Wikipedia:Requests for comment/User conduct/Archive 3
{{talkarchivenav}}
{{ambox|text=This archive contains all user rfcs from 2007, except for any that were archived without being properly formatted in table format. Any unformatted entries can be found at Wikipedia:Requests for comment/User conduct/Archive 1 }}
| class="wikitable"
| 15 Dec 2007 | Incivility. | Toyalla, Binky The WonderSkull | Threeafterthree [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia_talk%3ARequests_for_comment%2FThreeafterthree&diff=179403985&oldid=179385968 apologized] for any offense caused; RFC removed after a month of inactivity. |
| Gump
| 13 Dec 2007 | Incivility and disruptive editing relating to Rob Bell article. | RfC removed after inactive for over a month with no clear resolution. |
| COGDEN
| 12 Dec 2007 | COGDEN has been editing policy pages in a disruptive fashion over a period of several months. | COGDEN is editing in good faith, but perhaps inappropriately, COGDEN reduced contentious editing on policy pages. |
| Angie Y. 2
| 11 Dec 2007 | "Inserting POV and OR material into articles despite several warnings." | Angie to be mentored by Interrobang² |
| KmWeber 2
| 11 Dec 2007 | User repeatedly using a copy-and-paste unwarranted 'oppose' comment at all self-nominated RfAs. | Consensus appears to favor no action by the community at this time. |
| Quantumentanglement
| 16 Dec 2007 | Problems with WP:FRINGE issues and wikilawyering. | Quantumentanglement has been [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:Quantumentanglement blocked] indefinitely. |
| Bruce1333
| 8 Dec 2007 | POV pushing on articles; disruption | Moot; Bruce1333 indef [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:Bruce1333 blocked] by Ryulong on 08:30 UTC 2007-12-09 |
| MONGO 3
| 16 Nov 2007 | "a persistent pattern of disruptive editing and personal attacks regarding the "Attack Sites" issue" | ArbCom was unwilling to take case, RfC died for lack of interest |
| EJ220
| 11 Nov 2007 | WP:NPOV, WP:V. | Southern Texas, Malik Shabazz | EJ220 [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:EJ220 indefblocked] for vandalism. |
| Billy Hathorn
| 10 Nov 2007 | "Creation of prodigious numbers of non-notable biographies, longest deleted articles log I can recall seeing." | Billy never responded, some discussion at User talk:Billy Hathorn. |
| Anonimu
| 27 Oct 2007 | POV pushing on articles; disruption; incivility | Moot; Anonimu indef [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:Anonimu blocked] by Maxim on 02:08 UTC 2007-11-27 and by ArbCom case for a year on 17:20 UTC 2007-12-13 |
| Scipo
| 19 Oct 2007 | Edit-warring, incivility. | Wyatt Riot, twsx | Scipo indef blocked for sockpuppetry and block evasion (SSP report). |
| Angel David
| 19 Oct 2007 | POV pushing. | First Certifier, Second certifier | Delisted due to inactivity with no clear outcome; Walton One and Yamakiri indicated a willingness to mentor Angel David. |
| Camptown
| 16 Oct 2007 | Adding false information and removing sourced text. | Delisted due to inactivity. |
| Geoeg
| 16 Oct 2007 | Disruptive SPA. |
| Sm565
| 16 Oct 2007 | Edit-warring SPA. | User indef blocked by Moreschi ([http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:Sm565 log]). |
| Shamir1
| 16 Oct 2007 | Reverting against consensus, disruption. | tariqabjotu , okedem | Delisted due to inactivity. |
| Duke53
| 12 Oct 2007 | Incivility, edit warring, POV pushing. | Delisted due to inactivity. |
| Mattisse 2
| 5 Oct 2007 | Edits regarding Drapetomania article. | Delisted due to inactivity. |
| Gavin.collins
| 4 Oct 2007 | Several policy/guideline violations. | Turlo_Lomon, SamBC | Initially closed due to inactivity. Reopened for admin action, but reclosed due to invalid reasoning, and lack of recent evidence to indicate dispute is still ongoing. |
| Luisosio
| 1 Oct 2007 | Civility, original research, ownership, POV-pushing. | Luisosio stopped editing on 9 October 2007. |
| John Foxe
| 10 Sep 2007 | WP:OWN, WP:NPOV on First Vision article. | Delisted due to inactivity; discussion continued at Talk:First Vision. |
| Kmweber
| 3 Aug 2007 | Rude posting in RfAs | | No outcome, discussion at standstill, opinions are against blocking |
| NE2 3
| 21 Oct 2007 | Implementing the removal of "decommissioned" without consensus. | MedCab resolved this issue (mainly content) |
| Durova
| 23 Nov 2007 | Violation of WP:BLOCK, WP:AGF; request for admin recall. | Durova has resigned her administrative privileges. |
| Whig
| 10 Oct 2007 | Repeated violations of WP:GAME, WP:AGF, WP:CIVIL as well as violations of WP:CANVASS and WP:3RR. | Whig has been [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:Whig blocked indefinitely]. |
| Alkivar
| 27 Jul 2007 | Uncivil, misuse of admin position. |
| Tony Sidaway 4
| 4 Oct 2007 | "Matter was deemed resolved" |
| Nescio 2
| 13 Sep 2007 | WP:GAME, WP:OWN, WP:OR/WP:SYN, WP:CON | Delisted due to inactivity. |
| Ludovicapipa
| 6 Sep 2007 | WP:OR, WP:NPOV/WP:FRINGE, WP:RS, WP:V | Delisted due to inactivity. |
| Italiavivi
| 2 Sep 2007 | Disruptive editing | Italiavivi stopped editing on 11 September 2007. |
| Kwork
| 26 Aug 2007 | Disregarding core policies, POV pushing | Sethie, Reneeholle | Kwork [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&page=User:Kwork indefinitely blocked] for disruption on 27 October 2007. |
| Commodore Sloat
| 24 Aug 2007 | Apology offered and accepted; Proposed suggestions if further issues: dual mentorship for CSloat or ArbCom for multiple involved Editors |
| Chrisjnelson
| 19 Aug 2007 | WP:CIV, WP:NPA, WP:OWN, WP:EDITWAR | Proceeded to arbitration |
| DreamGuy 2
| 7 Aug 2007 | WP:CIV, WP:OWN, WP:AGF, WP:NPA | Gone to arbitration |
| NE2 (Second RFC)
| 2 Aug 2007 | WP:CONS, WP:WL, WP:NOT#BURO, WP:POINT, WP:FUC, WP:CANVASS | O, Master son | Issues settled. |
| Artaxerex
| 31 Jul 2007 | WP:NPA, Wikipedia:Civility, Wikipedia:Sock puppetry, WP:NPOV, WP:NOR, WP:EW, WP:BATTLE | Request for arbitration filed here. |
| Ryulong
| 30 Jul 2007 | WP:BLOCK. | The Evil Spartan, Videmus Omnia | User cautioned. |
| Peter morrell
| 20 Jul 2007 | Incivility, personal attacks, NPOV violations | Removed after Cuerden failed to sign in the right place; Morrell apologized |
| Jeffrey O. Gustafson
| 10 Jul 2007 | WP:CIVIL, WP:CSD, WP:NPA, WP:ADMIN | Proceeded to arbitration |
| Banno
| 8 Jul 2007 | WP:BLOCK | Apology issued. |
| Spartaz
| 7 Jul 2007 | WP:BLOCK | Action affirmed. |
| Angie Y.
| 5 Jul 2007 | WP:CIV, WP:NPA, WP:AGF and WP:CANVASS | User appears to have changed her behavior. |
| Alansohn
| 28 Jun 2007 | Wikilawyering, WP:POINT, WP:AGF, WP:NPA | Orginally closed on 14 August 2007, the RfC was re-closed again on 27 May 2008 due to the closure of Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Footnoted quotes which placed Alansohn on a editing restriction for one year. |
| NE2
| 22 Jun 2007 | Mainly WP:CONS | Disputes resolved |
| Assault11
| 11 Jun 2007 | Disruptive editing | No apparent resolution; stalled with closure of Wikipedia:Requests for mediation/Goguryeo for similar inactivity |
| Rhode Island Red
| 9 Jun 2007 | WP:NPA, WP:CIV and WP:OWN at Juice Plus | User agreed to take a break from editing the article |
| Mike18xx
| 6 Jun 2007 | WP:MEAT, WP:NPA and other subsequent issues. | User agreed to stop recruiting off-wiki meatpuppets |
| Atabek
| 7 Jun 2007 | Continued false accusations, harassment, and canvassing | Proceeded to arbitration |
| Bishonen 2
| 5 Jun 2007 | accused of making false charge of harassment; accused of inappropriate block | Ferrylodge, LCP | Unanimous rejection of assertions made, with the only exceptions being the persons bringing Rfc. |
| Martinphi
| 1 Apr 2007 | edit warring, pov-pushing and -forking, spamming, making use of meat puppets, abusing Wikipedia processes to game the system | No changes; proceeding to arbitration: Paranormal, Martinphi-ScienceApologist. |
| Tezza1
| 12 Mar 2007 | Disruptive editing, WP:DE, WP:TE, WP:N, WP:POINT, WP:CIVIL, WP:NPOV, WP:COI | Proceeded to mediation |
| KazakhPol
| 12 Feb 2007 | personal attacks, edit warring, calling editors vandals, inserting the word "terrorist" inappropriately into articles about Islamic groups, inappropriate tagging. |
| Logicus
| 1 February 2007 | Repeated disruptive editing involving original research on articles related to the History of Science. | Delisted due to inactivity. |
| Trödel
| 25 Jan 2007 | Abuse of blocking policy. | Trödel apologized for misuse of blocking and agreed to never block TheGreenFaerae again, though reserves the right to request another administrator to blcok him. |
| Yamla
| 30 Jan 2007 | Use of blocking to win content disputes. | Justen, Mr. Vitale, 71Demon | No changes. |
| Sir Nicholas de Mimsy-Porpington 2
| 18 Feb 2007 | Improper closing of AfDs. | No conclusion, though noted at time of close that Nick had stopped closing AfDs. |
| Jimmuldrow
| 18 Feb 2007 | Discussing edits; abiding by consensus; assuming good faith; neutrality; original research. | Although nothing conclusively resolved, all parties seem to be willing to move forward productively; closed per agreement |
| Essjay
| 2 Mar 2007 | Community Trust issues over fake PHDs, and using them in advantage of content disputes | Community certified | Closed as Essjay since left the project |
| Hildanknight
| 30 Jan 2007 | Self-filed RfC over "controversial" edits | Hildanknight, no second certifier | User opened an ER at Wikipedia:Editor review/Hildanknight as suggested. |
| StuRat 2
| 9 Jan 2007 | Incivility, use of "deletionist" as pejorative term. | No additional complaints were registered for an extended period of time, and the dispute appears to have stopped. |
| Raspor
| 3 Jan 2007 | "violating WP:NPA, WP:NOT, WP:3RR while dismissing policies governing article content." | Account was [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log/block&page=User:Raspor indefblocked] on 18 January 2007 by SlimVirgin and editor was community banned (WP:AN/I discussion). |
| Suemcp
| 1 Jan 2007 | Edit-warring, incivility, WP:V, WP:RS WP:NPOV and WP:OR violations. | Dispute stopped as Suemcp has been inactive since January 9 2007. |