method of levels

The Method of Levels originated in Bill Powers' phenomenological investigations into the mobility of awareness relative to the perceptual hierarchy.{{harvnb|Powers|2009}} He prepared a description of it for his 1973 book, Behavior: The Control of Perception, but the editor persuaded him to remove that chapter and the chapter on emotion.{{sfn|Powers|2009|p=121}} He continued to demonstrate the technique at PCT conferencesMeetings of the Control Systems Group, which is now the International Association for Perceptual Control Theory (IAPCT)). and other meetings. In the 1990s, David Goldstein of New Jersey (US) began using MOL in clinical practice with patients, and Timothy A. Carey, an Australian psychologist, also began using it and obtained a doctorate in clinical psychology primarily so that he could test it.{{sfn|Powers|2009|p=121}} Cary, Warren Mansell, Sara Tai, Eva de Hullu, and their colleagues and students continue to research, practice, and teach MOL on several continents. Eva de Hullu (Open Universiteit, the Netherlands), Warren Mansell (Curtin University, Perth, Australia) and Ana Churchman (Manchester University, UK) are leading collaborative development of an accreditation program on PCT principles, under the umbrella of the International Association for Perceptual Control Theory (IAPCT).

PCT is the theoretical foundation of MOL. PCT models satisfactory psychological functioning as successful control, and conversely it models psychological distress as the subjective consequence when ability to control important experiences is impaired. The most common source of distress found in practice is internal conflict, because each system in a conflict denies control to the other.

Conflict is usually transitory, but when it is not resolved and becomes chronic it may manifest as "inflexible control" and in distress processes such as worry, suppressed emotion, and self-criticism. In the PCT model, these are subjective experiences of dysfunction due to disruption of successful control.{{harvnb|Mansell|2005}}{{harvnb|Carey|2006}} The various therapeutic systems take such experiences as diagnostic of the many identified psychological disorders.{{harvnb|Carey|2011b|p=245}} Because PCT provides a unified model of these, MOL has been called a transdiagnostic therapy,{{harvnb|Mansell|Carey|Tai|2012}} but as it has no dependency on diagnostic categories it is a-diagnostic.

A conflict cannot be resolved while attention vacillates between incompatible goals and focuses on the experiences which are distressing. When the client has relocated attention above the level of the hierarchy from which the conflicting goals are set, an innate process called reorganization re-establishes satisfactory control. It is hypothesized that when any therapy is successful the mechanism is this innate capacity for reorganization in the client's nervous system, irrespective of the therapist's conceptual 'toolkit'.{{harvnb|Mansell|Carey|Tai|2012}}.

MOL enables resolution of internal conflict so that it no longer impairs control. When a person recovers control, the source of distress is eliminated, along with the associated behavioral and affective manifestations.

The core process is to redirect attention to higher levels in the client's control hierarchy by recognizing "background thoughts", bringing them into the foreground, and then being alert for more background thoughts while the new foreground thoughts are explored. By this "up-a-level" process, the client is helped to lead the way to the systems responsible for generating the conflict, and away from a preoccupation with the symptoms and efforts immediately associated with the conflict. If other matters of concern subsequently rise to awareness, the client may schedule time to talk about them. When the level-climbing process reaches an end state without encountering any conflicts, the need for therapy may have ended.

Carey's research into MOL began with the question whether MOL is sufficient in itself as an effective and efficient way of helping people resolve psychological distress. The result is clearly affirmative. More than two decades of case histories by different therapists in different settings working with different people about a wide range of different problems show that nothing additional is needed to enhance MOL. MOL is used effectively as the sole therapeutic modality with adults and young people, in primary care and secondary care, in alcohol and other drug services, in pain management clinics, in schools, in prisons, and in different countries and cultures.

An advantage for research is that records of ongoing evaluation have been a feature of MOL since its introduction into clinical practice, because MOL was developed as a therapy within the routine clinical settings in which it would be used. Numerous evaluations of MOL used in different settings by different therapists have been published.For example,

{{harvnb|Carey|2005}},

{{harvnb|Carey|Mullan|2007}},

{{harvnb|Carey|Mullan|2008}},

{{harvnb|Carey|Mullan|Carey|2007}},

{{harvnb|Carey|Carey|Mullan|Spratt|Spratt|2009}}

{{harvnb|Carey|Tai|Stiles|2013}}. These evaluations include novel methodologies such as Time 1 and Time 2 rather than pre- and post-designs and benchmarking,{{harvnb|Carey|Tai|Mansell|Huddy|Griffiths|Marken|2017}} and innovative metrics have been introduced such as the efficiency ratio.{{harvnb|Carey|Tai|Stiles|2013}} The evaluations have also included investigations into the perspective of patients as well as that of referring GPs.

In conjunction with another clinical innovation, Patient-Led Appointment Scheduling (PLAS), MOL has been demonstrated to reduce waiting times and improve access to services with no reduction of its effectiveness and efficiency as therapy.{{harvnb|Carey|2010}}{{harvnb|Carey|2011a}}{{harvnb|Carey|2016b}} In addition to the many evaluations of MOL in primary care settings, a randomised controlled trial in subjects with first-episode psychosis demonstrated that the retention in the trial at final follow-up was 97%, suggesting a successful feasibility outcome. The feedback provided by participants delivered initial evidence of the intervention for this population.{{harvnb|Griffiths|Mansell|Carey|Edge|Emsley|Tai|2018}}{{harvnb|Griffiths|Mansell|Carey|Edge|Emsley|Tai|2019}} The approach may also be effective in the treatment of sleep disorders{{harvnb|Grzegrzolka|McEvoy|Mansell|2019}} and suicidality.{{harvnb|Macintyre|Mansell|Pratt|Tai|2021}}

• Coherence therapy
• Common factors theory
• Focusing (psychotherapy)
• Metacognition

{{Reflist}}

• {{cite journal | last =Carey | first =T. A. | author-link = | title =Can patients specify treatment parameters? | journal =Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy | volume =12 | issue =4 | pages =326–335 | date =2005 | language = | url = | doi = 10.1002/cpp.454| access-date = }}

• {{cite book | last=Carey | first=T. A. | date=2006 | title=The Method of Levels: How to do psychotherapy without getting in the way | publication-place=Hayward, CA | publisher=Living Control Systems Publishing | isbn=978-0-9740155-4-5 | oclc=63193390 | url=https://books.google.com/books?id=Da9lPEDayPMC | access-date=27 March 2024}}

• {{cite book |last=Carey |first=T. A. |date=2010

|editor-last1= Bennett-Levy|editor-first1= J.

|editor-last2=Richards |editor-first2=D.

|editor-last3=Farrand |editor-first3=P.

|editor-last4=Christensen |editor-first4=H.

|editor-last5=Griffiths |editor-first5=K.

|editor-last6=Kavanagh |editor-first6=D.

|editor-last7=Klein |editor-first7=B.

|editor-last8=Lau |editor-first8=M. A.

|editor-last9=Proudfoot |editor-first9=J.

|editor-last10=Ritterband |editor-first10=L.

|editor-last11=Williams |editor-first11=C.

|editor-last12=White |editor-first12=J.|title=Oxford guide to low intensity CBT interventions |location= Oxford|publisher= Oxford University Press|pages= 331–338|chapter=Will you follow while they lead? Introducing a patient-led approach to low intensity CBT interventions |isbn=}}

• {{cite journal | last =Carey | first =T. A. | author-link = | title =As you like it: Adopting a patient-led approach to the issue of treatment length | journal =Journal of Public Mental Health | volume =10 | issue =1 | pages =6–16 | date =2011a | language = | url = | doi = 10.1108/17465721111134510| access-date = }}

• {{cite journal |last=Carey |first=T. A. |author-link= |title=Exposure and reorganization: the what and how of effective psychotherapy |journal=Clin. Psychol. Rev. |volume=31 |issue=2 |pages=236-48 |publisher= |location= |date=2011b |language= |url= |doi=10.1016/j.cpr.2010.04.004 |access-date= }}

• {{cite book | last=Carey | first=T. A. | year=2016b | title=Hold that thought: Two steps to effective counseling and psychotherapy with the Method of Levels | publication-place=Chapel Hill, NC | publisher=New View Publications | isbn=978-0-944337-59-2}}

• {{cite journal | last1=Carey | first1=T. A. | last2=Carey | first2=M. | last3=Mullan | first3=R. J. | last4=Spratt | first4=C. G. | last5=Spratt | first5=M. B. | title=Assessing the Statistical and Personal Significance of the Method of Levels | journal=Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy | volume=37 | issue=3 | date=2009 | issn=1352-4658 | doi=10.1017/S1352465809005232 | page=311-324| pmid=19371458 }}

• {{cite book | last1=Carey | first1=T. A. | last2=Mansell | first2=W. | last3=Tai | first3=S. J. | date=2015-06-05 | title=Principles-based counselling and psychotherapy: A Method of Levels approach | location=London | publisher=Routledge | isbn=978-0-415-73877-4 | oclc=898113412 | doi=10.4324/9781315695778}}

• {{cite journal | last1 =Carey | first1 =T. A. | last2 =Mullan | first2 =R. J. | author-link = | title =Patients taking the lead: A naturalistic investigation of a patient led approach to treatment in primary care | journal =Counselling Psychology Quarterly | volume =20 | issue =1 | pages =27–40 | date =2007 | language = | url = | doi = 10.1080/09515070701211304| access-date = }}

• {{cite journal | last1=Carey | first1=T. A. | last2=Mullan| first2=R. J. | title =Evaluating the Method of Levels | journal =Counseling Psychology Quarterly | volume =21 | issue =3 | pages =247–256 | date =2008 | url = | doi =10.1080/09515070802396012 | access-date = }}

• {{cite journal | last1 =Carey | first1 =T. A. | last2 =Mullan | first2 =R. J. | last3 =Carey | first3 =M. | author-link = | title =Patient lead treatment: An idea whose time has come | journal =Clinical Psychology Forum | volume =1 | issue = 177| pages =9–12 | date =2007 | language = | url = | doi = 10.53841/bpscpf.2007.1.177.9| access-date = }}

• {{cite journal | last1 =Carey | first1 =T. A. | last2 =Tai | first2 =S. J. | last3 =Mansell | first3 =W. | last4 =Huddy | first4 =V. | last5 =Griffiths | first5 = R.| last6 =Marken | first6 =R. S. | author-link = | title =Improving professional psychological practice through an increased repertoire of research methodologies: Illustrated by the development of MOL | journal =Professional Psychology: Research and Practice | volume =48 | issue =3 | pages =175–82 | date =2017 | language = | url = https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/147815/3/Manuscript%20for%20Professional%20Psychology%20Revised.pdf| doi =10.1037/pro0000132 | access-date = }}

• {{cite journal | last1 =Carey | first1 =T. A. | last2 =Tai | first2 =S. J. | last3 =Stiles | first3 =W. B. | title =Effective and efficient: Using patient-led appointment scheduling in routine mental health practice in remote Australia | journal =Professional Psychology: Research and Practice | volume =44 | issue =6 | pages =405–414 | date =2013 | language = | url = | doi =10.1037/a0035038 | access-date = }}

• {{cite journal |last1=Griffiths |first1=R. |last2=Mansell |first2=W. |last3=Carey |first3=T. A. |last4=Edge |first4=D. |last5=Emsley |first5=R. |last6=Tai |first6=S. J. |title=Method of levels therapy for first-episode psychosis: rationale, design and baseline data for the feasibility randomised controlled Next Level study |journal=BJPsych Open |date=September 2018 |volume=4 |issue=5 |pages=339–345 |doi=10.1192/bjo.2018.44 |pmid=30140445|pmc=6094182 }}

• {{cite journal |last1=Griffiths |first1=R. |last2=Mansell |first2=W. |last3=Carey |first3=T. A. |last4=Edge |first4=D. |last5=Emsley |first5=R. |last6=Tai |first6=S. J. |title=Method of levels therapy for first-episode psychosis: The feasibility randomized controlled Next Level trial |journal=Journal of Clinical Psychology |date=October 2019 |volume=75 |issue=10 |pages=1756–1769 |issn=0021-9762 |doi=10.1002/jclp.22820 |pmid=31240723|s2cid=191638657 |url=https://pure.manchester.ac.uk/ws/files/101391851/Next_Level_RCT_Journal_of_Clinical_Psychology_Manuscript_clean_version.docx }}

• {{cite journal |last1=Grzegrzolka |first1=J. |last2=McEvoy |first2=P. |last3=Mansell |first3=W. |title=Use of the Method of Levels Therapy as a Low-Intensity Intervention to Work With People Experiencing Sleep Difficulties |journal=Journal of Cognitive Psychotherapy |date=1 May 2019 |volume=33 |issue=2 |pages=140–156 |doi=10.1891/0889-8391.33.2.140 |pmid=32746389|s2cid=150433287 |url=https://pure.manchester.ac.uk/ws/files/85597160/Sleep_paper_revised_FINAL.docx }}

• {{cite journal |last1=Macintyre |first1=V. G. |last2=Mansell |first2=W. |last3=Pratt |first3=D. |last4=Tai |first4=S. J. |title=The Psychological Pathway to Suicide Attempts: A Strategy of Control Without Awareness |journal=Frontiers in Psychology |date=2021 |volume=12 |pages=588683 |doi=10.3389/fpsyg.2021.588683 |pmid=33815194|pmc=8012495 |doi-access=free }}

• {{Cite journal |last=Mansell |first=W. |date=June 2005 |title=Control theory and psychopathology: an integrative approach |journal=Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice |volume=78 |issue=2 |pages=141–178 |doi=10.1348/147608304X21400 |pmid=16004696 }}

• {{cite book |last1=Mansell |first1=W. |last2=Carey |first2=T. A |last3=Tai |first3=S. |title=A transdiagnostic approach to CBT using method of levels therapy |year=2012 |series=CBT distinctive features series |location=Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon; New York |publisher=Routledge |isbn=9780415507639 |oclc=774499959 |doi=10.4324/9780203081334 }}

• {{cite journal | last=Powers | first=W. T. | title=PCT and MOL: a brief history of Perceptual Control Theory and the Method of Levels | journal=The Cognitive Behaviour Therapist | volume=2 | issue=3 | date=2009 | issn=1754-470X | doi=10.1017/S1754470X08000111 | pages=118–122}}

{{refbegin|40em}}

• {{cite journal | last1=Bird | first1=T. | last2=Mansell | first2=W. | last3=Tai | first3=S. | title=Method of Levels: initial steps in assessing adherence and the development of a qualitative framework for mapping clients' control hierarchies | journal=The Cognitive Behaviour Therapist | volume=2 | issue=3 | date=2009 | issn=1754-470X | doi=10.1017/S1754470X09990158 | pages=145–166}}

• {{cite journal | last = Carey| first = T. A.| author-link = | title =What makes a psychotherapist effective? | journal =Psychotherapy in Australia | volume =5 | issue =3 | pages =52–59 | date =1999 | language = | url = | doi = | access-date = }}

• {{cite journal | last=Carey | first=T. A. | date=Spring 2001a | title=Investigating the role of redirecting awareness in the change process: A case study using the Method of Levels | journal=International Journal of Reality Therapy | volume=20 | number=2 | pages=26–30 | url=http://www.mwsu.edu/Assets/documents/academics/education/International_Journal_of_Reality_Therapy_Spring2001.pdf#page=28 | archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20140421110303/http://www.mwsu.edu/Assets/documents/academics/education/International_Journal_of_Reality_Therapy_Spring2001.pdf#page=28 | archive-date=2014-04-21}}

• {{cite journal | last = Carey| first = T. A.| author-link = | title =The Method of Levels: Offering a different approach to peer counseling programs | journal =International Journal of Reality Therapy | volume =21 | issue =1 | pages =13–16 | date =2001b | language = | url = | doi = | access-date = }}

• {{cite journal | last =Carey | first =T. A. | author-link = | title =Rebecca: A case study application of perceptual control theory | journal =Psychotherapy in Australia | volume =8 | issue =3 | pages =56–59 | date =2002 | language = | url = | doi = | access-date = }}

• {{cite journal | last =Carey | first =T. A. | author-link = | title =Conflict, as the Achilles heel of perceptual control, offers a unifying approach to the formulation of psychological problems | journal =Counselling Psychology Review | volume =23 | issue =4 | pages =5–16 | date =2008a | language = | url = | doi = 10.53841/bpscpr.2008.23.4.5| access-date = }}

• {{cite journal | last=Carey | first=T. A. | date=2008b | title=Perceptual Control Theory and the Method of Levels: Further Contributions to a Transdiagnostic Perspective | journal=International Journal of Cognitive Therapy | volume=1 | issue=3 | issn=1937-1209 | doi=10.1521/ijct.2008.1.3.237 | pages=237–255}}

• {{cite book |last=Carey |first=T. A. |date=2016a |editor-last1=Cooper |editor-first1=M. |editor-last2=Dryden |editor-first2=W. |title=The handbook of pluralistic counselling and psychotherapy |location=London |publisher=Sage Publishing |pages=288–299 |chapter=Boundaries: A pluralistic perspective and illustrative case study of the patient-led approach to appointment scheduling |isbn=}}

• {{cite journal | last1 =Carey | first1 =T. A. | last2 =Carey | first2 =M. | last3 =Stalker | first3 =K. | last4 =Mullan | first4 =R. J. | last5 =Murray | first5 =L. | last6 =Spratt | first6 =M. | author-link = | title =Psychological change from the inside looking out: A qualitative investigation | journal =Counselling and Psychotherapy Research | volume =7 | issue =3 | pages =178–85 | date =2007 | language = | url = | doi = 10.1080/14733140701514613| access-date = }}

• {{cite journal | last1 =Carey | first1 =T. A. | last2 =Mansell | first2 =W. | last3 =Tai | first3 =S. J. | author-link = | title =A biopsychosocial model based on negative feedback and control | journal =Frontiers in Human Neuroscience | volume =8 | issue =94 | date =2014 | page =94 | language = | url = | doi =10.3389/fnhum.2014.00094 | doi-access =free | pmid =24616685 | pmc =3937810 | access-date = }}

• {{cite book | last=de Hullu | first=E. | date=2023 | chapter=Exploring the perceptual control hierarchy | pages=3–28 | doi=10.1016/b978-0-323-91165-8.00008-1 | chapter-url=https://research.ou.nl/ws/portalfiles/portal/61798637/InterdisciplinaryHandbookofPerceptualControlTheory_vol.II_LivingInTheLoop_Chapter1.pdf#page=4 | editor-last=Mansell | editor-first=W. | editor-last2=Hullu | editor-first2=E. de | editor-last3=Huddy | editor-first3=V. | editor-last4=Scholte | editor-first4=T. | title=The Interdisciplinary Handbook of Perceptual Control Theory, Volume II: Living in the Loop | publisher=Academic Press | isbn=978-0-323-91165-8}}

• {{cite book | editor-last=Forssell | editor-first=D. | date=2020-08-14 | orig-year=2008 | title=Perceptual control theory: An overview of the third grand theory in psychology | edition=2020 | publisher=Living Control Systems | isbn=978-1-938090-12-7 | url=http://www.livingcontrolsystems.com/download/pct_readings_ebook_2016.pdf}}

• {{cite journal | last=Goldstein | first=D. M. | date=2007 | title=Method of Levels therapy: Helping the normal change process within a person when normal change doesn't seem to be happening by itself | journal=The International Journal of Healing and Caring | volume=7 | number=1 | pages=1–17 | url=https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/document?repid=rep1&type=pdf&doi=2e8a5644d46b557f465cf7e7cec4950fae75fb93}}

• {{cite conference | last=Goldstein | first=D. M. | date=29 October 2007 | title=The MOL Therapy Case Study of AF | event=Presented at the CSG 2008 Annual Conference | url=https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/document?repid=rep1&type=pdf&doi=dc909294db7331f4bde899456cea5f42ecf4e5ba}}

• {{citation | last=Goldstein | first=D. M. | date=29 March 2009 | title=Perceptual Control Theory Psychotherapy (PCT Psychotherapy) | url=https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/document?repid=rep1&type=pdf&doi=8caaa9113a6c6aac63b53a0e4e50638f2ca29a32}}

• {{cite web | last=Griffiths | first=R. M. | title=Conflict and Psychosis | website=Next Level | date=8 September 2016 | url=https://nextlevelstudy.wordpress.com/2016/09/08/conflict-and-psychosis/ | ref={{sfnref | Next Level | 2016}} | access-date=9 December 2024}}

• {{cite journal | last1=Griffiths | first1=R. M. | last2=Mansell | first2=W. | last3=Edge | first3=D. | last4=Carey | first4=T. A. | last5=Peel | first5=H. | last6=J. Tai | first6=S. | title='It was me answering my own questions': Experiences of method of levels therapy amongst people with first-episode psychosis | journal=International Journal of Mental Health Nursing | volume=28 | issue=3 | date=2019b | issn=1445-8330 | doi=10.1111/inm.12576 | pages=721–734| pmid=30701661 | url=https://pure.manchester.ac.uk/ws/files/83939002/MOL_psychosis_IJMHN_manuscript_AAM.docx }}

• {{cite journal | last=Mansell | first=W. | title=Perceptual Control Theory as an integrative framework and Method of Levels as a cognitive therapy: what are the pros and cons? | journal=The Cognitive Behaviour Therapist | volume=2 | issue=3 | date=2009 | issn=1754-470X | doi=10.1017/S1754470X08000093 | pages=178–196}}

• {{cite journal | last1=Mansell | first1=W. | last2=Carey | first2=T. A. | title=A century of psychology and psychotherapy: Is an understanding of control the missing link between theory, research, and practice? | journal=Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice | volume=82 | issue=3 | date=2009 | issn=1476-0835 | doi=10.1348/147608309X432526 | pages=337–353| pmid=19341533 }}

• {{cite book | last1=Mansell | first1=W. | last2=Goldstein | first2=D. M. | title=The Interdisciplinary Handbook of Perceptual Control Theory | chapter=Method of Levels Therapy | publisher=Elsevier | date=2020 | isbn=978-0-12-818948-1 | doi=10.1016/b978-0-12-818948-1.00013-7}}

• {{cite book | last =Powers | first =W. T. | author-link = | title =In Living Control Systems II: Selected papers of William T. Powers | publisher =Control Systems Group | series = | volume = | edition = | date =1992 | location =Gravel Switch, KY | pages = |chapter=An experiment with levels | language = | url = | doi = | isbn = }}

• {{citation | last=Powers | first=W. T. | date=15 December 2022 | orig-year=2010 | title=The Method of Levels: a Cognitive-Therapy synthesis | publication-place=Edgartown, Massachusetts, USA | publisher=International Association for Perceptual Control Theory | url=https://www.iapct.org/themes/psychology-mental-health/the-method-of-levels-a-cognitive-therapy-synthesis/ | access-date=27 March 2024}} Republished from {{citation | last=Powers | first=W. T.| date=16 August 2010 | title=The Method of Levels: a cognitive-therapy synthesis | url=http://www.pctweb.org/PCTMOL2.pdf | archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110714081432/http://www.pctweb.org/PCTMOL2.pdf | archive-date=2011-07-14}}

• {{cite journal | last=Richer | first=J. M. | date=2020 | title=Perceptual control theory: A Paradigm Shift? | journal=Human Ethology | volume=35 | issue=1 | doi=10.22330/he/35/079-090 | pages=79–90 | url=https://ishe.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/HE_2020_35_79-90.pdf}}

• {{cite book | last=Scholte | first=T. | title=The Interdisciplinary Handbook of Perceptual Control Theory, Volume II | chapter=Reorganization as anti-oppression: PCT, the Method of Levels, and the Theatre of the Oppressed | publisher=Elsevier | date=2023 | pages=349–378 | isbn=978-0-323-91165-8 | doi=10.1016/b978-0-323-91165-8.00014-7}}

{{refend}}

• {{anchor|IAPCT}}[https://www.iapct.org/ The International Association for Perceptual Control Theory (IAPCT)], with a [https://www.iapct.org/category/themes/psychology-mental-health/ section on MOL]
• {{anchor|Accreditation}}[https://www.iapct.org/themes/method-of-levels/mol-accreditation/ MOL accreditation]
• [https://methodoflevels.com/ MethodOfLevels.com] - A website by Timothy A. Carey
• [http://pctresources.com/ PCT Resources] - A website by William T. Powers
• [http://livingcontrolsystems.com/ Living Control Systems Publishing] - A website by Dag Forssell

{{Cognitive behavioral therapy}}

Category:Cognitive behavioral therapy