Wikipedia:Requests for checkuser/Case/NYC2TLV

=== NYC2TLV ===

• {{checkuser|NYC2TLV}}

• {{checkuser|Stentorian}}
• {{checkuser|Maccaphile}}
• {{checkuser|Kengineer1}}
• {{checkuser|SpeechFreedom}}
• {{checkip|65.206.55.31}}

User:NYC2TLV began editing June 24, 2006 and created the Joseph O. White article on June 26th, 2006.

• User:Stentorian began editing on June 26th, 2006 and oddly enough, the user's userpage was created by User:NYC2TLV. In at least one comment on the Joseph O. White AfD, the comment was signed by User:Stentorian, but made by User:NYC2TLV [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Joseph_O._White&diff=prev&oldid=60690417 diff] (to be fair, this is not a direct diff... Stentorian made the comment and then User:NYC2TLV came along and reformatted it).
• User:Maccaphile also began editing on June 26th, 2006. Made one edit to the Talk:Joseph O. White, then had a comment attributed on the AfD that was actually made by an ip User:65.206.55.31 -- and oddly enough, the user's userpage was ALSO created by User:NYC2TLV.
• User:Kengineer1 was created on June 26th, 2006 and their only contribution has been to support User:Stentorian on the AfD of Joseph O. White.
• Finally User:SpeechFreedom was created on June 26th as well and beyond contributing to the Joseph O. White AfD, has primarily edited articles previously edited by User:NYC2TLV or related to Israeli football (which is a topic User:NYC2TLV has contributed to heavily).

All this seems to point to the above users all being sockpuppets of User:NYC2TLV rather than meatpuppets. I'd like a checkuser to be sure.--Isotope23 13:19, 27 June 2006 (UTC)

• User:Stentorian has rejected the claim that he/she is a sockpuppet, so it looks like a checkuser is the only way to clear this up.--Isotope23 16:03, 27 June 2006 (UTC)

{{Inconclusive}} Definite meatpuppetry on the AfD, but the closing admin should be able to handle that. Mackensen (talk) 13:22, 1 July 2006 (UTC)