That What Is Not
{{EngvarB|date=September 2013}}
{{Use dmy dates|date=October 2024}}
{{Infobox album
| name = That What Is Not
| type = studio
| artist = Public Image Ltd
| cover = PILthatwhatisnot.jpg
| border = yes
| alt =
| released = 10 February 1992Cocatalog.loc.gov United States Copyright Office website
| recorded = 1991
| studio = Eldorado Studios, Los Angeles, United States
| genre = Alternative rock
| length = 49:37
| label = Virgin
| producer = Dave Jerden
| prev_title = The Greatest Hits, So Far
| prev_year = 1990
| next_title = This is PiL
| next_year = 2012
}}
{{Album ratings
| rev1 = AllMusic
| rev1score = {{Rating|2|5}}[{{AllMusic|class=album|id=r59790|pure_url=yes}} AllMusic review]
| rev2 = The Encyclopedia of Popular Music
| rev2score = {{rating|2|5}}{{cite book |last1=Larkin |first1=Colin |title=The Encyclopedia of Popular Music |date=2006 |publisher=MUZE |volume=6 |page=682}}
| rev3 = Entertainment Weekly
| rev3score = A{{Cite web|url=https://ew.com/article/1992/03/06/what-not/|title=That What Is Not|website=Entertainment Weekly}}
| rev4 = MusicHound Rock: The Essential Album Guide
| rev4score = {{rating|2|5}}{{cite book |title=MusicHound Rock: The Essential Album Guide |date=1999 |publisher=Visible Ink Press |page=905}}
| rev5 = The Rolling Stone Album Guide
| rev5score = {{Rating|2.5|5}}{{cite book|chapter=Public Image Ltd.|last1=Coleman|first1=Mark|last2=Matos|first2=Michaelangelo|title=The New Rolling Stone Album Guide|editor1-last=Brackett|editor1-first=Nathan|editor2-last=Hoard|editor2-first=Christian|publisher=Simon & Schuster |edition=4th |year=2004 |isbn=0-7432-0169-8|pages=[https://archive.org/details/newrollingstonea00brac/page/662 662–63]}}
| rev6 = Spin Alternative Record Guide
| rev6score = 2/10{{cite book |title=Spin Alternative Record Guide |date=1995 |publisher=Vintage Books |page=316}}
}}
That What Is Not is the eighth studio album by Public Image Ltd, released on 10 February 1992 in the US, and on 24 February 1992 in the UK.{{Cite web|url=https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/1992/04/17/gleefully-nasty-public-image/b760376e-8a4f-4e4d-9d68-b41e0bee4d19/|title=GLEEFULLY NASTY PUBLIC IMAGE|first=Joe|last=Brown|date=17 April 1992|work=The Washington Post}} It was the band's final album before a 20-year hiatus, and the final recordings with longtime members Allan Dias (bass) and John McGeoch (lead guitar).{{Cite web|url=https://www.allmusic.com/artist/public-image-ltd-mn0000364399/biography|title=Public Image Ltd. | Biography & History|publisher=AllMusic}}
Critical reception
The Los Angeles Times wrote that Lydon "has been able to stay somewhat current by rocking persuasively and directing his still considerable bile toward such germane targets as censors and militarists."{{Cite web|url=https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1992-03-28-ca-4201-story.html|title=O.C. POP MUSIC REVIEW : That What It Wasn't : A hard-to-take PiL and a so-so B.A.D. II and Blind Melon make for a tedious '120 Minutes.' Live, though, is lively.|date=28 March 1992|website=Los Angeles Times}} Entertainment Weekly wrote that the album "showcases PIL’s brutal version of modern dance rock, an angry sound that pummels rather than lulls." Trouser Press wrote that the songs "display either a loss of conviction, an absence of inspiration or a grave lack of effort."{{cite web |title=Public Image Ltd. |url=https://trouserpress.com/reviews/public-image-ltd/ |website=Trouser Press |access-date=25 December 2020}}
Track listing
All tracks written by PiL
{{Track list
|title1 = Acid Drops
|length1 = 6:35
|title2 = Luck's Up
|length2 = 4:07
|title3 = Cruel
|length3 = 5:18
|title4 = God
|length4 = 5:33
|title5 = Covered
|length5 = 4:40
|title6 = Love Hope
|length6 = 3:48
|title7 = Unfairground
|length7 = 5:16
|title8 = Think Tank
|length8 = 4:40
|title9 = Emperor
|length9 = 4:08
|title10 = Good Things
|length10 = 5:34
}}
Personnel
;Public Image Limited
- John Lydon – lead vocals (uncredited on actual album packaging)
- John McGeoch – lead guitar
- Gregg "J.P." Arreguin – rhythm guitar
- Allan Dias – bass, backing vocals, keyboards
- Curt "Kirkee B." Bisquera – drums, percussion
with:
- Tower of Power – horns on "Covered" and "Good Things"
- Jimmie Wood – harmonica on "Covered", "Love Hope" and "Good Things"
- Bonnie Sheridan – background vocals on "Good Things"
Track by track commentary by band members
"Acid Drops":
- John Lydon (1992): "[The song is about] censorship – that particularly relates to America, because there's a lot of vested interest groups, like all these religious fanatics. They're saying the human body, and everything connected with it, is dirty – that's wrong. I don't believe in censorship of any kind".Ralph Heibutzki: "15 Years Later Lydon's Still Howling" (South Haven Daily Tribune, 10 April 1992) "Well, [using a Sex Pistols sample for the song] started off as a joke. The producer threw it in one night for a laugh. I didn't find it too funny at first! But now I think it's perfect for the song. Oh, why not? I can't take myself too seriously".Ian Gittins: "Public Image Limited – Cruel As Fuck" (Melody Maker, 7 March 1992) "I'd recommend him to anyone – he's the best producer I've ever worked with. He's a rarity, in that he speaks his mind. He doesn't do things for fashionable reasons".
"Luck's Up":
- John Lydon (1999): “'Luck's Up' is about the hopelessness of junkies and druggies".John Lydon liner notes (Public Image Ltd.: "Plastic Box" compilation, Virgin Records, 1999)
"Think Tank":
- John Lydon (1992/99): “'Think Tank' is me having a go back at all the people who all the time rewrite and misrepresent the events of my past, usually middle-class journalists who were never there at the time". "Yes, ['Think Tank' is about rewriting] my history, in particular. I know Jon very well – I just don't like the slant of his bookJon Savage: "England's Dreaming – Sex Pistols and Punk Rock" (Faber and Faber, 1991) with that upper-class attitude of those who know everything, while us working-class bums know nothing".
=Related tracks=
"Criminal":Various Artists: "Point Break – Music From The Motion Picture" (MCA Records, released 9 July 1991 / release date according to United States Copyright Office website)
- John Lydon (1990/99): "A whole bunch of new stuff which will be recorded in January, February, March [1991] – that way, and I think in England. I couldn't tell you who the producer is at the moment, because me and my record company are squabbling! Yes, folks, I do love to drag my dirty laundry out in public!”Edwin Gould: "John Lydon Interview" (KROQ-FM radio station, Los Angeles, 6 November 1990) “'Criminal' was for the soundtrack for the movie Point Break.”
- Allan Dias (2004): "It was written specifically for the movie. I think initially it was one of John McGeoch's songs, or a sketch that he had, it was based on that. We went into the studio with a producer specifically to do that track, it was a one-off thing, it wasn't an outtake or anything. As I recall we were approached by someone from the movie, but I think we were in the middle of recording an album or something, possibly working on '9', and by the time we got the track done and put it to them it was too late to be considered for the title track. But they put it on there regardless".Scott Murphy: "Allan Dias Interview" (Fodderstompf.com website, May 2004)
Charts
class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders" |
Chart (1992)
! Peak |
---|
{{Album chart|UK2|46|date=19920604|rowheader=true|accessdate=March 1, 2025}} |
References
{{reflist}}
{{Public Image Ltd.}}
{{Authority control}}
Category:Public Image Ltd albums