Ring species

{{See also|History of speciation}}

File:Ring species seagull.svg|The Larus gulls interbreed in a ring around the arctic. 1: L. fuscus, 2: Siberian population of L. fuscus, 3: L. heuglini, 4: L. vegae birulai, 5: L. vegae, 6: L. smithsonianus, 7: L. argentatus

File:PT05 ubt.jpeg|Herring gull (Larus argentatus) (front) and lesser black-backed gull (Larus fuscus) (behind) in Norway: two phenotypes with clear differences

The classic ring species is the Larus gull. In 1925 Jonathan Dwight found the genus to form a chain of varieties around the Arctic Circle. However, doubts have arisen as to whether this represents an actual ring species.{{cite journal |last1=Liebers |first1=D. |last2=De Knijff |first2=P. |last3=Helbig |first3=A. J. |doi=10.1098/rspb.2004.2679 |title=The herring gull complex is not a ring species |journal=Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences |volume=271 |issue=1542 |pages=893–901 |year=2004 |pmid=15255043 |pmc=1691675}} In 1938, Claud Buchanan Ticehurst argued that the greenish warbler had spread from Nepal around the Tibetan Plateau, while adapting to each new environment, meeting again in Siberia where the ends no longer interbreed.{{cite web |url=https://www.zoology.ubc.ca/~irwin/GreenishWarblers.html |title=The greenish warbler ring species |first=Darren |last=Irwin}} These and other discoveries led Mayr to first formulate a theory on ring species in his 1942 study Systematics and the Origin of Species. Also in the 1940s, Robert C. Stebbins described the Ensatina salamanders around the Californian Central Valley as a ring species;{{cite web |url=https://evolution.berkeley.edu/a-closer-look-at-a-classic-ring-species/ |title=A closer look at a classic ring species: The work of Tom Devitt |work=Understanding Evolution|date=29 April 2021 }}This species ring forms the subject of "The Salamander's tale" in Richard Dawkins' The Ancestor's Tale, 2004. but again, some authors such as Jerry Coyne consider this classification incorrect.{{cite book |title=Speciation |author1=Coyne, Jerry A. |author2=Orr, H. Allen |date=2004 |pages=102–105 |publisher=Sinauer Associates |isbn=0-87893-091-4}} Finally in 2012, the first example of a ring species in plants was found in a spurge, forming a ring around the Caribbean Sea.{{cite journal |last1=Cacho |first1=N. Ivalú |last2=Baum |first2=David A. |title=The Caribbean slipper spurge Euphorbia tithymaloides: the first example of a ring species in plants |journal=Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences |date=7 September 2012 |volume=279 |issue=1742 |pages=3377–3383 |doi=10.1098/rspb.2012.0498 |pmid=22696529 |pmc=3396892}}

The biologist Ernst Mayr championed the concept of ring species, stating that it unequivocally demonstrated the process of speciation.{{cite journal |last1=Pereira |first1=Ricardo J. |last2=Wake |first2=David B. |title=Ring species as demonstrations of the continuum of species formation |journal=Molecular Ecology |date=November 2015 |volume=24 |issue=21 |pages=5312–5314 |doi=10.1111/mec.13412 |pmid=26509692 |s2cid=206182763 |doi-access=free|bibcode=2015MolEc..24.5312P }} A ring species is an alternative model to allopatric speciation, "illustrating how new species can arise through 'circular overlap', without interruption of gene flow through intervening populations…"{{cite journal |last1=Helbig |first1=A J |title=Evolutionary genetics: A ring of species |journal=Heredity |date=August 2005 |volume=95 |issue=2 |pages=113–114 |doi=10.1038/sj.hdy.6800679 |pmid=15999143 |s2cid=29782163 |doi-access=free}} However, Jerry Coyne and H. Allen Orr point out that rings species more closely model parapatric speciation.

Ring species often attract the interests of evolutionary biologists, systematists, and researchers of speciation leading to both thought provoking ideas and confusion concerning their definition. Contemporary scholars recognize that examples in nature have proved rare due to various factors such as limitations in taxonomic delineation{{cite journal |last1=Irwin |first1=Darren E |title=A novel approach for finding ring species: look for barriers rather than rings |journal=BMC Biology |date=December 2012 |volume=10 |issue=1 |pages=21 |doi=10.1186/1741-7007-10-21 |pmid=22410355 |pmc=3299606 |doi-access=free }} or, "taxonomic zeal"—explained by the fact that taxonomists classify organisms into "species", while ring species often cannot fit this definition. Other reasons such as gene flow interruption from "vicariate divergence" and fragmented populations due to climate instability have also been cited.

Ring species also present an interesting case of the species problem for those seeking to divide the living world into discrete species. All that distinguishes a ring species from two separate species is the existence of the connecting populations; if enough of the connecting populations within the ring perish to sever the breeding connection then the ring species' distal populations will be recognized as two distinct species. The problem is whether to quantify the whole ring as a single species (despite the fact that not all individuals interbreed) or to classify each population as a distinct species (despite the fact that it interbreeds with its near neighbours). Ring species illustrate that species boundaries arise gradually and often exist on a continuum.

File:Ensatina eschscholtzii ring species.jpg salamanders example of ring species]]

File:Greenish warbler ring.svg not shown]]

Many examples have been documented in nature. Debate exists concerning much of the research, with some authors citing evidence against their existence entirely.{{cite web |last=Coyne |first=Jerry |title=There are no ring species |publisher=Why Evolution is True |date=16 July 2014 |url=https://whyevolutionistrue.com/2014/07/16/there-are-no-ring-species/}}{{self-published inline|date=July 2021}} The following examples provide evidence that—despite the limited number of concrete, idealized examples in nature—continuums of species do exist and can be found in biological systems. This is often characterized by sub-species level classifications such as clines, ecotypes, complexes, and varieties. Many examples have been disputed by researchers, and equally "many of the [proposed] cases have received very little attention from researchers, making it difficult to assess whether they display the characteristics of ideal ring species."

The following list gives examples of ring species found in nature. Some of the examples such as the Larus gull complex, the greenish warbler of Asia, and the Ensatina salamanders of America, have been disputed.{{cite journal |last1=Alcaide |first1=Miguel |last2=Scordato |first2=Elizabeth S. C. |last3=Price |first3=Trevor D. |last4=Irwin |first4=Darren E. |title=Genomic divergence in a ring species complex |journal=Nature |date=July 2014 |volume=511 |issue=7507 |pages=83–85 |doi=10.1038/nature13285 |pmid=24870239 |bibcode=2014Natur.511...83A |hdl=10261/101651 |s2cid=4458956 |hdl-access=free}}{{cite journal |last1=Liebers |first1=Dorit |last2=Knijff |first2=Peter de |last3=Helbig |first3=Andreas J. |title=The herring gull complex is not a ring species |journal=Proc Biol Sci |date=2004 |volume=271 |issue=1542 |pages=893–901 |doi=10.1098/rspb.2004.2679 |pmid=15255043 |pmc=1691675}}{{cite journal |author=Highton, R. |date=1998 |title=Is Ensatina eschscholtzii a ring species? |journal=Herpetologica |volume=54 |issue=2 |pages=254–278 |jstor=3893431}}

• Acanthiza pusilla and A. ewingii{{Citation |title=Birds of Australia |edition=6 |author1=Simpson, K. |author2=Day, N. |author3=Trusler, P. |date=1999 |publisher=Princeton University Press}}
• Acacia karroo{{cite journal |last1=Ward |first1=David |title=Population differentiation in a purported ring species, Acacia karroo (Mimosoideae) |journal=Biological Journal of the Linnean Society |date=December 2011 |volume=104 |issue=4 |pages=748–755 |doi=10.1111/j.1095-8312.2011.01757.x |doi-access=free}}
• Alauda skylarks (Alauda arvensis, A. japonica and A. gulgula)
• Alophoixus{{cite journal |last1=Fuchs |first1=Jérôme |last2=Ericson |first2=Per G.P. |last3=Bonillo |first3=Céline |last4=Couloux |first4=Arnaud |last5=Pasquet |first5=Eric |title=The complex phylogeography of the Indo-Malayan Alophoixus bulbuls with the description of a putative new ring species complex |journal=Molecular Ecology |date=November 2015 |volume=24 |issue=21 |pages=5460–5474 |doi=10.1111/mec.13337 |pmid=26224534 |bibcode=2015MolEc..24.5460F |s2cid=44672012}}
• Aulostomus (Trumpetfish){{cite journal |last1=Bowen |first1=B. W. |last2=Bass |first2=A. L. |last3=Rocha |first3=L. A. |last4=Grant |first4=W. S. |last5=Robertson |first5=D. R. |title=Phytogeography of the Trumpetfishes (Aulostomus): Ring Species Complex on a Global Scale |journal=Evolution |date=2001 |volume=55 |issue=5 |pages=1029–1039 |doi=10.1554/0014-3820(2001)055[1029:pottar]2.0.co;2 |pmid=11430639 |s2cid=221735739 |doi-access=}}
• Camarhynchus psittacula and C. pauper
• Chaerephon pumilus species complex{{cite journal |last1=Naidoo |first1=Theshnie |last2=Goodman |first2=Steven M. |last3=Schoeman |first3=M. Corrie |last4=Taylor |first4=Peter J. |last5=Lamb |first5=Jennifer M. |title=Partial support for the classical ring species hypothesis in the Chaerephon pumilus species complex (Chiroptera: Molossidae) from southeastern Africa and western Indian Ocean islands |journal=Mammalia |date=1 January 2016 |volume=80 |issue=6 |doi=10.1515/mammalia-2015-0062 |s2cid=89517662}}
• Ensatina salamanders{{cite journal |last1=Moritz |first1=C. |last2=Schneider |first2=C. J. |last3=Wake |first3=D. B. |title=Evolutionary Relationships Within the Ensatina Eschscholtzii Complex Confirm the Ring Species Interpretation |journal=Systematic Biology |date=1 September 1992 |volume=41 |issue=3 |pages=273–291 |doi=10.1093/sysbio/41.3.273 |s2cid=49267121}}{{cite journal |last1=Moritz |first1=Craig |last2=Schneider |first2=Christopher J. |last3=Wake |first3=David B. |title=Evolutionary Relationships Within the Ensatina eschscholtzii Complex Confirm the Ring Species Interpretation |journal=Systematic Biology |date=September 1992 |volume=41 |issue=3 |pages=273–291 |doi=10.2307/2992567 |jstor=2992567}}
• Euphorbia tithymaloides is a group within the spurge family that has reproduced and evolved in a ring through Central America and the Caribbean, meeting in the Virgin Islands where they appear to be morphologically and ecologically distinct.
• Great tit (however, some studies dispute this example{{cite journal |last1=Päckert |first1=Martin |last2=Martens |first2=Jochen |last3=Eck |first3=Siegfried |last4=Nazarenko |first4=Alexander A. |last5=Valchuk |first5=Olga P. |last6=Petri |first6=Bernd |last7=Veith |first7=Michael |title=The great tit (Parus major) - a misclassified ring species |journal=Biological Journal of the Linnean Society |date=27 September 2005 |volume=86 |issue=2 |pages=153–174 |doi=10.1111/j.1095-8312.2005.00529.x |doi-access=}}{{cite journal |last1=Kvist |first1=Laura |last2=Martens |first2=Jochen |last3=Higuchi |first3=Hiroyoshi |last4=Nazarenko |first4=Alexander A. |last5=Valchuk |first5=Olga P. |last6=Orell |first6=Markku |title=Evolution and genetic structure of the great tit (Parus major) complex |journal=Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences |date=22 July 2003 |volume=270 |issue=1523 |pages=1447–1454 |doi=10.1098/rspb.2002.2321 |pmid=12965008 |pmc=1691391}})
• The greenish warbler (Phylloscopus trochiloides) forms a species ring, around the Himalayas.{{cite journal |last1=Alström |first1=Per |title=Species concepts and their application: insights from the genera Seicercus and Phylloscopus |journal=Acta Zoologica Sinica |volume=52 |issue=Suppl |pages=429–434 |year=2006 |s2cid=145032793 |url=http://www.actazool.org/temp/{D12A500A-EAD9-4908-BDB7-35A4CF1BB9A7}.pdf |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20110721235326/http://www.actazool.org/temp/%7BD12A500A-EAD9-4908-BDB7-35A4CF1BB9A7%7D.pdf |archive-date=21 July 2011}}{{cite journal |last1=Irwin |first1=D. E. |last2=Bensch |first2=S |last3=Irwin |first3=JH |last4=Price |first4=TD |title=Speciation by Distance in a Ring Species |journal=Science |date=21 January 2005 |volume=307 |issue=5708 |pages=414–416 |doi=10.1126/science.1105201 |pmid=15662011 |bibcode=2005Sci...307..414I |s2cid=18347146}} It is thought to have spread from Nepal around the inhospitable Tibetan Plateau, to rejoin in Siberia, where the plumbeitarsus and the viridanus appeared to no longer mutually reproduce.
• Hoplitis producta
• House mouse
• Junonia coenia and J. genoveva/J. evarete
• Lalage leucopygialis, L. nigra, and L. sueurii
• Larus gulls form a circumpolar "ring" around the North Pole. The European herring gull (L. argentatus argenteus), which lives primarily in Great Britain and Ireland, can hybridize with the American herring gull (L. smithsonianus), (living in North America), which can also hybridize with the Vega or East Siberian herring gull (L. vegae), the western subspecies of which, Birula's gull (L. vegae birulai), can hybridize with Heuglin's gull (L. heuglini), which in turn can hybridize with the Siberian lesser black-backed gull (L. fuscus). All four of these live across the north of Siberia. The last is the eastern representative of the lesser black-backed gulls back in north-western Europe, including Great Britain. The lesser black-backed gulls and herring gulls are sufficiently different that they do not normally hybridize; thus the group of gulls forms a continuum except where the two lineages meet in Europe. However, a 2004 genetic study entitled "The herring gull complex is not a ring species" has shown that this example is far more complex than presented here (Liebers et al., 2004):{{cite journal |last1=Liebers |first1=Dorit |last2=de Knijff |first2=Peter |last3=Helbig |first3=Andreas J. |title=The herring gull complex is not a ring species |journal=Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences |date=7 May 2004 |volume=271 |issue=1542 |pages=893–901 |doi=10.1098/rspb.2004.2679 |pmid=15255043 |pmc=1691675}} this example only speaks to the complex of species from the classical herring gull through lesser black-backed gull. There are several other taxonomically unclear examples that belong in the same species complex, such as yellow-legged gull (L. michahellis), glaucous gull (L. hyperboreus), and Caspian gull (L. cachinnans).
• Pelophylax nigromaculatus and P. porosus/P. porosus brevipodus (the names and classification of these species have changed since the publication suggesting a ring species)
• Pernis ptilorhynchus and P. celebensis
• Perognathus amplus and P. longimembris
• Peromyscus maniculatus{{cite journal |last1=Caire |first1=W. |last2=Zimmerman |first2=E. G. |title=Chromosomal and Morphological Variation and Circular Overlap in the Deer Mouse, Peromyscus Maniculatus, in Texas and Oklahoma |journal=Systematic Biology |date=1 March 1975 |volume=24 |issue=1 |pages=89–95 |doi=10.1093/sysbio/24.1.89}}
• Phellinus{{cite journal |last1=Parmasto |first1=Erast |title=Phellinus laevigatus s. l. (Hymenochaetales): a ring species |journal=Folia Cryptogamica Estonica |date=2007 |volume=43 |pages=39–49 |url=https://ojs.utlib.ee/index.php/FCE/article/view/13753}}
• Platycercus elegans (Crimson rosella) complex{{cite journal |last1=Joseph |first1=Leo |last2=Dolman |first2=Gaynor |last3=Donnellan |first3=Stephen |last4=Saint |first4=Kathleen M |last5=Berg |first5=Mathew L |last6=Bennett |first6=Andrew T.D |title=Where and when does a ring start and end? Testing the ring-species hypothesis in a species complex of Australian parrots |journal=Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences |date=7 November 2008 |volume=275 |issue=1650 |pages=2431–2440 |doi=10.1098/rspb.2008.0765 |pmid=18664434 |pmc=2603204}}{{cite journal |last1=Eastwood |first1=Justin R. |last2=Berg |first2=Mathew L. |last3=Ribot |first3=Raoul F. H. |last4=Raidal |first4=Shane R. |last5=Buchanan |first5=Katherine L. |last6=Walder |first6=Ken R. |last7=Bennett |first7=Andrew T. D. |title=Phylogenetic analysis of beak and feather disease virus across a host ring-species complex |journal=Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences |date=30 September 2014 |volume=111 |issue=39 |pages=14153–14158 |doi=10.1073/pnas.1403255111 |pmid=25225394 |pmc=4191811 |bibcode=2014PNAS..11114153E |doi-access=free}}
• Drosophila paulistorum{{cite journal |last1=Dobzhansky |first1=T. |last2=Spassky |first2=B. |title=Drosophila Paulistorum, A Cluster of Species in Statu Nascendi |journal=Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences |date=1 March 1959 |volume=45 |issue=3 |pages=419–428 |doi=10.1073/pnas.45.3.419 |pmid=16590403 |pmc=222578 |bibcode=1959PNAS...45..419D |doi-access=free}}
• Phylloscopus collybita and P. sindianus
• Phylloscopus (Willow warblers){{cite journal |last1=Bensch |first1=Staffan |last2=Grahn |first2=Mats |last3=Müller |first3=Nils |last4=Gay |first4=Laurene |last5=Åkesson |first5=Susanne |title=Genetic, morphological, and feather isotope variation of migratory willow warblers show gradual divergence in a ring |journal=Molecular Ecology |date=July 2009 |volume=18 |issue=14 |pages=3087–3096 |doi=10.1111/j.1365-294X.2009.04210.x |pmid=19457197 |bibcode=2009MolEc..18.3087B |s2cid=205361829}}{{cite journal |last1=Irwin |first1=Darren E. |title=Incipient ring speciation revealed by a migratory divide |journal=Molecular Ecology |date=July 2009 |volume=18 |issue=14 |pages=2923–2925 |doi=10.1111/j.1365-294X.2009.04211.x |pmid=19457189 |s2cid=13601570 |doi-access=free|bibcode=2009MolEc..18.2923I }}
• Powelliphanta{{cite journal |last1=Climo |first1=F. M. |title=The Powelliphanta gilliesi — traversi — hochstetteri — rossiana — lignaria — superba ring species (Mollusca: Pulmonata) |journal=New Zealand Journal of Zoology |date=June 1978 |volume=5 |issue=2 |pages=289–294 |doi=10.1080/03014223.1978.10428318}}
• Rhymogona silvatica and R. cervina (the names and classification of these species have changed since the publication suggesting a ring species)
• Melospiza melodia, a song sparrow, forms a ring around the Sierra Nevada of California{{cite journal |last1=Patten |first1=Michael A. |last2=Pruett |first2=Christin L. |title=The Song Sparrow, Melospiza melodia, as a ring species: Patterns of geographic variation, a revision of subspecies, and implications for speciation |journal=Systematics and Biodiversity |date=March 2009 |volume=7 |issue=1 |pages=33–62 |doi=10.1017/S1477200008002867 |bibcode=2009SyBio...7...33P |s2cid=154943}} with the subspecies heermanni and fallax meeting in the vicinity of the San Gorgonio Pass.
• Todiramphus chloris and T. cinnamominus

• Dialect continuum, a similar concept in linguistics
• Intergradation

{{reflist|30em}}

• [http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/1123973.stm Greenish Warbler]
• [https://www.zoology.ubc.ca/~irwin/GreenishWarblers.html Greenish Warbler maps and songs]
• [https://web.archive.org/web/20160416052319/http://www.ensatina.net/FILES/ensatina.htm Ensatina salamander]
• {{YouTube|Pb6Z6NVmLt8|Ring species – the abridged version}}, by Peter Hadfield (potholer54)
• [https://web.archive.org/web/20071016204715/http://museum.gov.ns.ca/mnh/nature/nsbirds/bns0177.htm Nova Scotia Museum of Natural History: Birds of Nova Scotia]
• [http://www.surfbirds.com/ID%20Articles/adriaensgulls1203.html Hybrid Gulls Breeding in Belgium]

{{Speciation}}

Category:Species

Category:Evolutionary biology