Login
Login

User:Ikip/AfD on average day

__TOC__

AfD on average day

Date: November 15, 2008

(102 articles, 53 deleted, 31 keep,20 kept, 11 no consensus 18 redirected3 merged)

  1. 31 out of 984 articles, which had copyright or BLP violations or were a hoax were not included articles, nearly one third, which were put up for deletion were created by editors whose very first contributions was the new article.
  2. 66 out of 98 articles, 67%, which were put up for deletion were created by editors who had 100 contributions or less when they created the article.
  3. 75 out of 98 articles, 76.5%, which were put up for deletion were created by editors who had 350 contributions or less when they created the article.

class="wikitable sortable"

!#!!Page listed on Articles for Deletion!! Nominator for deletionThree editors are responsible for 17.6% of the articles for deletion !!Creator of article!!Date article was created!!Article for deletion result!!Edit count of creator at time of article creation!!Message page of new user!!Did creator contact another editor about the deletionDetermines if creator was still editing on wikipedia when articles was put up for deletion. Whether the article being put up for deletion had any effect on the editor. !!Creator edits after the Article for deletion Determines whether creator stayed or left wikipedia

1

|Nintendo World Store

|JacobPowers

|64.237.179.155

|2005 07 28

|Keep

|0

|Never contacted

|

2

|Sura (film)

|Mgm

|Universal Hero

|2008 03 22

|Delete

|10820

| -

|

3

|Jez

|TTN

|Halfbrick

|2007 01 17

|Redirect, but merge

|44

|Welcome, Warning templates 7, Never contacted

|

4

|Amanda Lockhart

|TTN

|Ashleymtisdalefank

|2008 09 14

|Redirect, but merge

|0

|Warning templates 2

|

5

|Philby (The Kingdom Keepers)

|TTN

|Ashleymtisdalefank

|2008 09 14

|Redirect, but merge

|0

|Warning templates 2, Never contacted

|

6

|Finn Whitman

|TTN

|WiseOldRafiki

|2007 04 11

|Redirect, but merge

|0

|Question by new user, Warning templates 1

|

7

|Ulthuan

|TTN

|24.185.212.101

| 2004 08 10

|Delete

|2

|Warning templates only 1

|

8

|SCORES Broadcast

|Little Red Riding Hood

|Limp73

|2008 11 15

|Delete

|250

|welcome, Warning templates 1

|

9

|Ajit Ninan

|Mgm

|Xyn1

|2008 11 15

|Keep

|74

|Warning templates 3

|

10

|Terry Stembridge, Jr.

|Bongomatic

|Hirolovesswords

|2008 10 17

|Delete

|3490

| -

|

11

|Live USB system creator

|Master Thief Garrett

|SF007

|2008 06 03

|Delete

|1532

| -

|

12

|Why riding hood might cry

|skomorokh

|WtHIEU19

|2008 November 15

|Delete

|0

|Warning templates 4

|

13

|Paul Pantone

|Scott MacDonald

|68.34.65.100

|2004 07 13

|Delete

|2

|Never contacted

|

14

|Miss Puerto Rico 2000

|hexaChord

|Joseantravieso

|2008 11 15

|Redirect, but merged

|0

|Warning templates 4

|

15

|Intellectual Property and Art Digitization

|Oscarthecat

|Spdegabrielle

|2008 10 16

|Delete

|177

|Warning templates 1

|

bgcolor="#DDDDDD"

|16

|Asha Degree

|Onorem

|

|

|Delete, BLP issue'

|

|

|

17

|1970s Topps

|The Almighty Bob

|Libro0

|2006 12 25

|Keep

|541

|Various

|

18

|FilePile.com

|Schuym1

|Tranquileye

|2005 08 15

|Delete

|70

|Various

|

19

|Nonpseudoscience

|ESanchez013

|0XQ

|2008 11 15

|Delete

|633

|

|

20

|Dr. Ghadam-Ali Sarami

|A Stop at Willoughby

|Csarami

|2008 11 15

|Keep

|5

|

|

21

|Vania

|Biruitorul

|K0rean bab0

|2006 05 13

|Delete

|0

|

|

22

|List of Academy Award Historical and Non-Fictional Roles

|Ironholds

|Mr Hall of England

| 2008 November 15

|Delete

|4928

| -

|

23

|Www1

|KurtRaschke

|Sadads

|2008 11 11

|Delete

|75

|

|

24

|Cold Spring Tavern

|Kickstart70

|Jm51

|2006 06 10

|Keep

|510

|

|

25

|Fair Online Network

|Oscarthecat

|Virtuaalturg

|2008 11 15

|Delete

|3

|

|

26

|Glamour (charm)

|Ged UK

|Wolfkeeper

|2008 10 16

|Delete[http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&page=Glamour_(charm) Edit history]

|18780

| -

|

27

|Stewart Gull

|SGGH

|Brookie

|2006 12 13

|Redirect, but merged

|15961

| -

|

28

|Zrada Cultural Academy

|CactusWriter

|Marcoj

|2008 10 17

|Delete

|0

|

|

29

|Boris Kreiman

|BBiiis08

|Probuddha

|2008 09 20

|Keep

|5

|

|

30

|List of Boot Disks

|Mr Senseless

|NicholasBrand

|2008 11 15

|Delete

|8

|

|

31

|Workspace Macro

|DavidWS

|Automaite

|2008 11 12

|Keep

|0

|

|

32

|Minicalc

|Stepshep

|Ooliedoolie

|2008 November 03

|Delete

|0

|

|

33

|Journal For Plague Lovers

|Raven1977

|Ddddaniel

|2008 11 14

|Delete

|0

|

|

34

|Chico's (restaurant)

|Kickstart70

|JIP

|2005 09 29

|Delete

|1

|

|

bgcolor="#DDDDDD"

|35

|The Last Miracle Mile

|TrackerTV

|

|

|Delete, COPYRIGHT VIOLATION

|

|

|

36

|Wal-Mart Knowledge Management

|KurtRaschke

|Melissiahys2008

|2008 11 15

|Redirect

|0

|

|

37

|Leopard in Pakistan

|TrackerTV

|Hayatomermalik

|2008 11 15

|Merged

|15

|

|

38

|Wiser's Small Batch

|Ged UK

|Cp98ak

|2008 10 16

|Keep

|25

|

|

39

|Ireland (Home Nation)

|Guliolopez

|Sparten

|2008 08 31

|Delete

|296

|

|

40

|School no. 11 Mihai Eminescu

|Biruitorul

|Sunala255

|2008 11 14

|Merged

|2

|

|

41

|Aquasermo

|Blanchardb

|Gstsqs

|2008 11 14

|Delete

|0

|

|

42

|User:Ikip/NASCO Properties

|ChildofMidnight

|Jingoro

|2006 11 04

|Redirect

|1

|

|

43

|Newton Howard

|Dchall1

|Cads.media

|2007 01 05

|Delete

|0

|

|

44

|List of dodgeball variations

|Dendodge

|Fethers

|2006 12 24

|Keep

|228

|

|

45

|Sherbet (powder)

|Alexius08

|Obersachse

|2008 11 15

|Keep

|1931

| -

|

46

|Gerri Peev

|Steve Dufour

|Anthony717

|2008 03 08

|Keep

|1235

| -

|

47

|ZOMG!

|EconomicsGuy

|Vicener

|2007 11 09

|Keep

|3

|

|

48

|Greg Brady (broadcaster)

|Rtphokie

|Frellmedead

|2008 11 15

|Keep

|0

|

|

49

|Alex Tweddle

|Toddst1

|Atweddle

|

|Delete

|3

|

|

50

|Rollac

|CactusWriter

|Ladyb.jhb

|2008 10 17

|Delete

|0

|

|

51

|Wesnoth AI

|Strikeout Sister

|Wesnoth ai

|2008 11 15

|Delete

|0

|

|

52

|Based music

|Black Kite

|Yaneleksklus

|2008 08 27

|Delete

|0

|

|

53

|Uni5

|Hello_Control

|BTNHthugs

|2008 07 16

|Delete, recreated

|266

|

|

54

|Peter Catanzariti

|WWGB

|Jfranklin80

|2008 11 15

|Delete

|0

|

|

55

|James Wharton

|Doktorbuk

|Bjoel5785

|2006 10 22

|Redirected

|1713

| -

|

56

|Joe and Mildred Tabootie

|Undead warrior

|Blackbone 5000

|2006 02 26

|Delete

|14

|

|

57

|Craniac

|Undead warrior

|Blackbone 5000

|2006 02 26

|Redirect

|22

|

|

58

|Horace T. Wilter

|Undead warrior

|Blackbone 5000

|2006 02 26

|Delete

|14

|

|

59

|Rudy Tabootie

|Undead warrior

|Blackbone 5000

|2006 02 26

|Redirected

|13

|

|

60

|Snap (ChalkZone)

|Undead warrior

|Blackbone 5000

| 2006 02 26

|Delete

|12

|

|

61

|Heavy lobster

|Punkmorten

|Kevinhead

|2008 11 08

|Redirect, but merged

|5

|

|

62

|2WOW

|Mayalld

|Blueturtle01

|2008 08 05

|Keep

|866

|

|

63

|Rebecca Michaels

|Black Kite

|Rebecca Michaels

|2008 10 26

|Redirect, but merged

|0

|

|

64

|Halfway House (music venue)

|Flewis

|Nofuturenohope

|2007 07 10

|Delete

|0

|

|

65

|FPSBanana

|SkyWalker

|PurplG

|2007 11 27

|Delete

|19

|

|

66

|David Bouchier

|dougweller

|GooglePedia12

| 2008 11 14

|Delete

|140

|

|

67

|List of businesses involved in World War II

|Hollandmc

|Bmunden

|2006 12 20

|Delete

|59

|

|

68

|Wasteland (film)

|Girolamo Savonarola

|Manachiki

|2008 09 30

|Delete

|3

|

|

69

|Tajik Wikipedia

|MBisanz

|Soroush83

|2007 07 03

|Redirected

|192

|

|

bgcolor="#DDDDDD"

|70

|Pipe Beavers

|NickW557

|

|

|Delete HOAX

|

|

|

71

|Wacky Waters Adventure Park

|Ctjf83

|Firsfron

|2006 04 21

|Keep

|2887

| -

|

72

|Heaven Or Hell

|Toddst1

|GOLDRUSH

|2008 11 07

|Delete

|25

|

|

73

|Tom Freda

|Laval

|70.49.175.155

|2005 07 25

|Redirect, but merged

|0

|

|

74

|Anaconda 4: Trail of Blood

|Collectonian

|AliiiDeee

| 2008 08 07

|Delete

|89

|

|

75

|Marshall Field family

|Tavix

|Handicapper

|2006 12 14

|Redirect, but merged

|4592

|

|

76

|Nao Kudo

|Arthur Rubin

|Maka-maka

|2008 11 03

|Delete

|217

|

|

77

|Blue Fire Burning

|Vianello

|Nider

|2008 11 15

|Delete

|0

|

|

78

|Tiffany Weimer

|Arthur Rubin

|Popndopalis8

|2008 11 09

|Keep

|0

|

|

79

|Hannah Kane: Me and the Boys

|Mufka

|Hstarr1490

|2008 11 12

|Delete

|0

|

|

80

|Academy of Shotokan Karate

|Blast Ulna

|Charlesdrakew

|2007 03 14

|Keep

|16

|

|

81

|Supa Nova Productions

|Paul Erik

|N-Do19

|2007 09 01

|Delete

|0

|

|

82

|Darren Sadler

|Bongomatic

|L33th4x0rguy

|2008 10 17

|Delete

|943

|

|

83

|Energy and American Society

|ScienceApologist

|Johnfos

|2007 12 03

|Redirect

|9284

| -

|

84

|E. Kyle Datta

|ScienceApologist

|Johnfos

|2008 06 22

|Keep

|13846

| -

|

85

|Clipper Windpower

|ScienceApologist

|Johnfos

|2007 09 15

|Keep

|6837

| -

|

86

|Chuck Hansen

|ScienceApologist

|Johnfos

|2008 09 9

|Keep

|15617

| -

|

87

|Dian Grueneich

|ScienceApologist

|Johnfos

|2008 08 21

|Keep

|15322

| -

|

88

|David A. Schlissel

|ScienceApologist

|Johnfos

|2008 09 1

|Keep

|15503

| -

|

89

|David Mills (solar researcher)

|ScienceApologist

|Johnfos

|2007 02 26

|Keep

|339

|

|

90

|David Lowry

|ScienceApologist

|Johnfos

|2007 11 03

|Keep

|7912

| -

|

91

|North london stags

|The Windler

|George1191

|2008 11 10

|Delete

|0

|

|

92

|Folke Rydén

|EmilEikS

|Ennol

|2008 04 22

|Keep

|0

|

|

93

|Barrrow A.F.C.

|I-hunter

|Eagleabove

|2008 11 15

|Redirect

|0

|

|

94

|Action of 11 November 2008

|Nsk92

|XavierGreen

|2008 11 13

|Keep

|881

|

|

95

|Mission Prep Christmas Classic

|Raven1977

|Scives

|2008 10 07

|Delete

|0

|

|

96

|JDOG

|Otto4711

|DylanADD

|2008 03 24

|Keep

|0

|

|

97

|Golden Age Cartoons

|Jonny2x4

|Ninski

|2006 08 05

|Delete

|62

|

|

98

|Auto-Upturn

|Auzemandius

|Bolt

|2007 04 14

|Delete

|341

|

|

99

|The Illegal Waste

|TenPoundHammer

|Waxaposse

|2008 11 10

|Delete

|5

|

|

100

|Corey Price

|Parys

|BabyBritain32

|2006 December 10

|Delete

|52

|

|

bgcolor="#DDDDDD"

|101

|Aleksei Meng

|Axolotl Nr.733

|

|

|Delete, speedy, hoax

|

|

|

102

|David and the Giants

|TenPoundHammer

|GOLDRUSH

|2006 12 29

|Keep

|1

|

|

Notes

AfDs from October 1 2008 through February 18 2009

From: Wikipedia_talk:Articles_for_deletion#Abuse_of_AfD, editor: User_talk:74.137.108.115

From the October 1 2008 through February 18 2009 AfD logs, here are statistics for nominators with 35 or more nominations:

class="wikitable sortable"

! Nominator !! Nominations !! Keeps !! Deletes !! Keep % !! Delete %

Kww

| 36

| 4

| 27

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 11.11

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 75.00

Epbr123

| 36

| 2

| 31

| 5.56

| 86.11

VirtualSteve

| 36

| 11

| 15

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 30.56

|style="background-color:#FBB" | 41.67

The Rolling Camel

| 37

| 9

| 22

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 24.32

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 59.46

Fvw

| 37

| 5

| 30

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 13.51

| 81.08

Stifle/wizard

| 37

| 21

| 11

|style="background-color:#FAA" | 56.76

|style="background-color:#FAA" | 29.73

NurseryRhyme

| 38

| 10

| 23

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 26.32

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 60.53

Tnxman307

| 38

| 2

| 29

| 5.26

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 76.32

Roleplayer

| 39

| 1

| 32

| 2.56

| 82.05

Sandstein

| 39

| 3

| 28

| 7.69

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 71.79

Rtphokie

| 40

| 16

| 3

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 40.00

|style="background-color:#FAA" | 7.50

Flewis

| 40

| 10

| 22

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 25.00

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 55.00

Mattinbgn

| 41

| 5

| 30

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 12.20

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 73.17

Mr Senseless

| 41

| 6

| 27

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 14.63

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 65.85

Graymornings

| 46

| 10

| 30

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 21.74

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 65.22

Ros0709

| 46

| 12

| 30

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 26.09

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 65.22

Suntag

| 47

| 11

| 26

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 23.40

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 55.32

JohnCD

| 47

| 1

| 43

| 2.13

| 91.49

JaGa

| 49

| 8

| 33

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 16.33

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 67.35

Fabrictramp

| 50

| 3

| 42

| 6.00

| 84.00

McWomble

| 50

| 9

| 29

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 18.00

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 58.00

TheFarix

| 50

| 2

| 40

| 4.00

| 80.00

Paul75

| 51

| 2

| 34

| 3.92

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 66.67

MacGyverMagic

| 53

| 8

| 41

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 15.09

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 77.36

JBsupreme

| 53

| 18

| 18

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 33.96

|style="background-color:#FAA" | 33.96

WikiDan61

| 54

| 5

| 40

| 9.26

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 74.07

KurtRaschke

| 57

| 10

| 36

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 17.54

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 63.16

Oscarthecat

| 57

| 8

| 42

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 14.04

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 73.68

SchuminWeb

| 57

| 10

| 40

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 17.54

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 70.18

Roux

| 57

| 8

| 39

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 14.04

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 68.42

VasileGaburici (page does not exist)

| 59

| 11

| 32

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 18.64

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 54.24

Undead warrior

| 60

| 4

| 37

| 6.67

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 61.67

THF

| 61

| 20

| 28

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 32.79

|style="background-color:#FBB" | 45.90

Ecoleetage

| 62

| 2

| 47

| 3.23

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 75.81

JzG/help

| 63

| 30

| 25

|style="background-color:#FBB" | 47.62

|style="background-color:#FAA" | 39.68

Hello Control

| 64

| 4

| 48

| 6.25

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 75.00

Biruitorul

| 64

| 13

| 41

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 20.31

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 64.06

Michellecrisp

| 64

| 22

| 21

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 34.38

|style="background-color:#FAA" | 32.81

Mufka

| 66

| 11

| 39

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 16.67

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 59.09

Largoplazo

| 66

| 8

| 49

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 12.12

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 74.24

Ironholds

| 73

| 4

| 54

| 5.48

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 73.97

Gmatsuda

| 74

| 17

| 42

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 22.97

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 56.76

Collectonian

| 75

| 32

| 21

|style="background-color:#FBB" | 42.67

|style="background-color:#FAA" | 28.00

Timtrent

| 77

| 15

| 45

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 19.48

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 58.44

Carlossuarez46

| 85

| 15

| 57

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 17.65

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 67.06

RHaworth

| 90

| 12

| 70

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 13.33

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 77.78

Mr. Vernon

| 90

| 10

| 71

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 11.11

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 78.89

Girolamo Savonarola

| 91

| 16

| 61

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 17.58

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 67.03

Magioladitis

| 98

| 7

| 64

| 7.14

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 65.31

Richardcavell

| 114

| 7

| 93

| 6.14

| 81.58

Blanchardb

| 115

| 6

| 88

| 5.22

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 76.52

ScienceApologist

| 119

| 67

| 26

|style="background-color:#FAA" | 56.30

|style="background-color:#FAA" | 21.85

Bongomatic

| 128

| 32

| 65

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 25.00

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 50.78

Tavix

| 129

| 32

| 60

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 24.81

|style="background-color:#FBB" | 46.51

Mayalld

| 133

| 19

| 86

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 14.29

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 64.66

Schuym1

| 237

| 33

| 131

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 13.92

|style="background-color:#FCC" | 55.27

TenPoundHammer/Country

| 265

| 67

| 120

|style="background-color:#FDD" | 25.28

|style="background-color:#FBB" | 45.28

TTN

| 465

| 64

| 103

|style="background-color:#FEE" | 13.76

|style="background-color:#FAA" | 22.15

(These results were obtained by scraping AfD results using an automated script; there are most likely errors arising from this process, but I believe the general results are valid. Nominations not resulting in a "keep" or "delete" are included in the nominations count, but not the keep or delete counts. Please let me know of any discrepancies. – 74  01:04, 2 March 2009 (UTC))

(Table updated to reflect removal of a few bugs that mildly over-counted nominations and mildly under-counted keeps and deletes. Signatures with a link to user's talk page are now also included, leading to moderate to large changes for those editors. – 74  12:11, 2 March 2009 (UTC))

(Table updated to remove the influence of another bug: nominations with links to other users' pages were being mis-attributed to those users. This was discovered when JohnCD pointed out his AfD nomination stats were missing. Now the last valid user link in the nomination line is used (which may still fail for multi-line nominations and oddly-formed nominations). – 74  16:11, 2 March 2009 (UTC))

See also

;Stats

;User contributions

;Anecdotal evidence

  • Andrew Lih: [http://www.andrewlih.com/blog/2007/07/10/unwanted-new-articles-in-wikipedia/ Unwanted: New articles in Wikipedia]
  • Kelly Martin: [http://nonbovine-ruminations.blogspot.com/2007/07/pownce-and-wikipedia.html Pownce and Wikipedia]
  • Kelly Martin: [http://nonbovine-ruminations.blogspot.com/2007/07/what-do-lava-lamps-have-to-do-with.html What do lava lamps have to do with Wikipedia, anyway?]

;Other studies

External links

  • [http://math.about.com/library/weekly/aa020502a.htm Calculating mean mode median]
  • [http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/5/51/Time_Between_Edits_Graph_Jul05-Present.png Time Between Edits Graph July 05]