List of All Stars Awards winners (football)#1997

By the end of 2013, 387 different footballers had received awards.{{citation needed|date=August 2022}} For those with the highest numbers of awards, see GAA GPA All Stars Awards.

As of 2024, the players are from the following teams:

:Given as {{•}} Team, team's overall total/number of different players to have won while representing this team:

• Kerry, 159/64 (list)
• Dublin, 146/67 (list)
• Cork, 64/42 (list)
• Tyrone, 58/33 (list)
• Mayo, 54/33 (list)
• Meath, 48/26 (list)
• Galway, 48/34 (list)
• Donegal, 36/24 (list)
• Offaly, 30/19 (list)
• Armagh, 30/21 (list)
• Derry, 29/19 (list)
• Down, 23/18 (list)
• Roscommon, 16/12 (list)
• Kildare, 15/12 (list)
• Monaghan, 14/10 (list)
• Westmeath, 5/4
• Cavan, 5/5
• Laois, 5/5
• Fermanagh, 4/3
• Tipperary, 4/3
• Sligo, 4/4
• Leitrim, 2/2
• Louth, 2/2
• Antrim, 1
• Clare, 1
• Wexford, 1
• Wicklow, 1

No player has received an All Star while representing Carlow, Kilkenny**, Limerick, Longford, Waterford, or the overseas county teams of London and New York in football.

{{small|** Kilkenny no longer competes in the All-Ireland Senior Football Championship.}}

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Galway.svg P. J. Smyth	Galway	1
RCB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Johnny Carey	Mayo	1
FB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Jack Cosgrove	Galway	1
LCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Donie O'Sullivan	Kerry	1
RWB	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Eugene Mulligan	Offaly	1
CB	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Nicholas Clavin	Offaly	1
LWB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Patrick Reynolds	Meath	1
MD	File:Colours of Galway.svg Liam Sammon	Galway	1
MD	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Willie Bryan	Offaly	1
RWF	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Tony McTague	Offaly	1
CF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Ray Cummins	Cork	1
LWF	File:Colours of Sligo.svg Mickey Kearins	Sligo	1
RCF	File:Colours of Antrim.svg Andy McCallin	Antrim	1
FF	File:Colours of Down.svg Seán O'Neill	Down	1
LCF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Seamus Leydon	Galway	1

;County breakdown

• Galway = 4
• Offaly = 4
• Mayo = 1
• Kerry = 1
• Meath = 1
• Cork = 1
• Sligo = 1
• Antrim = 1
• Down = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Martin Furlong	Offaly	1
RCB	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Mick Ryan	Offaly	1
FB	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Paddy McCormack	Offaly	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Donie O'Sullivan	Kerry	2
RWB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Brian McEniff	Donegal	1
CB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Tommy Joe Gilmore	Galway	1
LWB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Kevin Jer O'Sullivan	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Willie Bryan	Offaly	2
MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mick O'Connell	Kerry	1
RWF	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Johnny Cooney	Offaly	1
CF	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Kevin Kilmurray	Offaly	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Tony McTague	Offaly	2
RCF	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Mickey Freyne	Roscommon	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Down.svg Seán O'Neill	Down	2
LCF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Paddy Moriarty	Armagh	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Offaly = 7
• Kerry = 2
• Donegal = 1
• Galway = 1
• Cork = 1
• Roscommon = 1
• Down = 1
• Armagh = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Cork.svg Billy Morgan	Cork	1
RCB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Frank Cogan	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Mick Ryan	Offaly	2
LCB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Brian Murphy	Cork	1
RWB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Liam O'Neill	Galway	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Tommy Joe Gilmore	Galway	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Kevin Jer O'Sullivan	Cork	2
MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg John O'Keeffe	Kerry	1
MD	File:Colours of Cork.svg Dinny Long	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Johnny Cooney	Offaly	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Kevin Kilmurray	Offaly	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Liam Sammon	Galway	2
RCF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Jimmy Barry-Murphy	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Ray Cummins	Cork	2
LCF	File:Colours of Derry.svg Anthony McGurk	Derry	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Cork = 7
• Offaly = 3
• Galway = 3
• Kerry = 1
• Derry = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paddy Cullen	Dublin	1
RCB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Donal Monaghan	Donegal	1
FB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Seán Doherty	Dublin	1
LCB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Robbie Kelleher	Dublin	1
RWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paddy Reilly	Dublin	1
CB	File:Colours of Sligo.svg Barnes Murphy	Sligo	1
LWB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Johnny Hughes	Galway	1
MD	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Dermot Earley	Roscommon	1
MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Paudie Lynch	Kerry	1
RWF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Tom Naughton	Galway	1
CF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Declan Barron	Cork	1
LWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg David Hickey	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Jimmy Barry-Murphy	Cork	2
FF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Jimmy Keaveney	Dublin	1
LCF	File:Colours of Galway.svg John Tobin	Galway	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Dublin = 6
• Galway = 3
• Cork = 2
• Donegal = 1
• Sligo = 1
• Roscommon = 1
• Kerry = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Paudie O'Mahony	Kerry	1
RCB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Gay O'Driscoll	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg John O'Keeffe	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Robbie Kelleher	Dublin	2
RWB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Peter Stevenson	Derry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Anthony McGurk	Derry	2
LWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Ger Power	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Cork.svg Dinny Long	Cork	2
MD	File:Colours of Down.svg Colm McAlarney	Down	1
RWF	File:Colours of Derry.svg Gerry McElhinney	Derry	1
CF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Ken Rennicks	Meath	1
LWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mickey O'Sullivan	Kerry	1
RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg John Egan	Kerry	1
FF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Mattie Kerrigan	Meath	1
LCF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Anton O'Toole	Dublin	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 5
• Dublin = 3
• Derry = 3
• Meath = 2
• Cork = 1
• Down = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paddy Cullen	Dublin	2
RCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Ger O'Keeffe	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg John O'Keeffe	Kerry	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Brian Murphy	Cork	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Johnny Hughes	Galway	2
CB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Kevin Moran	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Ger Power	Kerry	2
MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Brian Mullins	Dublin	1
MD	File:Colours of Cork.svg Dave McCarthy	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Anton O'Toole	Dublin	2
CF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Tony Hanahoe	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg David Hickey	Dublin	2
RCF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Bobby Doyle	Dublin	1
FF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mikey Sheehy	Kerry	1
LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Pat Spillane	Kerry	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Dublin = 7
• Kerry = 5
• Cork = 2
• Galway = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paddy Cullen	Dublin	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Gay O'Driscoll	Dublin	2
FB	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Pat Lindsay	Roscommon	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Robbie Kelleher	Dublin	3
RWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Tommy Drumm	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Paddy Moriarty	Armagh	2
LWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Pat O'Neill	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Brian Mullins	Dublin	2
MD	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Joe Kernan	Armagh	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Anton O'Toole	Dublin	3
CF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Jimmy Smyth	Armagh	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Pat Spillane	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Bobby Doyle	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Jimmy Keaveney	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg John Egan	Kerry	2

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Dublin = 9
• Armagh = 3
• Kerry = 2
• Roscommon = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Ollie Crinnigan	Kildare	1
RCB	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Harry Keegan	Roscommon	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg John O'Keeffe	Kerry	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Robbie Kelleher	Dublin	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Tommy Drumm	Dublin	2
CB	File:Colours of Cavan.svg Ollie Brady	Cavan	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Paudie Lynch	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Down.svg Colm McAlarney	Down	2
MD	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Tomás O'Connor	Offaly	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Ger Power	Kerry	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Declan Barron	Cork	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Pat Spillane	Kerry	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mikey Sheehy	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Jimmy Keaveney	Dublin	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg John Egan	Kerry	3

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 6
• Dublin = 3
• Kildare = 1
• Roscommon = 1
• Cavan = 1
• Down = 1
• Offaly = 1
• Cork = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paddy Cullen	Dublin	4
RCB	File:Colours of Monaghan.svg Eugene Hughes	Monaghan	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg John O'Keeffe	Kerry	5
LCB	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Tom Heneghan	Roscommon	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Tommy Drumm	Dublin	3
CB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tim Kennelly	Kerry	1
LWB	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Danny Murray	Roscommon	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Dermot Earley	Roscommon	2
MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Bernard Brogan	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Ger Power	Kerry	4
CF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Seán Walsh	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Pat Spillane	Kerry	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mikey Sheehy	Kerry	3
FF	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Seán Lowry	Offaly	1
LCF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Joe McGrath	Mayo	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 6
• Dublin = 3
• Roscommon = 3
• Monaghan = 1
• Offaly = 1
• Mayo = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Charlie Nelligan	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Harry Keegan	Roscommon	2
FB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Kevin Kehilly	Cork	1
LCB	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Gerry Connellan	Roscommon	1
RWB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Kevin McCabe	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tim Kennelly	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Danny Murray	Roscommon	2
MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Jack O'Shea	Kerry	1
MD	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Colum McKinstry	Armagh	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Ger Power	Kerry	5
CF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Dinny Allen	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Pat Spillane	Kerry	5
RCF	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Matt Connor	Offaly	1
FF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Eoin Liston	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg John Egan	Kerry	4

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 7
• Roscommon = 3
• Cork = 2
• Tyrone = 1
• Armagh = 1
• Offaly = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Martin Furlong	Offaly	2
RCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Jimmy Deenihan	Kerry	1
FB	File:Colours of Down.svg Paddy Kennedy	Down	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Paudie Lynch	Kerry	3
RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Páidí Ó Sé	Kerry	1
CB	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Richie Connor	Offaly	1
LWB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Séamus McHugh	Galway	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Jack O'Shea	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Seán Walsh	Kerry	2
RWF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Barry Brennan	Galway	1
CF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Denis 'Ogie' Moran	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Pat Spillane	Kerry	6
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mikey Sheehy	Kerry	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Eoin Liston	Kerry	2
LCF	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Brendan Lowry	Offaly	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 9
• Offaly = 3
• Galway = 2
• Down = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Martin Furlong	Offaly	3
RCB	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Mick Fitzgerald	Offaly	1
FB	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Liam O'Connor	Offaly	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Kevin Kehilly	Cork	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Páidí Ó Sé	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Seán Lowry	Offaly	2
LWB	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Liam Currams	Offaly	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Jack O'Shea	Kerry	3
MD	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Pádraig Dunne	Offaly	1
RWF	File:Colours of Fermanagh.svg Peter McGinnity	Fermanagh	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Joe Kernan	Armagh	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Matt Connor	Offaly	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mikey Sheehy	Kerry	5
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Eoin Liston	Kerry	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg John Egan	Kerry	5

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Offaly = 7
• Kerry = 5
• Cork = 1
• Fermanagh = 1
• Armagh = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Martin Furlong	Offaly	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Páidí Ó Sé	Kerry	3
FB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Stephen Kinneavy	Galway	1
LCB	File:Colours of Cork.svg John Evans	Cork	1
RWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Pat Canavan	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Tommy Drumm	Dublin	4
LWB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Jimmy Kerrigan	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Jack O'Shea	Kerry	4
MD	File:Colours of Down.svg Liam Austin	Down	1
RWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Barney Rock	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Matt Connor	Offaly	3
LWF	File:Colours of Down.svg Greg Blaney	Down	1
RCF	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Martin McHugh	Donegal	1
FF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Colm O'Rourke	Meath	1
LCF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Joe McNally	Dublin	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Dublin = 4
• Kerry = 2
• Offaly = 2
• Cork = 2
• Down = 2
• Galway = 1
• Donegal = 1
• Meath = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg John O'Leary	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Páidí Ó Sé	Kerry	4
FB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Mick Lyons	Meath	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Séamus McHugh	Galway	2
RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tommy Doyle	Kerry	1
CB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tom Spillane	Kerry	1
LWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg P. J. Buckley	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Jack O'Shea	Kerry	5
MD	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Eugene McKenna	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Barney Rock	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Eoin Liston	Kerry	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Pat Spillane	Kerry	7
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mikey Sheehy	Kerry	6
FF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Frank McGuigan	Tyrone	1
LCF	File:Colours of Derry.svg Dermot McNicholl	Derry	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 7
• Dublin = 3
• Tyrone = 2
• Meath = 1
• Galway = 1
• Derry = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg John O'Leary	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Páidí Ó Sé	Kerry	5
FB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Gerry Hargan	Dublin	1
LCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mick Spillane	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tommy Doyle	Kerry	2
CB	File:Colours of Monaghan.svg Ciarán Murray	Monaghan	1
LWB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Dermot Flanagan	Mayo	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Jack O'Shea	Kerry	6
MD	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Willie Joe Padden	Mayo	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Barney Rock	Dublin	3
CF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Tommy Conroy	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Pat Spillane	Kerry	8
RCF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Kevin McStay	Mayo	1
FF	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Paul Earley	Roscommon	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Monaghan.svg Eugene Hughes	Monaghan	2

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 5
• Dublin = 4
• Mayo = 3
• Monaghan = 1
• Roscommon = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Charlie Nelligan	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Harry Keegan	Roscommon	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Mick Lyons	Meath	2
LCB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg John Lynch	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tommy Doyle	Kerry	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tom Spillane	Kerry	2
LWB	File:Colours of Laois.svg Colm Browne	Laois	1
MD	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Plunkett Donaghy	Tyrone	1
MD	File:Colours of Laois.svg Liam Irwin	Laois	1
RWF	File:Colours of Monaghan.svg Ray McCarron	Monaghan	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Eugene McKenna	Tyrone	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Pat Spillane	Kerry	9
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mikey Sheehy	Kerry	7
FF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Damien O'Hagan	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Ger Power	Kerry	6

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 6
• Tyrone = 4
• Laois = 2
• Roscommon = 1
• Meath = 1
• Monaghan = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Cork.svg John Kerins	Cork	1
RCB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Robbie O'Malley	Meath	1
FB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Colman Corrigan	Cork	1
LCB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Tony Scullion	Derry	1
RWB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Niall Cahalane	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tom Spillane	Kerry	3
LWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Ger Lynch	Kerry	1
MD	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Gerry McEntee	Meath	1
MD	File:Colours of Derry.svg Brian McGilligan	Derry	1
RWF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg David Beggy	Meath	1
CF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Larry Tompkins	Cork	1
LWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Kieran Duff	Dublin	1
RCF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Val Daly	Galway	1
FF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Brian Stafford	Meath	1
LCF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Bernard Flynn	Meath	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Meath = 5
• Cork = 4
• Derry = 2
• Kerry = 2
• Dublin = 1
• Galway = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Monaghan.svg Paddy Linden	Monaghan	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Robbie O'Malley	Meath	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Colman Corrigan	Cork	2
LCB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Mick Kennedy	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Niall Cahalane	Cork	2
CB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Noel McCaffrey	Dublin	1
LWB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Martin O'Connell	Meath	1
MD	File:Colours of Cork.svg Shea Fahy	Cork	1
MD	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Liam Hayes	Meath	1
RWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Maurice Fitzgerald	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Larry Tompkins	Cork	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Kieran Duff	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Colm O'Rourke	Meath	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Brian Stafford	Meath	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Monaghan.svg Eugene Hughes	Monaghan	3

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Meath = 5
• Cork = 4
• Dublin = 3
• Monaghan = 2
• Kerry = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Gabriel Irwin	Mayo	1
RCB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Jimmy Browne	Mayo	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Gerry Hargan	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Dermot Flanagan	Mayo	2
RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Connie Murphy	Kerry	1
CB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Conor Counihan	Cork	1
LWB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Tony Davis	Cork	1
MD	File:Colours of Cork.svg Teddy McCarthy	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Willie Joe Padden	Mayo	2
RWF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Dave Barry	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Larry Tompkins	Cork	3
LWF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Noel Durkin	Mayo	1
RCF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Paul McGrath	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Eugene McKenna	Tyrone	3
LCF	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Tony McManus	Roscommon	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Cork = 6
• Mayo = 5
• Dublin = 1
• Kerry = 1
• Tyrone = 1
• Roscommon = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Cork.svg John Kerins	Cork	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Robbie O'Malley	Meath	3
FB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Steven O'Brien	Cork	1
LCB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Terry Ferguson	Meath	1
RWB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Michael Slocum	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Conor Counihan	Cork	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Martin O'Connell	Meath	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Cork.svg Shea Fahy	Cork	2
MD	File:Colours of Leitrim.svg Mickey Quinn	Leitrim	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg David Beggy	Meath	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Val Daly	Galway	2
LWF	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Joyce McMullan	Donegal	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Paul McGrath	Cork	2
FF	File:Colours of Wicklow.svg Kevin O'Brien	Wicklow	1
LCF	File:Colours of Down.svg James McCartan Jnr	Down	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Cork = 6
• Meath = 4
• Leitrim = 1
• Galway = 1
• Donegal = 1
• Wicklow = 1
• Down = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Michael McQuillan	Meath	1
RCB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Mick Deegan	Dublin	1
FB	File:Colours of Down.svg Conor Deegan	Down	1
LCB	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Enon Gavin	Roscommon	1
RWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Tommy Carr	Dublin	1
CB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Keith Barr	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Martin O'Connell	Meath	3
MD	File:Colours of Down.svg Barry Breen	Down	1
MD	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Martin Lynch	Kildare	1
RWF	File:Colours of Down.svg Ross Carr	Down	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Down.svg Greg Blaney	Down	2
LWF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Tommy Dowd	Meath	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Colm O'Rourke	Meath	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Brian Stafford	Meath	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Bernard Flynn	Meath	2

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Meath = 6
• Down = 4
• Dublin = 3
• Roscommon = 1
• Kildare = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Gary Walsh	Donegal	1
RCB	File:Colours of Clare.svg Seamus Clancy	Clare	1
FB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Matt Gallagher	Donegal	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Tony Scullion	Derry	2
RWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paul Curran	Dublin	1
CB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Martin Gavigan	Donegal	1
LWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Eamon Heery	Dublin	1
MD	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Anthony Molloy	Donegal	1
MD	File:Colours of Mayo.svg T. J. Kilgallon	Mayo	1
RWF	File:Colours of Derry.svg Anthony Tohill	Derry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Martin McHugh	Donegal	2
LWF	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg James McHugh	Donegal	1
RCF	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Tony Boyle	Donegal	1
FF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Vinny Murphy	Dublin	1
LCF	File:Colours of Derry.svg Enda Gormley	Derry	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Donegal = 7
• Derry = 3
• Dublin = 3
• Clare = 1
• Mayo = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg John O'Leary	Dublin	3
RCB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg John Joe Doherty	Donegal	1
FB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Dermot Deasy	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Tony Scullion	Derry	3
RWB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Johnny McGurk	Derry	1
CB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Henry Downey	Derry	1
LWB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Gary Coleman	Derry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Derry.svg Anthony Tohill	Derry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Derry.svg Brian McGilligan	Derry	2
RWF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Kevin O'Neill	Mayo	1
CF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Joe Kavanagh	Cork	1
LWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Charlie Redmond	Dublin	1
RCF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Colin Corkery	Cork	1
FF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Ger Houlahan	Armagh	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Derry.svg Enda Gormley	Derry	2

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Derry = 7
• Dublin = 3
• Cork = 2
• Donegal = 1
• Mayo = 1
• Armagh = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg John O'Leary	Dublin	4
RCB	File:Colours of Down.svg Miceal Magill	Down	1
FB	File:Colours of Leitrim.svg Seamus Quinn	Leitrim	1
LCB	File:Colours of Down.svg Paul Higgins	Down	1
RWB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Graham Geraghty	Meath	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Steven O'Brien	Cork	2
LWB	File:Colours of Down.svg D. J. Kane	Down	1
MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Jack Sheedy	Dublin	1
MD	File:Colours of Down.svg Gregory McCartan	Down	1
RWF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Peter Canavan	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Down.svg Greg Blaney	Down	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Down.svg James McCartan Jnr	Down	2
RCF	File:Colours of Down.svg Mickey Linden	Down	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Tommy Dowd	Meath	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Charlie Redmond	Dublin	2

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Down = 7
• Dublin = 3
• Meath = 2
• Leitrim = 1
• Cork = 1
• Tyrone = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg John O'Leary	Dublin	5
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Tony Scullion	Derry	4
FB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Mark O'Connor	Cork	1
LCB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Fay Devlin	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paul Curran	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Keith Barr	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Steven O'Brien	Cork	3
MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Brian Stynes	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Derry.svg Anthony Tohill	Derry	3
RWF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Jarlath Fallon	Galway	1
CF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Dessie Farrell	Dublin	1
LWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paul Clarke	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Tommy Dowd	Meath	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Peter CanavanFOTY	Tyrone	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Charlie Redmond	Dublin	3

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Dublin = 7
• Derry = 2
• Cork = 2
• Tyrone = 2
• Galway = 1
• Meath = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Finbar McConnell	Tyrone	1
RCB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Kenneth Mortimer	Mayo	1
FB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Darren Fay	Meath	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Martin O'Connell	Meath	4
RWB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Pat Holmes	Mayo	1
CB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg James Nallen	Mayo	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paul Curran	Dublin	3
MD	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg John McDermott	Meath	1
MD	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Liam McHale	Mayo	1
RWF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Trevor GilesFOTY	Meath	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Tommy Dowd	Meath	4
LWF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg James Horan	Mayo	1
RCF	File:Colours of Derry.svg Joe Brolly	Derry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Peter Canavan	Tyrone	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Maurice Fitzgerald	Kerry	2

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Meath = 5
• Mayo = 5
• Tyrone = 2
• Dublin = 1
• Derry = 1
• Kerry = 1

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Declan O'Keeffe	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Kenneth Mortimer	Mayo	2
FB	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Davy Dalton	Kildare	1
LCB	File:Colours of Offaly.svg Cathal Daly	Offaly	1
RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Séamus Moynihan	Kerry	1
CB	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Glenn Ryan	Kildare	1
LWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Eamonn Breen	Kerry	1
MD	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Pat Fallon	Mayo	1
MD	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Niall Buckley	Kildare	1
RWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Pa Laide	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Trevor Giles	Meath	2
LWF	File:Colours of Cavan.svg Dermot McCabe	Cavan	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Derry.svg Joe Brolly	Derry	2
FF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Brendan Reilly	Meath	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Maurice FitzgeraldFOTY	Kerry	3

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 5
• Kildare = 3
• Mayo = 2
• Meath = 2
• Offaly = 1
• Cavan = 1
• Derry = 1

[https://www.irishnews.com/sport/2017/11/20/news/the-irish-news---nov-20-1997-cavan-gaa-camp-disappointed-that-bernard-morris-not-in-allstar-nominations-1191466/ List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Galway.svg Martin McNamara	Galway	1
RCB	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Brian Lacey	Kildare	1
FB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Seán Marty Lockhart	Derry	1
LCB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Tomás Mannion	Galway	1
RWB	File:Colours of Kildare.svg John Finn	Kildare	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Glenn Ryan	Kildare	2
LWB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Seán Óg de Paor	Galway	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg John McDermott	Meath	2
MD	File:Colours of Galway.svg Kevin Walsh	Galway	1
RWF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Michael Donnellan	Galway	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Jarlath FallonFOTY	Galway	2
LWF	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Dermot Earley	Kildare	1
RCF	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Karl O'Dwyer	Kildare	1
FF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Pádraic Joyce	Galway	1
LCF	File:Colours of Tipperary.svg Declan Browne	Tipperary	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Galway = 7
• Kildare = 5
• Derry = 1
• Meath = 1
• Tipperary = 1

[https://www.irishnews.com/sport/2018/11/12/news/irish-news-past-papers---nov-12-1998-ulster-gain-only-five-football-allstar-nominations-sean-marty-lockhart-sole-derry-con-1482572/ List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Cork.svg Kevin O'Dwyer	Cork	1
RCB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Mark O'Reilly	Meath	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Darren Fay	Meath	2
LCB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Anthony Lynch	Cork	1
RWB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Ciarán O'Sullivan	Cork	1
CB	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Kieran McGeeney	Armagh	1
LWB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Paddy Reynolds	Meath	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg John McDermott	Meath	3
MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Ciarán Whelan	Dublin	1
RWF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Diarmaid Marsden	Armagh	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Trevor GilesFOTY	Meath	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg James Horan	Mayo	2
RCF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Philip Clifford	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Graham Geraghty	Meath	2
LCF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Ollie Murphy	Meath	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Meath = 7
• Cork = 4
• Armagh = 2
• Dublin = 1
• Mayo = 1

[https://www.rte.ie/sport/gaa/1999/1127/146832-gaa3/ List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Declan O'Keeffe	Kerry	2
RCB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Kieran McKeever	Derry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Séamus MoynihanFOTY	Kerry	2
LCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mike McCarthy	Kerry	1
RWB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Declan Meehan	Galway	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Kieran McGeeney	Armagh	2
LWB	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Anthony Rainbow	Kildare	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Derry.svg Anthony Tohill	Derry	4
MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Darragh Ó Sé	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Michael Donnellan	Galway	2
CF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Liam Hassett	Kerry	1
LWF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Oisín McConville	Armagh	1
RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mike Frank Russell	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Pádraic Joyce	Galway	2
LCF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Derek Savage	Galway	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 6
• Galway = 4
• Derry = 2
• Armagh = 2
• Kildare = 1

[https://www.irishtimes.com/sport/2000-football-all-stars-nominations-1.1111821/ List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Cormac Sullivan	Meath	1
RCB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Kieran Fitzgerald	Galway	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Darren Fay	Meath	3
LCB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Coman Goggins	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Declan MeehanFOTY	Galway	2
CB	File:Colours of Roscommon.svg Francie Grehan	Roscommon	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Galway.svg Seán Óg de Paor	Galway	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Galway.svg Kevin Walsh	Galway	2
MD	File:Colours of Westmeath.svg Rory O'Connell	Westmeath	1
RWF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Evan Kelly	Meath	1
CF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Stephen O'Neill	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Michael Donnellan	Galway	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Ollie Murphy	Meath	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Galway.svg Pádraic Joyce	Galway	3
LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Johnny Crowley	Kerry	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Galway = 6
• Meath = 4
• Dublin = 1
• Roscommon = 1
• Westmeath = 1
• Tyrone = 1
• Kerry = 1

[https://www.rte.ie/sport/football/2001/1101/159735-allstars/ List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Stephen Cluxton	Dublin	1
RCB	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Enda McNulty	Armagh	1
FB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paddy Christie	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Anthony Lynch	Cork	2
RWB	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Aidan O'Rourke	Armagh	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Kieran McGeeneyFOTY	Armagh	3
LWB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Kevin Cassidy	Donegal	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Darragh Ó Sé	Kerry	2
MD	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Paul McGrane	Armagh	1
RWF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Steven McDonnell	Armagh	1
CF	File:Colours of Sligo.svg Eamonn O'Hara	Sligo	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Oisín McConville	Armagh	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Peter Canavan	Tyrone	4
FF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Ray Cosgrove	Dublin	1
LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Colm Cooper	Kerry	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Armagh = 6
• Dublin = 3
• Kerry = 2
• Cork = 1
• Donegal = 1
• Sligo = 1
• Tyrone = 1

[https://web.archive.org/web/20201008210334/http://www.vodafone.ie/aboutus/media/press/show/BAU002852.shtml List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Laois.svg Fergal Byron	Laois	1
RCB	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Francie Bellew	Armagh	1
FB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Cormac McAnallen	Tyrone	1
LCB	File:Colours of Laois.svg Joe Higgins	Laois	1
RWB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Conor Gormley	Tyrone	1
CB	File:Colours of Laois.svg Tom Kelly	Laois	1
LWB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Philip Jordan	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Galway.svg Kevin Walsh	Galway	3
MD	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Seán Cavanagh	Tyrone	1
RWF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Brian Dooher	Tyrone	1
CF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Brian McGuigan	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Tipperary.svg Declan Browne	Tipperary	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Steven McDonnellFOTY	Armagh	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Peter Canavan	Tyrone	4
LCF	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Adrian Sweeney	Donegal	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Tyrone = 7
• Laois = 3
• Armagh = 2
• Galway = 1
• Tipperary = 1
• Donegal = 1

[https://www.irishtimes.com/sport/2003-football-all-star-nominees-1.384196/ List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Diarmuid Murphy	Kerry	1
RCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tom O'Sullivan	Kerry	1
FB	File:Colours of Fermanagh.svg Barry Owens	Fermanagh	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mike McCarthy	Kerry	2
RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tomás Ó SéFOTY	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg James Nallen	Mayo	2
LWB	File:Colours of Westmeath.svg John Keane	Westmeath	1
MD	File:Colours of Fermanagh.svg Martin McGrath	Fermanagh	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Seán Cavanagh	Tyrone	2
RWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Paul Galvin	Kerry	1
CF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Ciarán McDonald	Mayo	1
LWF	File:Colours of Westmeath.svg Dessie Dolan	Westmeath	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Colm Cooper	Kerry	2
FF	File:Colours of Derry.svg Enda Muldoon	Derry	1
LCF	File:Colours of Wexford.svg Matty Forde	Wexford	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 6
• Fermanagh = 2
• Mayo = 2
• Westmeath = 2
• Tyrone = 1
• Derry = 1
• Wexford = 1

[https://www.rte.ie/sport/football/2004/1019/186726-kerry/ List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Diarmuid Murphy	Kerry	2
RCB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Ryan McMenamin	Tyrone	1
- bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Mike McCarthy	Kerry	3
LCB	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Andy Mallon	Armagh	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tomás Ó Sé	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Conor Gormley	Tyrone	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Philip Jordan	Tyrone	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Seán Cavanagh	Tyrone	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Paul McGrane	Armagh	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Brian Dooher	Tyrone	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Peter Canavan	Tyrone	6
LWF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Owen Mulligan	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Colm Cooper	Kerry	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Stephen O'NeillFOTY	Tyrone	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Steven McDonnell	Armagh	3

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Tyrone = 8
• Kerry = 4
• Armagh = 3

[https://www.rte.ie/sport/football/2005/1013/197181-allstar/ List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Stephen Cluxton	Dublin	2
RCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Marc Ó Sé	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Fermanagh.svg Barry Owens	Fermanagh	2
LCB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Karl Lacey	Donegal	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Séamus Moynihan	Kerry	3
CB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Ger Spillane	Cork	1
LWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Aidan O'Mahony	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Darragh Ó Sé	Kerry	3
MD	File:Colours of Cork.svg Nicholas Murphy	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Paul Galvin	Kerry	2
CF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Alan Brogan	Dublin	1
LWF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Alan Dillon	Mayo	1
RCF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Conor Mortimer	Mayo	1
FF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Kieran DonaghyFOTY	Kerry	1
LCF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Rónán Clarke	Armagh	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 6
• Dublin = 2
• Cork = 2
• Mayo = 2
• Fermanagh = 1
• Donegal = 1
• Armagh = 1

[https://www.rte.ie/sport/football/2006/1018/210289-allstars/ List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Stephen Cluxton	Dublin	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Marc Ó SéFOTY	Kerry	2
FB	File:Colours of Derry.svg Kevin McCloy	Derry	1
LCB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Graham Canty	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tomás Ó Sé	Kerry	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Aidan O'Mahony	Kerry	2
LWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Barry Cahill	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Ciarán Whelan	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Darragh Ó Sé	Kerry	4
RWF	File:Colours of Meath GAA.svg Stephen Bray	Meath	1
CF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Declan O'Sullivan	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Alan Brogan	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Colm Cooper	Kerry	4
FF	File:Colours of Derry.svg Paddy Bradley	Derry	1
LCF	File:Colours of Monaghan.svg Tomás Freeman	Monaghan	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 6
• Dublin = 4
• Derry = 2
• Cork = 1
• Meath = 1
• Monaghan = 1

[http://www.hoganstand.com/article/index/83907 List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Westmeath.svg Gary Connaughton	Westmeath	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Conor Gormley	Tyrone	3
FB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Justin McMahon	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Westmeath.svg John Keane	Westmeath	2
RWB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Davy Harte	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tomás Ó Sé	Kerry	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Philip Jordan	Tyrone	3
MD	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Enda McGinley	Tyrone	1
MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Shane Ryan	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Brian Dooher	Tyrone	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Declan O'Sullivan	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Seán CavanaghFOTY	Tyrone	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Colm Cooper	Kerry	5
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Kieran Donaghy	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Armagh.svg Rónán Clarke	Armagh	2

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Tyrone = 7
• Kerry = 4
• Westmeath = 2
• Dublin = 1
• Armagh = 1

[https://www.independent.ie/sport/gaelic-football/vodafone-all-star-football-nominations-2008-26479439.html List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Diarmuid Murphy	Kerry	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Karl Lacey	Donegal	2
FB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Michael Shields	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tom O'Sullivan	Kerry	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tomás Ó Sé	Kerry	5
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Graham Canty	Cork	2
LWB	File:Colours of Cork.svg John Miskella	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Dermot Earley	Kildare	2
MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Séamus Scanlon	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Paul GalvinFOTY	Kerry	3
CF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Pearse O'Neill	Cork	1
LWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Tadhg Kennelly	Kerry	1
RCF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Daniel Goulding	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Declan O'Sullivan	Kerry	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Stephen O'Neill	Tyrone	3

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry = 7
• Cork = 5
• Donegal = 1
• Kildare = 1
• Tyrone = 1

[https://www.rte.ie/sport/football/2009/0925/255241-allstars/ List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Down.svg Brendan McVeigh	Down	1
RCB	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Peter Kelly	Kildare	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Michael Shields	Cork	2
LCB	File:Colours of Sligo.svg Charlie Harrison	Sligo	1
RWB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Paudie Kissane	Cork	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Cork.svg Graham Canty	Cork	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Philip Jordan	Tyrone	4
MD	File:Colours of Louth.svg Paddy Keenan	Louth	1
MD	File:Colours of Cork.svg Aidan Walsh	Cork	1
RWF	File:Colours of Down.svg Daniel Hughes	Down	1
CF	File:Colours of Down.svg Martin Clarke	Down	1
LWF	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Johnny Doyle	Kildare	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Colm Cooper	Kerry	6
FF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Bernard BroganFOTY	Dublin	1
LCF	File:Colours of Down.svg Benny Coulter	Down	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Cork = 4
• Down = 4
• Kildare = 2
• Sligo = 1
• Louth = 1
• Tyrone = 1
• Kerry = 1
• Dublin = 1

[https://www.independent.ie/sport/gaelic-football/rebels-dominate-all-star-nominations-26683180.html List of nominations]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Stephen Cluxton	Dublin	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Marc Ó Sé	Kerry	3
FB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Neil McGee	Donegal	1
LCB	File:Colours of Kildare.svg Michael Foley	Kildare	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Kevin Cassidy	Donegal	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Karl Lacey	Donegal	3
LWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Kevin Nolan	Dublin	1
MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Bryan Sheehan	Kerry	1
MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Michael Darragh MacAuley	Dublin	1
RWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Darran O'Sullivan	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Alan BroganFOTY	Dublin	3
LWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paul Flynn	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Colm Cooper	Kerry	7
FF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Andy Moran	Mayo	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Bernard Brogan	Dublin	2

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Dublin = 6
• Kerry = 4
• Donegal = 3
• Mayo = 1
• Kildare = 1

[https://www.rte.ie/sport/gaa/2011/1004/285620-allstarnominations/ List of nominees]

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Paul Durcan	Donegal	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Neil McGee	Donegal	2
FB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Ger Cafferkey	Mayo	1
LCB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Keith Higgins	Mayo	1
RWB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Lee Keegan	Mayo	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Karl LaceyFOTY	Donegal	4
LWB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Frank McGlynn	Donegal	1
MD	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Neil Gallagher	Donegal	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Cork.svg Aidan Walsh	Cork	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paul Flynn	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Alan Dillon	Mayo	2
LWF	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Mark McHugh	Donegal	1
RCF	File:Colours of Cork.svg Colm O'Neill	Cork	1
FF	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Michael Murphy	Donegal	1
LCF	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Colm McFadden	Donegal	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Donegal = 8
• Mayo = 4
• Cork = 2
• Dublin = 1

[https://www.rte.ie/sport/football/2012/1002/340084-donegal-dominate-all-star-nominations-with-12/ List of nominees]

{{cite web|url = http://www.independent.ie/sport/mdma-and-tony-kelly-scoop-top-gongs-at-gaa-gpa-all-star-awards-29738523.html|title= MDMA and Tony Kelly scoop top gongs at GAA GPA All Star Awards|date=8 November 2013|work=Irish Independent|access-date=18 November 2013}}

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Stephen Cluxton	Dublin	5
RCB	File:Colours of Monaghan.svg Colin Walshe	Monaghan	1
FB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Rory O'Carroll	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Keith Higgins	Mayo	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Lee Keegan	Mayo	2
CB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Cian O'Sullivan	Dublin	1
LWB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Colm Boyle	Mayo	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Michael Darragh MacAuleyFOTY	Dublin	2
MD	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Aidan O'Shea	Mayo	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paul Flynn	Dublin	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Colm Cooper	Kerry	8
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Seán Cavanagh	Tyrone	5
RCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg James O'Donoghue	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Bernard Brogan	Dublin	3
LCF	File:Colours of Monaghan.svg Conor McManus	Monaghan	1

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Dublin = 6
• Mayo = 4
• Monaghan = 2
• Kerry = 2
• Tyrone = 1

[https://www.the42.ie/2013-gaa-football-allstars-1112784-Oct2013/ List of nominees]

{{cite web|url = http://www.independent.ie/sport/gaelic-games/gaelic-football/kieran-donaghy-and-diarmuid-connolly-among-football-all-stars-30686629.html|title= Kieran Donaghy and Diarmuid Connolly among football All Stars|date=23 October 2014 |work=Irish Independent|access-date=11 November 2014}}

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | GK	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Paul Durcan	Donegal	2
RCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Paul Murphy	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Neil McGee	Donegal	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Keith Higgins	Mayo	3
RWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg James McCarthy	Dublin	1
CB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Peter Crowley	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Colm Boyle	Mayo	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Neil Gallagher	Donegal	2
MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg David Moran	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paul Flynn	Dublin	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Michael Murphy	Donegal	2
LWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Diarmuid Connolly	Dublin	1
RCF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Cillian O'Connor	Mayo	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Kieran Donaghy	Kerry	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg James O'DonoghueFOTY	Kerry	2

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Kerry= 5
• Donegal= 4
• Dublin= 3
• Mayo= 3

[https://www.the42.ie/allstar-football-2014-1711498-Oct2014/ List of nominees]

{{cite web|url=http://www.independent.ie/sport/gaelic-games/2015-gaagpa-allstars-revealed-tj-reid-and-jack-mccaffrey-pick-up-top-player-awards-34177657.html|title=GAA GPA Opel Hurling All Stars 2015|date=6 November 2015|work=Irish Independent|access-date=10 November 2015}}

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Brendan Kealy	Kerry	1
RCB	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Shane Enright	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Rory O'Carroll	Dublin	2
LCB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Philly McMahon	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Lee Keegan	Mayo	3
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Cian O'Sullivan	Dublin	2
LWB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Jack McCaffreyFOTY	|Dublin	1
MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Brian Fenton	Dublin	1
MD	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Anthony Maher	Kerry	1
RWF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Mattie Donnelly	Tyrone	1
CF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Ciarán Kilkenny	Dublin	1
LWF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Donnchadh Walsh	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RCF	File:Colours of Monaghan.svg Conor McManus	Monaghan	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | FF	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Aidan O'Shea	Mayo	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Bernard Brogan	Dublin	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Dublin= 7
• Kerry= 4
• Mayo= 2
• Tyrone= 1
• Monaghan= 1

[https://www.joe.ie/sport/the-nominations-for-the-2015-gaagpa-gaelic-football-all-stars-have-been-announced-513853 List of nominees]

{{Cite web|url=https://www.gaa.ie/football/news/2016-gaa-gpa-opel-football-all-stars/|title=2016 GAA/GPA Opel Football All-Stars|website=www.gaa.ie|date=3 November 2016 }}

class="wikitable" !Pos.!!Player!!Team!!Appearances
GK	File:Colours of Mayo.svg David Clarke	Mayo	1
RCB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Brendan Harrison	Mayo	1
FB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Jonny Cooper	Dublin	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LCB	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Philly McMahon	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | RWB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Lee KeeganFOTY	Mayo	4
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CB	File:Colours of Mayo.svg Colm Boyle	Mayo	3
LWB	File:Colours of Donegal GAA.svg Ryan McHugh	|Donegal	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Brian Fenton	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | MD	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Mattie Donnelly	Tyrone	2
RWF	File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Peter Harte	Tyrone	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | CF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Diarmuid Connolly	Dublin	2
bgcolor=#FFFFDD | LWF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Ciarán Kilkenny	Dublin	2
RCF	File:Colours of Dublin.svg Dean Rock	Dublin	1
FF	File:Colours of Tipperary.svg Michael Quinlivan	Tipperary	1
LCF	File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Paul Geaney	Kerry	1
bgcolor=#FFFFDD

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Dublin = 6
• Mayo = 4
• Tyrone = 2
• Donegal = 1
• Kerry = 1
• Tipperary = 1

[https://www.joe.ie/sport/here-are-the-gaagpa-football-all-star-nominations-for-2016-562843 List of nominees]

{{Cite news|url=https://www.rte.ie/sport/gaa/2017/1103/917310-dublin-mayo-as/|title=Dublin and Mayo dominate All Star football team|last=Sweeney|first=Peter|date=3 November 2017|work=RTE.ie|access-date=3 November 2017|language=en}}

class="wikitable" !Pos. !Player !Team !Appearances

bgcolor="#FFFFDD" |GK |File:Colours of Mayo.svg David Clarke |Mayo |2

RCB |File:Colours of Mayo.svg Chris Barrett |Mayo |1

FB |File:Colours of Dublin.svg Michael Fitzsimons |Dublin |1

bgcolor="#FFFFDD" |LCB |File:Colours of Mayo.svg Keith Higgins |Mayo |4

bgcolor="#FFFFDD"

RWB |File:Colours of Mayo.svg Colm Boyle |Mayo |4

bgcolor="#FFFFDD" |CB |File:Colours of Dublin.svg Cian O'Sullivan |Dublin |3

bgcolor="#FFFFDD" |LWB |File:Colours of Dublin.svg Jack McCaffrey |Dublin |2

MD |File:Colours of Tyrone.svg Colm Cavanagh |Tyrone |1

bgcolor="#FFFFDD" |MD |File:Colours of Dublin.svg James McCarthy |Dublin |2

bgcolor="#FFFFDD" |RWF |File:Colours of Dublin.svg Dean Rock |Dublin |2

bgcolor="#FFFFDD" |CF |File:Colours of Mayo.svg Aidan O'Shea |Mayo |3

LWF |File:Colours of Dublin.svg Con O'Callaghan |Dublin |1

RCF |File:Colours of Dublin.svg Paul Mannion |Dublin |1

bgcolor="#FFFFDD" |FF |File:Colours of Kerry GAA.svg Paul Geaney |Kerry |2

bgcolor="#FFFFDD" |LCF |File:Colours of Mayo.svg Andy MoranFOTY |Mayo |2

{{Color box|#FFFFDD|border=silver}} Player has previously been selected.

;County breakdown

• Dublin = 7
• Mayo = 6
• Kerry = 1
• Tyrone = 1

[https://www.the42.ie/dublin-mayo-football-all-stars-3607626-Sep2017/ List of nominees]