Wikipedia:Mapframe maps in infoboxes
{{infobox|above=Mapframe maps in infoboxes|image1={{Infobox mapframe|id=Q100|zoom=9|point=none}}|caption1=Example of a mapframe map in an infobox}}
This project page tracks the deployment of mapframe maps to infobox templates. The Infobox mapframe module assists in producing maps with limited or no additional inputs needed when an infobox is used in an article.
Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Mapframe maps in infoboxes was held in mid-2020. See the RFC for complete details, but a summary of the closes is:
- Mapframe mapping capability, and standard parameters for displaying mapframe maps (i.e. use of Module:Infobox mapframe), should be added to infoboxes
- No consensus for mapframe maps to be on by default
- Map placement should be determined by local consensus at each infobox
- If users do not specify coordinates in a parameter, coordinates from Wikidata should be used
- Switcher functionality should not be enabled by default
There are various ways in which individual infobox templates can customise how mapframe maps are used, including:
- Either on or off by default (with a parameter like {{para|mapframe}} {{tt|no}} or {{tt|yes}} to override the default)
- Default symbol, colour, zoom
- Using or not using Wikidata coordinates (when local values for coordinates are not provided)
- Showing a default geomask like {{Q|P17}} or {{Q|P131}}, if such values are present on the page's Wikidata item
For instructions on how to add to infoboxes, see Module:Infobox mapframe#Automatic maps in infoboxes. See also Template:Infobox mapframe#Examples.
Process
- Check the chosen infobox template for potential, such as:
- * presence of other map parameters
- * how often the infobox already has infobox mapframe transcluded manually, such as with a search engine query with
hastemplate:
and similar search terms, [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?go=Go&search=hastemplate%3A%22Infobox+military+installation%22+hastemplate%3A%22Infobox+mapframe%22&title=Special%3ASearch&ns0=1 like this] or [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?search=hastemplate%3A%22Infobox+military+installation%22+insource%3A%2F%5C%7B%5C%7Binfobox+mapframe%2F&title=Special%3ASearch&profile=advanced&fulltext=1&ns0=1 like this] - Examine the infobox talk page for any signs of map-related controversy
- If the latter check brings up anything, propose any changes first, and notify relevant wikiprojects
- Discuss any implementation nuances with infobox users/maintainers
- * Positioning inside the template
- * Whether to render wikidata coordinates / shapes by default
- * If there are multiple coordinates parameters, the choice of which one is rendered by mapframe
- * Matching widths of maps and images
- * Marker icon
- * Mapping of length/area parameters
- Update the template sandbox, per normal template editing
- Update the template test cases to make sure mapframe rendering is tested, esp. if defaults are changed
- Check for manual transclusions which don't use an identifiable map parameter, but rather some free-form parameter, which in turn may have to be fixed manually (to avoid mapframe duplication)
- * If they exist and you can't attend to them all immediately, disable the mapframe by default on them with something like this in an onByDefault check:
:::
- Update the live template
- Update the documentation
- Update the tracking table below
- Update any manual invocations of infobox mapframe to new syntax
- Check :Category:Pages with script errors for any fresh errors related to the change. Typical issues include:
- * coordinates present but not formatted with {{tl|coord}} - make sure template specifies it as such and fix broken call sites
- * broken coordinates parameters
Tracking
Column descriptions:
;Mapframe maps
:"{{tick}}" if the infobox can show mapframe maps (without users filling out a complete {{Tl|maplink}} template or {{Tag|mapframe|o}} tag)
:"{{Tick|color=blue}} Standard" if the infobox uses {{Code|{{((}}#invoke:Infobox mapframe{{!}}auto{{))}}}} for standard parameters, per Q1 of the RFC
;Documentation
:"{{tick}}" If the documentation has been updated
:"{{Tick|color=blue}} Standard" if the documentation uses {{Tl|Infobox mapframe/doc/parameters}}
:"{{Partly done}}" if there is incomplete documentation
{{Incomplete list}}
class="wikitable sortable"
! Template:Infobox ! Mapframe ! Documentation !! Notes ! Expected marker | ||||
aerial lift line | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} aerialway | |
airport | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} airport | |
Albanian settlement | {{tick}} town or city | |||
amusement park | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} amusement park | |
ancient site | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{cross}} ancient site/ruin, indigenous settlement | |
artwork | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | Can not be turned on if pushpin map is specified. Coding could be simplified (the {{tl|yesno}} isn't needed). | {{cross}} ? |
artwork/wikidata | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Cross}} ? | |
Australian electorate | Probably not too useful unless geoJSON maps of the boundaries are made/uploaded. | {{tick}} N/A | ||
Australian place | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | Under discussion re possible conversion to wrapper of Infobox settlement (October 2020). | {{tick}} town or city |
Australian road | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | Mapframe documentation collapsed, as per the rest of the doc | {{tick}} N/A |
Belgium municipality | Wrapper for Infobox settlement | {{tick}} town or city | ||
bell | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{cross}} bell | |
Berg | Wrapper for Infobox mountain | {{tick}} mountain | ||
body of water | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{cross}} lake | |
brewery | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | {{tick}} beer | |
bridge | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | {{tick}} bridge | |
building | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | {{tick}} building, building-alt1 | |
Burg | Wrapper for Infobox military installation | {{cross}} military base, fort or {{tick}} airfield, castle | ||
business park | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} commercial | |
campground | {{tick}} campsite | |||
Cape Verde settlement | Wrapper for Infobox settlement | {{tick}} town or city | ||
casino | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} casino | |
castrum | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{cross}} military base, fort | |
cave | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{cross}} cave | |
cemetery | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} cemetery | |
church | {{tick}} religious-christian | |||
civil conflict | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | {{cross}} ? | |
civilian attack | {{cross}} ? | |||
climbing area | {{cross}} ? | |||
climbing route | {{cross}} ? | |||
concentration camp | {{tick}} prison? or {{cross}} military base? | |||
convention center | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{cross}} ? | |
country | {{tick}} N/A | |||
crater | {{cross}} crater | |||
cycling championship | {{cross}} ? | |||
dam | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} dam | |
desalination plant | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | {{cross}} ? | |
diplomatic mission | {{tick}} | {{tick}} embassy | ||
distillery | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{cross}} distillery | |
ecoregion | {{tick}} N/A | |||
Egyptian tomb | {{cross}} tomb or mausoleum | |||
exchange | {{cross}} ? | |||
factory | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} industrial | |
farm | {{tick}} | Parameters standard, needs caption standardized | {{tick}} farm | |
Fluss | {{tick}} N/A | |||
forest | {{cross}} forest | |||
former subdivision | {{tick}} N/A | |||
frazione | {{tick}} town or city | |||
French commune | {{cross}} town or city | |||
Gebirgsgruppe | {{tick}} N/A | |||
German place | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | {{tick}} town or city | |
glacier | {{cross}} ? | |||
golf facility | {{tick}} golf | |||
government agency | {{cross}} government building | |||
Greece place | {{tick}} town or city | |||
heritage railway | {{tick}} rail or N/A | |||
Hindu temple | Partial wrapper around {{tl|Infobox religious building}} | {{cross}} religious-hindu, {{tick}} place-of-worship | ||
historic site | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{yellow tick}} [multiple options, some missing] | |
Holocaust event | {{?}} | |||
hospital | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} hospital, doctor, dentist | |
housing project | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{cross}} ? | |
Hungarian georegion | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | ||
hut | {{Cross}} hut | |||
institute | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{cross}} ? | |
islands | {{tick}} N/A | |||
Israel village | {{tick}} town or city | |||
Italian comune | {{tick}} | Always displayed collapsed if available | {{tick}} town or city | |
kommune | {{tick}} town or city | |||
landform | {{tick}} [multiple] | |||
language | {{tick}} N/A | |||
LDS Temple | {{tick}} place-of-worship | |||
library | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | {{tick}} library | |
lighthouse | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | {{tick}} lighthouse | |
London station | {{tick}} rail, bus, or {{cross}} transit station | |||
military conflict | {{cross}} military conflict/battle | |||
military installation | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | Default zoom not helped by free-form site_area | {{tick}} castle or {{Cross}} military base/fort |
military memorial | {{tick}} monument | |||
military operation | {{cross}} military conflict/battle | |||
mill building | {{Cross}} ? | |||
mine | {{Cross}} cave? | |||
mining | {{Cross}} cave? | |||
MMA training association | {{Cross}} ? | |||
monastery | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} multiple | |
monument | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} monument | |
motorway services | {{tick}} fuel | |||
mountain | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} mountain, volcano | |
mountain pass | {{cross}} ? | |||
museum | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | {{tick}} museum | |
New York City Subway station | {{tick}} rail or {{cross}} transit station | |||
NRHP | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{yellow tick}} [multiple options, some missing] | |
nuclear weapons test | {{tick}} | {{cross}} ? | ||
observatory | {{cross}} observatory | |||
oil field | {{tick}} oil-well | |||
oil refinery | {{tick}} oil-well or industrial | |||
oil spill | {{tick}} | {{cross}} ? | ||
park | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} park | |
Pennsylvania historic site | {{yellow tick}} [multiple options, some missing] | |||
pier | {{tick}} harbor? | |||
pipeline | {{tick}} N/A | |||
port | {{tick}} | does not use #invoke: / auto | {{tick}} harbor | |
port-of-entry | {{tick}} | {{tick}} entrance? | ||
Portuguese subdivision | {{tick}} town or city | |||
power station | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | {{tick}} power station, solar farm | |
power transmission line | {{tick}} N/A | |||
prison | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | Uses
| {{tick}} prison |
protected area | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{yellow tick}} [multiple options, some missing] | |
public transit accident | {{tick}} | {{Partly done}} | Parameters listed in TemplateData but not properly documented | {{cross}} ? |
pyramid | {{cross}} pyramid | |||
racecourse | {{tick}} racetrack, racetrack-boat, racetrack-cycling, racetrack-horse | |||
railway depot | {{tick}} | {{Partly done}} | Parameters listed but not properly documented | {{tick}} rail? |
reactor | {{Cross}} nuclear power plant | |||
retail market | {{tick}} | {{Cross}} marketplace/food hall | ||
religious building | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{yellow tick}} [multiple options, some missing] | |
residential college | {{cross}} ? | |||
restaurant | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} restaurant | |
river | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} water | |
road junction | {{tick}} | {{cross}} ? | ||
Russian district | {{tick}} N/A | |||
Russian federal subject | {{tick}} city or N/A | |||
Russian inhabited locality | {{cross}} | {{cross}} | Wrapper for Infobox settlement | {{tick}} town or city |
school | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} school | |
school district | {{tick}} school or N/A | |||
Scottish island | {{tick}} N/A | |||
settlement | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | 2020 RFC | {{tick}} town, city, or {{cross}} indigenous settlement |
shopping mall | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} shopping mall | |
Site of Special Scientific Interest | {{yellow tick}} [multiple options, some missing] | |||
ski area | {{tick}} skiing | |||
ski jumping hill | {{tick}} skiing | |||
Spanish missions in the Americas | {{tick}} religious-christian | |||
sport supporter group | {{cross}} ? | |||
sports rivalry | {{Cross}} ? | |||
spring | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{cross}} ? | |
station | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} rail, bus, or {{cross}} transit station | |
street | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | no obvious marker icon available | {{tick}} N/A |
swimming pool | {{tick}} swimming | |||
Switzerland municipality | {{tick}} | Always displayed collapsed if available | {{tick}} [multiple] | |
television station | |{{tick}} communications-tower | |||
terrestrial impact site | {{Cross}} ? | |||
Tibetan Buddhist monastery | {{tick}} place-of-worship | |||
transmitter | {{tick}} communications-tower | |||
tunnel | {{tick}} tunnel | |||
Turkey place | {{cross}} ? | |||
U.S. county | {{tick}} N/A | |||
UK country | {{tick}} N/A | |||
UK place | {{tick}} town or city | |||
university | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | has a temporary onByDefault check for embedded mapframes | {{tick}} college |
UNESCO World Heritage Site | {{tick}} [multiple] | |||
urban feature | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | type landmark too wide? | {{tick}} [multiple] |
valley | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{cross}} natural? | |
venue | {{yellow tick}} [multiple options, some missing] | |||
volcanic hotspot | {{cross}} ? | |||
waterfall | {{tick}} waterfall | |||
waterlock | {{tick}} dam? | |||
wildfire | {{cross}} fire | |||
windmill | {{tick}} | {{tick}} | {{tick}} windmill | |
winery | {{cross}} winery | |||
zoo | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{Tick|color=blue}} Standard | {{tick}} zoo, aquarium, or {{Cross}} aviary |