Brock \|url=http://sandiego.padres.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20090410&content_id=4210812&vkey=news_sd&fext=.jsp&c_id=sd \|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20090412195006/http://sandiego.padres.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20090410&content_id=4210812&vkey=news_sd&fext=.jsp&c_id=sd \|url-status=dead \|archive-date=April 12, 2009 \|title=Padres add pitcher Perdomo \|publisher=Sandiego.padres.mlb.com \|access-date=August 3, 2010}}
7	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|David\|Patton\|dab=baseball}} \| Colorado Rockies	Traded to the Chicago Cubs for cash considerations.
8	Detroit Tigers !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Kyle\|Bloom\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="2" \| LHP	Pittsburgh Pirates	Returned to the Pirates on March 29, 2009{{cite web \|author=Tom Krasovic \|url=http://www3.signonsandiego.com/weblogs/padres/2009/mar/29/padres-moving-burke-out/ \|title="Padres trade Burke to Mariners" by Padres Scorecard \|publisher=.signonsandiego.com \|date=March 29, 2009 \|access-date=August 3, 2010 \|url-status=dead \|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20100522174113/http://www.signonsandiego.com/weblogs/padres/2009/mar/29/padres-moving-burke-out/ \|archive-date=May 22, 2010 }}
9	Kansas City Royals !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Jose\|Lugo\|nolink=y}} \| Minnesota Twins	Traded to the Seattle Mariners for cash considerations. Returned to Twins on April 1, 2009{{cite web\|url=http://mlb.mlb.com/news/press_releases/press_release.jsp?ymd=20090401&content_id=4102624&vkey=pr_sea&fext=.jsp&c_id=sea \|title=Mariners outright Morse to AAA Tacoma, return Lugo to Minnesota \| Mariners.com: Official Info \|publisher=Mlb.mlb.com \|date=December 11, 2008 \|access-date=August 3, 2010}}
10	Oakland Athletics !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Benjamin\|Copeland\|nolink=y}} \| CF	San Francisco Giants
11	Arizona Diamondbacks !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|James\|Skelton\|nolink=y}} \| C	Detroit Tigers
12	Florida Marlins !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Zach\|Kroenke}} \| rowspan="2" \| LHP	New York Yankees	Returned to Yankees March 16, 2009{{cite web\|url=http://www.sun-sentinel.com/sports/sfl-marlins-yankees-zach-kroenke-0316,0,12933.story \|title=Topic Galleries – South Florida \|publisher=Sun-sentinel.com \|access-date=August 3, 2010}}
13	Houston Astros !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Gilbert\|De La Vara\|nolink=y}} \| Kansas City Royals	Returned to Royals on March 31, 2009{{cite web \|author=Alyson Footer \|url=http://houston.astros.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20090331&content_id=4096020&vkey=news_hou&fext=.jsp&c_id=hou \|title=Astros send De La Vara back to Royals \|publisher=Houston.astros.mlb.com \|access-date=August 3, 2010 \|url-status=dead \|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20120225064850/http://houston.astros.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20090331&content_id=4096020&vkey=news_hou&fext=.jsp&c_id=hou \|archive-date=February 25, 2012 }}
14	Minnesota Twins !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Jason\|Jones\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="8" \| RHP	New York Yankees	The Twins traded Charles Nolte to New York for Jones' rights.{{cite web\|url=http://www.twincities.com/sports/ci_12016220?nclick_check=1 \|title=Twins deal Class A pitcher to New York Yankees, keep Jones \|date=March 28, 2009 \|publisher=TwinCities.com \|access-date=August 3, 2010}}
15	New York Mets !scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\| {{sortname\|Darren\|O'Day}} \| Los Angeles Angels	Claimed off waivers by the Texas Rangers April 22, 2009
16	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Eduardo\|Morlan}} \| Tampa Bay Rays	Returned to Tampa Bay on March 19, 2009 {{cite web\|last=Haudricourt \|first=Tom \|url=http://www.jsonline.com/blogs/sports/41496022.html \|title=Tampa Bay reclaims Morlan \|publisher=JSOnline \|date=March 19, 2009 \|access-date=August 3, 2010}}
17	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Bobby\|Mosebach}} \| rowspan="2" \| Los Angeles Angels	Returned to Anaheim on April 1, 2009
18	Boston Red Sox !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Miguel\|González\|dab=pitcher}} \| Missed the entire season due to Tommy John surgery
19	Tampa Bay Rays !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Derek\|Rodriguez\|nolink=y}} \| Chicago White Sox	Returned to Chicago White Sox on March 23, 2009{{cite web \|url=http://www.tboblogs.com/index.php/sports/comments/rule-5-pick-rodriguez-back-to-sox/ \|title=Rays Report – Tribune staff Sports – from TBO.com Blogs \|publisher=Tboblogs.com \|date=March 23, 2009 \|access-date=August 3, 2010 \|url-status=dead \|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110716194503/http://www.tboblogs.com/index.php/sports/comments/rule-5-pick-rodriguez-back-to-sox/ \|archive-date=July 16, 2011 }}
20	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Iván\|Nova}} \| New York Yankees	Returned to Yankees on March 29, 2009
21	New York Mets !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Rocky\|Cherry}} \| Baltimore Orioles	Released by Mets after Baltimore refused to take him back{{cite news \|url=http://www.nydailynews.com/blogs/mets/2009/03/cherry-lands-in-al-east.html \|title=Cherry lands in AL East \|publisher=Nydailynews.com \|date=March 24, 2009 \|access-date=August 3, 2010 \|location=New York \|first=Andy \|last=Martino \|url-status=dead \|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20090328103835/http://www.nydailynews.com/blogs/mets/2009/03/cherry-lands-in-al-east.html \|archive-date=March 28, 2009 }}

;Minor league phases – notable players

Ricardo Nanita, OF, Washington Nationals from the Chicago White Sox
Guilder Rodríguez, SS, Texas Rangers from the Milwaukee Brewers
Dave Shinskie, RHP, Toronto Blue Jays from the Minnesota Twins

=2007=

;Major league phase{{cite web|url=http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/minorleagues/rule_5.jsp?season=2007 |title=2007 Rule 5 Draft | MLB.com |publisher=Mlb.mlb.com |date=January 20, 2016 |access-date=March 24, 2018}}

scope="col"\| Pick ! scope="col" style="width:150px;"\| By ! scope="col" style="width:140px;"\| Player !scope="col"\| Pos ! scope="col" style="width:150px;"\| From !scope="col" \| Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Tampa Bay Rays ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Tim\|Lahey}} \| rowspan="3" \| RHP	Minnesota Twins	Traded to Chicago Cubs on December 6, 2007, claimed off waivers by Philadelphia Phillies on March 28, 2008, returned to Minnesota on April 12, 2008
2	Pittsburgh Pirates ! scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\| {{sortname\|Evan\|Meek}} \| Tampa Bay Rays	Remained with the Pirates after Pittsburgh negotiated to retain his rights.
3	Baltimore Orioles ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Randor\|Bierd}} \| Detroit Tigers
4	San Francisco Giants ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|José\|Capellán\|nolink=y}} \| LHP	Boston Red Sox	Claimed by the Cincinnati Reds off waivers on March 12, 2008, returned to Boston on March 28
5	Florida Marlins ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Carlos\|Guevara\|Carlos Guevara (baseball)}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	Cincinnati Reds	Traded to the San Diego Padres for cash considerations on December 6, 2007, rights acquired from the Cincinnati Reds and he was outrighted the Padres' minor-league system
6	Cincinnati Reds ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Sergio\|Valenzuela\|nolink=y}} \| Atlanta Braves	Returned to Atlanta on March 10, 2008
7	Washington Nationals ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Matthew\|Whitney\|nolink=y}} \| 3B	Cleveland Indians	Returned to Cleveland on March 22, 2008
8	Houston Astros ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Wesley\|Wright}} \| LHP	Los Angeles Dodgers
9	Oakland Athletics ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Fernando\|Hernandez Jr.\|nolink=y}} \| RHP	Chicago White Sox	Returned to Chicago on April 16, 2008{{cite news\|url=http://blogs.chicagosports.chicagotribune.com/sports_hardball/2008/04/hernandez-re-ac.html \|title=Hardball: Hernandez re-acquired from Oakland \|publisher=Blogs.chicagosports.chicagotribune.com \|date=April 16, 2008 \|access-date=August 3, 2010}}
10	St. Louis Cardinals ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Brian\|Barton}} \| OF	Cleveland Indians
11	Toronto Blue Jays ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Randy\|Wells}} \| rowspan="4" \| RHP	Chicago Cubs	Returned to Chicago on April 16, 2008
12	Seattle Mariners ! scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\| {{sortname\|R. A.\|Dickey}} \| Minnesota Twins	Rights traded to Seattle in exchange for Jair Fernandez on March 29, 2008
13	New York Mets ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Steven\|Register}} \| Colorado Rockies	Returned to Colorado on March 27, 2008
14	San Diego Padres ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Michael\|Gardner\|nolink=y}} \| New York Yankees	Returned to New York on March 18, 2008
15	Philadelphia Phillies ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Travis\|Blackley}} \| LHP	San Francisco Giants	Rights acquired by Philadelphia
16	Washington Nationals ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Garrett\|Guzman\|nolink=y}} \| OF	Minnesota Twins	Rights traded to Washington on March 23, 2008 in exchange for a player to be named later or cash
17	San Diego Padres ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Callix\|Crabbe}} \| 2B	Milwaukee Brewers	Returned to Milwaukee on May 16, 2008
18	Philadelphia Phillies ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Lincoln\|Holdzkom\|nolink=y}} \| RHP	Boston Red Sox	Later made a free agent after Boston refused to take him back and eventually given a one-year deal by Boston.

; Minor league phases – notable players

Joshua Hill, RHP, Pittsburgh Pirates from the Minnesota Twins
Levi Romero, RHP, Texas Rangers from the Houston Astros
Víctor Gárate, LHP, Los Angeles Dodgers from the Houston Astros
Juan Cedeño, LHP, Detroit Tigers from the Washington Nationals
Dustin Majewski, OF, Texas Rangers from the Toronto Blue Jays
Brett Campbell, RHP, Milwaukee Brewers from the Washington Nationals
Clayton Hamilton, RHP, Texas Rangers from the Pittsburgh Pirates
Scott Mitchinson, RHP, Oakland Athletics from the Philadelphia Phillies
Adalberto Méndez, RHP, Florida Marlins from the Chicago Cubs
Ben Fritz, RHP, Detroit Tigers from the Oakland Athletics

=2006=

;Major league phase{{cite web|url=https://www.milb.com/milb/news/gcs-147804|title=2006 Rule 5 Draft results|work=Minor League Baseball|date=December 7, 2006|access-date=December 2, 2021}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos. !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Tampa Bay Devil Rays !scope="row" \| Ryan Goleski \| OF	Cleveland Indians	Traded to Oakland on December 7, 2006. Returned to Cleveland on March 28, 2007.
2	Kansas City Royals !scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\|{{sortname\|Joakim\|Soria}} \| RHP	San Diego Padres
3	Chicago Cubs ! scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\|{{sortname\|Josh\|Hamilton}} \| OF	Tampa Bay Devil Rays	Traded by the Cubs to the Cincinnati Reds for cash considerations.
4	Pittsburgh Pirates ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Sean\|White\|dab=baseball}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	Atlanta Braves	Traded by the Pirates to the Seattle Mariners for cash considerations.
5	Baltimore Orioles ! scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\|{{sortname\|Alfredo\|Simón}} \| Texas Rangers	Traded by the Orioles to the Philadelphia Phillies for Adam Donachie and cash considerations. He was returned to the Rangers on March 18, 2007.
6	Washington Nationals ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Jesús\|Flores}} \| C	New York Mets
7	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row" \| Edward Campusano \| LHP	Chicago Cubs	Traded by the Brewers to the Detroit Tigers for cash considerations, returned to the Cubs on October 10, 2007
8	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Jared\|Burton}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	Oakland Athletics
9	Houston Astros !scope="row" \| Lincoln Holdzkom \| Chicago Cubs	Returned to the Cubs on March 11, 2007
10	Philadelphia Phillies ! scope="row" \| Adam Donachie \| C	Kansas City Royals	Traded by the Phillies to the Baltimore Orioles for Alfredo Simón
11	Boston Red Sox ! scope="row" \| Nick Debarr \| RHP	Tampa Bay Devil Rays	Returned to the Devil Rays on March 12, 2007
12	Toronto Blue Jays ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Jason\|Smith\|dab=baseball}} \| IF	Chicago Cubs
13	San Diego Padres ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Kevin\|Cameron\|dab=baseball}} \| RHP	Minnesota Twins
14	Oakland Athletics ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Jay\|Marshall\|dab=baseball}} \| LHP	Chicago White Sox
15	Minnesota Twins ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Alejandro\|Machado}} \| rowspan="2" \| IF	Washington Nationals
16	New York Yankees ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Josh\|Phelps}} \| Baltimore Orioles
17	Washington Nationals ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Levale\|Speigner}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	Minnesota Twins
18	Philadelphia Phillies ! scope="row" \| Jim Ed Warden \| Cleveland Indians	Returned to the Indians on March 28, 2007
19	Philadelphia Phillies ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Ryan\|Budde}} \| C	Los Angeles Angels	Returned to the Angels on April 23, 2007

; Notable players chosen in the minor league phases

Salomón Manríquez, C, Colorado Rockies from the Washington Nationals
Josh Labandeira, INF, Florida Marlins from the Washington Nationals
Francisco Mateo, LHP, Cincinnati Reds from the Toronto Blue Jays
Cristhian Martínez, RHP, Florida Marlins from the Detroit Tigers
Brian Buscher, INF, Minnesota Twins from the San Francisco Giants

=2005=

;Major league phase{{cite web|work=MLB.com |url=http://mlb.mlb.com/content/printer_friendly/mlb/y2005/m12/d08/c1279235.jsp |title=Selection list of the 2005 Rule 5 Draft |access-date=April 9, 2019}}

scope="col" \| Pick ! scope="col" \| By ! scope="col" \| Player ! scope="col" \| Pos. ! scope="col" \| From ! scope="col" class=unsortable \| Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Kansas City Royals ! scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Fabio\|Castro}} \| rowspan="2" \| LHP	Chicago White Sox	Traded to the Texas Rangers for Esteban Germán
2	Colorado Rockies ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Luis Enrique\|Gonzales}} \| Los Angeles Dodgers
3	Tampa Bay Devil Rays ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Steve\|Andrade}} \| rowspan="5" \| RHP	Toronto Blue Jays	Traded to San Diego on December 7, 2005. Claimed off waivers by Kansas City on March 28, 2006. Released by Kansas City on June 9.{{cite web\|url=https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/a/andrast01.shtml#TRANS \|title=Steve Andrade Statistics and History \|publisher=Baseball-Reference.com \|access-date=April 26, 2011}}
4	Pittsburgh Pirates !scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Víctor\|Santos\|dab=baseball}} \| Kansas City Royals	Traded to the Philadelphia Phillies for cash considerations
5	Detroit Tigers ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Chris\|Booker\|dab=baseball}} \| Washington Nationals
6	San Diego Padres ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Seth\|Etherton}} \| Kansas City Royals
7	New York Mets ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Mitchell\|Wylie\|nolink=y}} \| San Francisco Giants
8	Florida Marlins ! scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\|{{sortname\|Dan\|Uggla}} \| 2B	Arizona Diamondbacks	Played in the 2006 MLB All-Star Game
9	Minnesota Twins ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Jason\|Pridie}} \| OF	Tampa Bay Devil Rays	Returned to Tampa Bay before start of season
10	Boston Red Sox ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|James\|Vermilyea}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	Toronto Blue Jays	Returned to Toronto on March 14, 2006
11	St. Louis Cardinals ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Juan\|Mateo}} \| Chicago Cubs
12	Florida Marlins ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Michael\|Megrew\|nolink=y}} \| LHP	Los Angeles Dodgers

;Notable players chosen in the minor league phases

Brandon Weeden, RHP, Kansas City Royals from the Los Angeles Dodgers
Jason Bourgeois, IF, Seattle Mariners from the Atlanta Braves
Eddie Bonine, Detroit Tigers from the San Diego Padres
Eugenio Vélez, IF, San Francisco Giants from the Toronto Blue Jays
Jayce Tingler, OF, Texas Rangers from the Toronto Blue Jays
Ben Diggins, RHP, Houston Astros from the Milwaukee Brewers
Tim Hummel, IF, Chicago White Sox from the St. Louis Cardinals
Alexi Ogando, OF, Texas Rangers from the Oakland Athletics
Cole Armstrong, C, Chicago White Sox from the Atlanta Braves
Dewon Day, LHP, Chicago White Sox from the Toronto Blue Jays

=2004=

;Major league phase{{cite web|url=http://www.espn.com/espn/wire/_/section/mlb/id/1945520 |title=2004 Rule 5 Draft Profiles - MLB |publisher=ESPN |date=December 13, 2004 |access-date=April 9, 2019}}

scope="col" \| Pick ! scope="col" \| By ! scope="col" \| Player ! scope="col" \| Pos. ! scope="col" \| From ! scope="col" \| Notes
class="wikitable plainrowheaders sortable"
1	Arizona Diamondbacks ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Angel\|Garcia\|dab=baseball}} \| RHP	Minnesota Twins	Traded to Tampa Bay, returned to Minnesota on March 30, 2005.
2	Kansas City Royals ! scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Andrew\|Sisco}} \| LHP	Chicago Cubs
3	Washington Nationals !scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Tyrell\|Godwin}} \| OF	Toronto Blue Jays
4	Milwaukee Brewers ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Marcos\|Carvajal}} \|RHP	rowspan="2" \| Los Angeles Dodgers	Sold by the Brewers to the Colorado Rockies
5	Colorado Rockies !scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Matt\|Merricks}} \| rowspan="2" \| LHP
6	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Luke\|Hagerty}} \| Chicago Cubs	Traded by the Orioles to the Florida Marlins
7	Philadelphia Phillies ! scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\|{{sortname\|Shane\|Victorino}} \| OF	Los Angeles Dodgers
8	Oakland Athletics ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Tyler\|Johnson\|dab=baseball, born 1981}} \| rowspan="2" \| LHP	St. Louis Cardinals
9	Minnesota Twins ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Ryan\|Rowland-Smith}} \| Seattle Mariners
10	Los Angeles Dodgers ! scope="row"\| {{sortname\|D. J.\|Houlton}} \| RHP	Houston Astros
11	Boston Red Sox ! scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Adam\|Stern}} \| OF	Atlanta Braves
12	Washington Nationals ! scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Tony\|Blanco}} \| IF	Cincinnati Reds

; Notable players chosen in the minor league phases

Chris Demaria, RHP, Kansas City Royals from the Pittsburgh Pirates
Lee Gronkiewicz, RHP, Toronto Blue Jays, from the Cleveland Indians
Keith Ramsey, LHP, Colorado Rockies, from the Cleveland Indians
Jean Machi, RHP, Tampa Bay Devil Rays, from the Philadelphia Phillies
Henry Owens, RHP, New York Mets, from the Pittsburgh Pirates
Rodrigo Rosario, RHP, Florida Marlins, from the Houston Astros
Chris Gomez, INF, Philadelphia Phillies, from the Baltimore Orioles
Arturo López, LHP, San Diego Padres, from the Los Angeles Dodgers
Víctor Moreno, RHP, Oakland Athletics, from the Minnesota Twins
Jan Granado, LHP, Minnesota Twins, from the Cincinnati Reds
Aaron Herr, INF, Seattle Mariners, from the Atlanta Braves
Edgar González, INF, Washington Nationals, from the Texas Rangers
Juan Cerros, RHP, Milwaukee Brewers, from the Cincinnati Reds
Armando Gabino, INF, Minnesota Twins, from the Cleveland Indians
José García, RHP, St. Louis Cardinals, from the Texas Rangers
Alejandro De Aza, OF, Florida Marlins, from the Los Angeles Dodgers
Jim Kavourias, OF, Washington Nationals, from the Florida Marlins
Jhonny Rivera, OF, Tampa Bay Devil Rays, from the Chicago White Sox
Dan Kolb, RHP, Washington Nationals, from the Milwaukee Brewers

=2003=

;Major league phase

scope="col" \| Pick ! scope="col" \| By ! scope="col" \| Player ! scope="col" \| Pos. ! scope="col" \| From ! scope="col" \| Notes
class="wikitable plainrowheaders sortable"
1	Detroit Tigers ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Chris\|Shelton\|dab=baseball}} \| C/IF	rowspan="2" \| Pittsburgh Pirates
2	San Diego Padres ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Rich\|Thompson\|dab=outfielder}} \| OF	Traded to the Kansas City Royals for No. 10 pick Jason Szuminski
3	Tampa Bay Devil Rays ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Alec\|Zumwalt}} \| RHP	Atlanta Braves	Returned to Atlanta on March 17, 2004
4	New York Mets ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Frank\|Brooks\|dab=baseball}} \| LHP	rowspan="3" \| Pittsburgh Pirates	Traded to the Oakland Athletics
5	Milwaukee Brewers ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Jeff\|Bennett\|dab=baseball}} \| RHP
6	Baltimore Orioles ! scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\|{{sortname\|José\|Bautista}} \| IF
7	Cincinnati Reds ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|David\|Mattox\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	New York Mets
8	Texas Rangers ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Chris\|Mabeus}} \| Oakland Athletics
9	Colorado Rockies ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Matt\|White\|dab=baseball, born 1977}} \| LHP	Cleveland Indians
10	Kansas City Royals ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Jason\|Szuminski}} \| RHP	Chicago Cubs	Traded to the San Diego Padres for No. 2 pick Rich Thompson
11	Montreal Expos ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Andy\|Fox}} \| IF	Texas Rangers
12	Toronto Blue Jays ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Talley\|Haines\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	Tampa Bay Devil Rays
13	Chicago White Sox ! scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\|{{sortname\|Jason\|Grilli}} \| Florida Marlins
14	St. Louis Cardinals ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Héctor\|Luna}} \| IF	Cleveland Indians
15	Boston Red Sox ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Lenny\|DiNardo}} \| LHP	New York Mets
16	Houston Astros ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Willy\|Taveras}} \| OF	Cleveland Indians
17	Detroit Tigers ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Mike\|Bumatay\|nolink=y}} \| LHP	Colorado Rockies
18	Colorado Rockies ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Luis\|González\|dab=infielder}} \|IF/OF	Cleveland Indians
19	Boston Red Sox ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Colter\|Bean}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	New York Yankees
20	Detroit Tigers ! scope="row" \| {{sortname\|Lino\|Urdaneta}} \| Cleveland Indians

; Notable players chosen in the minor league phases

Eric Valent, OF, New York Mets, from the Cincinnati Reds
Willie Collazo, LHP, Anaheim Angels, from the Atlanta Braves
Leslie Nacar, RHP, Kansas City Royals, from the San Francisco Giants
Ender Chávez, OF, Montreal Expos, from the New York Mets
Luis Jimenez, INF, Los Angeles Dodgers, from the Baltimore Orioles
John Foster, LHP, Chicago Cubs, from the Milwaukee Brewers
Tim Corcoran, RHP, Tampa Bay Devil Rays, from the Baltimore Orioles
Pete Zoccolillo, OF, Texas Rangers, from the Milwaukee Brewers
Danny Sandoval, INF, Colorado Rockies, from the Philadelphia Phillies
Alex Pelaez, INF, Anaheim Angels, from the San Diego Padres
Francisco Campos, RHP, Chicago White Sox, from the Milwaukee Brewers
Sergio Contreras, OF, Tampa Bay Devil Rays, from the Anaheim Angels

=2002=

;Major League phase{{cite web|url=http://www.baseballamerica.com/today/minors/rule5results02.html|archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20021218092755/http://www.baseballamerica.com/today/minors/rule5results02.html|title=2002 Rule 5 Draft Results|work=Baseball America|date=December 16, 2002|archivedate=December 18, 2002|accessdate=March 28, 2023}}

scope="col" \| Pick ! scope="col" \| By ! scope="col" \| Player ! scope="col" \| Pos. ! scope="col" \| From ! scope="col" \| Notes
class="wikitable plainrowheaders sortable"
1	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Enrique\|Cruz}} \| rowspan="2" \| IF	New York Mets
2	Tampa Bay Devil Rays !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Héctor\|Luna}} \| Cleveland Indians	Returned to Cleveland on March 29, 2003
3	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Buddy\|Hernandez\|nolink=y}} \| RHP	Atlanta Braves
4	Detroit Tigers !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Wil\|Ledezma}} \| rowspan="2" \| LHP	Boston Red Sox
5	Chicago Cubs !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Derek\|Thompson\|dab=baseball}} \| Cleveland Indians
6	Kansas City Royals !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|D. J.\|Carrasco}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	Pittsburgh Pirates
7	Pittsburgh Pirates !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Matt\|Roney}} \| Colorado Rockies
8	Colorado Rockies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Victor\|Hall\|nolink=y}} \| OF	Arizona Diamondbacks
9	Texas Rangers !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Marshall\|McDougall}} \| rowspan="2" \| IF	Cleveland Indians
10	Cleveland Indians !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Travis\|Chapman}} \| Philadelphia Phillies
11	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Luke\|Prokopec}} \| rowspan="2" \| RHP	Los Angeles Dodgers
12	Toronto Blue Jays !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Aquilino\|López}} \| Seattle Mariners
13	Boston Red Sox !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Javier\|López\|dab=baseball}} \| LHP	rowspan="2" \| Arizona Diamondbacks
14	Montreal Expos !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Luis\|Ayala\|dab=baseball}} \| RHP
15	Minnesota Twins !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|José\|Morban}} \| IF	Texas Rangers
16	Oakland Athletics !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Mike\|Neu\|dab=baseball}} \| rowspan="3" \| RHP	Cincinnati Reds
17	Atlanta Braves !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Chris\|Spurling}} \| Pittsburgh Pirates
18	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Matt\|Ford\|dab=baseball}} \| Toronto Blue Jays
19	San Diego Padres !scope="row" style="background:#fc0"\|{{sortname\|Shane\|Victorino}} \| OF	Los Angeles Dodgers
20	Kansas City Royals !scope="row" \|{{sortname\|Ronny\|Paulino}} \| C	Pittsburgh Pirates
21	Texas Rangers !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|John\|Koronka}} \| rowspan="3" \| RHP	Cincinnati Reds
22	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Blake\|Williams\|nolink=y}} \| St. Louis Cardinals
23	Toronto Blue Jays !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Gary\|Majewski}} \| Chicago White Sox
24	Boston Red Sox !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Matt\|White\|dab=baseball, born 1977}} \| LHP	Cleveland Indians
25	Oakland Athletics !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Rontrez\|Johnson}} \| OF	Texas Rangers
26	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Jerome\|Gamble\|nolink=y}} \| RHP	Boston Red Sox
27	Toronto Blue Jays !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Jason\|Dubois}} \| rowspan="2" \| OF	Chicago Cubs
28	Boston Red Sox !scope="row"\| {{sortname\|Adrian\|Brown\|dab=baseball}} \| Pittsburgh Pirates

;Notable minor league selections

David Manning, RHP, Milwaukee Brewers from the Minnesota Twins
Rico Washington, C, San Diego Padres from the Pittsburgh Pirates
Juan Cerros, RHP Cincinnati Reds from the New York Mets
Franklyn Gracesqui, LHP, Miami Marlins from the Toronto Blue Jays
Mike Cervenak, 3B, San Francisco Giants from the New York Yankees
Andy Cavazos, RHP, St. Louis Cardinals from the Texas Rangers
Junior Herndon, RHP, Boston Red Sox from the San Diego Padres
Nate Bland, LHP, Houston Astros from the New York Mets

=2001=

;Major league phase

Pick	By	Player	Pos.	From	Notes
class="wikitable"
1	Tampa Bay Devil Rays	Kevin McGlinchy	RHP	Atlanta Braves
2	Pittsburgh Pirates	Luis Ugueto	IF	Florida Marlins	Later traded by the Pirates to the Seattle Mariners for cash considerations.
3	Kansas City Royals	Miguel Asencio	rowspan="4" \| RHP	Philadelphia Phillies
4	Montreal Expos	Joe Valentine	Chicago White Sox	Later traded by the Expos to the Detroit Tigers for cash considerations.
5	Detroit Tigers	Jeff Farnsworth	rowspan="3" \| Seattle Mariners
6	Milwaukee Brewers	Jorge Sosa	Claimed off waivers from Milwaukee by Tampa Bay on March 18, 2002.
7	Anaheim Angels	Steve Kent	LHP	Sent to Tampa Bay for cash considerations on December 17, 2001.
8	Toronto Blue Jays	Corey Thurman	rowspan="2" \| RHP	rowspan="2" \| Kansas City Royals
9	San Diego Padres	Ryan Baerlocher
10	Oakland Athletics	Jason Grabowski	rowspan="2" \| IF	Seattle Mariners
11	San Francisco Giants	Félix Escalona	Houston Astros	Claimed off waivers from San Francisco by Tampa Bay on March 27, 2002
12	Milwaukee Brewers	Ryan Christenson	OF	Arizona Diamondbacks

;Notable players chosen in the minor league phases{{cite web|url=https://www.baseballamerica.com/today/minors/rule5results01.html|archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20020208134311/https://www.baseballamerica.com/today/minors/rule5results01.html|title=Rule 5 Draft Results|work=Baseball America|date=December 13, 2001|archivedate=February 8, 2002|accessdate=March 28, 2023}}

Jeff Pickler, 2B, Texas Rangers from the Milwaukee Brewers
Graham Koonce, 1B, Oakland Athletics from the San Diego Padres
Ntema Ndungidi, OF, Seattle Mariners from the Baltimore Orioles
Joe Dillon, 1B, Minnesota Twins from the Kansas City Royals

=2000=

;Major League Phase

Pick	By	Player	Pos.	From
class="wikitable"
1	Chicago Cubs	Scott Chiasson	rowspan="3" \| RHP	Oakland Athletics
2	Minnesota Twins	Brandon Knight	New York Yankees
3	Montreal Expos	Ted Rose	Cincinnati Reds
4	Baltimore Orioles	Jay Gibbons	IF	Toronto Blue Jays
5	Kansas City Royals	Endy Chávez	OF	New York Mets
6	Detroit Tigers	Jermaine Clark	rowspan="2" \| IF	Seattle Mariners
7	San Diego Padres	Donaldo Méndez	Houston Astros
8	Anaheim Angels	Rendy Espina	rowspan="2" \| LHP	Toronto Blue Jays
9	Los Angeles Dodgers	José Antonio Núñez	New York Mets
10	New York Mets	Julio Santana	RHP	San Francisco Giants

=1999=

;Major League Phase

Pick	By	Player	Pos.	From	Notes
class="wikitable"
1	Minnesota Twins	Jared Camp	RHP	Cleveland Indians	Later traded by the Twins to the Florida Marlins for Johan Santana.
2	Florida Marlins	style="background:#fc0" \|Johan Santana	LHP	Houston Astros	Later traded by the Marlins to the Minnesota Twins for Jared Camp.
3	Kansas City Royals	Damian Rolls	IF	Los Angeles Dodgers	Immediately sent to Tampa Bay as part of a conditional deal.{{cite web\|url=https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/r/rollsda01.shtml#TRANS \|title=Damian Rolls Statistics and History \|publisher=Baseball-Reference.com \|access-date=April 26, 2011}}
4	Tampa Bay Devil Rays	Chad Ogea	rowspan="4" \| RHP	Detroit Tigers
5	Montreal Expos	Marty McLeary	Boston Red Sox
6	Detroit Tigers	Mark Johnson	New York Yankees
7	Anaheim Angels	style="background:#fc0" \|Derrick Turnbow	Philadelphia Phillies
8	San Diego Padres	Kory DeHaan	OF	Pittsburgh Pirates
9	Milwaukee Brewers	Matt Williams	LHP	New York Yankees	Returned to New York on May 3, 2000.{{cite web\|url=https://www.baseball-reference.com/w/willima09.shtml#TRANS \|title=Matt Williams Statistics and History \|publisher=Baseball-Reference.com \|access-date=August 3, 2010}}
10	Seattle Mariners	Chad Alexander	rowspan="3" \| OF	Houston Astros
11	Toronto Blue Jays	DeWayne Wise	Cincinnati Reds
12	Oakland Athletics	Bo Porter	Chicago Cubs
13	Pittsburgh Pirates	Brian Smith	RHP	Toronto Blue Jays
14	San Francisco Giants	Dave Maurer	rowspan="2" \| LHP	San Diego Padres
15	Cincinnati Reds	Adrian Burnside	Los Angeles Dodgers
16	New York Mets	Jim Mann	rowspan="2" \| RHP	Toronto Blue Jays
17	Tampa Bay Devil Rays	Chris Reitsma	Boston Red Sox	Returned to Boston on March 28, 2000.

=1998=

;Major League Phase

Pick	By	Player	Pos.	From
class="wikitable"
1	Florida Marlins	Alberto Blanco	LHP	Houston Astros
2	Tampa Bay Devil Rays	David Lamb	IF	Baltimore Orioles
3	Detroit Tigers	Eric Ludwick	RHP	Florida Marlins
4	Montreal Expos	Ricky Williams	OF	Philadelphia Phillies
5	Minnesota Twins	Josue Espada	IF	Oakland Athletics
6	Pittsburgh Pirates	Scott Sauerbeck	LHP	New York Mets
7	Oakland Athletics	Eric Stuckenschneider	rowspan="2" \| OF	Los Angeles Dodgers
8	Philadelphia Phillies	David Miller	Cleveland Indians
9	Chicago White Sox	Jay Walker Chapman	RHP	Minnesota Twins
10	St. Louis Cardinals	Alberto Castillo	C	Philadelphia Phillies
11	Boston Red Sox	Joel Adamson	LHP	Oakland Athletics
12	Houston Astros	Glen Barker	rowspan="2" \| OF	Detroit Tigers
13	Chicago White Sox	Tyrone Pendergrass	Atlanta Braves

=1997=

;Major League Phase

Pick	By	Player	Pos.	From	Notes
class="wikitable"
1	Seattle Mariners	Jeff Huson	IF	Colorado Rockies	Released by Seattle July 8, 1998{{cite web\|url=https://www.baseball-reference.com/h/husonje01.shtml#TRANS \|title=Jeff Huson Statistics and History \|publisher=Baseball-Reference.com \|access-date=August 3, 2010}}
2	Philadelphia Phillies	Héctor Mercado	LHP	rowspan="2" \| Florida Marlins	Later traded by Philadelphia to the New York Mets for Mike Welch{{cite web\|url=https://www.baseball-reference.com/m/mercahe01.shtml#TRANS \|title=Hector Mercado Statistics and History \|publisher=Baseball-Reference.com \|access-date=August 3, 2010}}
3	Texas Rangers	style="background:#fc0" \|Scott Podsednik	OF
4	Atlanta Braves	Brian Edmondson	RHP	New York Mets
5	Arizona Diamondbacks	Stephen Randolph	LHP	rowspan="2" \| New York Yankees
6	Los Angeles Dodgers	Frank Lankford	RHP	Returned by the Dodgers to the Yankees May 15, 1998 {{cite web\|url=https://www.baseball-reference.com/l/lankffr01.shtml#TRANS \|title=Frank Lankford Statistics and History \|publisher=Baseball-Reference.com \|access-date=August 3, 2010}}
7	Detroit Tigers	Sean Runyan	LHP	San Diego Padres
8	Cincinnati Reds	Keith Glauber	RHP	rowspan="2" \| St. Louis Cardinals
9	Toronto Blue Jays	Luis Saturria	OF	Returned by the Blue Jays to the Cardinals March 20, 1998 {{cite web\|url=https://www.baseball-reference.com/s/saturlu01.shtml#TRANS \|title=Luis Saturria Statistics and History \|publisher=Baseball-Reference.com \|access-date=August 3, 2010}}
10	New York Yankees	Matt Williams	LHP	Tampa Bay Devil Rays
11	Chicago White Sox	Joe Davenport	RHP	Toronto Blue Jays

References

External links

Category:Minor league baseball

Category:Baseball in the United States lists

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Chicago White Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Shane\|Smith\|dab=baseball}} \|RHP	Milwaukee Brewers
2	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Liam\|Hicks}} \|C	Detroit Tigers
3	Los Angeles Angels !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Garrett\|McDaniels}} \|LHP	Los Angeles Dodgers
4	Athletics !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Noah\|Murdock}} \| rowspan="3" \|RHP	Kansas City Royals
5	Washington Nationals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Evan\|Reifert}} \|Tampa Bay Rays	Returned to the Rays on March 18.{{Cite web \|last=Adams \|first=Steve \|date=2025-03-18 \|title= Nationals Return Rule 5 Pick Evan Reifert To Rays \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/nationals-return-rule-5-pick-evan-reifert-rays.html \|access-date=2025-03-18 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
6	Toronto Blue Jays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Angel\|Bastardo}} \|Boston Red Sox
7	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Cooper\|Bowman}} \|2B	Athletics	Returned to the Athletics on March 12.{{Cite web \|last=McDonald \|first=Darragh \|date=2025-03-12 \|title= Reds Return Rule 5 Selection Cooper Bowman To Athletics \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/reds-return-rule-5-selection-cooper-bowman-to-athletics.html \|access-date=2025-03-12 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
8	Tampa Bay Rays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nathan\|Lavender}} \|LHP	New York Mets
9	Minnesota Twins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Eiberson\|Castellano}} \|RHP	Philadelphia Phillies	Returned to the Phillies on March 25.{{Cite web \|last=Adams \|first=Steve \|date=2025-03-25 \|title= Mickey Gasper, DaShawn Keirsey Make Twins’ Roster; Twins Exploring Bullpen Market \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/twins-rumors-reliever-mickey-gasper-dashawn-keirsey-make-roster.html \|access-date=2025-03-26 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
10	Chicago Cubs !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Gage\|Workman}} \|SS	Detroit Tigers
11	Atlanta Braves !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Anderson\|Pilar}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Miami Marlins	Returned to the Marlins on March 19.{{Cite web \|last=McDonald \|first=Darragh \|date=2025-03-19 \|title= Braves To Return Rule 5 Pick Anderson Pilar To Marlins \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/braves-to-return-rule-5-pick-anderson-pilar-to-marlins.html \|access-date=2025-03-19 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
12	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Juan\|Núñez\|dab=baseball}} \|Baltimore Orioles	Returned to the Orioles on March 25.{{Cite web \|last=McDonald \|first=Darragh \|date=2025-03-25 \|title= Padres Return Rule 5 Pick Juan Nunez To Orioles \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/padres-to-return-rule-5-pick-juan-nunez-to-orioles.html \|access-date=2025-03-25 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
13	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Connor\|Thomas}} \|LHP	St. Louis Cardinals
14	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mike\|Vasil}} \|RHP	New York Mets	Traded to the Rays on December 11.{{Cite web \|last=Morganstern \|first=Leo \|date=2024-12-11 \|title= Phillies Trade Rule 5 Pick Mike Vasil To Rays \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2024/12/phillies-trade-rule-5-pick-mike-vasil-to-rays.html \|access-date=2025-03-18 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}} Claimed off waivers by the White Sox on March 23.{{Cite web \|last=Deeds \|first=Nick \|date=2025-03-23 \|title= White Sox Claim Mike Vasil Off Waivers From Rays \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/white-sox-claim-mike-vasil-off-waivers-from-rays.html \|access-date=2025-03-23 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
15	Atlanta Braves !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Christian\|Cairo}} \|SS	Cleveland Guardians	Returned to the Guardians on March 19.{{Cite web\|title=Braves Return Rule 5 Pick Christian Cairo To Guardians\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2025/03/braves-return-rule-5-pick-christian-cairo-to-guardians.html\|access-date=March 19, 2025\|website=mlbtraderumors.com\|language=en}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Oakland Athletics !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mitch\|Spence}} \| rowspan="3" \|RHP	rowspan="2" \|New York Yankees
2	Kansas City Royals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Matt\|Sauer}} \| Returned to the Yankees on May 26.{{Cite web\|title=Yankees\|url=https://x.com/Yankees/status/1794779378850881975\|access-date=May 26, 2024\|website=x.com\|language=en}}
3	Colorado Rockies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Anthony\|Molina\|dab=baseball}} \|Tampa Bay Rays
4	Chicago White Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Shane\|Drohan}} \|LHP	Boston Red Sox	Returned to the Red Sox on June 12.{{Cite web \|last=McDonald \|first=Darragh \|date=2024-06-12 \|title= White Sox Return Rule 5 Pick Shane Drohan To Red Sox \|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2024/06/white-sox-return-rule-5-pick-shane-drohan-to-red-sox.html \|access-date=2024-06-23 \|website=MLB Trade Rumors}}
5	Washington Nationals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nasim\|Nuñez}} \|SS	Miami Marlins
6	St. Louis Cardinals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Ryan\|Fernandez}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Boston Red Sox
7	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Justin\|Slaten}} \|Texas Rangers	Traded to the Red Sox on December 6, 2023.{{Cite web \|last=Cerullo \|first=Mac \|date=2023-12-06 \|title=Red Sox acquire RHP Justin Slaten from Mets \|url=https://www.bostonherald.com/2023/12/06/red-sox-acquire-rhp-justin-slaten-from-mets/ \|access-date=2023-12-07 \|website=The Boston Herald}}
8	Cleveland Guardians !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Deyvison\|De Los Santos}} \|3B	Arizona Diamondbacks	Returned to the Diamondbacks on March 23, 2024.{{Cite web\|title=Diamondbacks get back Deyvison De Los Santos after Rule 5 selection\|url=https://arizonasports.com/story/3544879/diamondbacks-get-back-deyvison-de-los-santos-after-rule-5-selection/\|access-date=March 23, 2024\|website=arizonasports.com\|date=March 23, 2024 \|language=en}}
9	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Stephen\|Kolek}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Seattle Mariners
10	Texas Rangers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Carson\|Coleman}} \|New York Yankees	Returned to the Yankees on November 19, 2024.{{Cite web\|title=Yankees Select Caleb Durbin, Jesus Rodriguez\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2024/11/yankees-select-caleb-durbin-jesus-rodriguez.html\|access-date=November 20, 2024\|website=mlbtraderumors.com\|language=en}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Washington Nationals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Thaddeus\|Ward}} \|RHP \|Boston Red Sox \|
2	Oakland Athletics !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Ryan\|Noda}} \|1B \| rowspan="2" \|Los Angeles Dodgers
3	Pittsburgh Pirates !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|José\|Hernández\|dab=pitcher}} \|LHP
4	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Blake\|Sabol}} \|OF	Pittsburgh Pirates	Traded to the San Francisco Giants{{cite web \| url=https://sports.yahoo.com/giants-trade-blake-sabol-lose-023049958.html \| title=Giants trade for Blake Sabol, lose eight Double-A players in Rule 5 Draft }}
5	Detroit Tigers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Mason\|Englert}} \| rowspan="7" \|RHP	Texas Rangers
6	Colorado Rockies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Kevin\|Kelly\|dab=pitcher, born 1997}} \| rowspan="2" \|Cleveland Guardians	Traded to the Tampa Bay Rays{{cite web \| url=https://www.cleveland.com/guardians/2022/12/guardians-lose-pitchers-nic-enright-and-kevin-kelly-in-rule-5-draft.html \| title=Guardians lose pitchers Nic Enright and Kevin Kelly in Rule 5 draft \| date=December 7, 2022 }}
7	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nic\|Enright}} \|Returned to the Guardians on June 1{{Cite web \|title=Guardians' Nic Enright: Returned to Cleveland \|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/guardians-nic-enright-returned-to-cleveland/amp/ \|access-date=2023-07-09 \|website=www.cbssports.com}}
8	Chicago White Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nick\|Avila}} \|San Francisco Giants	Returned to the Giants on March 28{{cite web \| url=https://www.turlockjournal.com/sports/pro-sports/avila-returned-giants-soderstrom-reassigned-spring-trainings-wraps/ \| title=Avila returned to Giants; Soderstrom reassigned as spring trainings wraps up }}
9	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Andrew\|Politi}} \|Boston Red Sox	Returned to Red Sox on March 28{{Cite web\|title=Red Sox's Andrew Politi: Returns to Red Sox\|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/red-soxs-andrew-politi-returns-to-red-sox/amp/\|access-date=2023-03-28\|website=cbssports.com\|language=en}}
10	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Gus\|Varland}} \|Los Angeles Dodgers	Returned to Dodgers on May 22{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2023/05/brewers-return-rule-5-gus-varland-dodgers.html\|title=Brewers Return Gus Varland To Dodgers, Place Eric Lauer On Injured List\|work=MLB Trade Rumors\|first=Steve and Darragh McDonald\|last=Adams\|date=May 22, 2023\|accessdate=May 22, 2023}}
11	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Noah\|Song}} \|Boston Red Sox	Returned to Red Sox on August 4{{cite web \| url=https://www.masslive.com/redsox/2023/08/noah-song-lost-in-the-rule-5-draft-last-december-returns-to-red-sox.html?outputType=amp \| title=Noah Song, lost in the Rule 5 draft last December, returns to Red Sox \| date=August 4, 2023 }}
12	San Diego Padres !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|José\|López\|dab=pitcher}} \|LHP	Tampa Bay Rays	Returned to Rays on March 26{{Cite web\|title=Rays' Jose Lopez: Returned to Tampa Bay\|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/rays-jose-lopez-returned-to-tampa-bay/amp/\|access-date=2023-03-26\|website=cbssports.com\|language=en}}
13	Seattle Mariners !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Chris\|Clarke\|dab=baseball}} \| rowspan="3" \|RHP	Chicago Cubs	Returned to Cubs on March 26{{Cite web\|title=Cubs' Chris Clarke: Returned to CHC\|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/cubs-chris-clarke-returned-to-chc/amp/\|access-date=2023-03-26\|website=cbssports.com\|language=en}}
14	St. Louis Cardinals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Wilking\|Rodríguez}} \| rowspan="2" \|New York Yankees	Spent entire season on injured list, released and re-signed to minor league contract November 21 {{cite web \| url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/cardinals-wilking-rodriguez-re-signed-to-minors-contract/amp/ \| title=Cardinals' Wilking Rodriguez: Re-signed to minors contract }}
15	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Zach\|Greene}} \| Returned to Yankees on March 14{{cite web\|title=Yankees' Zach Greene: Returns to Yankees organization\|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/yankees-zach-greene-returns-to-yankees-organization/amp/\|access-date=2023-03-14\|website=cbssports.com\|language=en}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Richie\|Martin}} \|SS	Oakland Athletics
2	Kansas City Royals !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Sam\|McWilliams}} \| rowspan="4" \|RHP	Tampa Bay Rays	Returned to the Rays{{cite web\|url=https://www.tampabay.com/sports/2019/03/24/rule-5-pick-sam-mcwilliams-returned-to-rays/ \|title=Rule 5 pick Sam McWilliams returned to Rays \|publisher=Tampabay.com \|date=March 24, 2019 \|access-date=April 9, 2019}}
3	Chicago White Sox !scope="row" style="background:#fc0\|{{sortname\|Jordan\|Romano}} \|Toronto Blue Jays	Traded to the Texas Rangers, and returned to the Blue Jays{{cite web\|url=https://www.sportsnet.ca/baseball/mlb/rule-5-pitcher-jordan-romano-returning-blue-jays/\|title=Rule 5 pitcher Jordan Romano returning to Blue Jays\|work=Sportsnet\|date=March 24, 2019\|access-date=March 24, 2019}}
4	Miami Marlins !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Riley\|Ferrell\|nolink=y}} \|Houston Astros	Returned to the Astros{{cite web\|url=https://www.cbssports.com/fantasy/baseball/news/astros-riley-ferrell-sent-back-to-houston/\|title=Astros' Riley Ferrell: Sent back to Houston\|author=RotoWire Staff\|work=CBS Sports\|date=June 24, 2019\|access-date=June 24, 2019}}
5	Detroit Tigers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Reed\|Garrett}} \|Texas Rangers	Returned to the Rangers{{cite web\|url=https://sports.yahoo.com/tigers-return-rule-5-selection-214650257.html\|title=Tigers return Rule 5 selection Garrett to Rangers\|publisher=Yahoo Sports\|date=May 20, 2019 \|access-date=May 31, 2019}}
6	Cincinnati Reds !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Connor\|Joe}} \|IF/OF	Los Angeles Dodgers	Traded to the San Francisco Giants,{{cite web\|last=Simmons \|first=Rusty \|url=https://www.sfchronicle.com/giants/article/Pablo-Sandoval-s-future-even-murkier-after-13707692.php \|title=Pablo Sandoval's future even murkier after Giants acquire versatile Connor Joe from Reds \|publisher=SFChronicle.com \|date=March 21, 2019 \|access-date=April 9, 2019}} and returned to the Dodgers{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlb.com/news/rule-5-pick-connor-joe-returned-to-dodgers\|title=Rule 5 pick Joe returned to Dodgers\|work=MLB.com\|author=Ken Gurnick\|date=April 13, 2019\|access-date=May 31, 2019}}
7	Texas Rangers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Chris\|Ellis\|dab=baseball}} \|RHP	St. Louis Cardinals	Traded to the Royals,{{cite web\|last=Rieper \|first=Max \|url=https://www.royalsreview.com/2018/12/13/18139440/royals-rule-5-draft-sam-mcwilliams-chris-ellis-luciano \|title=Royals acquire two pitchers in the Rule 5 draft \|publisher=Royals Review \|date=December 13, 2018 \|access-date=April 9, 2019}} returned to the Cardinals{{cite web\|author=FOX Sports Midwest \|url=https://www.foxsports.com/midwest/story/st-louis-cardinals-get-former-rule-5-pick-chris-ellis-back-from-kansas-city-royals-040919 \|title=Cardinals get former Rule 5 pick Chris Ellis back from Royals \|work=FOX Sports \|date=April 9, 2019 \|access-date=April 9, 2019}}
8	San Francisco Giants !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Travis\|Bergen}} \|LHP	Toronto Blue Jays	Returned to Blue Jays.{{cite web\|author=Laura Armstrong\|url=https://www.thestar.com/sports/bluejays/2019/08/22/lefty-travis-bergen-latest-rule-5-returnee-for-blue-jays.html\|title=Lefty Travis Bergen latest Rule 5 returnee for Blue Jays\|work=Toronto Star\|date=August 22, 2019\|access-date=August 25, 2019}}
9	Toronto Blue Jays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Elvis\|Luciano}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Kansas City Royals
10	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Kyle\|Dowdy}} \|Cleveland Indians	Claimed by Rangers, and returned to Cleveland on July 28, 2019.{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2019/07/rangers-return-rule-5-pick-kyle-dowdy-to-indians.html\|title=Rangers Return Rule 5 Pick Kyle Dowdy To Indians\|author=George Miller\|website=MLB Trade Rumors\|date=July 28, 2019\|access-date=July 28, 2019}}
11	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Drew\|Jackson}} \|SS	Los Angeles Dodgers	Traded to the Baltimore Orioles in exchange for international bonus slot money,{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2018/12/2018-rule-5-draft-results.html\|title=2018 Rule 5 Draft Results\|website=MLB Trade Rumors\|date=December 13, 2018 \|access-date=December 14, 2018}} and returned to the Dodgers{{cite web\|url=https://www.baltimoresun.com/sports/orioles/bs-sp-orioles-drew-jackson-dodgers-20190410-story.html\|title=Orioles Rule 5 draftee Drew Jackson clears waivers, returned to Dodgers\|work=Baltimore Sun\|author=Nathan Ruiz\|date=April 10, 2019\|access-date=May 31, 2019}}
12	Arizona Diamondbacks !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Nick\|Green\|nolink=y}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	New York Yankees	Returned to the Yankees{{cite web\|url=http://arizonasports.com/story/1887606/arizona-diamondbacks-return-rule-5-pick-nick-green-to-yankees/ \|title=Arizona Diamondbacks return Rule 5 pick Nick Green to Yankees \|publisher=Arizonasports.com \|date=March 24, 2019 \|access-date=April 9, 2019}}
13	Seattle Mariners !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brandon\|Brennan}} \|Colorado Rockies
14	San Francisco Giants !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Drew\|Ferguson\|nolink=y}} \|OF	Houston Astros	Returned to the Astros{{cite web\|url=https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2019/03/giants-return-rule-5-pick-drew-ferguson-to-astros.html\|title=Giants Return Rule 5 Pick Drew Ferguson To Astros\|last=Adams\|first=Steve\|work=mlbtraderumors.com\|date=March 22, 2019\|access-date=March 22, 2019}}

scope="col"\|Pick !scope="col"\|By !scope="col"\|Player !scope="col"\|Pos !scope="col"\|From !scope="col"\|Notes
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders"
1	Houston Astros !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Patrick\|Schuster}} \|LHP	Arizona Diamondbacks	Sent to the San Diego Padres as the player to be named later for Anthony Bass, Returned to the Diamondbacks
2	Chicago White Sox !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Adrián\|Nieto}} \|C	Washington Nationals
3	Philadelphia Phillies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Kevin\|Munson}} \| rowspan="2" \|RHP	Arizona Diamondbacks	Returned to the Diamondbacks
4	Colorado Rockies !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Tommy\|Kahnle}} \|New York Yankees
5	Toronto Blue Jays !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Brian\|Moran\|dab=baseball}} \|LHP	Seattle Mariners	Traded to the Los Angeles Angels{{cite web\|url=http://www.ocregister.com/angels/rule-541334-moran-draft.html\|title=Angels acquire LHP Brian Moran in Rule 5 draft\|date=December 12, 2013\|access-date=December 10, 2015}}
6	New York Mets !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Seth\|Rosin}} \|RHP	Philadelphia Phillies	Traded to the Los Angeles Dodgers,{{cite web\|last=Adams \|first=Steve \|url=http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2013/12/dodgers-acquire-seth-rosin.html \|title=Dodgers Acquire Seth Rosin: MLB Rumors \|publisher=MLBTradeRumors.com \|access-date=December 12, 2013}} Claimed off waivers by the Rangers,{{cite web\|last=Cash \|first=David \|url=https://nolanwritin.com/2014/03/27/seth-rosin-acquired-by-the-texas-rangers-los-angeles-dodgers-spring-training-waivers/ \|title=Seth Rosin acquired by the Texas Rangers \|date=March 27, 2014 \|publisher=Fansided \|access-date=December 16, 2019}} Returned to the Phillies
7	Milwaukee Brewers !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Wei-Chung\|Wang}} \|LHP	Pittsburgh Pirates
8	Arizona Diamondbacks !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Marcos\|Mateo}} \|RHP	Chicago Cubs	Returned to the Cubs during spring training{{cite web\|url=https://www.chicagotribune.com/sports/baseball/cubs/chi-marcos-mateo-back-20140313,0,2190358.story\|title=Cubs get Mateo back from Diamondbacks\|work=tribunedigital-chicagotribune\|access-date=December 10, 2015}}
9	Baltimore Orioles !scope="row"\|{{sortname\|Michael\|Almanzar}} \|3B	Boston Red Sox	Returned to the Red Sox, later traded to Orioles