Wikipedia:WikiProject Citizendium Porting#Articles

| Accidental release source terms

| {{yes}}

| Jan 23, 2009

| The WP & CZ articles were mostly written by the same person; No significant differences

| Acid rain

| {{no}}

| Never

| Original version of the CZ article was ported from Encyclopedia of Earth

| Active attack

| {{no}}

| Never

| Seems to have opportunity for incoming wikilinks: Special:Search/Active attack

| Adams-Onís Treaty

| {{yes}}

| June 30,2010

| Most of the content is copied (without attribution) from Wikipedia. Imported one reference.

| Jane Addams

| {{no}}

| March 23, 2020

| Most if not all of the content appears to be copied without attribution from Wikipedia. Wikipedia article is now far more comprehensive.

| History of agriculture

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Air pollutant concentrations

| {{yes}}

| July 9, 2009

|

| Alice and Bob

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Anycast

| {{no}}

| Never

| Could benefit from porting of selected material that explains the concept. CZ has a better lede; the lede of the WP article is too jargon-heavy.

| Atmospheric dispersion modeling

| {{yes}}

| Nov 10, 2010

| The WP & CZ articles were mostly written by the same person

| Air pollution dispersion terminology

| {{yes}}

| Nov 10, 2010

| Copy of earlier WP article by largely by same editor I believe.

| Arthur J. Altmeyer

| {{yes}}

| July 3, 2010

| Tagged for clean up.

| American Institute of Chemical Engineers

| {{yes}}

| July 13, 2009

| Articles quite similar & share core contributor

| Amine gas treating

| {{Yes}}

| 8 November 2010

| The WP & CZ articles were mostly written by the same person, updates from CZ merged

| Ammonia production

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Joint Electronics Type Designation System

| {{no}}

| Never

| Articles are similar & share core contributor

| Ancient Celtic music

| {{yes}}

| Jun 20, 2009

|

| Anti-Saloon League

| {{yes}}

| Sep 5, 2010

| Citizendium article based on Wikipedia. No inline citations.

| ASIMO

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Azole

| {{yes}}

| July 10, 2009

|

| Bacteriophage

| {{no}}

| Never

| Appears to derive from WP (uncredited ?), but has added material and extensive re-write

| John Logie Baird

| {{yes}}

| October 1, 2010

| two words ported, citizendium article based on Wikipedia, but sans references

| Bar (unit)

| {{yes}}

| Jun 28, 2009

| Much of the Citizendium article is copied or paraphrased from the Wikipedia article.

| Australian Ringneck

| {{yes}}

| Jul 13, 2009

| The CZ article is an older version of the WP article, so no updating required.

| Charles A. Beard

| {{yes}}

| Aug 1, 2009

| CZ article is a less developed copy originating with an older version of the WP article.

| Biology

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Block cipher

| {{no}}

| Never

| will check today

| Boiling point

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Louis D. Brandeis

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Brute force attack

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Butler

| {{yes}}

| Jan 23, 2009

|

| Gaius Iulius Caesar (name)

| {{yes}}

| Jun 28, 2009

|

| Andrew Carnegie

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Catalytic reforming

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Caterpillar Club

| {{yes}}

| July 18, 2009

| CZ article is less developed version of WP article

| Augustin-Louis Cauchy

| {{yes}}

| Jun 22, 2009}

|

| Chemical engineering

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Chemistry

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Chiropractic

| {{n/a}}

| Never

| Importation strongly discouraged †

| Shirley Chisholm

| {{yes}}

| Sep 5th, 2010

| The Citizendium article has NPOV issues with her feminism and race. See the talk page of the Citizendium article.

| Congress of Industrial Organizations

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Civil society

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Coal

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Competition policy

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Complex number

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Compressibility factor

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Contraception (medical methods)

| {{no}}

| Never

| Last section of CZ article unusable here: Chatty, POV, uncited.

| Conventional coal-fired power plant, Fossil fuel power station

| {{yes}}

| 8 November 2010

| copied from CZ

| Countable set

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Covariance

| {{no}}

| Never

| Both articles are more difficult to understand than necessary; they could be far more valuable to the average reader if rewritten.

| Cryptanalysis

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Cryptography

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Cryptology

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| The Crystal Palace

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Merle Curti

| {{Yes}}

| 16 November 2010

| Rjensen, has kept these in step it seems.

| Cypherpunk

| {{yes}}

| August 14, 2010

| Most of information from citizendium article

| Félix d'Herelle

| {{yes}}

| August 10, 2010

| Citizendium is a fork off of an older Wikipedia version. No in line citations.

| Democrat Party (phrase)

| {{yes}}

| Jan 23, 2009

| Much common text; one must derive from other

| Demographic transition

| {{yes}}

| March 16, 2010

| Writer of article on citizendium ported the content

| DNA

| {{no}}

| Never

| The citizendium version is a degraded version of the Wikipedia article that tries to deal with too many subjects at once.

| Dog

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Dokdo

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Domain Name System

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Doom (video game)

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| List of drugs banned from the Olympics

| {{yes}}

| Jun 27, 2009

|

| Economics

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Edward I of England

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Ellipse

| {{no}}

| Never

| Email, Email system

| {{Yes}}

| 8 November 2010

| Copied to WP. Might be a clean up and merge candidate.

| U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Europe

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Evidence-based medicine

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Explosive material

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Michael Faraday

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Fertility

| {{yes}}

| Jun 27, 2009

| Needs more citations (WP:OR)
mixes in ideas of Demographic transition

| Flash evaporation

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Folk saint

| {{yes}}

| July 6, 2009

|

| Benjamin Franklin

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| John Franklin

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| (none)

| {{n/a}}

| Never

| Topic likely not notable ‡

| Gasoline

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Geometric progression

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| William Ewart Gladstone

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Grand Trunk Railway

| {{no}}

| Never

| Great Society

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Nathanael Greene

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Gross Domestic Product

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| L. J. Hanifan

| {{yes}}

| Jun 28, 2010

| Now imported into Wikipedia

| Henry's law

| {{yes}}

| Never

| Article copied from WP

| Richard Hofstadter

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Homeopathy

| {{n/a}}

| Never

| Importation strongly discouraged †

| Horizontal gene transfer

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Hydrodesulfurization

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Ideal gas law

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Industrial Revolution

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Infant colic

| {{no}}

| Never

| Mind WP:NOTHOWTO.
Contains unbalanced discussion of alternative medicine.

| International economics

| {{yes}}

| Jun 27, 2009

|

| Jet Set Willy

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Joan of Arc

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Joule-Thomson effect

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Kamehameha I

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Kerckhoffs' principle

| {{yes}}

| September 17, 2010

| Citizendium article has a lot of original research and tone problems

| Ketoconazole

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Leptotes (orchid)

| {{yes}}

| June 27, 2009

|

| Life

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Line (geometry)

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Literature

| {{n/a}}

| Jan 4, 2011

| Extremely Euro-centric and lacks in line citations.

| Theodor Lohmann

| {{yes}}

| Jun 27, 2009

|

| Joe Louis

| {{yes}}

| August 21, 2010

| Article is unreferenced. Ported one sentence and quote.

| Macromolecular chemistry

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Guglielmo Marconi

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| James Clerk Maxwell

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Barbara McClintock

| {{yes}}

| July 9, 2009

| Article copied from Wikipedia

| Merox

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Metabolism

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Microeconomics

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Natural gas

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Neighbourhood (mathematics)

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| NMR spectroscopy

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Northwest Passage

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Partial pressure

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Oil refinery, Petroleum refining processes

| {{Yes}}

| 8 November 2010

| Copied form CZ

| Orchid

| {{no}}

|

|

| Oxytocin

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Passive attack

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Naphtha, Petroleum naptha

| {{Yes}}

| 8 November 2010

| Copied from CZ

| Phosphorus

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| History of Pittsburgh

| {{yes}}

| 8 November 2010

| Copy of WP article of 2007 with poor attribution

| History of Pittsburgh

| {{yes}}

| 8 November 2010

| Copy of WP article of 2007 with no attribution

| Plane (geometry)

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Prime number

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Randomized controlled trial

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Relative volatility

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| RNA interference

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Rottweiler

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Scarborough Castle

| {{yes}}

| August 10, 2010

| Wikipedia version almost entirely replaced with higher quality citizendium article.

| Scientific method

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Set theory

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Great Siege of Scarborough Castle

| {{yes}}

| Jun 28, 2010

| Now imported into Wikipedia.

|

| {{no}}

| Never

| Now imported into Wikipedia.

| Cantor–Bernstein–Schroeder theorem

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Social capital

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| (none)

| {{n/a}}

| Never

| Likely not notable, does not cite secondary sources ‡

| Specific heat ratio

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Symphony

| {{no}}

| Never

| Citizendium article has 35 inline citations, while Wikipedia article has circa 16 inline citations (but an extensive "References" section of used - or potential? - sources).

| Telephone newspaper

| {{yes}}

| June 21, 2009

|

| Terrorism

| {{no}}

| Never

|

| Frederick Jackson Turner

| {{yes}}

| July 1, 2010

| Medium quality article, but imported a lot as our article was quite short.

| Tux

| {{yes}}

| June 30,2010

| Strongly against porting any more. A little information added from a low quality article.

| Frederick Twort

| {{yes}}

| July 2, 2010

| Based on a 2007 version of the Wikipedia article (without attribution).

| Vacuum distillation

| {{Yes}}

| 10 November 2010

| Incorporated material, mainly or all by User:Mbeychok into WP

| Van der Waals equation

| {{n/a}}

| Never

| Is a 2007 fork of WP article, and less developed a decade later.

| Johannes Diderik van der Waals

| {{yes}}

| Sep 11, 2010

| citizendium article based on Wikipedia one.

| Vapor pressure

| {{n/a}}

| Never

| CZ article has [http://en.citizendium.org/wiki?title=Vapor_pressure&action=history broken edit history] due to cut and paste, therefore copying would violate cc-by-sa.

| Vertebral subluxation

| {{n/a}}

| Never

| Importation strongly discouraged †

| Edwin E. Witte

| {{yes}}

| July 2, 2010

| Most of Wikipedia article overwritten.

| Wheat

| {{yes}}

| June 30, 2010

| High Quality article. Whole sections imported.

| World of Warcraft

| {{n/a}}

| Never

| Few footnotes. Nothing the Wikipedia article was missing. During December 2010, a new version was approved.