Thunder of Silence

{{Infobox television episode

| series = Shell Presents

| image = Thunder of Silence.png

| caption = Ad from SMH 22 Aug 1959

| season = 1

| episode = 6

| director = David Cahill

| teleplay = Stewart Stern

| photographer =

| airdate = {{Start date|1959|08|22|df=yes}}

| length =

| guests = John Meillon

| prev = The Big Day

| next = Ruth

}}

"Thunder of Silence" is an episode of the 1959 Australian TV drama anthology Shell Presents, and the fourth made in Sydney. It was based on an American play by Stewart Stern which had been produced in the U.S. with Paul Newman and Inger Stevens.{{cite news|date=20 July 1959|page=19|newspaper=Sydney Morning Herald|title=Local plays capture big audiences|url=https://www.newspapers.com/image/121563126/?terms=%22thunder%2Bof%2Bsilence%22}}{{cite news |url=http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article189931202 |title=TV Highlights |newspaper=The Biz |location=New South Wales, Australia |date=19 August 1959 |accessdate=14 September 2017 |page=6 |via=National Library of Australia}} It aired live on 22 August 1959 in Sydney{{Cite news|newspaper=Sydney Morning Herald|title=TV Guide|date=17 August 1959|page=17|url=https://www.newspapers.com/image/121519020/?terms=%22thunder%2Bof%2Bsilence%22}} with a recorded version airing on 28 November 1959 in Melbourne.

It was a drama of immigrant assimilation.{{cite book|publisher=Australian Public Intellectual Network|year=2007|editor1-first=Liz|editor1-last=Liz|editor2-first=Tim|editor2-last=Dolin|title=Australian Television History|series=ACH: The Journal of the History of Culture in Australia|chapter=Dramas and Dreams at Epping: Early Days of ATN-7's Drama Production|first=Ailsa|last=McPherson|page=160}} John Meillon played the lead.{{cite news |url=http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article189931202 |title=TV Highlights |newspaper=The Biz |location=New South Wales, Australia |date=19 August 1959 |accessdate=19 May 2016 |page=6 |via=National Library of Australia}} Australian TV drama was relatively rare at the time.{{cite magazine|first=Stephen|last=Vagg|url=https://www.filmink.com.au/60-australian-tv-plays-1950s-60s/|magazine=Filmink|title=60 Australian TV Plays of the 1950s & ‘60s|date=February 18, 2019}}

Plot

In the American mid-west, a middle aged farmer (John Tate) and his wife (Marion Johns) give shelter to a refugee from Europe (Richard Davies) and his daughter (Marion Johns). The refugee and the farmer have very different personalities and struggle to understand each other. The situation is resolved by the return of Everett (John Meillon), the farming couple's wandering son.

Cast

John Meillon as Everett
Richard Davies
Marion Johns
John Tate
John Llewellyn
Margo Carrigan

Production

Stewart Stern based the play on the reallife experiences of farmers in Maryland who took in refugees from Europe.

Stewart Stern wrote a letter from the USA wishing good luck to everyone connected to the play, and passing on ideas from Paul Newman as to how the role of Everett (the part he played on US TV) should be performed.{{cite news|title=Migrants in US Play|url=https://www.newspapers.com/image/121518954/?terms=%22thunder%2Bof%2Bsilence%22|newspaper=Sydney Morning Herald|date=17 August 1959|page=15}}{{cite news|newspaper=The Age|date=26 November 1959|page=27|url=https://www.newspapers.com/image/122417788/?terms=%22brett%2Bporter%22|title=Film of TV Drama Flown to Author in USA}} The letter was read out to the cast the night before the show was recorded. Producer Brett Porter said, "'these words from the author seemed to clarify everyone's conception of the play itself, and they went on to give what I firmly believe is the best production yet in the series."{{cite news|newspaper=Sydney Morning Herald|title=New TV drama on ATN 7|date=22 August 1959|page=4|url=https://www.newspapers.com/image/121521846/?terms=%22thunder%2Bof%2Bsilence%22}}

The play was filmed at ATN-7's studios in Epping. A tape recording was sent to Stern in the US.{{cite news|newspaper=The Age|url=https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=1IRVAAAAIBAJ&sjid=5KgDAAAAIBAJ&pg=5840%2C4355570|date=26 November 1959|page=14|title=Film of TV Drama Flown to Author in USA}}

Porter said, "I hope that showing this film, to people like Stern and Newman will prove to people in America that we have, in Australia, actors equal to the best in the world."

Margot Carrigan was in Take a Chance on ATN.{{cite news |url=http://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article189931202 |title=TV Highlights |newspaper=The Biz |location=New South Wales, Australia |date=19 August 1959 |accessdate=6 September 2020 |page=6 |via=National Library of Australia}}

Reception

The TV critic from the Sydney Morning Herald thought the play treated the theme "in the terms of a paperbacked women's novelette" with "sticky flood of sentimentality" and "naive philosophising" but thought Million "did very well to give a tense of life and vitality to a character whose motivation was obscure and whose dialogue, at times, was impossibly trite. Most of the time, his part sounded as though it had been written for James Dean by Ernest Hemingway—with neither of them at their best...

David Cahill's direction was fluent and uncluttered."{{cite news|newspaper=Sydney Morning Herald|title="Thunder of Silence" on television|date=24 August 1959|page=22|url=https://www.newspapers.com/image/121526798/?terms=%22thunder%2Bof%2Bsilence%22}}

The TV critic for The Age praised the production's "sound musical judgement" and opening documentary footage of refugees being vetted though felt Meillon "was much too preoccupied wrestling with the American accent" and although felt the play "was good entertainment" wondered why it was not adapted to be set in Australia.{{cite news|url=https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1300&dat=19591203&id=n6UUAAAAIBAJ&sjid=Sq8DAAAAIBAJ&pg=5201,547745&hl=en|title=Moldau sets the mood in moving drama about DPs|date=3 December 1959|page=14|newspaper=The Age}}

Meillon's performance led to his casting in A Tongue of Silver.{{cite news|newspaper=Sydney Morning Herald|title=Women dominate cast|date=14 September 1959|page=13}}