Timeline of bordism

{{short description|None}}

This is a timeline of bordism, a topological theory based on the concept of the boundary of a manifold. For context see timeline of manifolds. Jean Dieudonné wrote that cobordism returns to the attempt in 1895 to define homology theory using only (smooth) manifolds.{{cite book |last=Dieudonné |first=Jean |authorlink=Jean Dieudonné|title=A History of Algebraic and Differential Topology, 1900 - 1960 |date=2009 |publisher=Springer |isbn=978-0-8176-4907-4 |page=289 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=RUV5Dz90rDkC&pg=PA289 |language=en}}

Integral theorems

class="wikitable sortable" width="100%"

! Year

! style="width:22%" | Contributors

! Event

Late 17th centuryGottfried Wilhelm Leibniz and othersThe fundamental theorem of calculus is the basic result in integral calculus in one dimension, and a primal "integral theorem". An antiderivative of a function can be used to evaluate a definite integral over an interval as a signed combination of the antiderivative at the endpoints. A corollary is that if the derivative of a function is zero, the function is constant.
1760sJoseph-Louis LagrangeIntroduces a transformation of a surface integral to a volume integral. At the time general surface integrals were not defined, and the surface of a cuboid is used, in a problem on sound propagation.{{cite book |last1=Harman |first1=Peter Michael |title=Wranglers and Physicists: Studies on Cambridge Physics in the Nineteenth Century |date=1985 |publisher=Manchester University Press |isbn=978-0-7190-1756-8 |page=113 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=hj68AAAAIAAJ&pg=PA113 |language=en}}
1889Vito VolterraVersion of Stokes' theorem in n dimensions, using anti-symmetry.{{cite book |last1=Zeidler |first1=Eberhard |title=Quantum Field Theory III: Gauge Theory: A Bridge between Mathematicians and Physicists |date=2011 |publisher=Springer Science & Business Media |isbn=978-3-642-22421-8 |page=782 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=miwuxaEXvOsC&pg=PA782 |language=en}}
1899Henri PoincaréIn Les méthodes nouvelles de la mécanique céleste, he introduces a version of Stokes' theorem in n dimensions using what is essentially differential form notation.Victor J. Katz, The History of Stokes' Theorem, Mathematics Magazine Vol. 52, No. 3 (May, 1979), pp. 146–156, at p. 154. Published by: Taylor & Francis, Ltd. on behalf of the Mathematical Association of America {{JSTOR|2690275}}
1899Élie CartanDefinition of the exterior algebra of differential forms in Euclidean space.
c.1900Mathematical folkloreThe situation at the end of the 19th century is that a geometric form of the fundamental theorem of calculus is available, if everything was smooth enough when rigour is required, and in Euclidean space of n dimensions.

The result corresponding to setting the derivative equal to zero is to apply it to closed forms, and as such is "mathematical folklore". It is in the nature of a remark that there are integral theorems for submanifolds linked by cobordism. The analogue of the theorem on derivative zero would be for submanifolds M_1 and M_2 that jointly form the boundary of a manifold N, and a form \omega defined on N with d\omega = 0. Then the integrals I_1 and I_2 of \omega over the M_j are equal. The signed sum seen in the case of a boundary of dimension 0 reflects the need to use orientations on the manifolds, to define integrals.

1931–2W. V. D. HodgeThe vector calculus of low dimensions is given a place in general tensor calculus, in all dimensions, using differential forms and the Hodge star operator. The codifferential adjoint to the exterior derivative is the general form of divergence operator. Closed forms are dual to forms of divergence 0.{{cite book |last1=Atiyah |first1=Michael |title=Collected Works: Michael Atiyah Collected Works: Volume 1: Early Papers; General Papers |date=1988 |publisher=Clarendon Press |isbn=978-0-19-853275-0 |page=239 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=YJ0cZwxLECAC&pg=PA239 |language=en}}

Cohomology

class="wikitable sortable" width="100%"

! Year

! style="width:22%" | Contributors

! Event

1920sÉlie Cartan and Hermann WeylTopology of Lie groups.
1931Georges de RhamDe Rham's theorem: for a compact differential manifold, the chain complex of differential forms computes the real homology groups.{{SpringerEOM|title=De Rham theorem |id=De_Rham_theorem&oldid=13456}}
1935–1940Group effortThe cohomology concept emerges in algebraic topology, contravariant and dual to homology. In the setting of de Rham, cohomology gives classes of equivalent integrands, differing by closed forms; homology classifies regions of integration, up to boundaries. De Rham cohomology becomes a basic tool for smooth manifolds.
1942Lev PontryaginPublishing in full in 1947, Pontryagin founded a new theory of cobordism with the result that a closed manifold that is a boundary has vanishing Stiefel-Whitney numbers. From the folklore Stokes's theorem corollary, cobordism classes of submanifolds are invariant for the integration of closed differential forms; the introduction of algebraic invariants gives the opening for computing with the equivalence relation as something intrinsic.{{cite book|title=Canadian Mathematical Bulletin|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=Nvy0A_AW-MUC&pg=PA289|accessdate=6 July 2018|year=1971|publisher=Canadian Mathematical Society|page=289}}
1940sTheories of fibre bundles with structure group G; of classifying spaces BG; of characteristic classes such as the Stiefel-Whitney class and Pontryagin class.
1945Samuel Eilenberg and Norman SteenrodEilenberg–Steenrod axioms to characterise homology theory and cohomology, on a class of spaces.
1946Norman SteenrodThe Steenrod problem. Stated as Problem 25 in a list by Eilenberg compiled in 1946, it asks, given an integral homology class in degree n of a simplicial complex, is it the image by a continuous mapping of the fundamental class of an oriented manifold of dimension n? The preceding question asks for the spherical homology classes to be characterised. The following question asks for a criterion from algebraic topology for an orientable manifold to be a boundary.Samuel Eilenberg, On the Problems of Topology, Annals of Mathematics

Second Series, Vol. 50, No. 2 (Apr., 1949), pp. 247–260, at p. 257. Published by: Mathematics Department, Princeton University {{JSTOR|1969448}}

1958Frank AdamsAdams spectral sequence to calculate, potentially, stable homotopy groups from cohomology groups.

Homotopy theory

class="wikitable sortable" width="100%"

! Year

! style="width:22%" | Contributors

! Event

1954René ThomFormal definition of cobordism of oriented manifolds, as an equivalence relation.{{cite book |last1=Dieudonné |first1=Jean |authorlink=Jean Dieudonné|title=Panorama des mathématiques pures |date=1977 |publisher=Bordas |isbn=978-2-04-010012-4 |page=14 |language=fr}} Thom computed, as a ring under disjoint union and cartesian product, the cobordism ring \mathfrak{N}_* of unoriented smooth manifolds; and introduced the ring \Omega_* of oriented smooth manifolds.{{cite book |last1=Cappell |first1=Sylvain E. |author1-link=Sylvain Cappell|last2=Wall |first2=Charles Terence Clegg |author2-link=C. T. C. Wall|last3=Ranicki |first3=Andrew |author3-link=Andrew Ranicki|last4=Rosenberg |first4=Jonathan |title=Surveys on Surgery Theory: Papers Dedicated to C.T.C. Wall |date=2000 |publisher=Princeton University Press |isbn=978-0-691-04938-0 |page=4 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=hLBQ2w4pYBgC&pg=PA4 |language=en}} \mathfrak{N}_* is a polynomial algebra over the field with two elements, with a single generator in each degree, except degrees one less than a power of 2.
1954René ThomIn modern notation, Thom contributed to the Steenrod problem, by means of a homomorphism \Phi \colon \Omega^{\mathrm{SO}}_{\ast}(X) \to H_{\ast}(X,\Z), the Thom homomorphism.{{cite web |title=Steenrod problem – Manifold Atlas |url=http://www.map.mpim-bonn.mpg.de/Steenrod_problem |website=www.map.mpim-bonn.mpg.de}} The Thom space construction M reduced the theory to the study of mappings in cohomology H^\ast(\mathrm{MSO}(k)) \to H^\ast(X).{{SpringerEOM |id=Steenrod_problem&oldid=24570 |title=Steenrod problem |author-first=Yu. B. |author-last=Rudyak}}
1955Michel LazardLazard's universal ring, the ring of definition of the universal formal group law in one dimension.
1960Michael AtiyahDefinition of cobordism groups and bordism groups of a space X.{{SpringerEOM |id=Bordism&oldid=24384 |title=Bordism |author-first= D. V. |author-last=Anosov}}
1969Daniel QuillenThe formal group law associated to complex cobordism is universal.{{SpringerEOM |id=Cobordism&oldid=24052 |title=Cobordism |author-first=Yu. B. |author-last=Rudyak}}

Notes