User:Nightshift23/Enter your new article name here

{{Userspace draft|source=ArticleWizard|date=August 2010}}

Awards in the Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot

{{For|the general information on the Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot|Willem C. Vis Moot}}

:Image:Ship2.png

Four Awards are annually given in Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot: The Pieter Sanders Award, the Werner Melis Award, the Martin Domke Award and the Frédéric Eisemann Award, the latter being awarded to the best prevailing team in the oral rounds (the "Winner of the Moot").[http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/moot/rules17.pdf Rules of the Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot]

Pieter Sanders Award for the Best Memorandum for Claimant

The Pieter Sanders Award is given for the Best Memorandum on behalf of the Claimant. During the first three Moots, the Pieter Sanders Award was given for the Best Written Memoranda in support of the positions of Claimant and Respondent. (Subsequently, the Werner Melis Award was introduced as a separate award for the memorandum in support of the Respondent.)

The Award has been named after Professor Pieter Sanders (*1913), who is widely regarded as the "father" of modern international commercial arbitration.See B.E. Shipman, "Professor Pieter Sanders", International Law FORUM du droit international (2000), 41-44 He was one of the principal drafters of both the 1958 United Nations Convention on Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Award (the "New York Convention") and the 1976 UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules. Professor Sanders was also founder of the Law Faculty of Erasmus University Rotterdam (where he taught up to his retirement in 1981) and co-founder of the International Council for Commercial Arbitration (ICCA) and the Netherlands Arbitration Institute.

In the Second Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot, held in Vienna in 1995, he served as one of the three arbitrators in the Finals.

class="wikitable" style="text-align:center;margin-left:1em;float:center"
bgcolor="#cccccc"

!Moot

!Year

!Winner of the Pieter Sanders Award

1st

|1994

|Albert Ludwigs University of Freiburg

2nd

|1995

|University of Basel

3rd

|1996

|University of Cologne

4th

|1997

|University of Copenhagen

5th

|1998

|University of Münster

6th

|1999

|University of Basel

7th

|2000

|Ruprecht Karls University of Heidelberg

8th

|2001

|Albert Ludwigs University of Freiburg

9th

|2002

|University of Queensland

10th

|2003

|University of Bonn

11th

|2004

|tie: Ruprecht Karls University of Heidelberg; University of Zurich

12th

|2005

|University of Copenhagen

13th

|2006

|tie: Columbia University; University of Munich

14th

|2007

|Albert Ludwigs University of Freiburg

15th

|2008

|University of California, Berkeley

16th

|2009

|University of Sydney

17th

|2010

|University of New South Wales

Werner Melis Award for the Best Memorandum for Respondent

The Werner Melis Award is given for the Best Written Memorandum for Respondent. Unlike the three other awards in the Competition, this award did not exist during the first three Moots (1994-1996), but was only introduced in 1997. (During the first three Moots, the Pieter Sanders Award was given for the Best Written Memoranda in support of the positions of Claimant and Respondent.)

The Award has been named after DDr. Werner Melis (* 1935), President of the International Arbitral Centre of the Austrian Federal Economic Chamber (Vienna), Honorary Vice-President of International Council for Commercial Arbitration (ICCA) and a long-time supporter of the Vis Arbitration Moot.

The award is traditionally presented by Dr. Melis himself during the awards banquet concluding each Vienna Arbitration Moot.

class="wikitable" style="text-align:center;margin-left:1em;float:center"
bgcolor="#cccccc"

!Moot

!Year

!Winner of the Werner Melis Award

1st

|1994

| -

2nd

|1995

| -

3rd

|1996

| -

4th

|1997

|Deakin University

5th

|1998

|University of Münster

6th

|1999

|University of Basel

7th

|2000

|Ruprecht Karls University of Heidelberg

8th

|2001

|University of Zagreb

9th

|2002

|University of Mainz

10th

|2003

|University of Cologne

11th

|2004

|National University of Singapore

12th

|2005

|Humboldt University of Berlin

13th

|2006

|University of Munich

14th

|2007

|Albert Ludwigs University of Freiburg

15th

|2008

|University of Heidelberg

|16th

|2009

|Stockholm University

|17th

|2010

|University of New South Wales

Martin Domke Award for the Best Individual Oralist during the General Rounds

The Martin Domke Award is awarded to the Best Individual Oralist during the general rounds. This award for the general rounds of the Competition (i.e. the four oral hearings of each team on Saturday through Tuesday) will be won by the individual advocate with the highest average score during these rounds. To be eligible for this award a participant must have argued at least once for the Claimant and once for the Respondent.

The Award has been named after Martin Domke (1892-1980), Adjunct Professor of Law at New York University and a well-known scholar of international arbitration. Professor Domke was Vice President of the American Arbitration Association for 25 years and served as editor in chief of the Arbitration Journal. He also was the author of "Commercial Arbitration," published in 1965, and "The Law and Practice of Commercial Arbitration," published in 1968.

class="wikitable" style="text-align:center;margin-left:1em;float:center"
bgcolor="#cccccc"

!Moot

!Year

!Winner of the Martin Domke Award

1st

|1994

|Gregor Kirchhof, Albert Ludwigs University of Freiburg

2nd

|1995

|Chantal Niggemann, Albert Ludwigs University of Freiburg

3rd

|1996

|Kay-Jannes Wegner, University of Cologne

4th

|1997

|Camilla Andersen, University of Copenhagen

5th

|1998

|Biljana Dischlieva, Christian Albrechts University of Kiel

6th

|1999

|Carmen Klein, University of Cologne

7th

|2000

|Jan Stemplewitz, University of Münster

8th

|2001

|Trevor Stockinger, Loyola Law School of Los Angeles

9th

|2002

|tie: Marion Alice Jane Isobel, University of Queensland; Robina Kaye, University of Montpellier

10th

|2003

|tie: Andrew Molnar, Deakin University; Simun Soljo, University of New South Wales

11th

|2004

|Alexey Konovalov, Mari State University

12th

|2005

|tie: Charmaine Roberts, University of New South Wales; Anna-Maria Tamminen, University of Vienna

13th

|2006

|Sonu Dhanju, Osgoode Hall Law School

14th

|2007

|Steven Wayne Hopkins, Southern Methodist University

15th

|2008

|Lennart Beckhaus, University of Münster

16th

|2009

|Oliver Jones, The Honorable Society of Lincoln's Inn

17th

|2010

|Antonia Füller, Albert Ludwigs University of Freiburg

Frédéric Eisemann Award for the Best Team Orals (Winner of the Moot)

The winner of the oral rounds at Vienna is awarded the Frédéric Eisemann Award for the best prevailing team in the oral rounds. It is the most prestigious award in the Competition (designating the "Winner of the Moot").

The Award has been named after Frédéric Eisemann (1908- ), the highly respected former Secretary General of the International Court of Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce (1947-1973).

class="wikitable" style="text-align:center;margin-left:1em;float:center"
bgcolor="#cccccc"

!Moot

!Year

!Winner of the Frédéric Eisemann Award

1st

|1994

|Columbia University

2nd

|1995

|Albert Ludwigs University of Freiburg

3rd

|1996

|Cornell University

4th

|1997

|University of Queensland

5th

|1998

|University of Münster

6th

|1999

|Deakin University

7th

|2000

|University of Queensland

8th

|2001

|Monash University

9th

|2002

|National University of Singapore

10th

|2003

|National University of Juridical Sciences, Kolkata

11th

|2004

|Osgoode Hall Law School

12th

|2005

|Stetson University

13th

|2006

|Queen Mary, University of London

14th

|2007

|Albert Ludwigs University of Freiburg

15th

|2008

|Carlos III University of Madrid

16th

|2009

|Victoria University of Wellington

17th

|2010

|King's College London

Award-Winning Teams (1994-2010)

In the 17 years the Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot has been conducted, a total of 70 awards have been given:

  • 19 Pieter Sanders Awards (in 2004 and 2006 there was a tie, so two awards were given in those years),
  • 14 Werner Melis Awards (since this award did not exist until the 4th Moot in 1997),
  • 20 Martin Domke Awards (three ties, in 2002, 2003 and 2005) and
  • 17 Frederic Eisemann Awards.[http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/cisg/moot/mootlist.html List of Past Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moots]

Out of the approximately 270 universities that have sent teams to the Vis Moot in the past, only 36 have ever received an award (or more).

The List of Award-Winning Teams shown in the table below only covers the actual awards, not second and third places or honorable mentions. It counts all awards given since the inaugural Vis Moot held in 1994 up to the 17th Vis Moot (2010).

The Rank is based on the overall number of awards collected by the teams representing each university over the years. It not only includes the Sanders Awards, the Melis Awards and the Eisemann Awards, but also the Domke Awards, although the latter award is technically given to an individual member of the team, not the team as a whole. Whenever two (or more) teams have collected the same number of awards, a team which has received an Eisemann Award is ranked higher than the teams which have not (since the Eisemann Award designates the Winner of the Moot). Furthermore, teams which have received a team award (Sanders and Melis Awards) are ranked higher than those teams which have not (i.e. where a team member has received a Domke Award).

class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align:center;margin-left:1em;float:center"
bgcolor="#cccccc"
RankTeamCountrySandersMelisDomkeEisemann (Moot Winner)Award TotalParticipations
1Albert Ludwigs University of FreiburgGermany31329
5University of CologneGermany11204
8University of BaselSwitzerland21003
22University of BonnGermany10001
9University of CopenhagenDenmark20103
2University of MünsterGermany11215
4Ruprecht Karls University of HeidelbergGermany22004
22University of ZurichSwitzerland10001
3University of QueenslandAustralia10124
10Columbia UniversityUnited States10012
13University of MunichGermany11002
22University of California, BerkeleyUnited States10001
22University of SydneyAustralia10001
5University of New South WalesAustralia11204
7Deakin UniversityAustralia01113
22University of ZagrebCroatia01001
22University of MainzGermany01001
10National University of SingaporeSingapore01012
22Humboldt University of BerlinGermany01001
22Stockholm UniversitySweden01001
30Christian Albrechts University of KielGermany00101
30Loyola Law School Los AngelesUnited States00101
30University of MontpellierFrance00101
30Mari State UniversityRussia00101
30University of ViennaAustria00101
12Osgoode Hall Law SchoolCanada00112
30Southern Methodist UniversityUnited States00101
30The Honorable Society of Lincoln's InnUnited Kingdom00101
14Cornell UniversityUnited States00011
14Monash UniversityAustralia00011
14National University of Juridical Sciences, KolkataIndia00011
14Stetson UniversityUnited States00011|
14Queen Mary, University of LondonUnited Kingdom00011
14Carlos III University of MadridSpain00011
14|Victoria University of WellingtonNew Zealand00011
14King's College LondonUnited Kingdom00011

See also

  • Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot
  • [http://www.cisg.law.pace.edu/vis.html Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot, Vienna Official Website]
  • [http://www.maa.net Moot Alumni Association] (MAA), the Alumni Association of the Willem C. Vis International Commercial Arbitration Moot

References

{{Reflist}}