Blaine faction

{{Infobox political party

| name = Blaine faction

| leader = James G. Blaine
William P. Frye
Eugene Hale
William H. Robertson{{Cite web|title=The Remarkable Roscoe, Part III|url=https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/the-remarkable-roscoe-part-iii.htm|access-date=2023-01-13|website=www.nps.gov|language=en}}
William E. Chandler{{Cite web|title=James A. Garfield and Chester A. Arthur|author=Bernard A. Weisberger|url=https://www.encyclopedia.com/history/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/james-garfield-and-chester-arthur|access-date=2023-01-13|website=www.encyclopedia.com}}

| foundation = 1877

| ideology = Anti-Grantism{{Cite web|title=The Remarkable Roscoe: Friend and Nemesis of Presidents (Part I)|url=https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/the-remarkable-roscoe-friend-and-nemesis-of-presidents-part-i.htm|access-date=2023-01-13|website=www.nps.gov|language=en}}
Conservative liberalism
Classical liberalism
Economic nationalism
Protectionism
Hard money
Pro-spoils systemThis was prior to the Garfield assassination; the Blaine faction were not hostile to civil service reform afterwards.

| position = Center to Center-right

| country = the United States

| dissolution =

| split = Stalwart faction of the Republican Party

| footnotes =

| merged = Half-Breed faction of the Republican Party

| national = Republican Party
Half-Breed faction (1880)

}}

File:James G. Blaine - Brady-Handy.jpg by the Brady-Handy Photograph Collection.]]

The Blaine faction,{{Cite news|date=1880-04-22|title=THE GEORGIA REPUBLICANS.; SHERMAN AND BLAINE FACTIONS UNITING AND TRYING TO OVERPOWER THE SUPERIOR NUMBERS OF GRANT DELEGATES.|language=en-US|work=The New York Times|url=https://www.nytimes.com/1880/04/22/archives/the-georgia-republicans-sherman-and-blaine-factions-uniting-and.html|access-date=2023-01-13|issn=0362-4331}}{{Cite book|last=Conlin|first=Joseph R.|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=cXQWAAAAQBAJ&dq=blaine+faction&pg=PA436|title=The American Past: A Survey of American History|date=2013-01-29|publisher=Cengage Learning|isbn=978-1-285-50007-2|language=en|page=436}}{{Cite book|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=HO04AQAAMAAJ&dq=blaine+faction&pg=PA185|title=The Nation|volume=43|date=1886|language=en}}{{Cite news|date=1888-12-30|title=WHICH WOULD BE THE PREFERABLE ROW?|language=en-US|work=The New York Times|url=https://www.nytimes.com/1888/12/30/archives/which-would-be-the-preferable-row.html|access-date=2023-01-13|issn=0362-4331}}{{Cite book|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=ZpFEAQAAMAAJ&dq=blaine+faction&pg=PA632|title=Belford's Monthly|date=1890|volume=5|publisher=Belford, Clarke|language=en|page=632}}{{Cite news|date=1892-06-14|title=BOUTELLE FEELS VERY BAD.; HE DON'T LIKE THE WAY BLAINE AND HIS FRIENDS HAVE BEEN TREATED.|language=en-US|work=The New York Times|url=https://www.nytimes.com/1892/06/14/archives/boutelle-feels-very-bad-he-dont-like-the-way-blaine-and-his-friends.html|access-date=2023-01-13|issn=0362-4331}}{{Cite book|last1=Hammond|first1=Scott John|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=G8LWCwAAQBAJ&dq=blaine+faction&pg=PA572|title=Campaigning for President in America, 1788–2016|last2=Roberts|first2=Robert North|last3=Sulfaro|first3=Valerie A.|date=2016-04-25|publisher=ABC-CLIO|isbn=978-1-4408-5079-0|language=en|page=572}} also known as the Blaine section,{{Cite journal|last=Peskin|first=Allan|date=1984|title=Who Were the Stalwarts? Who Were Their Rivals? Republican Factions in the Gilded Age|journal=Political Science Quarterly|volume=99|issue=4|page=705|doi=10.2307/2150708|jstor=2150708 |issn=0032-3195}} was a political organization[https://web.archive.org/web/20211001182336/https://www.senate.gov/about/officers-staff/vice-president/morton-levi.htm About the Vice President | Levi Parsons Morton, 22nd Vice President (1889-1893)]. United States Senate via Internet Archive. Retrieved February 3, 2022. of Republicans in the United States during the presidency of Rutherford B. Hayes who coalesced around Maine U.S. senator James G. Blaine. Forming a coalition with the conservative Stalwart wing during the era,Banks, Ronald F. (June 1958). [https://digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4318&context=etd The Senatorial Career of William P. Frye], p. 5–6. The University of Maine. Retrieved February 3, 2022. they opposed civil service reform, as well as the conciliatory actions of the Hayes administration towards the South. Blaine himself would vote with Stalwarts in opposition to President Hayes' reform efforts, siding with Conkling's faction in December 1877 when voting against the nomination of Theodore Roosevelt Sr., to become New York Custom of Collectors.{{Cite web|title=TO CONSENT TO THE NOMINATION OF THEODORE ROOSEVELT AS COLLECTOR … -- Senate Vote #95 -- Dec 12, 1877|url=https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/45-2/s95|access-date=2023-01-13|website=GovTrack.us|language=en}}{{primary source inline|date=February 2024}}

The faction in the context of the Hayes years is often erroneously attributed as the congressional "Half-Breeds", a moderate wing of the Republican Party which advocated civil service reform. According to Richard E. Welch Jr., Blaine was not a Half-Breed during this time, instead taking part as a dissident member of the Stalwarts.{{sfn|Welch|p=91}} Half-Breeds trusted neither Blaine or Grant, preferring a "third man" for president in the 1880 United States presidential election who was a loyal advocate of civil service reform.Welch, Richard E., Jr. (1968). [https://vermonthistory.org/journal/misc/GeorgeEdmunds.pdf George Edmunds of Vermont: Republican Half-Breed], pp. 67–68. Vermont History. Retrieved February 3, 2022. According to Allan Peskin, Blaine never referred to his allies as "Half-Breeds", instead preferring the term "the Blaine Section".

The ambiguity between the Blaine faction and Half-Breeds regarding most of the Hayes presidency years is a revisionist historical inaccuracy that ignores the sharp contrasts between the groups; Blaine sharply came at odds with Hayes after 1877, and a mutual bitter antipathy was held between him and Half-Breed leader John Sherman that lasted for over a decade.Who Were the Stalwarts? Who Were Their Rivals? Republican Factions in the Gilded Age, p. 706.

Blaine's chief allies during the presidency of Rutherford B. Hayes were William P. Frye and Eugene Hale, both of whom later served in the United States Senate from Maine as colleagues.

Characteristics

The division and antipathy between the Conkling and Blaine factions was attributed to a personal rivalry between the two political bosses dating since the 1860s. However, their political machines had little differences between them, benefiting from patronage and the practices of the traditional spoils system. While the political organization of Roscoe Conkling emphasized support for "sound money" (also known as "hard money") in their association with New York financial interests, the Blaine organization placed stronger focus on industrial and railroad interests, in addition to their advocacy of the protective tariff.

{{multiple image

|direction=horizontal

|image1=William P. Frye - Brady-Handy.jpg

|width1=182

|caption1=Portrait of William P. Frye.

|image2=Eugene Hale - Brady-Handy.jpg

|width2=195

|caption2=Portrait of Eugene Hale.

}}

Hayes presidency

During the 1876 United States presidential election, Sen. Blaine supported the campaign of Rutherford Hayes against Bourbon Democrat opponent Samuel J. Tilden. Following the Compromise of 1877 and the Hayes administration's withdrawal of troops of the South, Blaine was grieved and distraught over the abandonment of Reconstruction efforts to an extent greater than the anguish expressed by Stalwart leaders Roscoe Conkling, J. Donald Cameron, and Zachariah Chandler.{{sfn|Muzzey|pp=130–133}}

The Blaine faction frequently sparred with the Hayes administration on occasions. At the residence of fellow U.S. senator John Sherman, Sen. Blaine advocated an appointment by Hayes of William Frye to become Attorney General of the United States. Instead, Hayes offered to grant the position to Eugene Hale, although Blaine intended to succeed Maine Sen. Hannibal Hamlin with Hale. The tension increased when Hayes had appointed staunch reformer Carl Schurz to become United States Secretary of the Interior. Schurz in the 1872 United States presidential election led the Liberal Republican Party revolt against Ulysses S. Grant, who Blaine campaigned on behalf of.{{sfn|Muzzey|p=66}}

In a temporary victory for Stalwarts on one occasion, Conkling secured the powerful position of Collector of the Port of New York for loyalist and future president Chester A. Arthur.{{Cite web|title=Stalwarts, Half Breeds, and Political Assassination |url=https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/stalwarts-half-breeds-and-political-assassination.htm|access-date=2023-01-13|website=www.nps.gov|language=en}} Arthur's tenure was marked with cronyism and corruption, hiring thousands of Republicans on the mere basis of political affiliation.{{Cite web|title=Arthur, Chester A.|url=https://www.encyclopedia.com/history/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/arthur-chester|access-date=2023-01-13|website=www.encyclopedia.com}} Hayes and Secretary of the Treasury John Sherman, a Half-Breed, subsequently fired Arthur from the post. The decision elicited criticism and distaste by both Stalwarts and the Blaine faction.{{Cite journal|last1=Corbett|first1=P. Scott|last2=Janssen|first2=Volker|last3=Lund|first3=John M.|last4=Pfannestiel|first4=Todd|last5=Waskiewicz|first5=Sylvie|last6=Vickery|first6=Paul|date=2014-12-30|title=The Key Political Issues: Patronage, Tariffs, and Gold|url=https://pressbooks.online.ucf.edu/osushistory/chapter/the-key-political-issues-patronage-tariffs-and-gold/|language=en}} The rift between the Blaine faction and the Hayes administration subsequently reached a point that effectively sealed any remaining chances for Hayes' potential re-election.

When Hayes nominated reform-friendly allies Edwin A. Merritt and Silas W. Burt to the positions of New York Custom of Collectors and Naval Officer respectively, prominent Half-Breed leaders such as George F. Hoar and Stanley Matthews voted to consent to the president's nominations while Blaine joined Stalwarts such as Conkling and William B. Allison in unsuccessful opposition.{{Cite web|title=TO CONSENT TO THE NOMINATION OF EDWIN A. MERRITT AS … -- Senate Vote #394 -- Feb 3, 1879|url=https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/45-3/s394|access-date=2023-01-13|website=GovTrack.us|language=en}}{{Cite web|title=TO CONSENT TO THE NOMINATION OF SILAS W. BURT AS … -- Senate Vote #395 -- Feb 3, 1879|url=https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/45-3/s395|access-date=2023-01-13|website=GovTrack.us|language=en}}{{primary source inline|date=February 2024}}

1880 Republican National Convention: Conkling and Blaine come to blows

In the 1880 United States presidential election, the Republican Party was marred by factionalism, divided into three main groups:

Stalwarts, headed by Roscoe Conkling, John A. Logan, as well as Simon Cameron and his son J. Donald CameronThe Senatorial Career of William P. Frye, p. 7.
Half-Breeds, headed by strategists George Frisbie Hoar, Henry L. Dawes and John D. Long of Massachusetts
the Blaine faction, organized by Frye and Hale

The Stalwarts pushed for a third, non-consecutive term for former president Ulysses S. Grant in their effort to revive the Radical Republicans' Reconstruction program of Thaddeus Stevens and Charles Sumner,{{sfn|Muzzey|p=160}} while Half-Breeds advocated a nomination of George F. Edmunds. There existed an irreconcilable feud between the Stalwarts and Blaine faction, attributed not to any grievances held by Grant, rather due to the persisting personal enmity between Conkling and Blaine.

According to Ronald F. Banks, Frye and Hale exhibited "amateurish and provincial" tendencies in their quarrels with Conkling, who humiliated Frye in a manner described as "half sneer and half insult." Frye reportedly only displayed "poise and eloquence" when seconding a nomination of Blaine.

Initially, none of the factions achieved their nomination aims. The Blaine faction and Half-Breeds ultimately formed an alliance to thwart the Stalwarts, throwing support to dark horse candidate James A. Garfield of Ohio. The Stalwarts' aims were weakened when pro-Grant New York Republicans were derailed by state senator and leading Blaine supporter William H. Robertson, whose opposition towards the Conkling forces triggered anti-Grant sentiment throughout the convention. A strategic maneuvering by Half-Breeds installed their leader Hoar as chairman of the convention, and Garfield was nominated. In the November general election, Garfield narrowly triumphed over Democratic nominee Winfield Scott Hancock.