Wikipedia talk:German userbox solution/Babel box straw poll
Let's hold a small straw poll what kind of boxes should or should not be migrated from templatespace to userspace.
Definition Babel-box: "This user lives in XYZ", "This user speaks XYZ" and their variations, where XYZ is a real language/country.
Controversial boxes
All controversial boxes should be migrated into userspace.
This is the minimun idea for resolving the userbox issue.
=Support=
=Oppose=
Controversial and Non-Controversial non-Babel boxes
all but the babel boxes should be migrated.
Pro: we get rid of ambiguity and possible grounds for discussions or deletions.
Con: we migrate more userboxes than really necessary.
=Support=
=Oppose=
All boxes
All boxes should be migrated.
Pro: we have no more ambiguity.
Con: we might break some inofficial conventions where to find babel boxes, babel boxes should never be controversial.