| class="wikitable sortable"
|+
! Year !! Building !! Address !! City !! State !! Notes !! Image !! Reference |
| 1845 | St. Paul Episcopal Church | 59 Court St | Dedham | Massachusetts | Destroyed by fire in 1856. | | [Roger G. Reed, Building Victorian Boston: The Architecture of Gridley J. F. Bryant (Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts Press, 2006)] |
| 1846 | Central Congregational Church | 804 Washington St | Bath | Maine | Nicknamed the "Chocolate Church" and now used as an arts center under that name. | 100px | |
| 1846 | St. James Episcopal Church | 120 Main St | Amesbury | Massachusetts | Destroyed by fire in 1899. | | [Journal of the Proceedings of the Fifty-sixth Annual Convention of the Diocese of Massachusetts (Boston: James B. Dow, 1846): 80-81.] |
| 1848 | "Fern Hill" for William P. Winchester | Coolidge Ave | Watertown | Massachusetts | The estate was acquired by adjacent Mount Auburn Cemetery in 1885, and the house was later demolished. | | |
| 1849 | St. Mary Episcopal Church | Bowdoin and Topliff St | Dorchester, Boston | Massachusetts | Destroyed by fire in 1887. The parish built a new church at a different site. | | [Journal of the Proceedings of the Fifty-ninth Annual Convention of the Diocese of Massachusetts (Boston: James B. Dow, 1849): 81.] |
| 1851 | "Wellesley" for H. H. Hunnewell | 845 Washington St | Wellesley | Massachusetts | The town was later named for the estate. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1988 as part of the Hunnewell Estates Historic District. | | [Keith N. Morgan, Buildings of Massachusetts: Metropolitan Boston (Charlottesville, VA: University of Virginia Press, 2009)] |
| 1854 | First Congregational Church of Saugus | 300 Central St | Saugus | Massachusetts | Still owned by the church, but used by the William Sutton Lodge of Masons. | | [History of Essex County, Massachusetts, ed. D. Hamilton Hurd, vol. 1 (Philadelphia: J. W. Lewis & Company, 1888)] |
| 1855 | Exeter Town Hall{{efn|name=Dwight|Credited to the partnership of Gilman & Dwight.}} | 10 Front St | Exeter | New Hampshire | Listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1973 as part of the Front Street Historic District. | 100px | |
| 1857 | Hotel Pelham | 351 Boylston St | Boston | Massachusetts | A young member of Gilman's firm, Alfred Stone, supervised construction.[Jean A. Follett, “The Hotel Pelham: A New Building Type for America,” American Art Journal 15, no. 4 (Autumn 1983): 58-73.] Demolished in 1915. | 100px | |
| 1857 | St. Paul Episcopal Church | 59 Court St | Dedham | Massachusetts | | | [History of Norfolk County, Massachusetts, ed. D. Hamilton Hurd (Philadelphia: J. W. Lewis & Company, 1884)] |
| 1858 | House for David Sears | 357 Kent St | Brookline | Massachusetts | Demolished. | | [James C. O'Connell, The Hub's Metropolis: Greater Boston's Development from Railroad Suburbs to Smart Growth (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 2013)] |
| 1858 | St. Andrew Episcopal Church | Hawthorne St | Chelsea | Massachusetts | From 1864 known as the St. Luke Episcopal Church. Burned in the Great Chelsea fire of 1908. | | |
| 1859 | Arlington Street Church, Unitarian | 80 Boylston St | Boston | Massachusetts | Demolished in 1915. | 100px | [Arlington Street Church NRHP Registration Form (1973)] |
| 1860 | Christ's Church | 70 Colchester St | Brookline | Massachusetts | Listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1978 as part of the Longwood Historic District. | | |
| 1864 | Newburyport Public Library | 94 State St | Newburyport | Massachusetts | The conversion of the 1771-built house of Nathaniel Tracy for library purposes. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1984 as part of the Newburyport Historic District. | 100px | ["[http://mhc-macris.net/Details.aspx?MhcId=NWB.365 NWB.365]", mhc-macris.net, Massachusetts Historical Commission, n.d.] |
| 1867 | Equitable Building{{efn|name=Kendall|Credited to the partnership of Gilman & Kendall.}} | 120 Broadway | New York | New York | Designed in association with consulting architect George B. Post. Burned in 1912. | 100px | [Sarah Bradford Landau and Carl W. Condit, Rise of the New York Skyscraper: 1865-1913 (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1996)] |
| 1867 | New York State Capitol{{efn|name=Kendall|Credited to the partnership of Gilman & Kendall.}} | State St | Albany | New York | Designed in association with architects Fuller & Laver. Kendall withdrew from the firm in 1868, and Gilman from the project in 1869. The building was not completed until 1899, with further contributions from architects Henry Hobson Richardson, Leopold Eidlitz and Isaac G. Perry. | 100px | [Andrea J. Lazarski, "Capitol Architects," Architects in Albany, ed. Diana S. Waite (Albany, NY: Mount Ida Press, 2009)] |
| 1868 | House for Benjamin E. Bates{{efn|name=Kendall}} | 9 E 40th St | New York | New York | Demolished. | | [Real Estate Record and Builders Guide 1, no. 15 (June 27 1868): 2.] |
| 1869 | Christ Chapel,
Trinity Episcopal Church | 371 Delaware Ave | Buffalo | New York | Intended as the first part of a church complex designed by Gilman for Christ Episcopal Church. Christ merged with Trinity in 1884, and the church was eventually built to designs by Cyrus Kinne Porter in 1884-86. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2008. | 100px | [Trinity Episcopal Church NRHP Registration Form (2008)] |
| 1869 | House for Eliza M. Gregory | 288 Madison Ave | New York | New York | Demolished. | | [Real Estate Record and Builders Guide 3, no. 68 (July 3 1869): 10.] |
| 1869 | St. John Episcopal Church | 1333 Bay St | Staten Island | New York | | | [New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, St. John's Church Designation Report (1974)] |
| 1870 | Houses for Sidney W. Hopkins | 13-17 E 57th St | New York | New York | Demolished. | | [Real Estate Record and Builders Guide 5, no. 124 (July 30 1870): 6.] |
| 1872 | Bennett Building | 139 Fulton St | New York | New York | | 100px | [New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission, Bennett Building Designation Report (1995)] |
| 1872 | Drexel Building | 23 Wall St | New York | New York | Demolished in 1913. | 100px | ["The Drexel Building," Harper's Weekly 17, no. 859 (June 14 1873): 509-510.] |
| 1873 | Butler Exchange | 111 Westminster St | Providence | Rhode Island | Demolished in 1925. | 100px | [William McKenzie Woodward and Edward F. Sanderson, Providence: A Citywide Survey of Historic Resources, ed. David Chase (Providence, RI: Rhode Island Historical Preservation Commission, 1986)] |
| 1874 | Equitable Building | 67 Milk St | Boston | Massachusetts | Demolished in 1922. | 100px | ["The New York Equitable Life Insurance Company's Building," Architectural Sketch-book 2, no. 3 (September 1874): n. p.] |
| 1877 | "The Paddocks" for DeLancey Astor Kane | 280 Davenport Ave | New Rochelle | New York | Later used as the Colony Club. Demolished during the 1980s. | 100px | ["Residence of De Lancey Kane, Esq., New Rochelle, Westchester Co., N. Y.," American Architect and Building News 3, no. 109 (January 26 1878): 31.] |
| 1877 | Westmoreland Hotel | 44 Union Sq E | New York | New York | Demolished in 1928. | | [Superior Court of the City of New York. General Term. De Witt C. Weeks and Francis Marion Weeks, Plaintiffs and Respondents, Against William McCarty Little, Individually, and as Executor, Etc. of Augusta M. Little, Deceased (and Others), Defendants and Appellants. Case on Appeal (New York: M. B. Brown, 1880)] |
| 1880 | Grace Chapel | 91 Harbor St | Branford | Connecticut | Demolished in 1925. | | ["Connecticut," Churchman 42, no. 14 (October 2 1880): 371.] |
| 1880 | House for George W. Quintard | 922 Fifth Ave | New York | New York | Demolished in 1949. | | [Real Estate Record and Builders Guide 26, no. 645 (July 24 1880): 679.] |
