Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship/Malcolmxl5

User:Malcolmxl5
run at Sat Aug 23 14:36:49 2008 GMT
Category:              8
Image talk:            2
Image:                 5
Mainspace              10961
Portal:                3
Talk:                  2452
Template:              18
User talk:             437
User:                  620
Wikipedia talk:        224
Wikipedia:             1449
avg edits per page     2.28
earliest               23:18, 9 April 2007
number of unique pages 7087
total                  16179
2007/4  77
2007/5  206
2007/6  611
2007/7  867
2007/8  807
2007/9  1127
2007/10 1068
2007/11 1101
2007/12 2751
2008/1  1180
2008/2  534
2008/3  1184
2008/4  737
2008/5  1272
2008/6  776
2008/7  1225
2008/8  656
(green denotes edits with an edit summary (even an automatic one), red
denotes edits without an edit summary)
Mainspace
147 [2]Lomana LuaLua
92  [3]Nigel Reo-Coker
84  [4]Celtic F.C. season 2000-01
82  [5]Freddy Eastwood
79  [6]Scott Carson
76  [7]Carlton Cole
76  [8]Teddy Sheringham
74  [9]Jermain Defoe
70  [10]Billy Bonds
63  [11]Stephen Bywater
60  [12]First Civil Service Commissioner
55  [13]Hayden Mullins
54  [14]Office for National Statistics
54  [15]Bobby Zamora
51  [16]Marlon Harewood
Talk:
23 [17]Freddy Eastwood
17 [18]Carlos T�vez
11 [19]Yossi Benayoun
8  [20]William Lawrence Balls
8  [21]Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
7  [22]Scott Parker (footballer)
7  [23]Arthur James Turner
6  [24]Julian Waterfall Pollack
6  [25]Trenton, Ontario
5  [26]Rayavaram (Krishna district)
5  [27]Billy Bonds
5  [28]Edward Vick
5  [29]Tilbury
4  [30]George Kay
4  [31]Alan Curbishley
Image:
4 [32]Keynsham Town.JPG
Portal:
2 [33]Wales/New article announcements
Template:
3 [34]Mansfield Town F.C. squad
2 [35]Wrexham F.C. squad
User:
248 [36]Malcolmxl5/Sandbox
174 [37]AlexNewArtBot/COISearchResult
70  [38]Malcolmxl5/Sandbox2
61  [39]Malcolmxl5
12  [40]AlexNewArtBot/COISearchResult/archive5
11  [41]AlexNewArtBot/COISearchResult/archive4
9   [42]Woody/Sandbox
4   [43]AlexNewArtBot/COISearchResult/archive2
4   [44]Fabrictramp
3   [45]Gogo Dodo
2   [46]Justmeherenow/Obama family of Kenya/Sandbox
2   [47]West Ham Fan
2   [48]MediaStudies110
User talk:
53 [49]Malcolmxl5
10 [50]Gogo Dodo
8  [51]Muffin Man 23
7  [52]69.157.65.118
6  [53]Poeloq
6  [54]Malcolmxl5/Archive 1
6  [55]Blotto adrift
5  [56]Joseffudge
5  [57]Redrocket
5  [58]Mr Hall of England
4  [59]Malcolmxl5/Sandbox
4  [60]Kurt Shaped Box
4  [61]Meco
4  [62]207.188.72.46
4  [63]86.160.240.191
Wikipedia:
150 [64]WikiProject Football
30  [65]WikiProject Football/New articles
14  [66]WikiProject Football/Booklist
12  [67]Articles for deletion/Frankie Loscavio
11  [68]Articles for deletion/Lewis Stanson
9   [69]WikiProject Football/Links
9   [70]Articles for deletion/Tymm Hoffman
9   [71]Articles for deletion/Nicolai Lomov
9   [72]Pages needing translation into English
8   [73]Administrator intervention against vandalism
7   [74]Articles for deletion/GlavUpDK
7   [75]Articles for deletion/Systemshock
7   [76]Articles for deletion/Celtic F.C. season 2000-01
6   [77]Articles for deletion/Log/2007 November 15
6   [78]Articles for deletion/John FitzGerald
Wikipedia talk:
165 [79]WikiProject Football
6   [80]New pages patrol/patrolled pages
5   [81]WikiProject Non-league football
3   [82]WikiProject Automobiles/Archive 10
3   [83]WikiProject Astronomy
3   [84]Manual of Style (flags)
2   [85]WikiProject Mathematics
2   [86]Noticeboard for India-related topics
2   [87]WikiProject Australia
2   [88]WikiProject Topical outlines
2   [89]Archived delete discussions
If there were any problems, please [90]email Interiot or post at
[91]User talk:Interiot.

• The edit count was retrieved from [http://toolserver.org/~interiot/cgi-bin/Tool1/wannabe_kate?username=Malcolmxl5&site=en.wikipedia.org this link] at 14:36, 23 August 2008 (UTC).

1. :* Surely an admin candidate who !votes Delete in AfDs for obviously non-encyclopedic articles should be a reason to support, not oppose? Or am I missing something? All those articles were obvious deletes apart from the two that ended up merge/no consensus. If we opposed everyone who !voted Delete on an AfD that was eventually kept, we'd have no admins at all. Also, some of those AfDs are over a year old.... bizarre. Wheelchair Epidemic (talk) 19:06, 23 August 2008 (UTC)

1. ::*From what I know, Le Grand Roi opposes the candidate if they have opposing viewpoints on any RfAs - CL — 19:58, 23 August 2008 (UTC)
2. :::*This is one of the the most idiotic and personal opposes I've seen. Yanksox (talk) 20:31, 23 August 2008 (UTC)
3. ::::*Immature responses are not how to convince people to support. --Happy editing! Sincerely, Le Grand Roi des Citrouilles^Tally-ho! 20:33, 23 August 2008 (UTC)
4. ::*I am opposing because those were encyclopedic articles that were unjustifiably deleted. --Happy editing! Sincerely, Le Grand Roi des Citrouilles^Tally-ho! 20:33, 23 August 2008 (UTC)
5. :::*This is a personal vendetta against the deleting admin, not the candidate at large. Furthermore, I'm sick of people that act almost like mere pond scum and just pounce on this like a soapbox. I remember one character in particular that did it to my RfA and others and was blocked sometime after for being a sockmaster. I'm not saying anything in particular, but just putting it out there. Yanksox (talk) 20:36, 23 August 2008 (UTC)
6. ::::*What?! I am opposing because I disagree with the candidate's interpretation of inclusion criteria and how they would likely close AfDs. Those discussions I cite above were closed by several different admins. Which one do I allegedly have a vendetta against? --Happy editing! Sincerely, Le Grand Roi des Citrouilles^Tally-ho! 20:41, 23 August 2008 (UTC)
7. :::*This is not a vendetta against the deleting admin, but against all admins who have ever deleted anything. --T-rex 21:21, 23 August 2008 (UTC)
8. ::::*If that were so, then I would not have would have to oppose those who closed Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adams equation, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Adult-child sex (2nd nomination), Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Alhaji sani labaran, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Bagot Beast, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Butt harp, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Canyon of the Vaginas, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Delboo, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dorian's identity, Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Easy-cook rice (joke), etc. I don't oppose people because they argue to delete as I myself have argued and nominated to delete more articles than I good number of editors I have seen have argued to keep. I oppose based on what and why editors argued to delete. Someone can actually be a deletionist of sorts and every thing they argued to delete I might not disagree with. Look through those whom I have supported and I am sure they have argued to delete here and there. It has nothing to do with simply arguing to delete, again, it is what I believe to be misinterpretations of inclusion criteria or incorrect arguments. --Happy editing! Sincerely, Le Grand Roi des Citrouilles^Tally-ho! 21:39, 23 August 2008 (UTC)
9. :Le Grand Roi, I understand your opinion, but can you at least provide diffs from, well, 2008 next time? Wizardman 21:24, 23 August 2008 (UTC)
10. ::I shall keep that in mind. --Happy editing! Sincerely, Le Grand Roi des Citrouilles^Tally-ho! 21:39, 23 August 2008 (UTC)
11. :::Le Grand Roi des Citrouilles has a right to oppose. He opposed my RFA, but I learned a lot because of his oppose !vote. It is important for editors to understand that deleting some articles can undo years of work of other editors. Masterpiece2000 (talk) 10:17, 26 August 2008 (UTC)