User:S Marshall/RfC close log

{{User:S Marshall/RfC close log/Index}}

201. On the EWG's position about PFAS regulation, 2 November 2023
202. About Belarus' role in the Russian invasion of Ukraine, 5 November 2023
203. What to do about Makiivka urban hromada, 2 December 2023
204. Who, exactly, are the Kurds?, 17 December 2023
205. A summary close, 17 December 2023
206. On Islamist terrorist attacks, 22 December 2023
207. Canadian, Québécois, or both?, 5 January 2024
208. Is the Daily Telegraph a reliable source?, 8 January 2024
209. Does Fred Sullivan need an infobox?, 12 January 2024
210. Concerning CSD G5, 12 January 2024
211. Regarding the Hamas attacks on Israel of 7th October 2023, 14 January 2024
212. On the scope of the Battle of Bakhmut, 23 January 2024
213. Of Donald Trump's presidential election campaign and the Colorado ruling, 25 January 2024
214. Of Donald Trump and the Abraham Accords, 9 February 2024
215. Race and Intelligence and Quillette, 10 February 2024
216. Whether to name the victims of the 2023 Lewiston shootings, 17 February 2024
217. On the reliability of Electronic Intifada, 27 February 2024
218. Who won the Battle of Bakhmut?, 8 March 2024
219. Of rape and rape-adjacent acts by Hamas terrorists on 7 October 2023, 9 March 2024
220. Of genocide in the Hamas-Israel war, 10 March 2024
221. The sexist remarks of Tim Hunt, 13 March 2024
222. Concerning white people who're Black Irish, 24 March 2024
223. Regarding Hunter Biden's emails, 9 June 2024
224. On SpaceX Starship test flights, 9 June 2024
225. Of the Russian Civil War, 14 June 2024
226. Normanism, Anti-Normanism, or both?, 26 June 2024
227. Trans issues and the Daily Telegraph, 7 July 2024, and this one was a right bugger's muddle. My close was challenged and a sysop, Seraphimblade, decided to revert it, claiming it was a BADNAC. This revert got reviewed at WP:AAR and was unanimously overturned here. Then Compassionate727 closed the close review as "overturn". That close was reverted by Hemiauchenia. Hemiauchenia's revert was counter-reverted by Extraordinary Writ, and then re-reverted by Serial Number 54129. After this Compassionate727 rescinded their close. Then, Procrastinating reader re-closed the close review as overturned to no particular result, and for two months nobody was willing to touch it, until Sandstein re-closed the original discussion as "no consensus" (which is what I wrote in the first place). Editors then changed the RSP listing to "no consensus", which is what I said it should be, so my close was fully reinstated with slightly different wording and other people's signatures.
228. Now I know my ABC, 1 August 2024
229. Herman Göring's Lede Image, 28 August 2024
230. On the Gaza genocide, 3 September 2024
231. Concerning Kamala Harris' ethnicity, 26 September 2024
232. The Names of Twitter, 30 September 2024
233. Whether to split WP:RSN, 2 October 2024
234. About notional election results, 13 October 2024
235. In the Russian invasion of Ukraine, is North Korea a belligerent?, 15 December 2024
236. On Donald Trump's age and health, 8 January 2025
237. What to say about a neo-Nazi's assault on a security guard, 19 January 2025
238. On Israel and the Gaza genocide, 19 January 2025
239. On Donald Trump's felony conviction, 26 January 2025
240. Of Hamas and recognition of Israel, 4 February 2025
241. Return of the names of Twitter, 5 February 2025
242. Regarding diaphonemic transcriptions, 17 February 2025
243. Should AI-generated images be banned on Wikipedia?, 14 April 2025
244. On self-published sources, 17 April 2025
245. Initials and acronyms, 18 April 2025
246. Is RFK Jr. an anti-vaccine activist and conspiracy theorist?, 27 April 2025