| class="wikitable" width="60%" cellpadding="5" |
| width="100"|Year
!width="300"|Winner
!width="300"|Show |
|---|
rowspan="5" style="text-align:center;"| 2010-2011[{{cite magazine|url=http://insidetv.ew.com/2011/06/06/critics-choice-television-awards/|title='Modern Family' cast nabs five Critics Choice Television Awards nominations|author=Jeff Labrecque|date=6 June 2011|magazine=Entertainment Weekly|accessdate=12 July 2012}}][{{cite web | last=Mitovich | first=Matt Webb | title=Critics' Choice TV Award Winners Include Stars from Fringe, Justified and Cougar Town | website=TVLine | date=2011-06-20 | url=https://tvline.com/2011/06/20/critics-choice-television-awards-winners/ | access-date=2022-01-17}}] | style="background:#B0C4DE;" | Mike Rowe | style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Dirty Jobs |
| Tom Bergeron | Dancing with the Stars |
| Cat Deeley | So You Think You Can Dance |
| Ty Pennington | Extreme Makeover: Home Edition |
| Ryan Seacrest | American Idol |
| style = "border-top:2px solid gray;"
|rowspan="5" style="text-align:center;"| 2011-2012[{{cite news |url=http://www.criticschoice.com/television-awards/critics-choice-television-awards-announces-nominations/ |title=2012 Critics' Choice Television Awards |date=2012-06-06 |publisher=BFJA |accessdate=2012-06-06 |archive-date=2013-06-03 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20130603133617/http://www.criticschoice.com/television-awards/critics-choice-television-awards-announces-nominations/ |url-status=dead }}][{{cite news|url=http://tvline.com/2012/06/05/critics-choice-television-nominations-2nd-annual/|title=Community, Breaking Bad, Parks and Rec, Mad Men, Girls Lead Critics’ Choice Nominations|author=Kimberly Roots|date=5 June 2012|work=TVLine|accessdate=12 July 2012}}] | style="background:#B0C4DE;" | Tom Bergeron | style="background:#B0C4DE;" | Dancing with the Stars |
| style="background:#B0C4DE;" | Cat Deeley | style="background:#B0C4DE;" | So You Think You Can Dance |
| Nick Cannon | America's Got Talent |
| Phil Keoghan | The Amazing Race |
| RuPaul | RuPaul's Drag Race |
| style = "border-top:2px solid gray;"
|rowspan="6" style="text-align:center;"| 2012-2013[{{cite web |title=Critics' Choice Television Awards |url=http://www.criticschoice.com/television-awards/ |publisher=Critics' Choice Awards |accessdate=May 22, 2013 |date=May 22, 2013 |url-status=dead |archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20120602110331/http://www.criticschoice.com/television-awards/ |archivedate=June 2, 2012 }}] | style="background:#B0C4DE;" | Tom Bergeron | style="background:#B0C4DE;"| Dancing with the Stars |
| Cat Deeley | So You Think You Can Dance |
| Gordon Ramsay | Hell's Kitchen / MasterChef |
| RuPaul | RuPaul's Drag Race |
| Ryan Seacrest | American Idol |
| Kurt Warner | The Moment |
| style = "border-top:2px solid gray;"
|rowspan="6" style="text-align:center;"| 2013-2014[{{cite magazine|title=Critics' Choice TV Awards 2014: And the nominees are...|magazine=Entertainment Weekly|url=http://insidetv.ew.com/2014/05/28/critics-choice-television-awards-nominees/|date=May 28, 2014|accessdate=July 24, 2014}}] | style="background:#B0C4DE;" | Neil deGrasse Tyson | style="background:#B0C4DE;"| Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey |
| Tom Bergeron | Dancing with the Stars |
| Carson Daly | The Voice |
| Cat Deeley | So You Think You Can Dance |
| Gordon Ramsay | MasterChef |
| RuPaul | RuPaul's Drag Race |
| rowspan="6" style="text-align:center;" |2014-2015
|style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Cat Deeley
|style="background:#B0C4DE;" |So You Think You Can Dance |
| Tom Bergeron
|Dancing with the Stars |
| Anthony Bourdain
|Anthony Bourdain: Parts Unknown |
| Phil Keoghan
|The Amazing Race |
| James Lipton
|Inside the Actors Studio |
| Betty White
|Betty White's Off Their Rockers |
| style="border-top:2px solid gray;"
| rowspan="6" style="text-align:center;" | 2015 (2)[{{cite magazine|title=Critics’ Choice Award Nominations: Complete List|magazine=Variety|url=https://variety.com/2015/film/awards/critics-choice-award-nominations-2016-nominees-full-list-1201660235/|date=December 14, 2015|accessdate=December 24, 2014}}] | style="background:#B0C4DE;" | James Lipton | style="background:#B0C4DE;" | Inside the Actors Studio |
| Ted Allen | Chopped |
| Phil Keoghan | The Amazing Race |
| Jane Lynch | Hollywood Game Night |
| Jeff Probst | Survivor |
| Gordon Ramsay | Hell's Kitchen |
| rowspan="6" style="text-align:center;" |2016
|style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Anthony Bourdain
|style="background:#B0C4DE;" |Anthony Bourdain: Parts Unknown |
| Ted Allen
|Chopped |
| Tom Bergeron
|Dancing with the Stars |
| Nick Cannon
|America's Got Talent |
| Carson Daly
|The Voice |
| RuPaul
|RuPaul's Drag Race |
| rowspan="6" style="text-align:center;" |2017
|style="background:#B0C4DE;" |RuPaul
|style="background:#B0C4DE;" |RuPaul's Drag Race |
| Ted Allen
|Chopped |
| Tyra Banks
|America's Got Talent |
| Tom Bergeron
|Dancing with the Stars |
| Cat Deeley
|So You Think You Can Dance |
| Joanna and Chip Gaines
|Fixer Upper |