2023–24 Plymouth Argyle F.C. season

{{updated|27 March 2024}}

{{Updated|24 September 2023}}

{{Extended football squad start|Championship|FA Cup|EFL Cup}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=1 |nat=ENG|pos=GK|name={{sortname|Michael|Cooper|dab=footballer}} |9+0|0|0+0|0|0+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=2 |nat=ENG|pos=DF|name={{sortname|Bali|Mumba}} |18+2|2|0+0|0|0+1|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=3 |nat=ENG|pos=DF|name={{sortname|Macaulay|Gillesphey}} |2+1|0|0+0|0|0+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=4 |nat=ENG|pos=MF|name={{sortname|Jordan|Houghton}} |18+2|0|0+0|0|0+1|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=5 |nat=ESP|pos=DF|name={{sortname|Julio|Pleguezuelo}} |10+4|0|0+0|0|2+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=6 |nat=ENG|pos=DF|name={{sortname|Dan|Scarr}} |16+2|1|0+0|0|1+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=7 |nat=ENG|pos=MF|name={{sortname|Matt|Butcher|dab=footballer}} |2+11|0|0+0|0|2+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=8 |nat=ENG|pos=MF|name={{sortname|Joe|Edwards|dab=footballer, born 1990}} |13+3|1|0+0|0|0+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=9 |nat=SCO|pos=FW|name={{sortname|Ryan|Hardie}} |13+3|6|0+0|0|0+2|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=10|nat=ENG|pos=FW|name={{sortname|Morgan|Whittaker}} |20+1|8|0+0|0|0+1|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=11|nat=ENG|pos=MF|name={{sortname|Callum|Wright}} |4+8|0|0+0|0|1+1|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=14|nat=ENG|pos=FW|name={{sortname|Mickel|Miller}} |6+8|0|0+0|0|1+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=15|nat=SLE|pos=FW|name={{sortname|Mustapha|Bundu}} |3+9|2|0+0|0|0+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=16|nat=ENG|pos=MF|name={{sortname|Lewis|Warrington|dab=footballer}}* |1+1|0|0+0|0|2+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=17|nat=ENG|pos=DF|name={{sortname|Lewis|Gibson|dab=footballer}} |18+0|0|0+0|0|0+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=18|nat=IRL|pos=MF|name={{sortname|Finn|Azaz}} |16+4|4|0+0|0|1+1|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=19|nat=IRL|pos=MF|name={{sortname|Tyreik|Wright}} |1+4|0|0+0|0|1+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=20|nat=ENG|pos=MF|name={{sortname|Adam|Randell}} |13+7|3|0+0|0|0+1|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=21|nat=NIR|pos=GK|name={{sortname|Conor|Hazard}} |12+0|0|0+0|0|0+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=22|nat=ZIM|pos=DF|name={{sortname|Brendan|Galloway}} |2+3|0|0+0|0|0+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=23|nat=NZL|pos=FW|name={{sortname|Ben|Waine}} |4+9|1|0+0|0|2+0|3}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=24|nat=ENG|pos=DF|name={{sortname|Saxon|Earley}} |1+0|0|0+0|0|1+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=25|nat=ENG|pos=GK|name={{sortname|Callum|Burton}} |0+0|0|0+0|0|2+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=28|nat=ENG|pos=MF|name={{sortname|Luke|Cundle}}* |11+8|3|0+0|0|2+0|1}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=29|nat=ENG|pos=DF|name={{sortname|Kaine|Kesler-Hayden}}* |16+3|0|0+0|0|2+0|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=34|nat=ENG|pos=MF|name={{sortname|Caleb|Roberts}} |0+0|0|0+0|0|0+1|0}}

{{Extended football squad player|no=35|nat=WAL|pos=FW|name={{sortname|Freddie|Issaka}} |0+2|0|0+0|0|1+1|0}}

|}

{{Updated|24 September 2023}}

{{Updated|24 September 2023}}

|-

| 30 June 2023 || CM || {{flagicon|ENG}} Conor Grant || {{fbaicon|ENG}} Port Vale || Released || {{cite news |title=Conor Grant joins the Valiants goalkeeper |url=https://www.port-vale.co.uk/news/2023/june/conor-grant-joins-the-valiants/ |access-date=28 June 2023 |publisher=Port Vale |date=28 June 2023}}

|-

| 30 June 2023 || CF || {{flagicon|WAL}} Luke Jephcott || {{fbaicon|SCO}} St Johnstone || Released || {{cite news |title=Welsh striker Jephcott joins St Johnstone |url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/66271314 |access-date=21 July 2023 |publisher=British Broadcasting Corporation |date=21 July 2023}}

|-

| 30 June 2023 || LB || {{flagicon|ENG}} Ryan Law || {{fbaicon|ENG}} Truro City || Released || {{cite news |title=Law, Craske and Pursall to Depart |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/law-craske-and-pursall-depart |access-date=5 May 2023 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=5 May 2023}}{{cite news |title=Law Returns to The White Tigers |url=https://www.trurocityfc.net/news/obed-yeboah-signs-for-the-white-tigers-2793125.html |access-date=26 July 2023 |publisher=Truro City |date=26 July 2023}}

|-

| 30 June 2023 || CM || {{flagicon|ENG}} Danny Mayor || {{fbaicon|ENG}} Fleetwood Town || Released || {{cite news |title=Experienced midfielder Danny Mayor added to Town's ranks |url=https://www.fleetwoodtownfc.com/news/2023/june/mayor-signing-announcement/ |access-date=26 June 2023 |publisher=Fleetwood Town FC |date=26 June 2023}}

|-

| 30 June 2023 || GK || {{flagicon|ENG}} James Morley || {{fbaicon|ENG}} Dobwalls || Released || {{cite news |title=Dobwalls sign Argyle Academy goalkeeper Morley |url=https://www.cornish-times.co.uk/sport/football/dobwalls-sign-argyle-academy-goalkeeper-morley-619774 |access-date=9 June 2023 |publisher=The Cornish Times |date=9 June 2023}}

|-

| 30 June 2023 || GK || {{flagicon|ENG}} Adam Parkes || {{fbaicon|ENG}} Plymouth Parkway || Released || {{cite news |title=Parkway capture Adams Parkes signature |url=https://www.ppfc.co.uk/parkway-capture-adam-parkes-signature/ |access-date=17 August 2023 |publisher=Plymouth Parkway FC |date=17 August 2023}}

|-

| 30 June 2023 || DF || {{flagicon|ENG}} Sam N'Sapu || {{fbaicon|}} Free agent || Released ||

|-

| 30 June 2023 || CB || {{flagicon|ENG}} Brandon Pursall || {{fbaicon|}} Free agent || Released ||

|-

| 30 June 2023 || CB || {{flagicon|WAL}} James Wilson || {{fbaicon|ENG}} Bristol Rovers || Released || {{cite news |title=Wilson to Depart |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/wilson-depart |access-date=13 June 2023 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=13 June 2023}}{{cite news |title=Bristol Rovers sign defender Wilson |url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/66004253 |access-date=23 June 2023 |publisher=British Broadcasting Corporation |date=23 June 2023}}

|-

| 12 January 2024 || CB || {{flagicon|ENG}} Macaulay Gillesphey || {{fbaicon|ENG}} Charlton Athletic || Undisclosed || {{cite news |title=Gillesphey Signs for Charlton Athletic |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/gillesphey-signs-charlton-athletic |access-date=12 January 2024 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=12 January 2024}}

|-

| 31 January 2024 || DM || {{flagicon|ENG}} Matt Butcher || {{fbaicon|ENG}} Wycombe Wanderers || Mutual Consent || {{cite news |title=Matt Butcher Leaves Argyle |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/matt-butcher-leaves-argyle |access-date=31 January 2024 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=31 January 2024}}{{cite news |title=Butcher's a Blue |url=https://www.wwfc.com/news/2024/january/31/butchers-a-blue/ |access-date=31 January 2024 |publisher=Wycombe Wanderers FC |date=31 January 2024}}

|}

{{notelist}}

On June 7, Plymouth Argyle announced their pre-season schedule, with friendlies against Plymouth Parkway, Torquay United, Forest Green Rovers, Salford City and Swindon Town.{{cite news |title=Pre-season schedule confirmed |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/pre-season-schedule-confirmed-0 |access-date=7 June 2023 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=7 June 2023}} A week later, a trip to Spain to face Scottish side Heart of Midlothian was also confirmed.{{cite news |title=Argyle To Play Hearts In Spain |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/argyle-play-hearts-spain |access-date=15 June 2023 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=15 June 2023}}

{{legend2|#CCFFCC|Win|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFFFCC|Draw|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFCCCC|Loss|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFFFFF|Fixtures|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = Friendly

| date = 6 July 2023

| time = 18:00 CEST
17:00 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 1–0

| result = W

| report = https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/issaka-sets-hearts-racing-pre-season-win

| team2 = Heart of Midlothian

| goals1 = Issaka {{goal|21}}

| stadium = Marbella Football Centre

| location = Marbella, Spain

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = Friendly

| date = 11 July 2023

| time = 19:30 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Parkway

| score = 0–2

| result = W

| report = https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/match-report-waine-and-hardie-strike-sink-parkway

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals2 = Waine {{goal|5}}
Hardie {{goal|83}}

| stadium = Bolitho Park

| location = Manadon

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = Friendly

| date = 15 July 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Blackpool

| score = 1–2

| result = W

| report = https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/match-report-blackpool-1-argyle-2

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 = Lavery {{goal||pen.}}

| goals2 = Miller {{goal}}
Hardie {{goal|}}

| stadium = Bloomfield Road

| location = Blackpool

| referee = Leigh Doughty

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = Friendly

| date = 18 July 2023

| time = 19:30 BST

| team1 = Torquay United

| score = 1–1

| result = D

| report = https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/match-report-argyle-share-spoils-plainmoor

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 = Ash {{goal|76}}

| goals2 = Whittaker {{goal|29}}

| stadium = Plainmoor

| location = Torquay

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = Friendly

| date = 22 July 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 5–1

| result = W

| report = https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/report-argyle-5-forest-green-rovers-1

| team2 = Forest Green Rovers

| goals1 = Hardie {{goal|24||29}}
Mumba {{goal|38}}
Wright {{goal|48}}
Whittaker {{goal|59}}

| goals2 = Stevens {{goal|33}}

| stadium = Harper's Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 0 (behind-closed-doors)

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = Friendly

| date = 25 July 2023

| time = 19:30 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = Cancelled

| result = P

| team2 = Salford City

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| note = Fixture was cancelled due to Home Park pitch undergoing resurfacing works.{{cite news |title=Changes to Argyle pre-season schedule |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/changes-argyle-pre-season-schedule |access-date=13 July 2023 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=13 July 2023}}

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = Friendly

| date = 29 July 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Swindon Town

| score = 3–1

| result = L

| report = https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/report-swindon-town-3-argyle-1-0

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 = Kemp {{goal|57}}
Hepburn-Murphy {{goal|59}}
Wakeling {{goal|86}}

| goals2 = Whittaker {{goal|69}}

| stadium = County Ground

| location = Swindon

}}

{{Fb overview2

|c=3

|c1=Championship |fm1= |lm1= |sr1=Matchday 1 |fp1= |w1=11 |d1=12 |l1=19 |f1=57 |a1=66

|c2=FA Cup |fm2= |lm2= |sr2=Third round |fp2=Fourth round |w2=1 |d2=1 |l2=1 |f2=5 |a2=6

|c3=EFL Cup |fm3= |lm3= |sr3=First round |fp3=Second round |w3=1 |d3=0 |l3=1 |f3=4 |a3=4

|u=9 April 2024

|s=[https://int.soccerway.com/teams/england/plymouth-argyle-fc/701/ Soccerway]

}}

{{main|2023–24 EFL Championship}}

{{:2023–24 EFL Championship|showteam=PLY}}

{{Fb_rs |hw=10 |hd=5 |hl=7 |hgf=41 |hga=34 |aw=3 |ad=7 |al=14 |agf=18 |aga=36 }}

{{Fb_rs footer|u=4 May 2024|s=[https://int.soccerway.com/teams/england/plymouth-argyle-fc/701/ Soccerway]}}

{{#invoke:sports rbr table|table|legendpos=b

| update=20 April 2024

| header=Round

| rnd29=30 |rnd30=31 |rnd31=32 |rnd32=33 |rnd33=29¹

| label1=Ground

| res1=H/A/H/A/H/A/A/H/A/H/H/A/H/A/H/A/H/A/H/A/A/H/H/A/A/H/A/H/A/A/H/H/H/A/H/A/A/H/A/H/A/H/H/A/A/H

| label2= Result

| res2=W/D/L/L/W/L/L/W/D/L/L/D/W/L/D/L/W/L/W/L/D/W/D/D/L/D/D/W/W/L/D/L/L/W/L/L/D/L/L/L/W/D/W/L/L/W

| label3= Position

| pos3=3/4/11/16/10/14/18/12/13/16/18/21/17/19/19/19/19/20/16/18/18/16/17/16/18/18/19/15/15/15/15/16/16/15/16/16/17/18/20/21/19/20/18/20/21/21

| color_W=green2|text_W=Win

| color_D=yellow2|text_D=Draw

| color_L=red2|text_L=Loss

| color_P=lightgrey|text_P=Postponed

| text_H=Home|text_A=Away

| color1=gold|color_2=green1|color_3-6=blue1|color_22–24=red1

| source=[https://int.soccerway.com/teams/england/plymouth-argyle-fc/701/ Soccerway]

| notes= {{plainlist|

• ¹ Matchday 29 (vs West Bromwich Albion) was postponed due to both sides continued involvement in the FA Cup.}}

}}

On 22 June, the EFL Championship fixtures were released.{{cite news |title=2023/24 Fixtures Announced |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/202324-fixtures-announced |access-date=22 June 2023 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=22 June 2023}}

{{legend2|#CCFFCC|Win|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFFFCC|Draw|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFCCCC|Loss|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFFFFF|Fixtures|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 1

| date = 5 August 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 3–1

| result = W

| report = https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/66345297

| team2 = Huddersfield Town

| goals1 = Whittaker {{goal|6}}
Mumba {{goal|73}}
Hardie {{goal|76}}
Edwards {{yel|88}}

| goals2 = Helik {{goal|45+6}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,446

| referee = Matt Donohue

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 2

| date = 12 August 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Watford

| score = 0–0

| result = D

| report = https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/66413440

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals2 = Scarr {{yel|71}}
Mumba {{yel|78}}

| stadium = Vicarage Road

| location = Watford

| referee = Geoff Eltringham

| attendance = 19,446

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 3

| date = 19 August 2023

| time = 12:30 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 1–2

| result = L

| report = https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/66482267

| team2 = Southampton

| goals1 =

• Scarr {{yel|10}}
• Hardie {{goal|51}} {{yel|58}}

| goals2 =

• Armstrong {{yel|30}}
• Charles {{yel|42}}
• Tella {{goal|49}}
• Manning {{yel|74}}
• Stephens {{yel|90+1}}
• Adams {{goal|90+4}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| referee = David Webb

| attendance = 16,392

| note = Live on Sky Sports

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 4

| date = 26 August 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Birmingham City

| score = 2–1

| result = L

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/birmingham-city-vs-plymouth-argyle/report/484738

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Hogan {{goal|8}}
• Sanderson {{yel|23}}
• Buchanan {{yel|73}}
• Stansfield {{goal|90+5}}

| goals2 =

• Randell {{yel|49}}
• Hardie {{goal|60}}

| stadium = St Andrew's Stadium

| location = Bordesley

| referee = John Busby

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 5

| date = 2 September 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 3–0

| result = W

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/plymouth-argyle-vs-blackburn-rovers/report/484756

| team2 = Blackburn Rovers

| goals1 =

• Azaz {{goal|27}}
• Whittaker {{yel|36}}
• Hardie {{yel|41}} {{goal|77}}
• Cundle {{goal|80}}

| goals2 =

• Pickering {{yel|88}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,067

| referee = Stephen Martin

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 6

| date = 16 September 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Preston North End

| score = 2–1

| result = L

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/preston-north-end-vs-plymouth-argyle/484769

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Holmes {{goal|1}}, {{yel|32}}
• Ledson {{yel|22}}
• McCann {{yel|89}}
• Cundle {{goal|80}}

| goals2 =

• Miller {{yel|19}}
• Hardie {{goal|61}}

| stadium = Deepdale

| location = Preston

| attendance = 17,542

| referee = Gavin Ward

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 7

| date = 19 September 2023

| time = 19:45 BST

| team1 = Bristol City

| score = 4–1

| result = L

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/bristol-city-vs-plymouth-argyle/report/484774

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Bell {{goal|3}}
• James {{goal|8}}
• Sykes {{goal|33}}
• Wells {{yel|35}}
• Tanner {{yel|67}}
• Cornick {{goal|80}}
• Yeboah {{yel|90+3}}

| goals2 =

• Randell {{goal|26}}

| stadium = Ashton Gate Stadium

| location = Ashton Gate

| attendance = 23,017

| referee = Matt Donohue

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 8

| date = 23 September 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 6–2

| result = W

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/plymouth-argyle-vs-norwich-city/report/484792

| team2 = Norwich City

| goals1 =

• Whittaker {{goal|15||45+3||59}}
• Scarr {{goal|35}} {{yel|68}}
• Azaz {{goal|45+5}}
• Cundle {{goal|90+7}}

| goals2 =

• Idah {{goal|72||78|pen.}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,469

| referee = Andrew Kitchen

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 9

| date = 30 September 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Hull City

| score = 1–1

| result = D

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/hull-city-vs-plymouth-argyle/report/484802

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Slater {{goal|44}}
• Christie {{yel|90}}
• Delap {{yel|90+4}}

| goals2 =

• Randell {{goal|22}}
• Azaz {{yel|47}}
• Pleguezuelo {{yel|77}}

| stadium = MKM Stadium

| location = Kingston upon Hull

| attendance = 20,312

| referee = David Webb

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 10

| date = 3 October 2023

| time = 19:45 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 0–2

| result = L

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/plymouth-argyle-vs-millwall/report/484813

| team2 = Millwall

| goals1 =

• Miller {{yel|31}}
• Pleguezuelo {{yel|63}}

| goals2 =

• McNamara {{yel|52}}
• Campbell {{yel|54}}
• Cooper {{yel|54}}
• Flemming {{goal|59}}
• Leonard {{yel|89}}
• Wallace {{yel|90+4}}
• Norton-Cuffy {{yel|90+7}}
• Saville {{goal|90+7}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 15,891

| referee = Oliver Langford

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 11

| date = 7 October 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 1–3

| result = L

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/plymouth-argyle-vs-swansea-city/report/484829

| team2 = Swansea City

| goals1 =

• Cundle {{goal|18}}
• Whittaker {{yel|55}}
• Kesler-Hayden {{yel|79}}

| goals2 =

• Yates {{goal|56}}
• Cooper {{goal|68}}
• Key {{goal|90}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,463

| referee = Lewis Smith

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 12

| date = 21 October 2023

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = West Bromwich Albion

| score = 0–0

| result = D

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/west-bromwich-albion-vs-plymouth-argyle/report/484845

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Mowatt {{yel|35}}
• Bartley {{yel|77}}

| goals2 =

• Azaz {{yel|27}}
• Houghton {{yel|42}}
• Scarr {{yel|50}}
• Miller {{yel|55}}
• Mumba {{yel|84}}
• Cooper {{yel|85}}
• Kesler-Hayden {{yel|86}}

| stadium = The Hawthorns

| location = West Bromwich

| attendance = 24,732

| referee = Stephen Martin

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 13

| date = 25 October 2023

| time = 19:45 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 3–0

| result = W

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/plymouth-argyle-vs-sheffield-wednesday/484854

| team2 = Sheffield Wednesday

| goals1 = Houghton {{yel|41}}
Kesler-Hayden {{yel|43}}
Bundu {{goal|44}}
Whittaker {{goal|45+3}}
Hardie {{goal|76}}

| goals2 = Iorfa {{yel|42}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,225

| referee = James Linington

}}

{{Football box collapsible

|round = 14

|date = 28 October 2023

|time = 15:00 BST

|report = https://www.skysports.com/football/ipswich-town-vs-plymouth-argyle/484862

|score = 3–2

|result = L

|team1 = Ipswich Town

|team2 = Plymouth Argyle

|goals1 =

• Luongo {{yel|32}}
• Mumba {{goal|45+1|o.g.}}
• Hirst {{goal|54}}
• Woolfenden {{yel|66}}
• Williams {{yel|68}}
• Edmundson {{yel|74}}
• Harness {{goal|86}}

|goals2 =

• Whittaker {{goal|7}}
• Miller {{yel|28}}
• Mumba {{yel|62}}
• Edwards {{goal|90+1}}

|stadium = Portman Road

|location = Ipswich

|attendance = 29,027

|referee = Gavin Ward

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 15

| date = 4 November 2023

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 3–3

| result = D

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/plymouth-argyle-vs-middlesbrough/484876

| team2 = Middlesbrough

| goals1 =

• Mumba {{goal|34}}
• Azaz {{goal|38}}
• Miller {{yel|70}}
• Cundle {{yel|72}}
• Whittaker {{goal|77}}

| goals2 =

• Coburn {{goal|23}} {{penmiss}} 60' {{goal|60}} {{yel|62}}
• Crooks {{yel|30}}
• Greenwood {{goal|64}}
• van den Berg {{yel|66}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,471

| referee = Darren England

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 16

| date = 11 November 2023

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Leeds United

| score = 2–1

| result = L

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/leeds-united-vs-plymouth-argyle/484887

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• James {{goal|21}}
• Piroe {{goal|28}}
• Gruev {{yel|90+3}}

| goals2 =

• Randell {{yel|33}}
• Whittaker {{yel|61}}
• Edwards {{yel|66}}
• Waine {{goal|84}}
• Gibson {{yel|89}}

| stadium = Elland Road

| location = Leeds

| attendance = 36,718

| referee = Josh Smith

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 17

| date = 25 November 2023

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 2–0

| result = W

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/plymouth-argyle-vs-sunderland/report/484900

| team2 = Sunderland

| goals1 =

• Whittaker {{goal|24}}
• Cundle {{yel|26}}
• Azaz {{goal|40}}
• Kesler-Hayden {{yel|85}}
• Randell {{yel|90+1}}
• Mumba {{yel|90+2}}

| goals2 =

• O'Nien {{yel|85}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,457

| referee = James Bell

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 18

| date = 28 November 2023

| time = 19:45 GMT

| team1 = Coventry City

| score = 1–0

| result = L

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/coventry-city-vs-plymouth-argyle/report/484907

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Wright {{goal|75}}
• Bidwell {{yel|90+3}}

| goals2 =

• Houghton {{yel|76}}
• Cooper {{yel|76}}
• Gibson {{yel|83}}

| stadium = Coventry Building Society Arena

| location = Coventry

| attendance = 22,790

| referee = Andy Davies

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 19

| date = 2 December 2023

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 2–1

| result = W

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/plymouth-argyle-vs-stoke-city/484924

| team2 = Stoke City

| goals1 =

• Houghton {{yel|7}}
• Bundu {{goal|43}}
• Randell {{goal|90+7}}

| goals2 =

• Campbell {{goal|23}}
• Vidigal {{yel|57}}
• Pearson {{yel|63}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,371

| referee = Samuel Barrott

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 20

| date = 9 December 2023

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Leicester City

| score = 4–0

| report = https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/67598361

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Mavididi {{goal|14|pen.|52}}
• Daka {{goal|49}}
• Ndidi {{goal|55}}

| goals2 =

• Gibson {{yel|42}}
• Miller {{yel|44}}
• Galloway {{yel|67}}

| stadium = King Power Stadium

| location = Leicester

| attendance = 31,265

| referee = Sunny Sukhvir Gill

| result = L

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 21

| date = 13 December 2023

| time = 19:45 GMT

| team1 = Queens Park Rangers

| score = 0–0

| result = D

| report = https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/67633513

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Field {{yel|2}}
• Paal {{yel|31}}

| goals2 =

• Scarr {{sent off|0|25}}
• Cundle {{yel|86}}
• Butcher {{yel|90+3}}
• Hazard {{yel|90+6}}

| stadium = Loftus Road

| location = Shepherd's Bush

| attendance = 16,339

| referee = Tony Harrington

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 22

| date = 16 December 2023

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 3–2

| result = W

| report = https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/67667435

| team2 = Rotherham United

| goals1 =

• Azaz {{goal|45+5|pen.|52}}
• Whittaker {{goal|90+6}}

| goals2 =

• Lindsay {{goal|16}}, {{yel|49}}
• Ayala {{sent off|2|25|55}}
• Odoffin {{yel|36}}
• Nombe {{yel|45+3}}
• Eaves {{goal|77}}
• Rathbone {{yel|90+2}}
• Johansson {{yel|90+3}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,025

| referee = Gavin Ward

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 23

| date = 23 December 2023

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 3–3

| result = D

| report = https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/67735151

| team2 = Birmingham City

| goals1 =

• Edwards {{yel|26}}, {{goal|43}}
• Waine {{goal|68}}
• Whittaker {{goal|86}}
• Randell {{yel|90+1}}

| goals2 =

• Stansfield {{goal|15}}, {{yel|16}}
• James {{goal|39}}, {{yel|70}}
• Longelo {{yel|60}}
• Bacuna {{goal|62}}, {{yel|62}}
• Miyoshi {{yel|87}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,589

| referee = Graham Scott

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 24

| date = 26 December 2023

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Cardiff City

| score = 2–2

| result = D

| report = [https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/67756819 BBC report]
[https://www.skysports.com/football/cardiff-city-vs-plymouth-argyle/484979 Sky report]

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Butcher {{goal|31|o.g.}}
• Grant {{goal|47}}

| goals2 =

• Whittaker {{goal|18||66}}
• Gibson {{yel|44}}

| stadium = Cardiff City Stadium

| location = Cardiff

| attendance = 23,583

| referee = Andy Davies

| note =

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 25

| date = 29 December 2023

| time = 18:00 GMT

| team1 = Southampton

| score = 2–1

| result = L

| report = [https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/67798407 BBC report]

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Alcaraz {{goal|56}}
• Adams {{goal|63}}

| goals2 =

• Hardie {{goal|90+1}}

| stadium = St Mary's Stadium

| location = Southampton

| attendance = 30,559

| referee = James Linington

| note =

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 26

| date = 1 January 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 3–3

| result = D

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/plymouth-argyle-vs-watford/485008

| team2 = Watford

| goals1 =

• Azaz {{goal|20}}
• Whittaker {{goal|27}}
• Hardie {{goal|42}}
• Mumba {{yel|59}}
• Randell {{yel|86}}

| goals2 =

• Kayembe {{goal|11}}
• Koné {{goal|38}}
• Livermore {{yel|43}}
• Andrews {{goal|57}}
• Healey {{yel|87}}
• Asprilla {{yel|88}}
• Matheus Martins {{yel|88}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,355

| referee = Bobby Madley

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 27

| date = 13 January 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Huddersfield Town

| score = 1–1

| result = D

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/huddersfield-town-vs-plymouth-argyle/485017

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 = Koroma {{goal|38}}
Thomas {{yel|50}}

| goals2 = Whittaker {{goal|12}}
Wright {{yel|26}}
Hazard {{yel|62}}
Phillips {{yel|64}}
Randell {{yel|75}}

| stadium = Kirklees Stadium

| location = Huddersfield

| attendance = 20,253

| referee = Tom Nield

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 28

| date = 20 January 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 3–1

| result = W

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/plymouth-argyle-vs-cardiff-city/485032

| team2 = Cardiff City

| goals1 =

• Hardie {{goal|31||52}}
• Phillips {{yel|35}}
• Miller {{yel|41}}
• Mumba {{yel|50}}
• Scarr {{yel|61}}
• Whittaker {{goal|81}}

| goals2 =

• Ng {{goal|10}}, {{yel|38}}
• Mëïté {{yel|36}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,471

| referee = Steve Martin

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 30

| date = 3 February 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Swansea City

| score = 0–1

| result = W

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/swansea-city-vs-plymouth-argyle/485059

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Cabango {{yel|22}}
• Cooper {{yel|71}}

| goals2 =

• Whittaker {{goal|18}}
• Hazard {{yel|71}}
• Gyabi {{yel|76}}
• Miller {{yel|82}}

| stadium = Swansea.com Stadium

| location = Landore

| attendance = 16,965

| referee = Sam Allison

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 31

| date = 10 February 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Sunderland

| score = 3–1

| result = L

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2370888

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Ba {{yel|10}}
• Ekwah {{goal|52}}
• Clarke {{goal|59}}
• Bellingham {{goal|67}}

| goals2 =

• Whittaker {{yel|24}}
• Phillips {{yel|33}}
• Hardie {{goal|39}}
• Mumba {{yel|44}}
• Gyabi {{yel|69}}
• Sorinola {{yel|87}}

| stadium = Stadium of Light

| location = Sunderland

| attendance = 41,269

| referee = Anthony Backhouse

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 32

| date = 14 February 2024

| time = 19:45 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 2–2

| result = D

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2370898?

| team2 = Coventry City

| goals1 =

• Randell {{yel|18}}
• Whittaker {{goal|55}}
• Miller {{goal|68}}

| goals2 = Simms {{yel|63}}, {{goal|66}}

• Latibeaudiere {{yel|75}}
• Thomas {{yel|85}}
• Kitching {{goal|90+6}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,799

| referee = Keith Stroud

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 33

| date = 17 February 2024

| time = 12:30 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 0–2

| result = L

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2370908

| team2 = Leeds United

| goals1 =

• Randell {{yel|38}}
• Gibson {{yel|53}}

| goals2 =

• Gnonto {{goal|10}}
• Rutter {{goal|72}}
• Rodon {{yel|88}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,818

| referee = Matt Donohue

| note = Fixture was originally set for a 15:00 kick-off, but was pushed forward for live Sky Sports coverage.{{cite news |title=Leeds (H) Chosen By Sky Sports |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/leeds-h-chosen-sky-sports |access-date=4 January 2024 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=4 January 2024}}

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 29{{cite news |title=West Brom (H) New Date |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/west-brom-h-new-date |access-date=12 January 2024 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=12 January 2024}}

| date = 20 February 2024

| time = 19:45 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 0–3

| result = L

| report = https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/68280916

| team2 = West Bromwich Albion

| goals1 =

| goals2 = Kipre {{goal|61}}
Johnston {{goal|76}}
Fellows {{goal|90+1}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance =

| referee = Tom Nield

| note = Fixture was originally scheduled for 27 January, but was postponed due to both sides continued involvement in the FA Cup.{{cite news |title=Plymouth Argyle Trip To Be Rearranged |url=https://www.wba.co.uk/news/plymouth-argyle-trip-be-rearranged |access-date=8 January 2024 |publisher=West Bromwich Albion FC |date=8 January 2024}}

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 34

| date = 24 February 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Middlesbrough

| score = 0–2

| result = W

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2370920

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Ayling {{yel|37}}

| goals2 =

• Sorinola {{goal|7}}
• Miller {{yel|26}}
• Hardie {{goal|31}}

| stadium = Riverside Stadium

| location = Middlesbrough

| attendance = 25,578

| referee = Sunny Sukhvir Gill

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 35

| date = 2 March 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 0–2

| result = L

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2370932

| team2 = Ipswich Town

| goals1 =

• Galloway {{yel|72}}

| goals2 =

• Sarmiento {{yel|59}}
• Galloway {{goal|63|o.g.}}
• Chaplin {{yel|71}}
• Moore {{goal|74}}
• Travis {{yel|78}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 16,871

| referee = Josh Smith

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 36

| date = 5 March 2024

| time = 19:45 GMT

| team1 = Sheffield Wednesday

| score = 1–0

| result = L

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2370947

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Gassama {{goal|60}}
• Diaby {{yel|89}}

| goals2 =

• Forshaw {{yel|45}}
• Randell {{yel|58}}

| stadium = Hillsborough Stadium

| location = Owlerton

| attendance = 23,037

| referee = Stephen Martin

| note = Fixture was originally scheduled for 6 March, but was brought forward 24 hours for live Sky Sports coverage.{{cite news |title=Sheffield Wednesday (A) To Be Live On Sky Sports |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/sheffield-wednesday-be-live-sky-sports |access-date=15 February 2024 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=2 February 2024}}

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 37

| date = 9 March 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Blackburn Rovers

| score = 1–1

| result = D

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2370950

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Szmodics {{goal|7}}
• Brittain {{yel|33}}
• McFadzean {{sent off|0|54}}
• Ayari {{yel|90}}

| goals2 =

• Mumba {{yel|56}}
• Whittaker {{goal|74}}

| stadium = Ewood Park

| location = Blackburn

| referee = Andrew Kitchen

| attendance = 14,108

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 38

| date = 16 March 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 0–1

| result = L

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2370968?

| team2 = Preston North End

| goals1 =

• Miller {{yel|41}}
• Sousa {{yel|63}}

| goals2 =

• Keane {{yel|17}}
• Millar {{goal|43}}
• McCann {{yel|75}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| referee = John Busby

| attendance = 16,076

1049 away

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 39

| date = 29 March 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Norwich City

| score = 2–1

| result = L

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2370980

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Sargent {{goal|67}}
• Phillips {{goal|74|o.g.}}

| goals2 =

• Whittaker {{goal|10}}
• Randell {{yel|18}}
• Sorinola {{yel|30}}
• Miller {{yel|35}}
• Devine {{yel|70}}
• Houghton {{yel|70}}
• Forshaw {{yel|80}}
• Pleguezuelo {{yel|82}}

| stadium = Carrow Road

| location = Norwich

| referee = James Linington

| attendance = 26,622

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 40

| date = 1 April 2024

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 0–1

| result = L

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2370992?

| team2 = Bristol City

| goals1 =

• Devine {{sent off|2|54|78}}
• Gibson {{yel|62}}
• Houghton {{yel|90}}

| goals2 =

• Twine {{yel|28}}
• Wells {{goal|57}}, {{yel|90+6}}
• Pring {{yel|88}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| referee = Keith Stroud

| attendance = 16,866

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 41

| date = 5 April 2024

| time = 20:00 BST

| team1 = Rotherham United

| score = 0–1

| result = W

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2371006

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals2 =

• Mumba {{goal|32}}

| stadium = New York Stadium

| location = Rotherham

| referee = Oliver Langford

| attendance = 9,863

| note = Fixture was initially scheduled for 6 April, but was moved for live Sky Sports coverage.{{cite news |title=Rotherham (A) Chosen By Sky Sports |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/rotherham-chosen-sky-sports |access-date=15 March 2024 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=7 March 2024}}

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 42

| date = 9 April 2024

| time = 19:45 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 1–1

| result = D

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2371012

| team2 = Queens Park Rangers

| goals1 =

• Adomah {{goal|85|o.g.}}

| goals2 =

• Dykes {{yel|42}}
• Field {{goal|73}}
• Willock {{yel|90+6}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| referee = Jeremy Simpson

| attendance = 16,928

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 43

| date = 12 April 2024

| time = 20:00 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 1–0

| result = W

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2371028

| team2 = Leicester City

| goals1 =

• Bundu {{goal|21}}
• Miller {{yel|30}}
• Forshaw {{yel|41}}
• Hardie {{yel|49}}
• Whittaker {{yel|50}}
• Waine {{yel|90+1}}

| goals2 =

• Ndidi {{yel|45+4}}
• Vestergaard {{yel|69}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| referee = Robert Jones

| attendance = 16,861

| note = Fixture was initially scheduled for 13 April, but was moved for live Sky Sports coverage.{{cite news |title=Leicester City (H) Chosen By Sky Sports |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/leicester-city-h-chosen-sky-sports |access-date=15 March 2024 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=13 March 2024}}

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 44

| date = 20 April 2024

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Stoke City

| score = 3–0

| result = L

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2371043

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Wilmot {{yel|26}}
• Campbell {{yel|36}}
• Hoever {{yel|36}}, {{goal|43}}
• Manhoef {{goal|45+2}}
• Burger {{goal|90+3}}

| goals2 =

• Cooper {{yel|35}}
• Mumba {{yel|36}}
• Scarr {{yel|62}}
• Devine {{yel|69}}

| stadium = bet365 Stadium

| location = Stoke-on-Trent

| referee = Bobby Madley

| attendance = 24,674

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 45

| date = 27 April 2024

| time = 15:00 BST

| team1 = Millwall

| score = 1–0

| result = L

| report = https://www.efl.com/match-centre/g2371051

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Cooper {{goal|83}}

| goals2 =

| stadium = The Den

| location = Bermondsey

| referee = Andy Davies

| attendance = 17,863

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = 46

| date = 4 May 2024

| time = 12:30 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 1–0

| result = W

| report = https://www.skysports.com/football/news/11688/13126887/plymouth-argyle-1-0-hull-city-joe-edwards-winner-keeps-pilgrims-in-the-sky-bet-championship

| team2 = Hull City

| goals1 =

• Edwards {{goal|40}}

| goals2 =

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| referee = Darren Bond

| attendance = 16,881

}}

{{main|2023–24 FA Cup}}

Plymouth joined the competition in the third round, and were drawn at home to Sutton United,{{cite news |title=Argyle drawn at Home to Sutton in the Emirates FA Cup |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/argyle-drawn-home-sutton-emirates-fa-cup |access-date=11 December 2023 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=3 December 2023}} then away to Leeds United in the fourth round.{{cite news |title=Argyle Away To Leeds United In The Emirates FA Cup Fourth Round |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/argyle-away-leeds-united-emirates-fa-cup-fourth-round |access-date=8 January 2024 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=8 January 2024}}{{cite news |title=Norwich & Plymouth home games confirmed |url=https://www.leedsunited.com/news/team-news/32717/fixtures-norwich-plymouth-home-games-confirmed |access-date=12 January 2024 |publisher=Leeds United FC |date=12 January 2024}}

{{legend2|#CCFFCC|Win|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFFFCC|Draw|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFCCCC|Loss|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFFFFF|Fixtures|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = Third round

| date = 6 January 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 3–1

| result = W

| report =

| team2 = Sutton United

| goals1 =

• Cundle {{goal|18}}
• Edwards {{yel|65}}
• Hardie {{goal|68|pen.}}
• Whittaker {{goal|90+1}}

| goals2 =

• Kizzi {{yel|34}}
• Angol {{goal|50}}
• Clay {{yel|60}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 15,643

| referee = Will Finnie

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = Fourth round

| date = 27 January 2024

| time = 15:00 GMT

| team1 = Leeds United

| score = 1–1

| result = D

| report =

| team2 = Plymouth Argyle

| goals1 =

• Anthony {{goal|31}}, {{yel|31}}

| goals2 =

• Randell {{goal|73}}

| stadium = Elland Road

| location = Leeds

| attendance = 35,247

| referee = Lewis Smith

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = Fourth round replay

| date = 6 February 2024

| time = 19:45 GMT

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 1–4

| aet = yes

| result = L

| report = https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/68204371

| team2 = Leeds United

| goals1 =

• Wright {{yel|58}}
• Galloway {{goal|78}}
• Phillips {{yel|80}}

| goals2 =

• Gnonto {{goal|66}}
• Rodon {{yel|70}}
• Summerville {{goal|97}}
• Rutter {{goal|111}}
• Hardie {{goal|117|o.g.|}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance =

| referee = Rob Jones

}}

{{main|2023–24 EFL Cup}}

Plymouth were drawn at home to Leyton Orient in the first round{{cite news |title=Argyle Drawn At Home To Leyton Orient In The Carabao Cup |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/argyle-drawn-home-leyton-orient-carabao-cup |access-date=22 June 2023 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=22 June 2023}} and to Crystal Palace in the second round.{{cite news |title=Argyle draw Crystal Palace at home in The Carabao Cup |url=https://www.pafc.co.uk/news/argyle-draw-crystal-palace-home-carabao-cup |access-date=10 August 2023 |publisher=Plymouth Argyle FC |date=9 August 2023}}

{{legend2|#CCFFCC|Win|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFFFCC|Draw|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFCCCC|Loss|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{legend2|#FFFFFF|Fixtures|border=1px solid #AAAAAA}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = First round

| date = 8 August 2023

| time = 19:45 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 2–0

| result = W

| report = https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/66368510

| team2 = Leyton Orient

| goals1 =

• Waine {{goal|25||38}}
  Cundle {{yel|48}}

| goals2 =

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 10,324

| referee = Sunny Sukhvir Gill

}}

{{football box collapsible

| round = Second round

| date = 29 August 2023

| time = 19:45 BST

| team1 = Plymouth Argyle

| score = 2–4

| result = L

| report = https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/66577563

| team2 = Crystal Palace

| goals1 =

• Waine {{goal|6}}
  Cundle {{goal|46}}

| goals2 = Édouard {{goal|58}}
Mateta {{goal|61||62||83}}

| stadium = Home Park

| location = Plymouth

| attendance = 15,826

| referee = Dean Whitestone

}}

{{reflist}}

{{Plymouth Argyle F.C.}}

{{Plymouth Argyle F.C. seasons}}

{{2023–24 in English men's football}}

{{DEFAULTSORT:2023-24 Plymouth Argyle F.C. Season}}

Category:Plymouth Argyle F.C. seasons

Plymouth Argyle F.C.

Category:English football clubs 2023–24 season