Talk:Muhammad/Archive index

! Discussion Topic !! Replies (estimated) !! Archive Link

| General thoughts about the article

| aims or claims

| Caliphate Expansion

| death

| Major revision

| Broke up pro and con section, moved it to other parts of article

| OneGuy and his reverts

| Aisha's marriage and consumation

| Boys over 12

| Anonymous deleter

| Created Muhammad as warrior page

| Rearranged per Mustafaa's suggestions

| Your restraint is appreciated, IFaqeer

| What do you mean shai POV?

| Death of Muhammad

| Someone revised history!

| Mohammed, Muhammed, Mohammad

| Battle of Badr

| Companions

| re:changes to this article

| Proposed insertion in intro

| Suggested intro

| announcing NPOV proposal, new policy

| Urchid's latest edits

| POV sticker added

| His name

| Muhammad and his slaves section

| Evidence for being first written constitution?

| Prophetic career -- prophecy

| Muhammad as influental

| Pictures and WP:Civility

| Anon Sunni changing Death of Muhammad section

| Birthdays

| Battle of Uhud

| Considering

| ON linkspamming

| One of most influential people in history

| AE Edits

| "Final prophet of Islam"

| Muslim sources report

| Iconoclasts at work?

| User: Chaosfeary

| the image

| Overloading intro para with detail

| Muhammad's children

| I'd like to call a Vote on a picture of Mohammed

| Edit war about atheist website

| Stability pact

| Titles of veneration

| Survival or choice

| Name

| Curious about Spelling

| Caption on Miraj picture

| Protection

| Question from a newcomer

| Zora

| Dang hadith

| Jyllands-Posten Muhammad cartoons controversy

| Problems?

| about the sections Muslims veneration of Muhammad.

| Links to Muslim biographies of Muhammad

| Who is the prophet Muhammad (s.a.s)?

| Muhammad as "Father of Islam"?

| My Question is

| Persian painting

| PBUH

| Someone added a bunch of text to the "sources" section

| Zulfiqar/Thulfiqar

| Hair Colour

| RE Tor Andrae

| The "they believe" fallacy

| Kuffr

| Life according to Sira

| Theological discussions of the nature of Muhammad

| More on "Founder"

| Delisted Good Article

| Musaylimah

| Druze and Baha'i religion

| Aminz's NPOV'ing edits

| Copyediting

| Link-pruning

| Timothy Usher

| Was Muhammad the founder of Islam?

| Muhammad as Founder section

| Founder (continued)

| Jeremy's edits

| rvv?

| Historical views

| Question about last prophet bit

| References?

| Stylistic apostasy

| Saad ibn Muadh

| Founder, yet again

| his own faith?

| Muhammad the Honest and Helpful Child

| My edit

| "to all mankind"

| Robotic vandalism

| Temp version put up as regular version

| How's that for titles and subtitles?

| Bilal's edits

| Edits by Natalinasmpf

| NPOV

| While everyone else slept ...

| References multiplying

| "A major figure"

| Introduction to article - how to say who Muhammad was in as short and reasonably accurate a manner as possible

| typo

| Compromise?

| How WP policy favors secular points of view

| Decision Now

| Can we vote yet?

| Primordial Islam?

| Wrongfully?

| Edit warring

| Furthermore

| Ali Sina's inclusion in the New Quotations Section

| Section: The first revelations (Cannot have first revelations)

| Section: The first revelations (Cannot have first revelations) 2

| sources

| Massacre in Khaybar?

| Not only a POV but also Wrong

| Use of Stillman quote for claim regarding "ha-meshugga"

| "Muhammad" a title?

| Islam template

| "Description" section

| Remark

| Sabotage by FayssalF (Szvest)

| Article size

| Copyright Violation

| Marhaba

| Formatting Issue?

| Picture of re-dedication

| Freaking Propoganda

| Header edit war - reaching consensus

| A Simple Situation

| Concerning the page lock

| Establish vs. Founded

| MAHOMET

| Muhammad was not a pedophile.

| Baphomet

| re: use of the term "idols" and User:Opiner's related edits

| Images

| Problems with Introduction - Weasel Words

| Footnotes

| Caliphate picture

| Verifiability

| Adolf Hitler

| List of founders of world religions

| Asking again is Qur'an really a major source for Muhammads life?

| God & Allah

| Opiner changes

| Coherence?

| Slavery

| "a religion he called Islam"

| Negative traits of Mohammed suppressed

| "Historical Founder"

| Just a small remark:

| My addition to the intro

| Schimmel Mahomet & Mahound

| Marriage to a child

| Proabivouac , Stop "misrepresenting" the sources

| Esposito references

| Your censorship

| Semi-protection requested

| "Historical View"

| Dawah trash

| Observation

| Muhammad Pic

| Accurate Text was Removed!!! Either declare biases or Delete Whole Article.

| Must everything be pure quotes from other sources, to avoid POV … I do not believe so?

| Family Life

| Restatement of Underlying Issues

| Depictions removal

| Awkward section

| this article is a disgrace, and extremely revisionist

| Depictions

| POV masking as fact

| Literary reforms

| Book not scholarly enough?

| Please vote

| Muhammad the reformer – still POV

| Str's recent edits

| Welcome

| Request for clarification

| Any objection

| Muhammad and Bible Prophesy

| STATEMENTS

| Clarity

| NPOV and sources

| Kindness to the Children and the Happy Animoos

| Image Criteria: Sandbox

| My Sources

| Arab Custom

| Original research w.r.t. Animals

| Moved to reform section

| Truthspreader Double Standard on Hadith

| Should the article talk about Muhammad's kindness to pets, and if so, what should be said?

| Protection

| Mediation

| Status update

| Wikipedia policy for using extremist sites

| Proposal by BostonMA 23:36, 3 December 2006 (UTC)

| What does he look like?

| My revert to User:CmdrObot

| Short absence

| Aisha criticism

| Can we archive some of this?

| Hagia Sophia

| Child article for 'Muhammad and the Jewish tribe of Medina'

| Picture of Muhammad

| suggestion

| Battle of Uhud

| Main sources

| Reference cleanup

| Gospel of Barnabas

| The Garbage Sources

| Image:Miraj2.jpg

| Muhammad and Jewish Tribes

| Muhammad and the West

| Sincerety of Muhammad

| Details of Revelation

| Quote from Schimmel

| Britannica Encyclopedia

| Muhammad and the Jews

| Vandalism

| Muhammad and Jewish tribes political

| Sources

| OR tag

| New List of Participants

| Recent PB edits

| we need to add this in order to make a correct representation of the Life of the Prophet (Allah's peace be upon him)

| Review

| Sincerity question

| Idea how to fix image dispute.

| Muhammad naked?

| Use of an anachronistic image of Muhammad

| Image of Muhammed?

| Example how to fix the image problem used elsewhere on Wikipedia.

| An essay on Muhammad's pictures

| Wipeout

| What you would do...

| People should think

| Being offended by pictures

| Another Idea

| The image has historical, education, and artistic interest. Removing it pushes WP out of NPOV.

| Another suggestion: one click away

| Depictions of Muhammad(the section)

| What about other views of Muhammad?

| Outside Resources

| Picture supporters attention:

| Muhammad at the Supreme Court building

| both of them are deffending !!!!

| Suggestion

| My two cents on images of Muhammad

| New calligraphic image

| The issue is very simple

| Who can comfirm?

| Comparing the articles of two Abrahamic prophets in Wikipedia.

| Wikipedia Policy = No respect for Religion ?

| Image logjam

| It's all about the REASON

| To everybody offended by the images

| What might actually work

| Image proposal

| Al-Biruni

| References Related to Misleading and Wrong information presented by images (see section above)

| I Think That The Solution Is In The Caption

| Arbitration

| Another vote (yawn): Let's keep it simple

| Back to protection please

| The name is informal and unencyclopedic

| Truth vs Verifiability

| Wikipedia is NOT censored? Really?

| Drawn by al-Biruni?

| Edit warring

| Al-Biruni

| Protection

| since when was there consensus on the lead image?

| Columbus v. Mohammad

| Why I cannot edit the article

| User:Alim777

| Does the article John F. Kennedy autopsy feature photographs of same?

| Good

| Undue weight concerns

| This mediation is going nowhere

| Another possibility

| Review (2)

| French

| Lead image

| Calligraphy size

| Results of a Survey

| Now Research with referernces

| Images should be removed

| Another proposal

| How about putting the picture "below the fold"?

| 16th Century: Thing of Beauty (More calligraphies)

| intro section

| Shahada image

| Ref tags

| Section on "Miracles in the Muslim biographies" hardly mentions anything about miracles

| Muhammad's attitude

| Depictions of Muhammad

| May be the last voting

| This talk page is an ongoing disgrace

| Two visual depictions in lead

| Compromise found?

| Original Compromise found

| Compromise on Pictures

| Let's look at it another way

| TfD nomination of Template:Linkimage

| Why is the Al-Biruni manuscript picture right at the bottom?

| Muhammad and the Jews

| On two pics in lead

| Thank you for inviting me to this mediation

| New Version

| Hidden table of contents

| Gospel of Barnabas

| Why is this article locked

| Age of Muhammad at his death

| Edit summaries

| Archive for Talk:Muhammad/images

| Check Wikipedia:WikiProject Countering systemic bias

| Vandalism?

| Introduction

| Gnostic saint?

| Images

| South Park

| Illiteracy

| Mentioning Aisha

| Cleaning up false accusations

| Etymology

| Why?

| Why is the heated discussion?

| Restoration of unnecessary and obscure language

| Miracles of Muhammad

| Muhammed founder of islam?

| Picture caption

| Muhammd and the founder of islam

| Arbitration

| Images of Prophet Mohammad

| Proposed talk subpage

| Is discussion at all possible?

| My Strange Doubletake on this Issue

| Sir Salman Rushdie

| reverting blake

| Simple Questions Regarding the Blake Image

| more questions

| Just a suggestion

| Previous conflict in Medina

| Header

| citations, citations

| Semi-protect this article please

| IPA Pronunciation on page

| Kotham and Halabi

| Destroying references

| Beginning of the conflict section

| Karen Armstrong

| RFC

| Controversy

| Arabic

| The beginning of the conflict

| Arrow's addition

| Pro's latest version

| Begining of conflict section

| Prisoner

| Conflict with Mecca section

| Aisha

| User:Arrow740, you are now reinserting your POV to a disputed passage you have refused to enter mediation on

| Pretty simple here

| This is Mohammad

| Hijra or Migration

| Last years in Mecca

| Muslim views of Muhammad

| Aisha II

| Protection

| Some information from Encyclopedia Britannica

| Arrow740 and Aminz edit war

| Proposal II

| Chunk II

| Unprotected?

| Response

| Removal of the Pics of Muhammad

| On the first paragraph...

| bios

| uniformity of Kaaba

| Depiction

| Madina/Medina?

| Further Reading Addition

| Name

| this article is far too long

| PLEASE REMOVE PICTURES OF THE BELOVED PROPHET(peace and blessings be upon him)

| Jesus to Christians and Muhammad to Islam

| De-protected

| POV pushing

| Please remove the Illustrations

| remove the critism section

| Banu Qaynuqa

| Second picture

| Prophet Mohammed in Hinduism

| please remove the pictures

| Arbitration Request created

| Removal of offensive material

| could someone who is good at archiving a heated page, please archive?

| Too many leading thingies

| Who is this 'we' so many refer to here?

| Not actually Muhammad

| Arrow

| i think

| Need clarification

| neutral point of view

| "The only way acceptable to God"

| How To Get Wikipedia to remove the Pictures of Mohammed

| A new suggestion

| Better citation needed

| Where is the validation of the pictures.?!! if you cant validate then remove it..!!! as easy as that.

| Typo in the header

| Respecting the others doctrine

| لا يحل

| Wikipedia is not a free encyclopedia

| Images

| Reflist & Notes

| Calling attention to the FAQ list

| A vivid explanation, and pure request

| Wikipedia should act as a responsible organization and should immediately remove all such offensive materials. Not to mention, it shouldn't have been published at first place

| Please remove the pictures

| Request to improve the text below images

| Remove these pictures

| why cant i edit this page ?

| Problem with the FAQ

| More calligraphy please

| Dealing with "Remove pictures of the Prophet PBUH" - and cleanup of the talk page

| use of "to conquer"

| The image of no scholarly/historic significance

| Is full protection necessary?

| Appearance of Muhammad

| FAQ improvement possibility.

| pictures, wikipedia servers

| REMOVE PICTURES

| Portraits showing Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him)

| Is it worth it?

| Why the Face?

| Notice to all those who wish Wikipedia to remove pictures of Muhammad

| Argument from popularity / Petition

| No permission from Islam

| A reminder

| Thanks

| Arbitration

| Muhammad himself didn't approve of painting living objects

| Wikipedia is not an Islamic website

| Arguments for Keeping the images

| Censorship

| This whole discussion is bogus

| Suggestion for a solution

| Analysis and a proposal

| Death (murder) of Muhammad

| This is Pointless

| Painted by muslims

| Islamic scholar: Wikipedia's use of the images is not problematic

| Images Irrelevant to the article

| Please remove the picture of Muhammad

| Freedom of expression is a God-given right...and an American practice that is sacred.

| This isn't a first amendment issue

| Who painted the images of Muhammed to begin with?

| Become an active editor

| A compromise?

| Bahaullah connection

| The way to proceed: Principles and not Practical Solutions

| Operational activities

| It's Wikipedia, not...

| to article space

| Suggestion

| Archiving of this talk page

| Penis thread was censored by deletion. I've put it back.

| Erroneous description of picture of Mohammed

| 100,000 Muslims protest Wikipedia

| Have some respect.

| Archiving and Subpages (or, "Where is my conversation thread?")

| Come on people, isn't all this fight a little too much?

| Posted under "Need Clarification"

| self reference

| Gallery?

| Isra and Mi'raj

| Who moved the pictures further down?

| Proposal: Warning + full images

| No accomodations should be made at all

| Removal of the prophet's pictures

| You are all been used as a tool

| Spelling

| Removal of the prophet's pictures

| A logical error

| Censoring wikipedia = idolizing Muhammad ?

| Question about the pictures?

| Come on guys

| I have a question

| Unprotection

| Top posted comment

| Remark

| What if we destroy all the pictures of muhammad?

| SPAM

| sensitivity

| Commons link

| Image:Mohammed kaaba 1315.jpg

| Question about FAQ page: Content that can be considered blasphemous

| Shadow Article

| Images on the Arabic Wikipedia

| What educational value there is?

| Why are the pictures gone?

| PETITION FOR 10,000 REACHES 300,000+

| Bahira

| Censorship

| Muhammad's other roles: Lede worthy?

| Guardian article on Muhammad images

| Come on, this has gone a little too much...

| Possible Solution?

| Scriptural Question

| The Qur'an was not authored by Muhammad

| The Arabian Background

| fix this typo

| this article is not following NPOV guidelines

| Problem with "Non-Consenting Viewers" Argument

| Please consider this external link

| Location of Warning Notice

| Broken Caption

| Historiography of the Prophet's life

| If these Pictures were real?

| Mahmoud123's edit

| Good article nomination

| References cleaned up

| POV check:Beginnings of the Qur'an

| Ghadir khum

| Reforms

| Verification needed

| Aftermath

| Inheritance

| Captioning

| Wrong resources

| Ali and Kalam

| New change in WP:MOSISLAM

| Edit warring

| Aisha's age important to Islamic theocracy

| Central human figure

| Link FA - Update

| Confusion over wording in article

| Please, we need a portrait of muhammed like everyone else on WikiPedia

| Another possible way to approach this problem.

| infobox

| Second Pledge of al-`Aqaba

| Just A question

| Massive changes by Wikidas

| Picture Should be REMOVED

| Views of Muhammad

| Editting Muhammad Articles

| Remove Images

| Part of Muslim (Shiah) Supports the Picture

| Images

| Hindu scripture section

| Niema

| Too many lies in this para=

| Here we go again:)......

| Add to his [Muhammad] early life a little?

| Edit requested

| What about adding that link?

| A Friendly Suggestion

| A sincere advice and a remedy

| Remove ALL the pictures depicting Muhammad (PBUH)

| US Presidents Descended from Muhammed

| Should we just cull any talk on removing images straight away ?.

| What if Wikipedia considers this

| FAQ images

| Yathrib vs Medina

| Muhammad and Terrorism

| Delete something from the article ?

| Prophet Muhammad (peace upon him)

| A Muslim reaction

| Comment

| Isra and Mi'raj

| Images

| Uploading Our Beloved Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) is offensive

| Honorifics

| Sources

| how much donation you need to remove the pictures..

| Muhammad's face is blurred out in pic Siyer-i Nebi 298a.jpg

| Pictures are Facutally Incorrect

| The depictions of Hazrath Mohammed SAW (pbuh)

| Online petition to remove images

| A mistake that no one can deny

| Removal of Pics required

| pictures of our prophet muhammad (SAW) must be removed from this site

| Please take our prophet Muhammed (pbuh) picture of from the article.

| The initial revelation date

| Common Era

| Incorrect history - revise the matter

| Ta'la al Badru 'Alayna

| Muhammad and Temporal Lobe Epilepsy (TLE)

| Traditional views

| Russan painting

| European and Western views

| New FAQ entry

| Young

| Atrocities

| Prophet Muhammad's Picture

| Rumour about Muhammad's horse

| Pictures of Muhammad

| Opening words

| Image Violation

| Way to go Wikipedia!!!

| founder of religion misconception

| A neutral islamic point of view !

| I need to make some changes to article name "Muhammad"

| European and Western views

| Wikipedia's attention is drawn to a page on facebook.

| Comment by Haney G.

| better idea

| Incorrect link!!!

| A new(?) idea

| Pictures of Muhammad

| Guru Nanak's view of Muhammad

| Opening Paragraph

| Broken link

| "muhammad" used for Jesus claim

| References for the beginnings of armed conflict

| What happened to filter 131?

| Please Remove Photos depicting Prophet

| Remove the pictures of Muhammed now

| Sarosh and sources

| About the phrase remarkably prices

| Precise Knowledge Leading to Negative Perceptions

| Russian painting of Muhammad.

| High ethical principles demand that the pictures of the Prophet be removed from this article

| NEW USER COMMENT, 17/JAN/10

| Do you think as a human should you harm any other human?

| Please remove the picture

| Wives and children

| Transliterations

| Accuracy of source 9/ verbal descriptions

| Why Was my Question Removed About Muhammed's African Origins?

| Image Improvements

| Spelling Error

| "Founder"??

| Removal of all the pics depicting Rasool Allah PBUH

| Bad edit

| Pictures

| "Wives and Children" needs edited!

| Some Famous Quotes About Prophet Muhammad (Pbuh)

| Aisha was 6 when she was married and marriage was consummated when she was 9

| Article is too long

| Correction required concerning Shahada

| Problems With Introduction

| Caricatures

| Saint Joseph, Saint Mathhew is allowed, Swami vivekananda is allowed but not Prophet simply Muhammad

| Draw Muhammad Day

| "Muhammad is" vs. "Muhammad was"

| Tony fox

| Pictures

| Founder of Islam?, NPOV dispute

| Founder of Islam!

| Proper use of English language

| About Hazrat Muhammad(pbuh)'s pictures:objectionable OR blasphamous

| Remove Illustrated images posted in this artcle

| Procedure to hide the images at Muhammad page

| Consensus

| Proposed removal of deliberately provocative images

| Unsourced sentences

| Illustrations of muhammad