Jurisdictional arbitrage

{{short description|Practice of taking advantage of discrepancies between legal jurisdictions}}

Jurisdictional arbitrage is the practice of taking advantage of discrepancies between competing legal jurisdictions. It takes its name from arbitrage, the practice in finance of purchasing a good at a lower price in one market and selling it at a higher price in another. Just as in financial arbitrage, the attractiveness of jurisdiction arbitrage depends largely on its transaction costs, here the costs of switching legal service providers from one government to another.{{cite web

|url=http://patrifriedman.com/projects/socs/commented/drawer/dynamic_geography.html

|title=Dynamic Geography: A Blueprint for Efficient Government

|publisher=Patrifriedman.com

|access-date=2008-02-29

|last=Friedman

|first=Patri

|author-link=Patri Friedman

}}{{Dead link|date=February 2020 |bot=InternetArchiveBot |fix-attempted=yes }}

The lower the exit costs for leaving the jurisdiction (unrestricted emigration, cheap travel, liquidity of assets) the more desirable and feasible it is. Conversely, high entry costs into the more favourable jurisdiction are an inhibitor on jurisdictional arbitrage; certain tax havens such as Andorra grant permanent residency rights to immigrants only if they meet certain criteria. Jurisdictional arbitrage is a significant concept in modern free market anarcho-capitalism.

Applications

The practice of individuals seeking asylum involves appealing to a jurisdiction with favorable individual rights for residency, where the individual's native jurisdiction is seen by them to offer insufficient protection. For example, women have fled West African nations which practice tribal female genital mutilation and/or extremist IslamNo interpretation of Islam demands female circumcision, contrary to popular opinion. See Reliance of the Traveller and Tools of the Worshipper (Umdat al-Salik), trans. Nuh Ha Mim Keller in favour of European and North American jurisdictions.

{{cite news

|url=https://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn?pagename=article&node=&contentId=A13252-2000Dec15

|title=Asylum Seeker Is Impostor, INS Says

|newspaper=The Washington Post

|access-date=2008-02-29

|last=Branigin

|first=William

|author2=Douglas Farah

|date=2000-12-20

}}

{{cite news

|url=https://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9C04E6DB1F39F931A15757C0A960958260

|title=Not So Harsh on Refugees

|work=The New York Times

|access-date=2008-02-29

|date=1996-04-22

}}

In July 2019, one of the wives--Princess Haya--of the ruler of Dubai was in a London courtroom to ask the state to provide and enforce a non-molestation order for her and what is known as a forced marriage protection order for their daughters; otherwise the women would be forced to submit to the Sharia law jurisdiction of Sheikh Mohammed.{{cite news |title=Dubai ruler's wife asks UK court for forced marriage protection order |url=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jul/30/dubai-rulers-wife-asks-uk-court-for-forced-marriage-protection-order |publisher=Guardian News & Media Limited |date=30 July 2019}}

=Outlawry=

Jurisdictional arbitrage has also been utilized to hinder attempts at governmental prosecution, by transnational criminals such as terrorists,"Anti-terror measures hit formal finance", Oxford Analytica, 2004-05-25. Retrieved 2008-02-29. "This is especially important given terrorists' ability to exercise jurisdictional arbitrage." money launderers, and cyber-attackers.{{cite journal

|author=Kshetri, N.

|year=2005

|title=Pattern of global cyber war and crime: A conceptual framework

|journal=Journal of International Management

|volume=11

|issue=4

|pages=541–562

|doi=10.1016/j.intman.2005.09.009

|s2cid=44984081

|url=http://libres.uncg.edu/ir/uncg/f/N_Kshetri_Pattern_2005.pdf

}}

Prior to recent international mobilization against the practice, there existed a long-standing tradition of ousted state leaders such as Mohammed Reza Pahlevi, Idi Amin and Augusto Pinochet finding refuge and retirement abroad to avoid prosecution in their native jurisdiction.{{cite book|title=Universal Jurisdiction: National Courts and the Prosecution of Serious Crimes Under International Law|editor=Stephen Macedo |date=February 1, 2006 |publisher=University of Pennsylvania Press|isbn=0-8122-1950-3|page=164}} Pinochet, one-time military leader of Chile sought to evade retributive prosecution in his native jurisdiction by seeking refuge in the United Kingdom. He was later prosecuted by the Spanish court of Baltasar Garzón according to the principle of universal jurisdiction.

To counteract this phenomenon, most countries have signed bilateral extradition treaties with most other countries, and some governments adopted the principle of universal jurisdiction, which has enabled individuals to be prosecuted for offences (particularly alleged human rights violations and war crimes) committed outside the jurisdiction of prosecution – the legal structure of nations such as Belgium and Spain allow for this, as does that of international tribunals operating under the aegis of the United Nations.

=Tax policy=

A similar attempt at governmental collusion to limit the use of jurisdictional arbitrage for tax avoidance is the policy of tax harmonization. The membership of European governments in the European Union resulted in a collection of nations with a limited set of common legal structures (Four Freedoms) which has resulted in tax competition by the otherwise less-developed nations (such as Ireland in the early 1990s) whereby governments compete for foreign investment by lowering their tax rates significantly below those of their neighbours. This strategy has been adopted in the form of a flat tax by various Eastern European nations, which has resulted in calls for harmonization of tax rates by the traditionally more developed nations such as France, Britain and Germany.

{{cite news

|url=http://www.nytimes.com/1998/12/10/news/10iht-eu.t_0.html

|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110805161741/http://www.nytimes.com/1998/12/10/news/10iht-eu.t_0.html

|archive-date=2011-08-05

|title=Blair and Schroeder Agree on Taxes

|last=Buerkle

|first=Tom

|publisher=International Herald Tribune

|access-date=2012-03-02

|date=1998-12-10

|url-status=dead

}}

=Labour=

In the view of one journalist, Microsoft's satellite office in Vancouver was set up because the US Immigration and Naturalization Service was given to restrict the immigration of programmers.{{cite web|title=Microsoft pressures U.S. in Vancouver move |url=http://www.canada.com/nationalpost/financialpost/story.html?id=3a2cbdc5-95ad-45b5-9fb1-fe1fb3656f37&k=23394 |publisher=National Post |access-date=2012-03-02 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20160304091525/http://www.canada.com/nationalpost/financialpost/story.html?id=3a2cbdc5-95ad-45b5-9fb1-fe1fb3656f37&k=23394 |archive-date=2016-03-04 |date=2007-07-06 |url-status=dead }}

The Blueseed project intended to launch a ship 12 nautical miles from the shore (and thus in international waters) with the goal of allowing entrepreneurs without US work visas legally to work for and create companies close to Silicon Valley.{{cite web|last=McCullagh |first=Declan |title=Visa problems? 'Seasteading' your startup may be the answer |url=http://news.cnet.com/8301-31921_3-57320213-281/visa-problems-seasteading-your-startup-may-be-the-answer/ |publisher=CNET |access-date=2012-03-02 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20111122034410/http://news.cnet.com/8301-31921_3-57320213-281/visa-problems-seasteading-your-startup-may-be-the-answer/ |archive-date=2011-11-22 |date=2011-11-08 |quote=the entire enterprise could be jeopardized by immigration officials irritated by what amounts to jurisdictional arbitrage and a clever legal hack |url-status=dead }}

Advocates

Anarcho-capitalists hope that by subdividing existing governmental jurisdictions into city-states (such as Singapore), competition among jurisdictions for citizens will lead to a diversity of legal climates including more favourable jurisdictions for liberty and self-determination.{{cite journal

|author=Huebert, J.H.

|year=2005

|title=No Duty To Obey The State: Reply To Barnett

|journal=Journal of Libertarian Studies

|volume=19

|issue=4

|pages=79–81

|url=https://mises.org/library/no-duty-obey-state-reply-barnett

|access-date=2008-02-29}} Cypherpunks and crypto-anarchists also cite low exit costs and fluidity of movement across jurisdictions as a significant means of advancing individual freedom through the free movement of information and capital.{{cite journal

|author=Menthe, D.

|year=1998

|title=Jurisdiction In Cyberspace: A Theory of International Spaces

|journal=Telecommunication & Technology Law Review, Michigan

|volume=4

|pages=69

|url=http://www.mttlr.org/volfour/menthe.pdf

|access-date=2008-02-29

|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20080820061153/http://www.mttlr.org/volfour/menthe.pdf

|archive-date=2008-08-20

|url-status=dead

}}{{cite journal

|author=Clarke, R.

|year=1997

|title=Encouraging Cyberculture'

|journal=CAUSE in Australasia

|volume=97

|url=https://www.anu.edu.au/people/Roger.Clarke/II/EncoCyberCulture.html

|access-date=2008-02-29

|archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20080312161835/http://www.anu.edu.au/people/Roger.Clarke/II/EncoCyberCulture.html

|archive-date=2008-03-12

|url-status=dead

}} The concept of seasteading is an attempt to increase the possibility of jurisdictional arbitrage by decreasing the cost of switching governments.

A notable proponent and practitioner of jurisdictional arbitrage is Canadian businessman and perpetual traveler Calvin Ayre, founder of online gambling consortium Bodog Entertainment Group.{{cite news |first=Martin |last=Bashir |title=Online Gambling Mogul Living it Up |url=https://abcnews.go.com/Nightline/story?id=2108601&page=1 |work=ABC News |publisher=MSNBC |date=2006-07-07 |access-date=2008-02-29 }} Although online gambling is illegal in the United States, a market which accounts for 95% of Bodog's sales, the company pays no corporate taxes there as its activities are distributed across different jurisdictions to minimise tax burden. "We run a business that can't actually be described as gambling in each country we operate in. But when you add it all together, it’s Internet gambling."{{cite news |first=Matthew |last=Miller |title=Catch Me If You Can |url=https://www.forbes.com/forbes/2006/0327/112_print.html |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20060521204658/http://www.forbes.com/forbes/2006/0327/112_print.html |url-status=dead |archive-date=May 21, 2006 |work=Forbes |date=2006-03-27 |access-date=2008-02-29 }}

Jurisdictional arbitrage

Applications

=Outlawry=

=Tax policy=

=Labour=

Advocates

See also

References

Further reading