Login
Login

Wikipedia:Requests for comment/User conduct/Archive 2

{{talkarchivenav}}

{{ambox|text=this archive contains cases from late 2005 and all of 2006. Older discussions and unformatted entries are in the previous archive. }}

class="wikitable"
Sir Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington

| 29 Dec 2006

| Misuse of admin powers (blocking, deletion), WP:CIVIL

| Malber, Cindery

| Nothing resolved, participants tired of arguing.

Tim Smith

| 29 Dec 2006

| "conducting a low-grade edit war and misusing WP processes", ignoring WP:NPOV and giving undue weight to a minority viewpoint.

| FeloniousMonk, Guettarda

| No additional complaints were registered for an extended period of time, and the dispute appears to have stopped.

BrandonYusufToropov

| 21 Dec 2006

| Personal attacks and incivility.

| Karl Meier, Coelacan

| RFC closed by JzG on 16 January 2007: "no further input for 14 days, and no evidence presented of a continuing problem."

Vintila Barbu

| 17 Dec 2006

| Suspicions of plagiarism need discussion.

| User:Jmabel, User:Dahn

| Allegation denied, no source identified, paragraph remains in article as unreferenced.

StuRat

| 13 Dec 2006

| Attempting to change customary behavior at Wikipedia:Reference Desk, "a tendency to favor rules-lawyering over discussing the fundamental issue".

| Hipocrite, Friday

| RFC did not resolve dispute but "served to clarify somewhat the positions of the disputants" and was superseded by StuRat 2.

Psychohistorian

| 13 Dec 2006

| Abuse and incivility.

| Fourdee, Thulean

| Closed after inactive for a month.

BooyakaDell

| 12 Dec 2006

| Edit conflicts, sockpuppet allegations, Notability

| SirFozzie, Lethaniol

| User in focus was indefblocked as a Sockpuppet of a banned user via WP:AN

Mitsos

| 7 Dec 2006

| Promoting an admitted political bias, incivility, personal attacks, edit-warring.

| Spylab, SandyDancer

| Archived after over a month of inactivity; the RFC "alerted some editors and administrators about the kinds of policy violations Mitsos has committed on Wikipedia ... This page can be used as evidence if other disputes come up regarding the editor" (RFC results discussion).

Kelly Martin 3

| 6 Dec 2006

| RFC filed by Kelly Martin as a forum for editors to air their grievances about her

| Initial statement of dispute was not certified by other editors due to nonstandard format of RFC.

| Kelly Martin stopped participating in RFC on 10 December 2006 and RFC was closed after a month of inactivity.

Jance

| 6 Dec 2006

| Violations of WP:CIVIL and WP:AGF.

| Samir, Sarah Ewart

| User was [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:Jance indefblocked] 21 February 2007 by Cbrown1023 (WP:AN/I discussion).

Piotrus

| 5 Dec 2006

| WP:CIVIL, WP:NPA, WP:AGF, WP:REVERT, WP:WHEEL, WP:NPOV, WP:SPAM, WP:POINT

| Ghirlandajo, M.K

| Arbitration

Keltik31

| 30 Nov 2006

| POV-pushing, incivility, personal attacks.

| Db099221, JoshuaZ

| User was [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:Keltik31 indefblocked] on 10 November 2007 by Addhoc.

Abu badali

| 29 Nov 2006

| Image tagging issues; "concerns about Abu badali's approach to fair-use image challenges" (from subsequent ArbCom case).

| Irpen, Tvccs

| Evolved into Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Abu badali.

Seabhcan

| 18 Nov 2006

| Incivility

| Tom Harrison, Tbeatty

| Arbitration

RPJ

| 7 Nov 2006

| User:RPJ continues to violate WP:NPOV, WP:NPA, WP:OR, WP:CIVIL and WP:V.

| Gamaliel, Ramsquire

| Arbitration

PMA

| 26 Nov 2006

| Misuse of blocking power

| Thatcher131, Sarah Ewart

| Resigned sysop position

JR Pietri

| 13 Aug 2006

| WP:CIVIL, WP:SPAM

| Guinnog, Viridae

| {{#if:

}

|-

| Ferick

| 6 Aug 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Snake Liquid

| 1 Aug 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Insert-Belltower

| 21 Aug 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| UCRGrad

| 21 Jul 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Francespeabody

| 20 Jul 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Darwinek

| 18 Jul 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Wiarthurhu

| 16 Jul 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Sheynhertz-Unbayg

| 11 Jul 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Telex
({{#if: {{{user|}}} | {{{user}}} | Telex}})

| 11 Jul 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| JD UK

| 2 Jul 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Teemu Ruskeepää

| 29 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Gundagai editor

| 26 Jul 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| Gone to arbitration

|-

| Irpen

| 23 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Michaellovesnyc

| 23 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Brya

| 22 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: Gone to arbitration |Gone to arbitration}}

|-

| Imacomp

| 22 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Michael D. Wolok

| 21 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Frater FiatLux

| 21 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Mines45

| 21 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Maddyfan

| 15 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Dr1819

| 11 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Swainstonation

| 11 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Rick Norwood

| 7 Jun 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| SNIyer12

| 22 May 2006

| {{#if: {{{desc|}}} | {{{desc}}}}}

| {{#if: {{{cert1|}}} | {{{cert1}}}}}{{#if: {{{cert2|}}} |
{{{cert2}}}}}

| {{#if: |}}

|-

| Alastor Moody

| 16 Sep 2006

| User has a history of useless and/or irrelevant edits to talk pages (particularly on WikiProject Tropical cyclones), in violation of WP:NOT (a chat room).

| Coredesat, Hello32020

| Withdrawn when the disputed conduct did not recur

|-

| CrazyInSane

| 7 Aug 2006

| WP:AGF, WP:CIVIL WP:SOCK, WP:NOR and WP:NPOV issues.

| JoshuaZ, LtPowers

| Agreement to close

|-

| WikiRoo

| 10 Jul 2006

| POV pushing, personal attacks

| Garywill, User:AbsolutDan

| Indef banned by community

|-

| Block of Richard Arthur Norton (1958- )

| 27 Jul 2006

| Concerns regarding the block of User:Richard Arthur Norton (1958- ). Note: unlike most RFCs, there is no concern about abuse but rather a concern about broader issues of process drift and precedent.

| UninvitedCompany

| Stale

|-

| Nescio

| 14 Jul 2006

| Nescio has frequently engaged in violations of WP:POINT to the detrement of the articles he edits.

| Zer0faults, Rangeley

| Stale; Nescio has left Wikipedia

|-

| Kelly Martin2

| 8 Aug 2006

| Forming a new policy in order to close off ongoing discussion pertaining to an issue

| Johntex, Mecu

| Kelly Martin has left Wikipedia, also similar issues were raised in an unrelated arbitration case.

|-

| Vivaldi

| 20 May 2006

| POV editing, ignoring consensus

| Arbustoo, FeloniousMonk

| Arbitration

|-

| Sceptre

| 2 Aug 2006

| Blocking of ed g2s

| Sceptre, Johntex

| Sceptre is no longer an admin

|-

| MONGO

| 24 Jun 2006

| Misuse of blocking power

| Pokipsy76, CBD

| Arbitration for similar issues

|-

| BenH

| 26 Jun 2006

| Poor or unverifiable contributions, does not respond on talk pages

| CFIF, CoolKatt number 99999

| Indef banned by community

|-

| Der alte Hexenmeister

| 19 Jun 2006

| POV pushing, uncivil behavior, vandalism

| ems57fcva,Chris Hillman

| User is no longer active in Wikipedia

|-

| Hatto

| 9 Jun 2006

| Extremely uncooperative user; vandalism, reverts, copywrite problems, non-communication, disruption, edit warring, NPOV, disregard for policy, more.

| freshgavin, Geo.plrd, "Numorous sic other users listing complains sic on Hatto's talk pages", Mackan

| Stale

|-

| Lupo

| 13 May 2006

| Abuse of admin rules in ruling and POV of Soviet pre-1973 images

| Kuban kazak, Grafikm fr

| Stale

|-

| Ed Poor (2)

| 31 May 2006

| Imposing his own POV

| FeloniousMonk, Ladlergo

| Arbitration

|-

| Ericsaindon2

| 5 Jun 2006

| POV pushing and original research

| Will Beback, Adambiswanger1

| Sent to arbitration

|-

| Brian G. Crawford

| 18 May 2006

| Bad faith nomintions at AfD, personal attacks, template misuse, assuming bad faith, and incivility

| Backburner001, Apyule

| Community ban

|-

|CoolKatt number 99999

|17 May 2006

|Incivility

|Kafziel,CFIF

|Sent to arbitration

|-

| Gene Nygaard

| 10 May 2006

| Persistently imposes his own style preferences on scientific articles

| Worldtraveller, Sadi Carnot

| Stale

|-

|Xino

|5 May 2006

|Abrasiveness

|Golbez, Waka

|

|-

|Hamsacharya dan

|30 Apr 2006

|POV pushing

|Hanuman Das, Computerjoe

|

|-

|TheKingOfDixie

|29 Apr 2006

|Refusing to accept consensus

|Threeafterthree, Shenme

|

|-

| Pat8722

| 27 Apr 2006

| Revert war at Libertarianism

| Rhobite, Cadr

| Arbitration

|-

|Kurt Leyman

|26 Apr 2006

|Adding unverifiable information

|SuperDeng, Grafikm fr

|

|-

|Adam Carr

|23 Apr 2006

|Personal attacks

|Zleitzen, BruceHallman

|

|-

|Israelbeach

|23 Apr 2006

|Using Wikipedia to promote his own interests.

|Woggly, Jpgordon

|Banned for posting personal information [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:Israelbeach]

|-

|Fadix

|22 Apr 2006

|Lack of civility

|Cool Cat, Grandmaster

|

|-

|86.10.231.219

|22 Apr 2006

|Trolling

|Midgley, Jfdwolff

|

|-

|Whaleto

|13 Apr 2006

|Adding links to his own alternative medicine web site to medical topics in violation of WP:V and WP:RS

|Midgley, Tearlach

|

|-

|Merecat

|13 Apr 2006

|POV pushing

|Nescio, Kevin Baas

|Banned as a reincarnation of Rex071404

|-

|Mccready

|4 Apr 2006

|POV pushing on chiropractic articles

|Ombudsman, R. Koot

|

|-

|Ombudsman

|2 Nov 2005

|POV pushing on vaccine topics

|Jfdwolff, Geni

|

|

|-

|}