Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Xiao-i

{{AFD help}}

:{{la|1=Xiao-i}} – (View AfDView log | edits since nomination)

:({{Find sources AFD|title=Xiao-i}})

does not clearly demonstrate the company's notability through significant independent sources, which is a key requirement for Wikipedia. Much of the information appears to rely on primary or promotional sources, lacking in-depth third-party coverage that would confirm its broader impact or importance. Additionally, the article may contain promotional language, which violates Wikipedia's guidelines on neutrality RodrigoIPacce (talk) 12:14, 24 October 2024 (UTC)

• Note: This discussion has been included in the list of Companies-related deletion discussions. RodrigoIPacce (talk) 12:14, 24 October 2024 (UTC)
• Note: This discussion has been included in the deletion sorting lists for the following topics: Computing and China. WCQuidditch ☎ ✎ 20:24, 24 October 2024 (UTC)
• Comment: Adding another FindSources for an alternate company name which is used in coverage of the case with Apple:

:Zhizhen Network Technology: {{Find sources AFD|title=Zhizhen Network Technology}}

• Keep per the significant coverage in multiple independent reliable sources.

  1. Journal articles:

     1. {{cite journal |date=2013 |title=小i机器人为每个人的生活带来改变 |trans-title=Xiao-i Robot brings changes to everyone's life |language=zh |url=https://qikan.cqvip.com/Qikan/Article/Detail?id=45032190 |script-journal=zh:信息对抗技术 |trans-journal=Software Industry and Engineering |via={{ill|CQVIP|zh|維普資訊}} |issn=2097-163X |issue=2 |pages=33–37 |accessdate=2024-10-28 }}

        The abstract notes: "小i机器人成立于2001年，长期专注于智能机器人技术研究和开发，在自然语言处理和人机交互技术方面已经获得了多项国家发明专利。业务涉及通信、金融、政府、电子商务、智能家电和汽车等行业，经过十多年实际项目的不断验证和优化，小帆器人在智能人机交互（文本、语音等）的全渠道整合应用上领先中国，已成为中国智能机器人第一品牌。"

        From Google Translate: "Xiao-i was founded in 2001 and has long been focusing on the research and development of intelligent robot technology. It has obtained a number of national invention patents in natural language processing and human-computer interaction technology. Its business involves communications, finance, government, e-commerce, smart home appliances and automobiles. After more than ten years of continuous verification and optimization of actual projects, Xiaofan Robot leads China in the omni-channel integrated application of intelligent human-computer interaction (text, voice, etc.) and has become the No. 1 brand of intelligent robots in China."

     2. {{cite journal |date=2017 |title=由“小i机器人”案引发的探讨 |trans-title=Discussion triggered by the "Xiao-i" case |language=zh |url=https://lib.cqvip.com/Qikan/Article/Detail?id=90836770504849554849484853 |script-journal=zh:知识产权法研究 |trans-journal=Intellectual Property Right Law Research |via={{ill|CQVIP|zh|維普資訊}} |issue=1 |pages=63–74 |accessdate=2024-10-28 }}

        The abstract notes: "从苹果公司向专利复审委员会申请无效宣告伊始,'小i机器人'案历经一审、二审,北京市高级人民法院最终撤销一审判决。对于该案中所涉及的专利说明书充分公开标准及该领域技术人员的判断标准也引起了各方关注。该专题以'东方知识产权沙龙第27讲'内容为基础,以公开充分为切入点,对专利文件的体系化理解进行梳理与反思,并围绕技术类案件之特点进行讨论,以期更多人关注专利制度与相关实践"

        From Google Translate: "Since Apple applied to the Patent Reexamination Board for invalidation, the "Xiao-i" case has gone through the first and second trials, and the Beijing High People's Court finally revoked the first-instance judgment. The full disclosure standard of the patent specification involved in this case and the judgment standard of technicians in this field have also attracted attention from all parties. This topic is based on the content of "Lecture 27 of the Oriental Intellectual Property Salon", takes full disclosure as the starting point, sorts out and reflects on the systematic understanding of patent documents, and discusses the characteristics of technical cases, in order to attract more attention to the patent system and related practices."

     3. {{cite journal |date=2014 |title=能互动改变生活——小i机器人亮相软博会智能机器人技术引关注 |trans-title=Intelligent interaction changes life - Xiao-i debuts at Soft Expo, intelligent robot technology attracts attention |language=zh |url=https://lib.cqvip.com/Qikan/Article/Detail?id=50258902&from=Qikan_Article_Detail |script-journal=zh:软件产业与工程 |trans-journal=Software Industry and Engineering |via={{ill|CQVIP|zh|維普資訊}} |issue=6 |pages=6–7 |accessdate=2024-10-28 }}

        The article notes: "5月29日～31日，由工业和信息化部、国家发展和改革委员会、... 作为上海团队的代表企业，小i机器人（上海智臻网络科技有限公司）携带其最新的实体服务机器人亮相展会,吸引了大批观众现场互动，其中不乏领导、专家及各大媒体，成为软博会展馆中众人瞩目的焦点。"

        From Google Translate: "From 29 to 31 May 29, the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology, the National Development and Reform Commission,... As the representative enterprise of the Shanghai team, Xiao-i (Shanghai Zhizhen Network Technology Co., Ltd.) brought its latest physical service robot to the exhibition, attracting a large number of audiences to interact on the spot, including leaders, experts and major media, and became the focus of everyone's attention in the exhibition hall of the Software Expo."

  2. Books:

     1. {{cite book |last1=Liu |first1=Fangdong 刘芳栋 |last2=Lin |first2=Wei 林伟 |last3=Zhu |first3=Jianliang 朱建良 |last4=Zhang |first4=Xinliang 张新亮 |date=2016 |title=机器人+:正在席卷全球的机器人革命 |trans-title=Robots: Robot Is Over the World's Robot Revolution |language=zh |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=gAHKDQAAQBAJ&pg=PT145 |location=Beijing |publisher={{ill|China Railway Publishing House|zh|中国铁道出版社}} |via=Google Books |isbn=978-3-16-148410-0 |accessdate=2024-10-28 }}

        The book notes: "小i机器人是由上海智臻网络科技有限公司开发的,后来在交通银行的支持下,小i机器人率先被应用于银行业,在银行大厅中担任起了大堂 经理,可以通过语音功能与客户进行自然的沟通,帮助客户解答有关银 行业务方面的疑问。小i机器人除了被应用于实体机器人Ina外,还被应用在了负责接待 的机器人Nao、智能扫地机器人及一系列的智能家居产品上,而且它们 都有一个共同的属性——服务机器人。"

        From Google Tranlate: "The Xiao-i robot was developed by Shanghai Zhizhen Network Technology Co., Ltd. Later, with the support of Bank of Communications, the Xiao-i robot was first used in the banking industry and served as a lobby manager in the bank lobby. It can communicate with customers naturally through voice functions and help customers answer questions about banking business. In addition to being used in the physical robot Ina, the Xiao-i robot is also used in the reception robot Nao, the smart sweeping robot and a series of smart home products, and they all have a common attribute - service robots."

     2. {{cite book |date=2020 |title=人工智能实践录 |trans-title=Artificial Intelligence Practice |language=zh |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=itBqEAAAQBAJ&pg=PT357 |location=Beijing |publisher={{ill|Posts & Telecommunications Press|zh|人民邮电出版社}} |via=Google Books |isbn=978-7-115-50553-8 |accessdate=2024-10-28 }}

        The book notes: "案例31:小i机器人—12345城市管理自流程系统 小i机器人与贵阳市人民政府共同打造的国家级“人工智能大 数据云服务平台”,发挥贵阳大数据综合试验区数据基础优势和 小i在人工智能关键技术(自然语言处理、深度语义理解、知识 表示和推理、语音识别、机器学习和分析决策等)、行业应用积 累和人才方面的优势,并将平台的核心能力与贵阳政务治理、"

        From Google Translate: "Case 31: Xiao-i - 12345 City Management Self-Process System The national-level "AI Big Data Cloud Service Platform" jointly built by Xiao-i and Guiyang Municipal People's Government leverages the data foundation advantages of Guiyang Big Data Comprehensive Experimental Zone and Xiaoi's advantages in key AI technologies (natural language processing, deep semantic understanding, knowledge representation and reasoning, speech recognition, machine learning and analytical decision-making, etc.), industry application accumulation and talent, and integrates the core capabilities of the platform with Guiyang government governance,"

  3. Analyst reports:

     1. {{cite news |last=Lantier |first=Brian |date=2024-08-28 |title=Xiao-I Corporation-ADS |url=https://s27.q4cdn.com/906368049/files/News/2024/Zacks_SCR_Research_08282024_AIXI_Lantier.pdf |publisher=Zacks Investment Research |accessdate=2024-10-28 |archiveurl=https://archive.today/2024.10.28-102522/https://s27.q4cdn.com/906368049/files/News/2024/Zacks_SCR_Research_08282024_AIXI_Lantier.pdf |archivedate=2024-10-28 }}

        The analyst report notes: "As we have noted in the past, Xiao-I has made several attempts to demonstrate the potential of its AI tools by integrating its chatbot technology into everyday products. To date, we have seen these tools deployed for a “smart” baby crib to monitor sleep patterns or a “smart” speaker that could act as a virtual therapist. In our opinion, these products were principally built to demonstrate use cases for the company’s technology, but they did not have broad commercial application and the cost to develop hardware would make them cost-prohibitive for Xiao-I to bring to market."

        The analyst report notes: "Investors may recall that in our initiation report we briefly mentioned that in 2012, the company sued a subsidiary of Apple for patent infringement related to Apple’s Siri tool. Xiao-I alleges that Siri infringes on its intelligent assistant patent. The company updated that lawsuit in 2020 seeking damages in excess of $1.0 billion. We have held the belief that this lawsuit is unlikely to result in a meaningful settlement or win for Xiao-I but given the size of the damages being sought investors should be aware of the suit."

  4. News articles:

     1. {{cite news |last=Fang |first=Jia-liang 房家梁 |date=2019-11-28 |title=小i机器人入选胡润2019中国人工智能企业“百强榜” |trans-title=Xiao-i was selected into Hurun's 2019 China Artificial Intelligence Enterprise "Top 100 List" |language=zh |url=https://www.chinanews.com/business/2019/11-28/9019446.shtml |publisher=China News Service |accessdate=2024-10-28 |archiveurl=https://archive.today/2024.10.28-101408/https://www.chinanews.com/business/2019/11-28/9019446.shtml |archivedate=2024-10-28 }}

        The article notes: "近日，财富榜排榜机构胡润研究院携手知识产权与科创云平台汇桔，联合发布《IP助燃AI新纪元—2019中国人工智能产业知识产权发展白皮书》 (以下简称“白皮书”)，小i机器人与华为、... 共同入选《2019中国人工智能企业知识产权竞争力百强榜》，并跻身百强榜第33名。"

        From Google Translate: "Recently, the Hurun Research Institute, a ranking organization of the Fortune list, and the intellectual property and science and technology innovation cloud platform Huiju jointly released the "IP Fueling the New Era of AI - 2019 China Artificial Intelligence Industry Intellectual Property Development White Paper", hereinafter referred to as the "White Paper", . Xiaoi Robot, Huawei, and... were jointly selected into the "2019 China Artificial Intelligence Enterprise Intellectual Property Competitiveness Top 100 List", and ranked 33rd in the top 100 list."

        The article notes: "7月，在艾瑞咨询发布的《2019年中国人工智能产业研究报告》中，小i机器人成为2019年人工智能产业图谱中最高频亮相的企业之一，是多条赛道上的领先代表；小i机器人研究院团队在由斯坦福大学发起的国际权威机器阅读理解评测SQuAD1.1挑战赛中"

        From Google Translate: "In July, in the "2019 China Artificial Intelligence Industry Research Report" released by iResearch Consulting, Xiaoi Robot became one of the companies that appeared most frequently in the 2019 artificial intelligence industry map, and is a leading representative in multiple tracks; Xiaoi Robot Research Institute team ranked third in the SQuAD1.1 Challenge, an international authoritative machine reading comprehension evaluation initiated by Stanford University"

     2. {{cite news |date=2020-08-05 |title=索赔100亿 小i机器人诉苹果侵权案重启 |trans-title=Claiming 10 billion yuan, Xiao-i's case against Apple for infringement is reopened |language=zh |newspaper={{ill|China Business News|zh|第一财经日报}} }}

        The article notes: "小i机器人于2001年在上海成立，是人工智能技术和产业化平台供应商，最初的商业化产品为智能客服机器人（VCA）。 ... 小i机器人对比分析，认为Siri技术方案落入小i机器人完全拥有自主知识产权的ZL200410053749.9号专利（2004年申请、2009年授权）范围。"

        From Google Translate: "Xiao-i was established in Shanghai in 2001. It is a supplier of artificial intelligence technology and industrialization platforms. Its initial commercial product was the intelligent customer service robot (VCA). ... Xiao-i made a comparative analysis and believed that Siri's technical solution fell into the scope of patent No. ZL200410053749.9 (applied in 2004 and authorized in 2009), which Xiao-i completely owns independent intellectual property rights."

     3. {{cite news |last=Fang |first=Jia-lang 房家梁 |date=2020-02-13 |title=应对返岗潮，小i机器人以AI技术多向支持防疫工作 |trans-title=In response to the return to work trend, Xiao-i uses AI technology to support pandemic prevention work in multiple ways |language=zh |url=https://www.chinanews.com.cn/business/2020/02-13/9089791.shtml |publisher=China News Service |accessdate=2024-10-28 |archiveurl=https://archive.today/2024.10.28-100915/https://www.chinanews.com.cn/business/2020/02-13/9089791.shtml |archivedate=2024-10-28 }}

        The article notes: "针对社区的返工人群，小i机器人按照各地区防疫部署和具体需求，通过向社区提供免费的防疫外呼机器人服务，通过语音识别、语义理解等技术进行语音交互，根据话术模版，对小区居民发起电话外呼，"

        From Google Translate: "In response to the returnees in the community, Xiaoi Robot provides free pandemic prevention outbound robot services to the community in accordance with the epidemic prevention deployment and specific needs of each region. It uses voice recognition, semantic understanding and other technologies for voice interaction, and initiates outbound calls to community residents based on speech templates."

  There is sufficient coverage in reliable sources to allow Xiao-i ({{zh|c=小i机器人}}) to pass Wikipedia:Notability (organizations and companies)#Primary criteria, which requires "significant coverage in multiple reliable secondary sources that are independent of the subject".

  Cunard (talk) 10:55, 28 October 2024 (UTC)

:

{{resize|91%|Relisted to generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus.}}
Please add new comments below this notice. Thanks, The Herald (Benison) (talk) 12:17, 31 October 2024 (UTC)

• Keep: Broadly, the available coverage sits under four headings: (1) announcement-based coverage of new products/ joint ventures, which falls under :WP:CORPTRIV, (2) discussion of the long-running patent case vs. Apple (which may be or become more appropriate as a distinct article about the IP case rather than a party to it), (3) recent items about their NASDAQ listing and a subsequent action which would again fail :WP:CORPDEPTH , and (4) articles about the company itself, which what is needed here. It bothers me that the wording of this AfD nomination presents no specific :WP:BEFORE rationale in these respects. While I would prefer to find more discussion of the firm in its own right, I feel that the 2018 Digital Finance article already referenced in the article, plus some of the items quoted by {{u|Cunard}} above are sufficient for :WP:NCORP. AllyD (talk) 10:16, 1 November 2024 (UTC)

{{clear}}

:The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this page.