What We Did
{{Use mdy dates|date=May 2025}}
{{Infobox album
| name = What We Did
| type = studio
| artist = M. Gira and D. Matz
| cover = M Gira -D Matz What We Did.jpg
| alt =
| released = {{Start date|2001|11|13}}
| recorded =
| venue =
| studio =
| genre =
| length = {{Duration|m=48|s=19}}
| label = Young God
| producer = {{flatlist|
- Michael Gira
- Dan Matz
}}
| chronology = Michael Gira
| prev_title = Somniloquist
| prev_year = 2000
| next_title = Solo Recordings at Home
| next_year = 2001
| misc = {{Extra chronology
| artist = Dan Matz
| type = studio
| prev_title =
| prev_year =
| title = What We Did
| year = 2001
| next_title = Blank Ages
| next_year = 2011
}}
}}
What We Did is a collaborative studio album by Swans frontman Michael Gira and Windsor for the Derby member Dan Matz. It was released on November 13, 2001 through Gira's Young God Records label.
Musical style
What We Did has a considerably more pop-oriented and accessible sound, compared to Gira's other solo works. The majority of the lyrics on the album were written by Matz.
Critical reception
{{Music ratings
|rev1 = Allmusic
|rev1score = {{rating|4|5}}{{cite web | url=http://www.allmusic.com/album/what-we-did-mw0000594292 | title=Michael Gira - What We Did | publisher=Allmusic | accessdate=July 27, 2015 | author=Jurek, Thom}}
|rev2 = Pitchfork
|rev2score = 8.4/10{{cite web | url=http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/3455-what-we-did/ | title=M. Gira / D. Matz - What We Did | publisher=Pitchfork | date=December 4, 2001 | accessdate=July 28, 2015 | author=Carr, Daphne}}
}}
Allmusic critic Thom Jurek described the album as "a finely wrought album of relayed styles and layered textures enfolding one another into a music that could have only been made by these two men, with a small host of guests who appear intermittently," and further stated: "The songs here are all questions that are more pronounced after their seeming narratives have entered back into the silence from whence they came." Daphne Carr of Pitchfork wrote: "The rewards of this record aren't reaped through immediate digestibility, but through repeated suggestion. Still, this is by far the most palatable of Gira's growing mass of output and an indication of continued innovation in collaborating with those whose moods, ideas, and melodies augment his own dark brilliance." Philip Sherburne of Wondering Sound described it as "one of the quietest albums in Michael Gira’s catalog."{{cite web | url=http://www.wonderingsound.com/review/m-gira-d-matz-what-we-did/ | title=M. Gira / D. Matz, What We Did | publisher=Wondering Sound | date=November 27, 2011 | accessdate=May 10, 2020 | author=Sherburne, Philip |archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20160304093333/http://www.wonderingsound.com/review/m-gira-d-matz-what-we-did/ |archivedate=March 4, 2016}}
Track listing
{{Track listing
| collapsed =
| headline =
| extra_column =
| total_length = 48:19
| all_writing = Michael Gira and Dan Matz except where noted
| all_lyrics =
| all_music =
| title1 = Pacing the Locks
| note1 =
| writer1 =
| lyrics1 =
| music1 =
| extra1 =
| length1 = 4:41
| title2 = Is/Was
| note2 =
| writer2 =
| lyrics2 =
| music2 =
| extra2 =
| length2 = 7:19
| title3 = Cold Creeping
| note3 =
| writer3 =
| lyrics3 =
| music3 =
| extra3 =
| length3 = 3:55
| title4 = Lines
| note4 =
| writer4 =
| lyrics4 =
| music4 =
| extra4 =
| length4 = 3:47
| title5 = Brown Eyes
| note5 =
| writer5 =
| lyrics5 =
| music5 =
| extra5 =
| length5 = 2:01
| title6 = 17 Hours
| note6 =
| writer6 = {{flatlist|
- Tamer Eid
- Gira
- Matz
- Luke Michel
- Todd Watts
- Erik Wenberg
}}
| lyrics6 =
| music6 =
| extra6 =
| length6 = 6:19
| title7 = Stitches
| note7 =
| writer7 =
| lyrics7 =
| music7 =
| extra7 =
| length7 = 5:16
| title8 = Waiting Beside Viragio
| note8 =
| writer8 =
| lyrics8 =
| music8 =
| extra8 =
| length8 = 2:16
| title9 = Forcing Mary
| note9 =
| writer9 =
| lyrics9 =
| music9 =
| extra9 =
| length9 = 3:06
| title10 = Quiet One
| note10 =
| writer10 =
| lyrics10 =
| music10 =
| extra10 =
| length10 = 3:25
| title11 = Sunflower
| note11 =
| writer11 = {{flatlist|
- Matz
- Mack David
- Gira
- Neil Diamond
}}
| lyrics11 =
| music11 =
| extra11 =
| length11 = 3:20
| title12 = The Brightest Star
| note12 =
| writer12 =
| lyrics12 =
| music12 =
| extra12 =
| length12 = 3:37
}}
Personnel
- Michael Gira – vocals, performance, production
- Dan Matz – vocals, performance, production
- Anna Neighbor – backing vocals (4, 5, 12)
- James Plotkin – guitar, vocals (1, 2)
References
{{Reflist}}
External links
- {{Discogs release|722709|type=album}}
{{Michael Gira}}
{{Authority control}}
Category:2001 collaborative albums