Login
Login

Wikipedia:Mediation Cabal/Cases/2008-06-16 Unidentified flying object/Proposals

This page is for proposals related to Case: 2008-06-16 Unidentified flying object. User should:

  • Add their proposed wording to one of the sections, replacing {{tlx|lorem}} with their proposal.
  • Not sign their section with the standard ~~~~
  • Not comment on other sections, this will be done at the discussion page
  • Not change the wording of proposals, they should add a new proposal with the changed wording

Proposal I

(original version)

:Taken from Talk:UFO#Proposal for Revising UFO article and has been severely outspoken, listed here for NPOV reasons

style="background:#d9d9d9"
I. Introduction.

Tell what UFO is and what its about.

II. History of UFO

(Blue Book, Grudge, the Hills other history)

A. UFO History before 1800AD

B. UFO History 1800-1900 AD

1. Era of the mysterious Airships.

2. Aurora "Incident"

C. UFO History 1900-2000

III. Theories on what UFO are.

A. The Pro-UFO side

B. The Skeptics Side

C. Any other theories and ideals on what UFO may or may not be.

D. Other Views on UFO

E. The Religion Angle on UFO

F. NASA Government Law Enforcement view on UFO

IV. Sightings

A. Famous Sightings

B. Citizens Sightings

C. Astronomer, NASA, Government, Law Enforcement sighting

D. Trucker, Ship Crew, Etc Sightings.

E. Abductions

F. Other

V. Conclusion.

VI Sources and Web links.

Proposal II

(mediator version)

:Taken from Talk:UFO#Mediation and has been disagreed on, listed here for NPOV reasons

style="background:#AADDFF"
Same article, with UFO section like

Alternate theories

Extra-terrestrial origin

Stuff goes here Stuff goes here Stuff goes here Stuff goes here Stuff goes here

:or

Popular theories

Extra-terrestrial origin

Stuff goes here Stuff goes here Stuff goes here Stuff goes here Stuff goes here

Proposal 1

style="background:#AADD00"
??. Government investigations and records

A. American

B. Australian

c. Brazilian

D. British

E. Canadian

F. French

G. Others

Proposal 2

style="background:#FFFF33"
#That there be a recognition that the only notability of this topic lies in its connection to hypotheses about the existence of extra-terrestrials, and the subsequent pseudoscientific debates that sprang up around those theories. By consequence, a significant portion of the article should be devoted to discussing those theories.

  1. That these debates be treated as a conflict between fringe ET theorists and equally fringe skeptics, without particular commitment by the scientific community as a whole. This is to prevent the article from becoming an unbiased assault on ET-type theories by leveraging a scientific opinion that does not, in fact, exist.

Proposal 3

style="background:#FFD980"
#History

  1. Evidence (or lack thereof)
  2. Explanations
  3. IFOs
  4. ETH/other hypotheses
  5. Of Truth and Theories (extraordinary claims, etc.)
  6. Government reports
  7. US
  8. UK
  9. France
  10. Others
  11. Ufology
  12. Prominent believers
  13. UFO categorization
  14. Fringe physics/reverse engineering
  15. Conspiracy theories
  16. List of UFO sightings
  17. Popular culture

Proposal 4

style="background:#FDDEDB"
{{lorem}}

Proposal 5

style="background:#DCFFA0"
{{lorem}}

Proposal 6

style="background:#e0e09f"
{{lorem}}

Proposal 7

style="background:#99FFCC"
{{lorem}}

Proposal 8

style="background:#FF99FF"
{{lorem}}

Proposal 9

style="background:#ccb695"
{{lorem}}

Proposal 10

style="background:#00FFCC"
{{lorem}}

Proposal 11

style="background:#33FF00"
{{lorem}}

Proposal 12

style="background:#ffeb99"
{{lorem}}

Proposal 13

style="background:#adc9ff"
{{lorem}}

Proposal 14

style="background:#a1e3a1"
{{lorem}}

Proposal 15

style="background:#ffc7ff"
{{lorem}}

References

{{collapse top|References}}

{{reflist|2}}

{{collapse bottom}}