Miss America 1958

! Placement

! Contestant

|

• {{flag|Colorado|1911}} – Marilyn Van Derbur

|

• {{flag|Georgia (U.S. state)|1956|name = Georgia}} – Jody Elizabeth Shattuck

|

• {{flag|Oklahoma|1941}} – Mary Nancy Denner

|

• {{flag|California}} – Lorna M. Anderson

|

• {{flag|Florida|1900}} – Dorothy Maria Steiner

|

• {{flag|Arizona}} – Lynn Freyse
• {{flag|Missouri}} – Sara Ann Cooper
• {{flag|Nevada|1929}} – Loni Jess Gravelle
• {{flag|North Carolina|1885}} – Elaine Herndon
• {{flag|Oregon}} – Judith Faye Hansen

! Awards

! Contestant

|

• {{flagicon|Arizona}} Arizona - Lynn Freyse
• {{flagicon|Georgia (U.S. state)|1956}} Georgia - Jody Elizabeth Shattuck
• {{flagicon|North Carolina|1885}} North Carolina - Elaine Herndon

|

• {{flagicon|Indiana}} Indiana - Gloria Ruth Rupprecht
• {{flagicon|Missouri}} Missouri - Sara Ann Cooper
• {{flagicon|Oregon}} Oregon - Judith Faye Hansen (tie)
• {{flagicon|Pennsylvania}} Pennsylvania - Jennie Rebecca Blatchford (tie)

! Awards

! Contestant

|

• {{flagicon|New Mexico}} New Mexico - Glynnelle Hubbard

|

• {{Flagicon|Alabama}} Alabama - Anna Stange
• {{Flagicon|Connecticut}} Connecticut - Susan Lightbown
• {{Flagicon|Idaho}} Idaho - Carene Clark
• {{Flagicon|Kentucky}} Kentucky - Jane Brock
• {{Flagicon|Nebraska}} Nebraska - Kathleen L. Nielson
• {{Flagicon|Utah}} Utah - Francine Louise Felt
• {{Flagicon|Vermont}} Vermont - Joan Hewitt

|+

!State

!Name

!Hometown

!Age

!Talent

!Placement

!Awards

!Notes

|Anna Stange

|Birmingham

|

|Monologue from Mourning Becomes Electra

|

|Non-finalist Talent Award

|

|Lynn Freyse

|Tucson

|

|Dramatic Reading from The Country Girl

|Top 10

|Preliminary Lifestyle & Fitness Award

|Later starred in the TV series Hazel

|Suzanne Scudder

|Hot Springs

|

|Vocal

|

|

|

|Lorna Anderson

|Sacramento

|

|Accordion, "Dark Eyes"

|3rd runner-up

|

|

|Joan May Fitzpatrick

|Windsor

|

|

|

|

|

|Bette Lieb

|Chicago

|

|Dramatic Monologue from Romeo and Juliet

|

|

|

|Marilyn Van Derbur

|Denver

|20

|Organ, "Tea for Two" & "Tenderly"

|Winner

|

|

|Susan Lightbown

|Fairfield

|

|Vocal, "Wouldn't it be Loverly" from My Fair Lady

|

|Non-finalist Talent Award

|

|Kathleen Ann D'Attillio

|Wilimington

|

|Piano

|

|

|

|June Cook

|Arlington, VA

|20

|Piano, "Rhapsody in Blue"

|

|

|

|Dorothy Maria Steiner

|Boca Raton

|

|Dramatic Reading, "Such is Your Heritage"

|4th runner-up

|

|

|Jody Shattuck

|Atlanta

|20

|Vocal & Dance, "Namely You" from Li'l Abner

|1st runner-up

|Preliminary Lifestyle & Fitness Award

|

|Sandra Lei Lauhiwa Forsythe

|Honolulu

|

|Hula

|

|

|

|Carene Clark

|Pocatello

|

|Classical Vocal from Die Fledermaus

|

|Non-finalist Talent Award

|

|Jeannie Beacham

|Downers Grove

|

|Drama, "The Great Debates"

|

|

|

|Gloria Rupprecht

|Valparaiso

|

|Vocal/Comedy Skit, "My Hero"

|

|Preliminary Talent Award

|

|Carol Fleck

|Oskaloosa

|19

|Dance

|

|

|

|Georgiana Rundle

|Axtell

|21

|Vocal, "Habanera" & "Getting to Know You"

|

|

|

|Jane Brock

|Liberty

|

|Piano

|

|Non-finalist Talent Award

|

|Beverly Leigh Norman

|Shreveport

|

|Vocal, "My Own True Love"

|

|

|

|Carol Ann Bartels

|Bath

|

|Drama/Art

|

|

|

|Nancy Elizabeth Norris

|Silver Spring

|

|Dramatic Monologue, "A Letter to my Parents"

|

|

|

|Daly Hirsch

|Boston

|

|Drama

|

|

|

|Valerie Strong

|Williamsburg

|

|Piano, "Brazil"

|

|

|

|Ardyce Gustafson

|St. Paul

|

|Vocal Medley from My Fair Lady

|

|

|

|Mary Allen

|Yazoo City

|

|Dance & Art Presentation

|

|

|

|Sara Cooper

|Buckner

|

|Charleston Dance

|Top 10

|Preliminary Talent Award

|Daughter of Major League Baseball player, Walker Cooper

|Kathleen L. Nielsen

|Lincoln

|

|Dance

|

|Non-finalist Talent Award

|Later Miss Iowa USA 1959

|Loni Gravelle

|Reno

|

|Piano, "Piano Concerto in A Minor" by Edvard Grieg

|Top 10

|

|

|Holly Arnel

|New London

|

|Drama

|

|

|

|Janet Ressler

|Union

|

|Vocal

|

|

|

|Glynnelle Hubbard

|Farmington

|19

|Dance

|

|Miss Congeniality

|

|Janet Corrigan

|Huntington

|

|Vocal, "True Love"

|

|

|

|Astrid Papamichael

|New York City

|

|Vocal

|

|

|

|Elaine Herndon

|Durham

|

|Vocal & Dance

|Top 10

|Preliminary Lifestyle & Fitness Award

|

|Helen Winje

|Minot

|

|Vocal

|

|

|

|Linda Hattman

|Mansfield

|

|Ballet

|

|

|

|Mary Nancy Denner

|Alva

|

|Poetry Recitation, "The Ballad of the Harp Weaver" by Edna St. Vincent Millay

|2nd runner-up

|

|

|Judith Hansen

|Astoria

|

|Classical Vocal, "Mi Chiamano Mimi" from La bohéme

|Top 10

|Preliminary Talent Award

|

|Jennie Rebecca Blatchford

|Hollidaysburg

|

|Baton Twirling, "St. Louis Blues" & "The Stars and Stripes Forever"

|

|Preliminary Talent Award

|

|Winnie Rodríguez

|

|

|

|

|

|

|Beatrice Turek

|Providence

|

|Art Display

|

|

|

|Cecilia Colvert

|Greenwood

|18

|Pantomime/Vocal, "C'est si bon" by Eartha Kitt

|

|

|Mother of Miss South Carolina 1988, Anna Graham Reynolds

|Patricia Miller

|Mobridge

|

|Vocal

|

|

|

|Amanda Lee Whitman

|Nashville

|

|Trampoline/Tumbling, "The Third Man Theme"

|

|

|Performed the first trampoline talent act in the Miss America competition

|Carolyn Calvert

|Austin

|

|Monologue from Medea

|

|

|

|Francine Louise Felt

|Salt Lake City

|

|Violin

|

|Non-finalist Talent Award

|

|Joan Hewitt

|Brattleboro

|

|Art Presentation & Original Skit with original music

|

|Non-finalist Talent Award

|

|Rebecca Lee Edmunds

|Roanoke

|

|Dance

|

|

|

|Janice Sickle

|Fairmont

|

|Vocal & Dance

|

|

|

|Joan Hentschel

|Wauwatosa

|18

|Interpretive Dance, "3:00 in the Morning"

|

|

|