Carolands

The woman who built Carolands, Harriett Pullman Carolan (1869–1956), was the daughter of George Pullman, a 19th-century industrialist, one of Chicago's wealthiest men, and founder of the Pullman Company, famous for its Palace railway cars. In Chicago in 1892, Harriett Pullman married Francis Carolan of San Francisco and moved with him to California. In 1912, she acquired {{convert |554|acres|ha|0}} of land in Hillsborough,{{cite web |url=http://carolands.org/history/ |title=History |author= |date=2015 |website=Carolands Foundation |access-date=19 March 2015 }} on which she intended to build a house and garden that would excite "the wonder and admiration of America" and reflect her many refined and cultivated interests.{{Citation |last=Price |first=Paul |date=March 2008 |title=Carolands Hillsborough, California |periodical=Architecture |pages=2}} The result was a masterpiece of Beaux-Arts architecture, inspired by the court architecture of Louis XIV. Carolan chose the site, the highest in the neighborhood, for its commanding views of the San Francisco Bay and the surrounding hills.

Harriett Carolan commissioned plans for the chateau from the Parisian architect Ernest Sanson, at the time France's foremost designer of prestigious private houses. Sanson was a classicist, and his design for the chateau's exterior was inspired by the 17th-century designs of François Mansart. He was seventy-six years old, near the end of a long and distinguished career, and never visited the California site. Carolan engaged the San Francisco-based Willis Polk, a distinguished architect in his own right, to be the structural designer and construction manager, instructing him to faithfully execute Sanson's designs.{{Citation |last=Price |first=Paul |date=March 2008 |title=Carolands Hillsborough, California |periodical=Architecture |pages=3}}

France's leading landscape architect, Achille Duchêne, designed Carolands' gardens. Duchêne's work was inspired by the works of the great 17th-century landscape designer André Le Nôtre, whose most famous creations included the gardens at the Palace of Versailles, Vaux-le-Vicomte and the Jardins des Tuileries. In his original, ambitious design for Carolands, Duchêne planned miles of roadways leading across extensive grounds, landscaped with thousands of shrubs and trees, accented by fountains and statuary. Only a small portion of the scheme was ever built.

Soon after Harriett Carolan secured the land in 1912, Duchêne arrived in San Francisco to lay out the grand parterre gardens. In late 1913, Ernest Sanson began to design the house. His plans included a dry moat around two sides of the house, discreetly located to provide light and air, and access, to the service spaces in the basement, while not blocking views of the gardens from the principal rooms on the main floor. In his design, Sanson incorporated three 18th-century period rooms that Carolan had purchased in Paris with the advice of the famous antique dealer Boni de Castellane.

In 1914, Willis Polk began grading the great terraces planned by Duchêne, sending progress photographs to the owner and her architects. Polk began to build the reinforced concrete superstructure he had designed, creating the infill walls with brick, finishing them with concrete stucco, sanded and scored to resemble natural limestone.{{Citation |last=Price |first=Paul |date=March 2008 |title=Carolands Hillsborough, California |periodical=Architecture |pages=4}}

File:017416pv.jpg for HABS in August 1974]]

In mid-1916, the elaborate interior elements began arriving on the site. The house as completed had ninety-eight rooms, including nine bedrooms and baths for the owners and their guests, each with an antechamber to guarantee quiet and privacy. The service spaces were equally elaborate: a kitchen with walls and ceiling made of white glass tiles; a service elevator connecting all floors; and a butler's pantry and mezzanine with walls of Delftware tile. In the fall of 1916, Harriett and Frank Carolan moved in with their staff.

Harriett Carolan did not use her house for long: she separated from Frank Carolan in 1917 and closed the chateau the following year. After the separation, she moved to New York City, while Frank remained in California where he died in 1923. Two years later, Harriett married Col. Arthur Schermerhorn, and while the couple occasionally occupied Carolands, in 1928 Harriett removed her furniture and put the property up for sale.

The U.S. Government considered buying Carolands to use as a Western White House in 1939,{{cite news |url=http://www.sfmuseum.org/hist10/carolans.html |title=One of Peninsula's First Fashionables Slips Into Town |author=Robbins, Mildred Brown |date=1 October 1939 |newspaper=San Francisco Chronicle |access-date=25 March 2015 |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20150402025116/http://www.sfmuseum.org/hist10/carolans.html |archive-date=2 April 2015 }} and again during the Kennedy administration, but both times declined to purchase.

In 1945, Tomlinson Moseley bought the house and surrounding 550 acres (2.2 km²) from the Schermerhorns and began to sub-divide the land and build additional houses. In 1947, Life Magazine published an article about a charity event held at the house,{{cite journal |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=60kEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA138 |title=Life Goes to a Party in a Deserted Mansion |author= |date=17 March 1947 |journal=LIFE Magazine |access-date=19 March 2015 }} the first opportunity for San Francisco-area residents to see its interior. According to the article, the house had been abandoned for twenty-five years, so that plumbing for the event had to be provided by a fire hose, and lighting required the use of portable generators and flood lights.

File:017413pv.jpg

In 1948, Moseley sold the property, by then reduced to {{convert |25|acres|ha|0}}, to Mrs. S. Coe Robinson. By 1950, she had carved off much of the remaining land into smaller parcels and begun to contemplate demolishing the house.

Countess Lillian Remillard Dandini purchased Carolands Chateau in 1950,{{cite news |url=http://www.sfgate.com/homeandgarden/article/THE-HOUSE-ON-THE-HILL-After-four-years-and-20-2582214.php |title=The House on the Hill: After four years and $20 million, the famed Carolands mansion is set for another century |author=Richter, Judy |date=11 July 2007 |newspaper=San Francisco Chronicle |access-date=19 March 2015 }} saving it from demolition by speculators interested in developing the land, and uninterested in the house's architectural significance. Prior to her marriage in 1932 to Mexican-born Count Alessandro Dandini di Cesena, Lillian Remillard was an heir to the Remillard Brothers fortune, which derived from a brick manufacturing business dating back to California's gold rush, a business that benefitted greatly from the construction boom following the 1906 earthquake. During the twenty-three years (until her death) that she lived at Carolands, the countess entertained often and made the house available for numerous charity benefits. She frequently invited San Francisco's French community to the house and opened it annually to the San Francisco Bay area's French students. Her generosity in sharing the house inspired the Town of Burlingame to give her the town's "Woman of the Year" award.

In her later years the Countess Dandini lacked the necessary funds to maintain the house, and after she died in 1973 it was once again at risk of demolition.{{cite web |url=http://lunaproductions.com/the-heiress-and-her-chateau/ |title=The Heiress and Her Chateau: Carolands of California |author= |date=2015 |website=Luna Productions |access-date=19 March 2015 }} The countess willed the house and the remaining {{convert |5.83|acre|m2}} to the Town of Hillsborough to be used as a French and Italian musical, artistic and literary center,{{cite news |url=http://www.insidebayarea.com/sanmateocountytimes/localnews/ci_3867593 |title=Chateau revived after much tragedy |author=Morente, Christine |date=26 May 2006 |publisher=Inside Bay eArea |access-date=20 March 2015 }} but was unable to include an endowment. The Town of Hillsborough declined the gift, ruling the proposed use inconsistent with the town's charter while noting it could not afford to pay the cost to maintain the property.

In 1975, the house was added to the list of California Historical Landmarks (CHL #886), and to the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP #75000478).{{cite web |url=https://npgallery.nps.gov/nrhp/GetAsset?assetID=fc3325cf-d6c5-41a2-a055-dd7a59485101 |format=pdf |title=National Register of Historic Places Inventory — Nomination Form: The Carolands |author1=Turner, Paul V. |author2=Eliassen Jr., John Weld |author3=Ringler, Donald P. |author4=Von Homola, Beatrice |website=United States National Park Service |date=7 April 1975 |access-date=7 March 2016 }} Nevertheless, Carolands suffered from frequent changes in ownership after Countess Dandini's death.

In 1976, Dr. Selwyn McCabe won the house in a probate auction, but declined to purchase, deferring to the next bidder, Rose 'Roz' Franks. In 1979, Franks lost the house to George I. Benny, who in turn lost it to foreclosure in 1982, after conviction for conspiring to defraud institutional lenders.

At the time, adult filmmakers gained access to the site where they produced the 1982 film All American Girls.{{Citation needed|date=June 2024}}

During these years, Carolands was often vacant, and curious local high school students often entered the house.{{cite news |url=http://www.insidebayarea.com/sanmateocountytimes/localnews/ci_3867589 |title=Chateau's troubled history attracts curious |author=Morente, Christine |date=26 May 2006 |publisher=Inside Bay Area |access-date=20 March 2015 }} In 1985, David Allen Raley, a security guard, lured two high school students onto the property where he sexually assaulted and stabbed them, leaving them for dead in a ravine near San Jose.{{cite news |url=http://www.mercurynews.com/history/ci_26545365/carolands-mansion-murder-testimony-from-david-raleys-trial |title=Carolands mansion murder: Testimony from David Raley's trial |author=Romero, Lorenzo |date=7 April 1987 |newspaper=San Jose Mercury News |access-date=20 March 2015 }} They managed to climb out of the ravine and flag down a passing motorist for help, but one later died of wounds received during the ordeal.{{cite news |url=https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=m7pPAAAAIBAJ&sjid=gVMDAAAAIBAJ&pg=6872%2C2737919 |title=Girls lured by attacker |author= |agency=UPI |date=5 February 1985 |newspaper=Mohave Daily Miner |access-date=20 March 2015 }} Raley had bragged earlier that day that he often received bribes from curious students interested in the mansion's interior, but that "he only let girls in."{{cite news |url=https://www.apnews.com/4ddb268116e3b58e326526855441cf0a |title=Authorities Say Police Buff Ran His Own Disneyland to Attract Girls |author= |agency=AP |date=5 February 1985 |work=AP News |access-date=26 September 2019 |archive-date=September 26, 2019 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20190926151450/https://www.apnews.com/4ddb268116e3b58e326526855441cf0a |url-status=dead }} He was convicted, and received the death penalty in 1988.{{cite news |url=http://www.mercurynews.com/crime-courts/ci_26545368/carolands-mansion-murder-survivor-laurie-mckenna-speaks-20 |title=Carolands mansion murder: Survivor Laurie McKenna speaks, 20 years later |author=Mintz, Howard |date=24 September 2006 |newspaper=San Jose Mercury News |access-date=20 March 2015 }}

{{multiple image

|image1=017418pv.jpg

|caption1=Bordeaux Salon. Photograph by Boucher for HABS in Aug 1974

|image2=Carolands Chateau - Bordeaux Salon 2.16.2013.jpg

|caption2=After 2013 restoration

|align=right|direction=vertical}}

In 1986, Michael DeDomenico, an heir to the family controlling Rice-a-Roni and Ghirardelli, bought Carolands,

and that year developers commissioned an Environmental Impact Report in support of a proposal to further subdivide the land and build additional houses. In 1989, the house suffered superficial damage in the Loma Prieta earthquake leading its owners to consider demolishing it. In 1997, a new owner proposed carving the house into fifteen condominiums,{{cite news |url=http://www.sfgate.com/news/article/Historic-Mansion-Opens-Door-To-Debate-Strict-3240182.php |title=Historic Mansion Opens Door To Debate |author=Wilson, Marshall |date=19 August 1997 |newspaper=San Francisco Chronicle |access-date=19 March 2015 }} but the Hillsborough town charter banned multi-family residences.

In 1991, the Hillsborough Designer Showhouse was held at Carolands, attracting 68,000 visitors, each paying $20 admission, netting more than $1 million for the sponsoring charity and reviving interest in the house.{{cite news |url=https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1991-09-08-re-2720-story.html |title=Karras Tackles Malibu Move |author=Ryon, Ruth |date=8 September 1991 |newspaper=Los Angeles Times |access-date=19 March 2015 }} Among the visitors were Dr. Ann Johnson, who would later buy Carolands, and her interior decorator, Mario Buatta, who would help her to restore it.

In 1998, Johnson and her husband, mutual fund billionaire Charles Bartlett Johnson, bought the house and the remaining land for under $6 million. The Johnsons undertook extensive renovations and restorations of the house, often hosting events there.{{cite web|last=Eerdmans |first=Emily |date=6 November 2009 |title=Carolands House Visit, Part I |url=http://emilyevanseerdmans.blogspot.com/2009/11/carolands-house-visit-part-i.html |access-date=19 March 2015}}

Billionaire businessperson Charles B. Johnson and his wife bought the Carolands Chateau in 2009 for $26 million.{{Cite web |last=Ernsthausen |first=Jeff |date=2023-07-26 |title=How the Ultrawealthy Use Private Foundations to Bank Millions in Tax Deductions While Giving the Public Little in Return |url=https://www.propublica.org/article/how-private-nonprofits-ultrawealthy-tax-deductions-museums-foundation-art |website=ProPublica |language=en}} By 2023, it was appraised at $130 million. In 2012, Johnson and his wife donated the Carolands Chateau to his private foundation, "Carolands Foundation". The couple filed for tax-exempt status for the mansion, as they said that the mansion would be open to self-guided public tours every weekday from 9–5. By valuing the mansion so highly and by obtaining tax-exempt status, the Johnsons collected more than $38 million in tax savings from the estate over five years. However, the mansion was not open to the public 40 hours per week or subject to self-guided tours. Rather, it was only open to a few dozen lottery winners who could access the mansion on a guided tour for two hours from 1PM on most Wednesdays. Tax and legal experts questioned the validity of the high appraisal for the mansion and the tax-exempt status of the estate.

File:Carolands Chateau- North Facade showing the distictive dome on the West Facde 2013.jpg|Carolands Chateau: North Façade showing the distinctive dome on the West Façade 2013

File:Caroland Chateau- West Facade from the gardens in the Morning Sun 2013.jpg|Carolands Chateau: West Façade from the gardens in the Morning Sun 2013

File:Carolands Chateau- South Facade with Porte-cochère gates Feb.13 .jpg|Carolands Chateau: South Façade with Porte-cochère gates 2013

File:Carolands, South Facade from Rose Garden Terrace, 2013.jpg|Carolands Chateau- from Rose Garden Terrace 2013

File:Carolands Chateau, Interior Porte-cochère.jpg|Carolands Chateau: Interior Porte-cochère

File:Carolands Chateau- South Front Garden view -2013.jpg|Carolands Chateau- South Front Garden view -2013

File:Carolnads, Western Garden view from Bordeaux Room 2013.jpg|Carolands Chateau- Garden view West from Bordeaux Salon 2013

File:Carolands Chateau- West Garden and fountains from Harriett's Bederoom balcony 2013.jpg|Carolands Chateau- West Garden and fountains from Harriett's Bedroom balcony 2013

File:Carolands Chateau- Duchêne Border Parterre 2013.jpg|Carolands Chateau- Duchêne Border Parterre 2013

File:Carolands Chateau- Entry Courtyard view across Gardens 2013.jpg|Carolands Chateau- Entry Courtyard view across Gardens 2013

File:Carolands Chateau - West Terrace and Spinx Feb 2013.jpg|Carolands Chateau- West Terrace and Sphinx 2013

File:Carolands Chateau, Grand Staircase.2013.jpg|Carolands Chateau: Grand Staircase after restoration

File:Carolands Chateau, Interior Upper Gallery.jpg|Carolands Chateau: Upper Gallery and Main Staircase

In 2006 a feature-length documentary, Three Women and a Chateau, which tells the nearly 100-year history of Carolands, premiered at the Santa Barbara International Film Festival and was featured in seven other film festivals, winning Best Documentary (Grand Jury Award) at the Rhode Island International Film Festival.{{citation needed|date=October 2018}}{{Cite web|url=http://lunaproductions.com/the-heiress-and-her-chateau/|title=The Heiress and Her Chateau, a PBS documentary|website=lunaproductions.com|access-date=2019-09-06}}

The Heiress and Her Chateau: Carolands of California, a one-hour documentary about the chateau, first premiered January 19, 2014 on KQED-TV, and the following year was broadcast nationally on PBS. It was nominated for [https://emmysf.tv/files/2015/06/Emmy15NomPR.pdf two Emmy Awards:] Outstanding Achievement – Cultural/Historical Documentary and Outstanding Achievement - Writer. Both documentaries were made by [http://lunaproductions.com/the-heiress-and-her-chateau/ Luna Productions].

{{reflist|30em}}

• California Department of Parks and Recreation, California Historical Landmarks (1981)
• California State Historic Building Code, California Senate Bill no. 2321, September, 1984
• C. Michael Hogan, Steven Wanat et al., Environmental Impact Report for the Proposed Nine Unit Subdivision at 565 Remillard Drive (Carolands Chateau Site), Hillsborough, prepared for the town of Hillsborough by Earth Metrics Inc, Burlingame, California, January 15, 1986
• Chet Rhodes, The Doomed Chateau, San Francisco Chronicle, July, 1985
• John Horgan, Carolands Chateau may be Razed, Peninsula Times, June, 1985
• {{cite book |url=http://www.carolands.org/book.htm |title=Carolands: Ernest Sanson, Achille Duchêne, Willis Polk |author1=Dwyer, Michael Middleton |author-link1=Michael Middleton Dwyer |author2=Hales, Mick (Photographer) |location=Redwood City |publisher=San Mateo County Historical Association and Institute of Classical Architecture & Art |date=2006 |access-date=19 March 2015 |isbn=978-0-9785259-0-3 |oclc=77238885 }}

• {{cite book |url=http://www.rizzoliusa.com/book.php?isbn=9780847839650&v=email |title=California Splendor |author1=Masson, Kathryn |author2=Glomb, David (Photographer) |date=2013 |publisher=Rizzoli |location=New York |access-date=19 March 2015 |isbn=978-0-8478-3965-0 |oclc=823046128}}

• {{cite book |url=http://www.rizzoliusa.com/book.php?isbn=9780847840724 |title=Mario Buatta: Fifty Years of American Interior Decoration |author1=Buatta, Mario |author2=Eerdmans, Emily |author3=Rense, Paige |date=2013 |publisher=Rizzoli |location=New York |access-date=19 March 2015 |isbn=978-0-8478-4072-4 |oclc=832278609 }}

• {{cite journal |url=http://digimag.rrd.com/18Media/Peninsula200812/default.asp |title=Deck the Halls |author1=Seymour, Ann |author2=Hutcheson, Jack (Photographer) |date=December 2008 |journal=Gentry |access-date=20 March 2015 |pages=112–123 |format=Requires Adobe Flash Player |issn=1545-7664 |publisher=18 Media |location=Menlo Park |archive-date=March 4, 2016 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20160304030110/http://digimag.rrd.com/18Media/Peninsula200812/default.asp |url-status=dead }}

• {{cite book |title=Gardens private & personal: A Garden Club of America Book |author1=D'Oench, Nancy |author2=Martin, Bonny |author3=Hales, Mick (Photographer) |publisher=Abrams |location=New York |date=2008 |isbn=978-0810972803 |oclc=183162315 }}

• {{cite web |url=http://www.architecturaldigest.com/AD100/2010/mario_buatta/buatta_slideshow_122006 |author1=Bissell, Therese |author2=Hales, Mick (Photographer) |title=Romancing History |date=20 December 2006 |access-date=20 March 2015 |website=Architectural Digest }}

• {{cite news |url=http://www.sfgate.com/homeandgarden/article/Hillsborough-s-Downton-Abbey-5150689.php |title=Hillsborough's Downton Abbey |author=Kho, Nancy Davis |date=18 January 2014 |newspaper=San Francisco Chronicle |access-date=19 March 2015 }}

{{Commons category|Carolands}}

• {{Official website}}
• [https://npgallery.nps.gov/nrhp/AssetDetail?assetID=fc3325cf-d6c5-41a2-a055-dd7a59485101 The Carolands] at the National Register of Historic Places
• [https://www.loc.gov/pictures/search/?q=Photograph:ca0813&fi=number&op=PHRASE&va=exact&co%20=hh&st=gallery&sg%20=%20true Library of Congress Historical American Buildings Survey]
• [https://archive.today/20140319212747/http://gis.co.sanmateo.ca.us/countygis/applications/gisapp_PropReviewMap.asp?APN=030051010 San Mateo County – Property Summary]
• [http://lunaproductions.com/the-heiress-and-her-chateau/ Web page for Emmy nominated PBS documentary on Chateau Carolands, "The Heiress and Her Chateau"]

{{National Register of Historic Places }}

Category:Houses completed in 1915

Category:Beaux-Arts architecture in California

Category:History of San Mateo County, California

Category:Houses in San Mateo County, California

Category:Houses on the National Register of Historic Places in California

Category:National Register of Historic Places in San Mateo County, California

Category:Second Empire architecture in California

Category:1915 establishments in California

Category:Gilded Age mansions